Knights of Sidonia Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 01, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

全巻読みました。

I've read the whole volume.

なんとなくで読み始め、ズッポリはまり全巻購入…何度読み返しても面白い!!

Somehow I started reading it and bought the full volume of Zuppoli Mari... it's interesting no matter how many times I reread it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 02, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメで知りました。

I learned about it in anime.

アニメをみて原作購入しました。普段可愛い感じの絵柄のマンガを読むほうなんで、作画はちょっと苦手です…でも内容がすっごく面白くて一気読みしてしまいました。読まず嫌いはいけませんね。もし作画が苦手で迷ってる方がいたら、１巻だけでもよいので読んでみて下さい( ∗•ω•∗)*。

I watched the anime and bought the original one. I usually read comics with cute designs, so I'm a little bad at drawing... but the content was so interesting that I read them all at once. Don't hate it without reading it. If there are people who aren't good at drawing and are at a loss, please read it because only 1 volume is fine (* • Ω • *) *.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

凄すぎる

That's too amazing

とにかく未来を描く表現力が素晴らしい。風景とかも細かく描いてありいろいろ想像して楽しめる作品です。

Anyway, the expressive power to depict the future is amazing. Scenery and the like are also drawn in detail, and it is a work that you can enjoy imagining various things.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 07, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

わかりづらいとこもあるけど

There are places that are hard to understand

This review contains spoilers. ガウナVS人間のスケールの大きいSFマンガです。地球外生命体ガウナに太陽系は滅ぼされ、人間の生き残りをかけた方舟であるシドニア。アニメ化になるのもうなずける気がします。登場人物がわかりづらいとこやいきなり過去の話にとんだり読み直してやっとわかってきました(^-^;) 男でもない女でもない、性別があったりクローン人間ありのまさに近未来って感じで独特の世界観にどっぷりハマっちゃいました(o´∀`)b dTVでアニメも観ましたが確かにアクション部分などアニメのが分かりやすいし原作の独特のタッチが苦手な人はアニメの方から観る事をお薦めします。完結して感想として、シュガフ船撃破なんかあっけなかった気がする。つむぎのことも…そんなみんな丸く収まっていいのか？！と思いましたが、人気のあるうちに終わらせたかったのかなとも考えました。弐瓶先生、何はともあれお疲れ様でした！後は落合vs谷風の戦いをアニメで再現されるのがすごく楽しみです(≧∇≦)b

This review contains spoilers. It's a large-scale sci-fi manga about Gauna vs. Humans. Sidonia is an ark where the solar system was destroyed by the extraterrestrial Gauna, and human survival was at stake. I feel like it's no wonder that it's going to be made into an anime. I was completely addicted to the unique worldview because the characters were hard to understand and suddenly reread past stories (^-^;) I was completely addicted to the unique worldview, feeling like the very near future, with genders and cloned humans (o'∀`) I also watched the anime on b dTV, but it's certainly easy to understand the anime, such as the action part, and I recommend watching it from the anime. As an impression of it being completed, I feel like defeating the Sugaf ship was a surprise. Tsumugi too... is it OK for everyone to fit in a circle?! I thought, but I also thought that they wanted to finish it while it was popular. Anyway, thank you for your hard work, Professor Nihei! After that, I'm really looking forward to recreating the battle between Ochiai and Tanikaze in an anime (≧ 126) b

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 10, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

13巻まで読了

Read up to 13 volumes

This review contains spoilers. アニメの話になりますが初めて見た時、映像が3Dだし次々と仲間が死ぬし主人公が悪者扱いされるわで暗い内容なのかと自分には見るに耐えない物語だと思いました。でも気になって漫画で読んでみたら苦境の中でも主人公が戦いの成果を上げ続けることにより様々な誤解が解け信頼できる仲間や好意を抱く人が増えホっとしました。そして後半は明るく面白い話も描かれるようになり13巻では『マジか』と思える話と気になる挿し絵がありました。

This review contains spoilers. It's an anime story, but when I first watched it, I thought it was an unbearable story for myself to see if the content was dark because the images were 3D, friends died one after another, and the main character was treated as a villain. But when I was curious and read it in comics, I was relieved that various misunderstandings were resolved due to the fact that the main character continued to achieve battle results even in a difficult situation, and the number of reliable friends and people with good intentions increased. Also, bright and interesting stories began to be drawn in the second half, and in volume 13, there were stories that seemed “serious” and interesting illustrations.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 04, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

複雑だけど読みやすい

Complicated but easy to read

弐瓶さんの他作品に比べて、格段に読みやすいです。複雑で設定もいろいろあって描写も独特で、でも説明などは一切なくて、ひたすら読んで察しないといけないのが弐瓶さんの作品だと思っていました。むしろそれが良いと思っていたのですが、今回シドニアの騎士を読んで、読者側に優しくなってる！とびっくりしました。笑相変わらず複雑な世界観ですが夢中で読んでしまいました。

Compared to Nihei's other works, it's much easier to read. I thought it was Nihei-san's work because it was complicated, there were various settings, and the depiction was unique, but there were no explanations at all, and I just had to read and guess. Rather, I thought that would be good, but now that I've read Knights of Sidonia, I'm being kind to the readers! I was surprised. lol it's still a complicated view of the world, but I was obsessed with reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 24, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

ニビンベン

Nibimben

弐瓶勉さんのマンガの中で一番わかりやすいマンガです。日常はほんわかハーレムですが、戦闘になるとさすがです！また他作品にもたびたび出てくる、とある武器がめちゃめちゃかっこいいんですよ！少し読みにくいかもしれませんが、読み込むほど深い味わいの素敵なマンガです。

This is the easiest manga to understand among Tsutomu Nihei's comics. Everyday life is a warm harem, but when it comes to battles, it's amazing! Also, a certain weapon that often appears in other works is really cool! It may be a bit difficult to read, but it's a wonderful manga with a deep flavor the more you read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

地球外生命体

extraterrestrials

地球外生命体との戦いを描いていますが、シドニア内部の生活や心理描写が面白いです。アニメも面白いのでお勧めです。

It depicts a battle with extraterrestrials, and the depiction of life and psychology within Sidonia is interesting. The anime is also interesting, so I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 19, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

SFロボット物。

Sci-fi robot stuff.

世界観の設定が理解出来ないと読んでいて「？」な事が多いかもしれません。が、理解が出来れば面白く読めます。途中から人外ハーレム物か？と思う程に主人公がモテ出して、ちょっと読むのをやめようかと考えてしまいました。が、つむぎちゃんが可愛くて可愛くてついつい完結まで読んでしまいました。触手が苦手な女の自分を虜にするヒロイン、つむぎちゃん。恐ろしい子です…

I read that I don't understand the setting of the worldview and “?” There may be a lot of such things. But if you understand it, it's interesting to read. is it a harem thing in the middle? The main character became so popular that I thought about it, and I thought about stopping reading it for a moment. But Tsumugi-chan is so cute and so cute, I just read it to the end. Tsumugi-chan is a heroine who captivates herself as a woman who doesn't like tentacles. she's a horrible kid...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

まさに独特

Truly unique

コアなファンと苦手な人にわかれる作品だと思う。でも自分は好きです。ガン○ムが好きな人は興味惹かれると思います。

I think it's a work that can be divided between core fans and people who don't like it. But I like it myself. I think people who like Gun-Mu will be intrigued.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 15, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

SF感はある

It has a sci-fi feel

敵の様相、宇宙空間の戦闘はトップをねらえ！を思い出しました。

Look at the enemy, aim for the top in outer space battles! It reminded me of it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 31, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメの方が良い

Anime is better

ちょっと顔の見分けが付かない絵なんですがストーリーは面白いです、アニメから入りましたが動きがあるアニメの方が解りやすく原作よりアニメの方が良い珍しい作品、そろそろアニメ完結編お願いします。

It's a picture where you can't tell the faces apart, but the story is interesting; the anime with movement is easier to understand, and the anime is a rare work where the anime is better than the original, so please complete the anime soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 30, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

ＳＦ

science fiction

アニメを先に見ました。いろいろとツッコミたい部分はあるけど面白いです。

I watched the anime first. There are a lot of hard parts, but it's interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 04, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

独特な世界観

A unique view of the world

独特な世界観で、初めはなかなか読みにくいのですが、読んでくうちにどんどん引き込まれてく作品です！あとツムギが可愛いです☆

It's a unique worldview, and it's quite difficult to read at first, but as I read it, I was drawn more and more into the work! Also, tsumugi is cute ☆

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 16, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

弐瓶作品初心者用

Nihei works for beginners

This review contains spoilers. 作者の他作品に比べて、ギャグ成分が増え、画もシンプルな感じになっており、分かりやすい。ただ、最後がちょっと駆け足で、あるキャラがまさかの展開になってたり驚かされた。

This review contains spoilers. Compared to the author's other works, the number of gag elements has increased, and the pictures have a simple feel, making them easy to understand. However, the last one was a bit of a rush, and I was surprised that a character unexpectedly developed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメから

From anime

アニメの独特の雰囲気が好きでした。原作も読んでみましたが、１回じゃ理解できず・・・何度も読み返せる作品だと思います。

I liked the unique atmosphere of the anime. I also read the original story, but I can't understand it once... I think it's a work I can reread over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 09, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

引き込まれる

I'm drawn in

前から興味があり、一巻を購入して続きが気になり少しずつ買ってます。謎だらけの世界ですが、引き込まれます。面白いです。

I've been interested in it since before, and after buying one volume, I'm worried about the continuation, so I'm buying it little by little. It's a world full of mysteries, but it draws you in. It's interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

好み分かれる作品

Works with different tastes

時間かけてジックリ読み込む作品。絵などで、好み分かれると思います。アニメで大まかに見て、漫画でわかりにくいところ読み込んで、って感じがいいかなと思います。久々に、読み込みました！

It's a work that takes time to quickly read. I think people can have different tastes depending on pictures etc. I think it would be nice to look at it broadly in an anime and read in places that are difficult to understand in comics. It's been a while since I loaded it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメ観てました

I was watching an anime

アニメが好きで、原作を読むのを迷ってたけど、３巻まで読みました。…すごいな(*´∇｀)解りにくい画面はアニメを思い出して… 難しい用語や設定は原作で… 補完！あースッキリした～

I like anime, and I was hesitant to read the original story, but I read up to 3 volumes. ... amazing (*'`) the screen that's hard to understand reminds me of the anime... the difficult terms and settings are in the original... complement! ah, that was refreshing~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 31, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

独特の世界にハマっていく

Become addicted to a unique world

ドンドン読みたくなります。難しいところもありますが、独特の世界観で面白いと思います。

It makes me want to read it. There are some difficult points, but I think it's interesting because of its unique view of the world.

Helpful

Reviews for Knights of Sidonia Manga