A Silent Voice Manga Reviews (P.11)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 16, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

映画観てからの原作！

Original story after watching the movie!

原作読まずに先に映画のほうを観て、あまりの感動に号泣したので原作も読破しました！映画では描かれてなかったニュアンスや細かい出来事など、余すところなく吸収して楽しめました。ホカホカする余韻がたまりません。

I watched the movie first without reading the original story, and I was so moved that I cried through the original story too! I was able to fully absorb and enjoy the nuances and details that were not depicted in the movie. The warm afterglow is irresistible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 08, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

漫画の方がいい

Manga is better

映画も話題となりましたが、やっぱり原作の方が詳細に描かれているのでいいと思いました。

The movie also became a hot topic, but after all, I thought it would be nice because the original story was depicted in more detail.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 08, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せになって欲しい。

I want them to be happy.

興味深いテーマなので読み続けたいと思っているのですが、ちょっと１巻で心が折られそうになりました。１巻だけだとは思うのですが、けしていじめが主題ではないのですが、読み進めるのにちょっと気合が必要…。

It's an interesting subject, so I want to keep reading, but I almost broke my heart after volume 1. I think it's only volume 1, but it's not about bullying, but I need a little bit of energy to read on...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 27, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けた

I was able to cry

基本1巻目からは泣けないのですが、泣けました。映画になっている理由が1巻目からでもわかりますよ。本当泣けます?読むときはハンカチとティッシュを用意ですね笑

Basically, I haven't been able to cry since volume 1, but I was able to cry. You can tell why it was made into a movie even from the first volume. can you really cry? I prepare handkerchiefs and tissues when I read lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 27, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

人の感情

Human emotions

This review contains spoilers. 主人公が、聴覚障害という理由だけでいじめられていて(いじめている人は、面白がっている)障害のある子がいじめられることが多いことがよくわかるし、いじめられた人は、そういうことが原因で人間不信になる可能性があることを、伝えてくれる作品でいろいろと考えさせられる、作品だと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. The main character is bullied only because he is deaf (people who bully them are amused), and I think it's a work that conveys that children with disabilities are often bullied, and that people who have been bullied may become distrustful of humans due to such things, and I thought it was a work that made me think about various things.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 23, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

<div>泣ける</div>

<div>I can cry</div>

最初は主人公ほんとクソで、何このやろーって思うんだけど、月日がたって出会ったときからの二人の関係がすごく切ないです。ヒロインがいい子過ぎます。

At first, the main character was really bad, and I wonder what this is, but the relationship between the two has been really sad since the months and days have passed since they met. The heroine is too nice.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 21, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

色々

various

考えさせられる作品です。主人公が小学生の頃やったことは許されることではないけれど、みんな形は違ってもこういう失敗を乗り越えて大人になっていくんだろうなぁ。何か自分が目をそらしてきた過去の失敗をえぐられるような気持ちになるけど、それが不快ではない不思議な作品です。

It's a work that makes me think. What the main character did when he was in elementary school isn't forgivable, but I wonder if everyone overcomes this kind of failure and becomes an adult, even if they are in different shapes. It's a strange work that makes me feel like I'm being gawed over past mistakes I've looked away from, but that's not uncomfortable.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 17, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

きれいな終わり方

A pretty way to end

This review contains spoilers. 上手く心理描写がかけていてひきこまれました。小さい時に自分のクラスにもらあったいじめを思い出しました。子どもだけど、学校の中に社会があって、その社会は大人になってもそんなに変わらなくて。さすが映画化にもなる漫画なぁと思います。最後は終わりはキレイだけど、もっと2人に進展があってもよかったんじゃないの？って思います。笑

This review contains spoilers. The psychological depiction was so good that I was drawn in. It reminded me of the bullying I received in my class when I was little. I'm a kid, but there's a society within the school, and that society hasn't changed that much even when I become an adult. As expected, I think it's a comic that can also be made into a movie. The end is beautiful at the end, but wouldn't it have been nice if 2 more people had made progress? I think so. lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 15, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

いじめって・・・

Bullying is...

いじめって、全くかかわらずに学校生活を送った人っていないと思います。被害者、加害者、傍観者によらず・・・だからこの登場人物の誰かには、自分と重ねられるんじゃないかな。過去の後悔は今に生かすべき！遅すぎることなんてない！！って思えると思います。

I don't think anyone lived their school life without getting involved in bullying at all. It doesn't depend on the victim, the perpetrator, or the bystanders... so I wonder if some of these characters will be able to overlap with me. You should make use of past regrets in the present! It's never too late!! I think that's what you think.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 12, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

有名だったので読みました

I read it because it was famous

映画にもなったので、漫画を読んでから観に行きました。キャラがどの子もリアルで魅力的だったりムカついたり(笑)で、作者さんの上手さを感じました！かわいさんが最後まで「あー、いるいるこんな子…」と思わせてくれました。ある意味で一番リアルかも(笑)

It was also made into a movie, so I read the manga before I went to see it. All of the characters were realistic, charming, and annoying (laughs), and I felt that the author was good at it! Cutie made me think “Oh, this girl exists...” until the end. Maybe it's the most real in a sense (lol)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 11, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

読みやすい

readable

女の子が可愛い。絵もストーリーも読みやすく、続きが読みたくなる。

The girls are cute. The pictures and story are easy to read, and it makes me want to read more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 06, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

映画も見ました

I also watched a movie

とにかく読み進めるのに気持ちが滅入るところもありますが、それを乗り越える二人や仲間たちの成長に見応えあり心が洗われます。

Anyway, there are places where my feelings are depressed as I read on, but the growth of the two people and their friends who overcome it is impressive, and it washes my heart.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 05, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

絵は好きでないですが…

I don't like pictures, but...

絵は好きでないですが、自分もいじめの経験があるので、うなずく事も多かったです。彼らの心の交流に涙が出ました。

I don't like painting, but I've also experienced bullying myself, so I often nodded. The exchange of their hearts brought tears to my eyes.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 04, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

This review contains spoilers. 考えさせられる話です。周りの感情や本人たちの葛藤が強く出ていて気持ちが高ぶる、あの言葉が忘れられないです。

This review contains spoilers. It's a thought provoking story. I can't forget those words that strongly express the emotions around me and the conflicts of the people themselves and make me feel so excited.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 02, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

想い。

feelings.

言葉は何も伝えない、想いが伝わる瞬間ってありますよね？そこまで行くには困難が付きまとうのですが、、。

There are moments when words don't convey anything, and feelings are conveyed, right? It's going to be difficult to get that far, but...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 02, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

◎

◎

よかったです。泣いた。心情とか描写もよく書かれてて映画を観た後に読んだのですがいろいろわかるところもあってよかった。最後もいい終わり方だったなって思いました、、

That was great. I cried. Feelings and descriptions are also well-written, and I read it after watching the movie, but I'm glad that there are many things I understand. I thought it was a good way to end at the end too...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 26, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

後半、ブレた？

Were you blurry in the second half?

This review contains spoilers. 中盤までの各キャラクターの心情の描き方は本当に細やかで素晴らしく、コミック全巻紙で揃えて一生平積みしておこうと思えるほどの気に入りっぷりだった。が。ヒロインが身投げしたあたりからストーリーがずれてしまった気がする。主人公が意識不明になった直後から周りのキャラの背景が群像劇的に展開されていくのだが、なんだか唐突に粗い(たとえば眉毛くんの背景とか。これだけの説明では、共感なんてできない。)友人たちと作り上げてきた映画の完成を以て物語を収束にもっていっていこうとしているが、肝心の映画には主人公もヒロインもイマイチ絡みきれていないし、映画のストーリーも、気持ちが重ならない。主人公が意識を取り戻した後はなんだか、テンポが悪い。本作には、『聴覚障害を主軸に据えて、過去な赦されない行いをしてしまった主人公がどう赦されてゆくか』をという展開を期待していたのだが。実際は、自らの酷い行いが災いして人間不信に陥ってしまった主人公が、如何に人間関係を再構築していくか、という物語だった。聴覚障害がただの舞台装置で終わってしまったのがなんとも残念。途中まで心酔していたから、このギャップが本当に残念。自分はファンにはなれなかったけれど、公式ファンブックを読んで作者意図だけはきちんと理解しておきたいと思う。

This review contains spoilers. The way the feelings of each character up to the middle are drawn was really detailed and wonderful, and I liked it so much that I thought I'd arrange all the comics on paper and lay them flat for the rest of my life. but. I feel like the story was off from where the heroine threw herself. Right after the main character becomes unconscious, the backgrounds of the surrounding characters unfold dramatically, but it's somehow abruptly rough (like the background of Eye-kun, for example. (I can't sympathize with this explanation alone.) I'm trying to bring the story to a conclusion with the completion of the film I've made with my friends, but neither the main character nor the heroine are completely entangled in the essential film, and the story of the movie doesn't overlap. Somehow the tempo is bad after the main character regains consciousness. I was expecting the development of “How the protagonist, who has committed unforgivable acts in the past, is forgiven, with hearing impairment as the main axis.” Actually, it was a story about how the protagonist, who had fallen into distrust of humanity due to his own terrible behavior, reconstructs human relationships. What a pity that my hearing impairment ended up being just a stage set. I was intoxicated until halfway through, so this gap is really disappointing. I wasn't able to become a fan, but I would like to read the official fan book and properly understand the author's intentions.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 07, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

胸にささる

Put it on your chest

全巻読みました！他の方のレビューにもあるように最後まで読まないとわからないお話虐めから色んな人達の色んな立ち位置によって考え方や生き方読む人によっては主人公側または友達側だったり最後まで読んでみてあんなに嫌な教師だと思っていた主人公達の小学校担任教師ですらもしかしたら、と全方向からの目線でも考えさせらました。コレがダメなんだとかだから良いのだとか良し悪しですら人によって変わる。普遍的にある大事なのは足掻き続ける姿だと私自身この歳になってもいつまでも悩み足掻き続けなければ！と共感できました。心に刺さる作品のひとつです。

I've read the whole volume! As you can see in other people's reviews, it made me think from an all-direction perspective, that you can't understand the story until the end, the way of thinking and way of life depending on the various positions of the various people, depending on who reads it, the protagonist's side or friend's side, or even the elementary school homeroom teacher of the main characters who read it until the end and thought it was such a disgusting teacher. Whether this is bad or good because it's good or bad changes from person to person. What is universally important is the figure of continuing to scratch my feet, and even at this age, I myself must keep worrying and scratching my feet forever! I was able to agree with you. It's one of those works that stick to my heart.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

漫画でこんなに泣いたのは初めて。

This is the first time I've cried this much in a comic.

映画が高評価なので興味持ち、youtubeで予告見た後こらえきれず漫画全巻購入しました。障害、イジメと重いテーマを扱っていますが、罪を背負い続け、謙虚な気持ちで硝子ちゃんに向き合う将也を見て、二巻目からはだいぶ心軽やかに読めました。花より男子が大嫌いな私はいじめの加害者と被害者が恋愛関係になるなんて到底理解できず反感を抱いてました。でもこの主人公の将也は罪悪感がヒシヒシと伝わり、贖罪をし続け、硝子ちゃんだけなく周囲からの信頼を勝ち取る所が素晴らしい。いじめておきながら何事もなかったかのように引っ付く花男とはまるで違っていて過去の罪を許せる。山場では涙が自然と溢れてきました。最後は素直に二人を応援できる気持ちにさせてくれる青春漫画だったと思います。ただ、まだ完結しちゃダメ。この先が見たかった！という不満もあります。だから星4つで。

The movie was highly rated, so I was interested, and after watching the preview on YouTube, I couldn't hold back and bought all the comics. It deals with heavy themes such as disability and bullying, but I was able to read it quite lightly from the second volume when I saw Masaya, who continues to carry sins and faces Glass with a humble feeling. I hate boys over flowers, and I felt antipathy because I couldn't understand at all that the perpetrator and victim of bullying would have a romantic relationship. However, it is wonderful that Masaya, the main character, has a sense of guilt conveyed to him, continues to atone for his sins, and wins the trust not only of Glass but also of those around him. He's completely different from Hanao, who bullies him but sticks around as if nothing had happened, and he can forgive his past sins. Tears naturally overflowed in the mountains. At the end, I think it was a youth comic that made me feel like I could honestly support them. However, it can't be completed yet. I wanted to see the future! There is also a complaint about that. So with 4 stars.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 16, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

後悔先に立たず

Don't stand ahead of regrets

This review contains spoilers. いじめの罪の深さに気付いた主人公、いくら後悔しても反省しても、犯した罪は消えません…傷は残ります…て話ですか。絵も好きで、面白かったのでどんどん読めましたが、どこか胸糞悪い気持ちは、ずっと残りました。最後まで植野の良さは分かりませんでした。なんでもかんでも気持ちをぶっちゃける事と、心を開く、という事は違うのです。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story about the protagonist who realizes the depth of the crime of bullying, and no matter how much he regrets or reflects, the crime he committed won't go away... his scars will remain... I also liked pictures, and they were interesting, so I was able to read more and more, but the feeling of being somewhat heartbroken remained for a long time. I didn't know how good Ueno was until the end. There is a difference between breaking your mind about anything and opening your heart.

Helpful

Reviews for A Silent Voice Manga