MangaPlaza

Sorry! You need an account to do that! Sign up now to get the most out of your MangaPlaza experience!

Register For Free!

Already registered?

All

Romance

MP Originals

Action

BL

Adult Romance

Yuri

Fantasy

Drama

Horror

Harlequin

Light Novels

|

Find Titles

Search Menu

Search by Genre

Explore Premium

New
Best Sellers
SALE
Coupon
Now Free

Search by Popular Keywords

Others

Search by Author

Special Collections

Reviews for Which Hana? Manga

Overall :

4.7

135 Global Ratings

5 star

73%
4 star

27%
3 star

0%
2 star

0%
1 star

0%

101 - 120 of 130 Reviews

Sort by

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

Translate All Reviews to English

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

前向きな一歩

A positive step

This review contains spoilers. 山田花ちゃんの体を借りて高校生として生活することで、自分を見つめ丁寧に生きようとする来生花さん。二人の人格や記憶がクロスすることで、お互いに自分よりも相手を尊重し、前を向くことができて良かった。花さんにはチカが、花ちゃんにはハルさんがそれぞれ寄り添い力になってくれるでしょう。現象としては不思議な出来事ではあるが、そこは敢えてツッコまない方向で。

This review contains spoilers. By borrowing Yamada Hana's body and living as a high school student, Kisuki Hana looks at herself and tries to live carefully. Since their personalities and memories intersect, it was nice to be able to respect each other more than themselves and look forward. Chika will be close to Hana, and Haru will be there to help Hana. As a phenomenon, it is a strange event, but it is in a direction where they dare not get bogged down.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 05, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

入れ替わり方が新しい！！

The replacement method is new!!

よくある男女の入れ替わりよりも断然面白かった。花さんが花ちゃんのためにあれこれ頑張ってる姿がやさぐれてた花さんとは思えないよねw。2人の花が前向きになろうとしてる姿に元気をもらえました。ちなみに私は菊子さんが大好きです！

It was definitely more interesting than the usual exchange of men and women. The sight of Hana working so hard for Hana-chan doesn't seem like Hana was easy lol. I was energized by the sight of the two flowers trying to be positive. Incidentally, I love Kikuko!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

設定が面白い

The setting is interesting

This review contains spoilers. ストーリーの設定が凝っていて面白いです。同じ作者さんの琉球ファンタジー風の作品も読んでいますが、入れ替わり系&年下男子が得意ジャンルなのかな？普通に考えると入れ替わったことに気づいた時点でまず最初に自分の安否を確認する気がしますが、そこは漫画ということで深く考えずにラストまで楽しみました。

This review contains spoilers. The story setting is elaborate and interesting. I've also read Ryukyu Fantasy-style works by the same author, but I wonder if alternative genres and younger boys are good at? When I think about it normally, I feel like I'll check my safety first when I notice that it has been replaced, but since it's a comic, I enjoyed it until the end without thinking too much about it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった、その後チラッと読みたい！

Great, I want to take a quick read after that!

とにかくよかったです?。最後は、もうちょい続き読みたかった～番外編とか希望します‼お願いしたいです?

it was good anyway?. Finally, I wanted to keep reading it a little longer ~ I want an extra edition or something ‼ I want to ask for it?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 20, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

This review contains spoilers. 元に戻ってあげたい気持ちと戻りたくない気持ちの描写が切ない。

This review contains spoilers. The depiction of the feeling that I want to go back to normal and the feeling that I don't want to go back is sad.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 07, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

作者買い

Buy the artist

小田原先生のお話が好きで読み始めましたがあっという間に６巻…！すこし重たい話ですが、明るいテンポの良い会話も含んでいるのでどんどん読み進められます。ハルさんチカくん花ちゃん花さん、みんな幸せになって欲しいですが、どうなるのか続きが気になります。

I liked Odawara-sensei's stories and started reading them, but in no time there were 6 volumes...! It's a bit heavy story, but it also contains bright, well-paced conversation, so I can read on. I want everyone to be happy, Haru-san, Chika-kun, Hana-san, and I'm worried about what will happen.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 20, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

どっちに⁉

Which way ⁉

読み始めたら、止まらなくなりました。最後はどうなるのか、花だけじゃなく、見守る2人のイケメンの今後が気になります。

Once I started reading it, I couldn't stop. What will happen at the end, I'm worried not only about the flowers, but also about the future of the two handsome men watching.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 20, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ドキドキ

pounding

凄く気になる作品！花ちゃんはどうなるの〜？気になって仕方ありません。早く続きが見たいです！

I'm really interested in this work! What's going to happen to Hana? I can't help but be worried. I want to see the continuation soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 27, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

どっちの花が残る？

Which flowers will remain?

This review contains spoilers. 前の花とハルくん、今の花とチカくん、どっちも上手くいって欲しいけど花が融合し始めた？そうするとハルくんとチカくんのどちらか選ばなくてはいけないのかな？ただキスギさんがまだ実家に帰って本当に死んだか確認してないのでそこが気になるところですね

This review contains spoilers. I want both the previous flower and Haru-kun, and the current flower and Chika-kun to go well, but have the flowers started fusing? Then I wonder if I have to choose between Haru-kun and Chika-kun? However, Kisugi hasn't been back to her parents' house yet to confirm if she really died, so that's something I'm worried about

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 21, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い設定

An interesting setting

入れ替わりの設定で面白い。ミステリー好きな人は読んで楽しめると思います。まだまだいろいろな謎が多くて、気になる。どういうエンドでまとまるのか楽しみです。

The alternate settings are interesting. I think people who like mysteries will enjoy reading it. There are still so many mysteries that I'm curious. I'm looking forward to seeing what kind of end it all comes together.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

結末が気になる

I'm worried about the ending

久しぶりに読み返しました。また楽しめました、まだ完結してなかった？内容が現実離れしてるところ(精神の入れ替わり？)のでどんな終わり方もありそうで、本当の花ちゃんは戻ってくるのかなとか、想像したりして。

I reread it after a long time. I enjoyed it again, wasn't it finished yet? Where the content is far from reality (change of mind?) So it seems like it could end in any way, and I was imagining that the real Hana would come back.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが〜

Continued~

早く読みたいです花さん花ちゃん、どちらもハッピーエンドになるといいけど。入れ替わる展開は多々ありますが、これは面白いです

I want to read Hana San Hana soon, I hope both have happy endings. There are many developments that are being replaced, but this is interesting

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 10, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる〜！！

I'm worried about the continuation!!

ザ少女！みたいなお話が歳を取って苦手になってきたのですが(笑)、こちらは軽いミステリー要素もあり楽しめました！何よりもチカくんが良すぎる！ただ、確かに展開がやや遅く感じるのでそこが気になりました…が、長く続いても伏線回収して完結してくれるなら良いかな。今後の展開も楽しみにしています(*＾＾*)

the girl! I'm not good at stories like that as I've gotten older (laughs), but this one also has a light mystery element, so I enjoyed it! Above all else, Chika-kun is too good! However, it certainly feels like the development is a bit slow, so I was worried about that... but even if it continues for a long time, it would be nice if they could collect foreshadowing and complete it. I'm also looking forward to future developments (*^^*)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 09, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

謎もあって面白いです作者さんの女の子は可愛くてさっぱり前向きで男の子はイケメンだったり一生懸命可愛いで大好きです続きが気になります

There's also a mystery and it's interesting. I love the author's girl because she's cute and fresh and positive, and the boy is so handsome and cute, I'm curious about the continuation

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

末恐ろしい

Terrible

This review contains spoilers. チカ君がホントに末恐ろしい‥!花ちゃんの過去はかなり深刻そうだけど戻れれば両思い？一方で花さんは悲恋になっちゃうのかしらネアカのチカ君の失恋はみたくないなしかし、男子高校生のチカ君と花さんは応援したいけど高２にときめく２０代後半男性はちょっとキモいと思ってしまう勝手ですいません

This review contains spoilers. chika-kun is really horrible...! Hana's past seems pretty serious, but if we can go back, will we have both feelings? On the other hand, I wonder if Hana becomes a sad love, I don't want to see Chika from Neaka's heartbreak, but male high school students Chika and Hana want to cheer but men in their late 20s who are excited about high 2 think it's a bit creepy

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 27, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

チカちゃんかわゆす

Chika-chan is cute

入れ替わりものは多いですが、ヒーロー役が二人とも入れ替わりを把握しているのは面白いですね。しかしハルさんとチカちゃん、イケメンです。

There are a lot of replacements, but it's interesting that both of the hero characters know how to replace them. However, Haru and Chika-chan are good-looking guys.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 10, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

なんだか切ない、でもあったかい

It's kind of sad, but warm

三巻までは入れ替わりという非現実的な中で、キュンもありのお話しで何となく気に入り読んでましたが、四巻は内容が濃い！友情やヒトとの関わり方、誰かを想う気持ち…ハマりました。続きが待ち遠しいです。

It's an unrealistic story where up to volume 3 is being replaced, and I somehow liked it and read it, but volume 4 has a lot of content! Friendships, relationships with people, feelings of thinking about someone... I'm addicted to it. I can't wait for the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ハルチカくん

Haruchika-kun

This review contains spoilers. 鋭い！よく見てくれてるし、ダメな部分もわかってくれて好きと言ってくれてるので、なんとかハルチカ君を好きになってハッピーエンドになって欲しいと思ってます！ハルキさんは、両想いなんでしょうけど、なんか自分本位な気がして…オススメしません。笑

This review contains spoilers. sharp! They've been watching closely, and they've understood the bad parts and said they like it, so I want them to somehow fall in love with Haruchika-kun and have a happy ending! Haruki probably has both feelings, but I feel like she's self-centered... I don't recommend it. lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

花

Flower

以前の主人公の境遇が可哀想ですが、今の生活で報われてくれたらいいです。

The circumstances of the protagonist before are pitiful, but it would be nice if his current life paid off.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

キュンキュン

Kyun Kyun

イケメン2人と花ちゃんのやりとりが楽しくてほっこりしますし、ときめきをばら撒かれた時はキュンキュンします。これからの展開がドキドキで気になります。

The interaction between the two handsome guys and Hana is fun and makes me feel relaxed, and it makes me cringe when their crushes are scattered around. I'm excited and curious about future developments.

Helpful

Stay Connected!

Subscribe to
Our Newsletter
Add to
Home Screen
Our Premium
Membership
Instagram

Other Social Media：X | X(BL) | Facebook | Youtube | TikTok

Register For Free!