THE SCENE OF MY RUMSPRINGA Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーリー重視の方はオススメです。

Recommended for those who focus on the story.

一巻完結ながら文字数が多く読み応えもあり、満足度が高い作品です。重厚なストーリーの中にもクスっと笑える所があり、それぞれのキャラクターが魅力的で異国モノが苦手な私でも物語にすぐに引き込まれました。最後は基本的にはハピエンなのですが、頭のなかでは整理ができないような複雑な感情の涙が出て、すごく余韻が残りました。何度でも読み返したくなる作品です。

Although one volume is complete, it has many characters and is easy to read, and it is a highly satisfying work. There are places where I can laugh even more in the heavy story, and each character is fascinating, and I was immediately drawn into the story, even though I don't like foreign things. At the end, it's basically happy, but tears of mixed emotions that I couldn't sort out in my head came out, and it left a great afterglow. It's a work you'll want to reread over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 24, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

性別、宗教を超えた愛

Love beyond gender and religion

読後の温かい気持ちと少しのもの哀しさが心地良い。時代背景もすごく刺さりました…！自らにとって大切な人、大切な場所を選択するという葛藤が丁寧に描かれていてとても胸に響きました。この作品に出会えて良かったです。

The warm feeling and slight sadness after reading it is comforting. The historical background really stuck with me too...! The conflict of choosing people and places that are important to me was carefully depicted, and it really resonated with my heart. I'm glad I came across this work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 12, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

親愛なる

dearest

This review contains spoilers. 親愛なるジーンのスピンオフですか、傷ついた心の持ち主に純粋な魂の持ち主が優しく寄り添っていくさまが素敵なお話でした。お互いに必要でというところ、普遍的なところが素敵

This review contains spoilers. Was it a spinoff of Dear Gene? It was a wonderful story about how the owner of a pure soul gently snuggles up to the owner of a broken heart. The fact that we need each other and the fact that they are universal is wonderful

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

本当に素敵でした。

It was really nice.

This review contains spoilers. 星が5つじゃ足りない。スタンディングオベーション。とても美しくオズの父の願いだったり、テオの様々だったりを昇華していて、うるうると涙腺潤みっぱなしでした。泣くなというほうが無理。きっとオズは月を見ることが嫌だっただろうな、とかその辺りも考えて泣いてしまいました。彼らのNY生活がどうなるのか、そしてオズの夢がどうなるのかは描かれていませんが、きっと2人が2人でいられる限り大丈夫な気がしました。生きていると、選択の連続で、それが自分にとって有益だったり、相手のための利になったり、その場その場で違ったりするけれど、自分の人生のための選択は自分のためでありたいと思いました。いつどんな形でそれが訪れるかは分かりませんが、その時が来るまでに沢山の物を見て、触れて、感じて豊かな人生にしたいと思います。この作品に出会えて、よかった。

This review contains spoilers. 5 stars isn't enough. standing ovation. It was so beautiful that Oz's father's wishes and Theo's various things were sublimated, and my lacrimal glands were still moisturized when I moisturized it. It's impossible to say don't cry. I cried thinking that Oz must have hated looking at the moon. It doesn't depict what their life in NY would be like or what their dream of Oz would be like, but I definitely felt like it would be fine as long as the two of them could stay together. When I'm alive, I make a series of choices, which are beneficial to me, an advantage for my partner, and different on the spot, but I wanted the choices for my life to be for myself. I don't know when and in what form it will come, but I want to have a rich life by seeing, touching, and feeling many things until that time comes. I'm glad I came across this work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

読み応えがある

It's worth reading

読むと遠いところに旅した気持ちになります。一冊なのに何冊も読んだような読後感。余韻がすごいです。BLとしてももちろんよいのだけれどしっかりしたストーリーで非常に満足感があります。

Reading it makes me feel like I've traveled far away. After reading it, I felt like I had read many books even though it was one book. The afterglow is amazing. Of course it's good as a BL, but I'm very satisfied with the solid story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

自分で選んで、生きていく

Choose your own and live

今ある自分の生活に疑問を持ったことはあっただろうか。もちろん不満や希望、生きて生活していく中での喜怒哀楽は一分一秒ごとに私の中で生まれている。だけれども、自分の目で見て体験して自分の持ちうるもの全てを投げ打ってでもここで生きていくと決められるほどの責任はあるのか。そこまで大それた決断をして生きていく必要がないほど、今現代は色々なことが飽和状態であると思う。しかし、この作品に出会ったからには自分の胸に手を当てて考えてみたい。過去は変えられなくとも、今これから私の思うままに。やりたいこと出来ること、自分で選択して生きていく責任を。

Have you ever had doubts about your current life? Of course, dissatisfaction, hope, and joy, anger, sorrow and joy as we live our lives are born within me minute by minute. But is there such a responsibility that I can decide to live here even if I see and experience it with my own eyes and throw everything I can? I think the present day is so saturated with so many things that there is no need to make such big decisions and live. However, now that I've come across this work, I want to put my hands on my chest and think about it. Even if I can't change the past, I'll do whatever I want now from now on. Being able to do what you want, and the responsibility to make your own choices and live.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 09, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

私は、君たちは、どう生きるか。

How will I, and you guys, live.

This review contains spoilers. フォローさん達の絶賛レビューを読んで、ずっと読みたいと思っていた作品でした。レビューの高評価に激しく納得。きっと私はこの作品をこれから何度も読み返すのだろう思います。すごく美しく、切なく、悲しくとも希望の光の差すお話だったと思います。誰も何も悪くない。それぞれの価値観を否定するつもりはないし、できない。ただあなたは、私は、「どう生きるか」「どう生きたいか」。故郷を捨てたとしても、家族と離れることとなっても、夢を諦めたとしても、それぞれに守りたいもの、手にしたいものがある。それぞれが人生の岐路で、覚悟を決めてそれを選ぶ。まさに、「きみたちはどう生きるか」という問いかけだったように思います。オズとテオは、人生の岐路で進むべき道を選んだ。…というところで物語は終わり、ここから先の２人未来は分かりません。これからシリーズ作品の「親愛なるジーンへ」を読みますが、そこで少しその未来に触れることはできるのでしょうか？？オズとテオが選んだ道は、決して平坦な道ではないでしょうが、温かく、光に満ちたものでありますように。心から２人の幸せを願っています。吾妻先生の作品は「桜田先輩改造計画」と「藤咲忍はかく語りき」を読んだ事がありましたが、振り幅の大きさと激しさに、鞭打ち症になりそうなくらいの衝撃を受けました。(全力の賛辞です)素晴らしい作品をありがとうございました。

This review contains spoilers. I read rave reviews from my followers, and it was a work I've always wanted to read. I was extremely convinced by the high ratings of the reviews. I'm sure I'll be rereading this work over and over again. I think it was a very beautiful, sad, and sad story that shines a ray of hope. Nobody's doing anything wrong. I don't intend to deny each value, and I can't. However, you and I are “how do you live” and “how do you want to live.” Whether you abandon your hometown, leave your family, or give up on your dreams, everyone has something they want to protect and something they want to get. Each of them is at a crossroads in their lives, and they decide to prepare for it and choose it. Exactly, I think it was a question of “how will you live?” Oz and Theo chose the path they should take at a crossroads in their lives. The story ends at..., and the future of the two of them from here on out is unknown. I'm going to read the series “Dear Jean,” but can I touch that future a little bit there? The path chosen by Oz and Theo will not be an easy one, but may it be warm and full of light. I sincerely wish them both happiness. I have read “Sakurada Senpai Remodeling Plan” and “Fujisaki Shinobu's Tales” in Azuma sensei's works, but I was shocked by the magnitude and intensity of the amplitude to the point where it almost became whiplash. (Full compliment) Thank you so much for your wonderful work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けます…

It makes me cry...

This review contains spoilers. 作家買い！シリーズ買いです！アーミッシュのテオが出会い恋をする、NYでダンサーの夢に破れたオズとのラブストーリー。愛する家族、友人、故郷を捨てテオがオズと生きる道を選択した覚悟が痛いほど伝わってきます。みんながそれぞれに相手の幸せを願い、毎日を必死に生きている。ラブストーリーでありながらヒューマンドラマのような素晴らしい作品！大好きです！悲しみ切なさとともに未来への期待感もある読後です。

This review contains spoilers. Buy a writer! I'm buying the series! A love story where Amish Theo meets and falls in love with Oz, who was torn apart by her dream as a dancer in NY. It painfully conveys the determination that Theo chose to live with Oz after abandoning his beloved family, friends, and hometown. Everyone lives desperately every day, hoping for the other person's happiness. While it's a love story, it's a wonderful work like a human drama! I love it! After reading it, along with sadness and sadness, there is also a sense of anticipation for the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

すっごく面白かった

That was sooo funny

体感的には400ページくらいの物語を読んだ感じで、余韻もものすごい。最初から最後まで無駄がない展開。ノスタルジックな雰囲気もすごく良かった。2人の今後が少しでも見れたら嬉しかったな。

In terms of experience, I feel like I've read a 400-page story, and the afterglow is amazing. A seamless development from beginning to end. The nostalgic atmosphere was also really nice. I was happy to be able to see even a little bit about the future of the two of them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

とても、とても、素敵なお話です

It's a very, very, very nice story

This review contains spoilers. アーミッシュという文化がここまで丁寧に描かれているのは初めて読みました。アーミッシュのテオとニューヨークから流れてきたオズ、この二人を軸に周りの人達もみんなが自分の進むべき道を一生懸命生きている。そこに二人の気持ちが少しずつ愛に変わっていく様子がリアルに描かれていると思います。どうか、それぞれが幸せでありますように!!!

This review contains spoilers. This is the first time I've read that the Amish culture has been so carefully depicted. Centering on these two people, Theo from the Amish and Oz who came from New York, everyone around them is living hard on the path they should take. I think it realistically depicts how the feelings of the two gradually turn into love there. I hope everyone is happy!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 26, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ハッピーエンド

happy ending

アーミッシュやラムスプリンガというものを初めて知ったので面白かった。時代的にも環境的にもどことなく閉塞感や寂寥感があって、テオの純朴さや明るさに救われた。ハッピーエンドで良かった。

I first learned about Amish and Lamb Springa, so it was interesting. There was a sense of blockage and loneliness both in terms of the times and the environment, and I was saved by Theo's simplicity and brightness. I'm glad it had a happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

作風いいな。。

Nice style..

「親愛なるジーンへ」の流れで拝読しました。今まで読んだ他のBLと違った作品でした。人の出会いと別れ、生き方など静かに暖かく流れているなと思います。電子書籍だからたまたま出会えた作家さんでした。本当に良かったです。

I read it in the “Dear Jean” style. It was a different work from any other BL I've read so far. I think people's encounters, breakups, and ways of life flow quietly and warmly. It was an author I happened to meet because it was an e-book. It was really nice.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

勉強になる

It's a learning experience

アーミッシュのこんな習慣を知らなかったので勉強になりました地に足のついた作品という印象が強く残っています

I didn't know about this Amish custom, so I learned a lot. I have a strong impression that it's a grounded work

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

いやぁ映画って本当にいいものですね…

Well, movies are really good...

読了後私の脳内に、ん十年前の金曜ロードショーのBGMが流れ水野晴郎さんの名台詞が…親愛なるジーンへの時も思いましたが、ラムスプリンガの情景も美しい一本の映画の様でした。親愛なるジーンへが素晴らしすぎてラムスプリンガは長らくカートに入ったまま購入できずにいましたが何を躊躇っていたんだか、期待を裏切らない素晴らしい作品でした。心から購入して良かったです。それではまた次回さよならさよならさよなら〜（淀川長治さんもいらてくれました）

After reading it, the BGM from the Friday Road Show ten years ago played in my mind, and Mizuno Haruro's famous line... I also thought about the time for Dear Gene, but the scene of Lamb Springa was like a beautiful movie. Dear Jean was so wonderful that I couldn't buy Lamb Springa in my cart for a long time, but it was a wonderful work that didn't disappoint what I was hesitating about. I'm glad I bought it from the bottom of my heart. See you next time goodbye goodbye goodbye ~ (Mr. Nagaharu Yodogawa came too)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 26, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

映画を観たかのような満足感

A sense of satisfaction as if you were watching a movie

This review contains spoilers. 1巻で完結するのですが、構成に過不足がまったくなく、満足して読み終えられる作品です。アーミッシュの青年のテオがモラトリアム期間として過ごすラムスプリンガー、その際にオズと出会い、恋に落ち……というわかりやすいといえばわかりやすいお話なのですが、それだけではなく信仰に関するもの、人生の選択ですからビターな面も多くあります。それがまたこの作品の良いスパイスになっていて、あとがきにも書いてらっしゃいましたがハピエンなんですがどこか切ない、寂しさもあります。この先の2人がどういう人生を歩むかはわかりませんが、どうか幸せに、苦しい時も支え合って生きていってほしいなと思うばかりです。シリーズの親愛なるジーンへもとっっっっても良い作品で、こちらの作品とリンクする場面も多くどちらも読めばさらに楽しめるかと思いますのでぜひ両作品読んでいただきたい！です！最高！！

This review contains spoilers. Although it is completed in 1 volume, there are absolutely no excesses or deficiencies in the structure, and it is a work that you can finish reading with satisfaction. It's an easy-to-understand story where Theo, an Amish young man, spends his time as a moratorium, meets Oz at that time and falls in love... but not only that, it's also about faith, and since it's a life choice, there are many bitter aspects. That is also a good spice for this work, and although you wrote it in the afterword, it's a happy one, but it's also kind of sad and lonely. I don't know what kind of life the two will lead in the future, but I just want them to live happily and support each other even in difficult times. It's a really good work in the series Dear Jean, and there are many scenes linked to this work, and I think you'll enjoy it even more if you read both, so be sure to read both! That's it! the best!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 25, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしい作品です

It's a great work

This review contains spoilers. 本当に読んでよかったです。主人公２人ともそれぞれ幸せになれる選択ができたと思う。いろいろ考えさせられた一冊です。ハッピーエンドだけれど余韻がすごい。

This review contains spoilers. I'm really glad I read it. I think both of the main characters were able to make choices that would make them happy. It's a book that made me think a lot. It has a happy ending, but the afterglow is amazing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ぐぅ…っっ好きっ

wow... I like it

『親愛なるジーンへ』を読むにはこちらの作品も読んだ方がより楽しめるというレビューを読んで購読。いやー、良かったです！外国もの設定好きな癖にブッ刺さりまくり。「アーミッシュ」「ラムスプリンガ」という知らなかった文化についても知ることができました。純真無垢なテオが他の世界を知るにつれ、どんどん男前になっていくのが切なくもあり萌えました。先の見えない展開でどーなるの？大丈夫？とハラハラしながら読み終えました。じーんときたし、きゅんとしたし、色々考えちゃう余韻の残る読後感…。親愛なるジーンへの期待値が爆上がりです！いってきます！

To read “Dear Jean,” read a review that says that those who also read this work can enjoy it even more, and subscribe. Well, that was great! I'm obsessed with my habit of liking foreign settings. I was also able to learn about cultures I had never known about the “Amish” and “Ramspringa.” As the innocent Theo got to know the rest of the world, it was sad and fascinating that he became more and more handsome. What will happen if we can't see the future? are you okay? I finished reading it in a state of frustration. A lingering feeling after reading that made me think a lot, and it made me think a lot... Expectations for dear Gene are skyrocketing! I'm going!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

映画化してもいいくらい

Enough to make it into a movie

This review contains spoilers. モノクロの漫画なのに美しく爽快な村の空の色やキラキラしたNYの街の光、人のために流す涙の美しさ、髪を乱す乾いた風の中の砂埃までありありと味わえるような表現力の高さに脱帽です。いわゆる少女漫画絵なのにそこにいる人たちがリアルに立って生きているようで、汗の匂いや体温まで伝わってくるよう。ページをめくってすぐの、バレエのレッスンをしながら静かに涙を流す幼きオズワルドを見た瞬間こちらの涙腺もダバっと溢れてしまいました。ストーリーも最初から最後まで、アメリカの古い映画を見ているようで、心からワクワクした。親愛なるジーンへを先に読んでレビューしていたのにこちらは書いていなかったことに気がついて、好きなところを羅列するだけの文になってしまった。この人生で出会えてよかったと思える1冊です。

This review contains spoilers. Even though it's a black and white comic, I take my hat off to the high level of expressiveness that you can enjoy the beautiful and exhilarating color of the village sky, the sparkling lights of the city of NY, the beauty of tears shed for people, and even the dust in the dry wind that disturbs the hair. Even though it's a so-called girls' manga picture, the people there seem to be standing and living in real life, and the smell of sweat and even body temperature seem to be transmitted. As soon as I turned the page, my lacrimal glands overflowed the moment I saw young Oswald quietly shedding tears while taking ballet lessons. From beginning to end, the story was like watching an old American movie, and I was really excited. I read Dear Gene first and reviewed it, but I realized that it wasn't written here, and it ended up being just a list of things I liked. It's a book I'm glad I met in this life.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

内容がもう、、かなり良い

The content is already... pretty good

異文化だったので、わたしには少し難しいかなと思って敬遠していたのですが、この作品のBLCDの評判が気になっていたので読んで見ました。これはすごい！泣きます。絶対読むべき。素敵です。産まれた場所での生活や価値観、でも自分自身はどう行きたいのか、家族とは、優しさとは、全て入っています。何度も読み返したいです。

It was a different culture, so I shunned it because I thought it would be a bit difficult for me, but I was concerned about the BLCD reputation of this work, so I read it. this is amazing! I'm going to cry. You should definitely read it. It's wonderful. Life and values in the place where you were born, how you want to go about yourself, family, and kindness are all included. I want to read it over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

感慨深い

Impressive

This review contains spoilers. 引き込まれる深い話でした。最初はレビューみて勝手にバッドエンドなのかなぁと思ってましたが、幸せってそれぞれなんだなぁと考えさせられました。自分だったらどっちの道を選ぶかすごく考えさせられました。結局答えは出ませんでしたが…『素晴らしい呪い。』うーんとっても深い。まさにその通り

This review contains spoilers. It was a deep story that drew me in. At first, looking at the reviews, I was wondering if it was a bad end, but it made me think that happiness is different. It really made me think about which path I would choose. In the end, I didn't get an answer... “A wonderful curse.” Hmm, that's very deep. Exactly

Helpful

Reviews for THE SCENE OF MY RUMSPRINGA Manga