Which Hana? Manga Reviews (P.5)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 07, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

いやはや

Iyahaya

羨ましい体験ですなっ！なんか…ハラハラしながらどんどん読み続けてました。

It was an enviable experience! Somehow... I was still reading more and more in jarring.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 22, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

28OLが階段から落ちて気が付くと女性高校生になっていてしかし同じ名前だということそこから始まる恋愛。男の子が素敵すぎてきゅんきゅんします。自分がこの世にいないとしって本当のハナちゃんが戻ってくるときのために準備しているなんていい人すぎるやろと思ってしまします。不思議な話だけど続きが読みたくなる作品です。皆幸せになってほしいそんな物語です。

When 28 OL falls down the stairs and notices, they are female high school students, but they have the same name, so the romance begins there. The boy is so nice that he whines. It makes me think that even if I'm not in this world, I'm too nice to be preparing for when the real Hana comes back. It's a strange story, but it's a work that makes me want to read more. It's a story where I want everyone to be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 21, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

どっちも?

both?

イケメン2人からとかほんまにずるいやろ！！私も混ぜておくれーー?

Starting with 2 handsome guys is really sly!! can you mix it up too?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 23, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

初恋ダブルエッジをみてとんできました。この話も非常に好きです、個人的には完全に晴親くん推しです！なので希望としては晴親くんと結ばれてほしい！！

I've been watching Hatsukoi Double Edge. I also really like this story; personally, I totally recommend Haruchika-kun! So as a matter of hope, I want them to tie up with Haruchika-kun!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 29, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ワクワクします。

I'm excited.

謎が散りばめられていて、とても面白いです。今後どうなるのか読めないので、一番続きが気になります。登場人物が皆良い子なので、そういう意味でもストレスなく読めると思います。

It's full of mysteries, and it's very interesting. I can't read what's going to happen in the future, so I'm worried about the continuation. All of the characters are good kids, so I think I can read it without stress even in that sense.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 30, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

男性キャラがカッコいい?

are male characters cool?

この作者さんの作品は、男性キャラの絵も行動がカッコいいのでキュンときます?ありそうでなかったストーリーで、どういう結末になるのか…気になります！

In this artist's work, the pictures of male characters are also cool in their actions, so it's exciting? It's an unlikely story, and I wonder how it will end... I'm curious!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーリー展開が楽しみ

I'm looking forward to the story development

小田原先生の絵が大好きで、過去の作品も読みました。今回も素敵で、続きが気になって仕方ありません?

I love Odawara-sensei's paintings, and I've read his past works. It was wonderful this time too, can't help but be curious about the continuation?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる！

I'm worried about the continuation!

入れ替わった二人がどうなるのか、とっても気になります。続きが楽しみ♪

I'm really curious about what will happen to the two people who have been replaced. I'm looking forward to the continuation ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

三角…ん～四角関係かな？面白いね！

triangle... huh... square relationship? That's interesting!

This review contains spoilers. 元の自分が死んでるってことは…もう戻るってことはない感じがするなぁ。。。受け入れて生きていくって感じなのかなぁ…まだ1刊だけなのにすでにラストが気になる！！！戻らない前提として、個人的には花ちゃん×チカちゃんでくっついて欲しいなぁ。

This review contains spoilers. The fact that my original self is dead... I feel like I'm never going back... I wonder if it's like accepting and living... I'm already worried about the last one even though it's only the 1st edition!!! As an assumption that they won't go back, I personally want Hana-chan and Chika-chan to stick together.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 19, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

花

Flower

面白かった。絵もすごく好き。男の子二人がかっこよすぎ。話も面白くて早く続きが読みたいです。

That was interesting. I also really like pictures. The two boys are too cool. The story is also interesting and I want to read more soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

This review contains spoilers. 設定はありがちだけど、かなり面白い。入れ替わり事故で、本当の自分が死んでいると言う設定が、もとの花ちゃんに戻ると、自分が死んだことになるので、消えてしまう。今のはなちゃんに、迷惑がかからないように、一生懸命生きようとする主人公が、素敵！これから先、2人の男の子のどちらかが花ちゃんをゲットするのかと思うと、ドキドキが止まらないです。

This review contains spoilers. The settings tend to be tricky, but it's pretty interesting. The setting that says that my true self is dead due to a replacement accident, but when I return to my original Hana, it means that I have died, so it disappears. The main character who tries to live her life so as not to bother Hana-chan now is wonderful! I can't stop being excited when I think that either of the two boys will get Hana from now on.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

さすが、小田原先生。ハラハラ、ドキドキ。この先、花が周りの人達とどうなるのか期待。

As expected, Odawara sensei. I'm so excited. I'm looking forward to seeing what Hana will do with the people around her in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が可愛くて面白い

The picture is cute and interesting

This review contains spoilers. ネタとしてはありがちですが、絶対に面白く料理されるはず…と思いながら読み進めたら、やっぱり面白い。ただの入れ替わりじゃなかった。生きられるのはどちらか一人で、当然花ちゃんの方。身体を失った花さん、魂の居場所が分からない花ちゃん、それぞれの事情が気になります。絵が可愛く、甘いシーンの見せ方がとても素敵な作家さんなので、恋の行方も楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. It's easy to use as a topic, but if you read on while thinking that it should definitely be cooked in an interesting way... it's still interesting. It wasn't just a replacement. Of course, Hana is the only one who can live. I'm worried about the circumstances of Hana, who lost her body, and Hana, who doesn't know where her soul is. The pictures are cute, and the artist has a very nice way of showing sweet scenes, so I'm also looking forward to the whereabouts of love.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 15, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ややこしいけど面白い?

Confusing but interesting?

This review contains spoilers. 見た目は高校生、中身は28歳って、コ◯ンくん風やけど、こっちは外見と中身が他人だからややこしい。イケメンたちと三角関係は、羨ましいけどやっぱりややこしい??

This review contains spoilers. It looks like a high school student, and the inside is 28 years old, so it's a bit confusing because the exterior and contents are different people. I envy the love triangle with handsome guys, but it's still complicated??

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 05, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

中身28歳なのにイケメンと女子高生ライフ

Inside: Life as a high school girl with a handsome guy even though she's 28 years old!

28歳が女子高生の体になるというあらすじが気になって購入してしまいました。まだ1巻しか出ていないので、気になる要素がいっぱいでまだまだ先が長そうな印象。階段から落ちたら、別人の体になってしまっていたという所から物語が始まる今作。本物の女子高生である山田花ちゃんの意識は一体どこへ行ってしまったのか？この物語自体どういう風に終わるのか？気になることがいっぱいです。山田花ちゃんになってしまった主人公は、実際は28歳で、上司にも恵まれず彼氏にも恵まれず人生そのものに嫌気がさしていた現代社会に生きる女性でした。それがいきなり女子高生として生活を送ることになり、別人だけど山田花ちゃんのフリをするしかなくて戸惑いつつも生田荘の住人である(本来)年下なイケメンに不覚にもドキドキしてしまって振り回されたりと、28歳視点で女子高生生活を送れるこの状況には、主人公の思考に共感が持ててドキドキします。私も花ちゃんになって彼らと共同生活がしてみたいです(笑)しかし本物の花ちゃんに体をお返ししたいという目的が果たされるのか等、恋をしているどころじゃない問題が山積み。恋をしちゃっても本来の自分の体ではないし、本物の花ちゃんを差し置いて恋人なんて作れるわけないし…色々とどうするんだろう？と先が気になってます。優しい陽希さんは素敵だしわりと距離詰めてくる感じにドキドキするし、それでいて本物の花ちゃんに関して何か秘密を知っていそうなところも気になります。でもそれ以上に花ちゃんの同級生である晴親くんの、ズケズケ物言うけど意外と優しいやつで、変わり者っぽいけど真っ直ぐな性格で、今の花が花ちゃんの為に前向きに頑張っている姿を見て好きになってくれたことにキュンキュンしました。1巻ラストの積極性にはやられました。ないないない男子高校生だぞ？！本来の自分だったら犯罪だぞ？！てかこれ花ちゃんの体だぞ？！と2巻から悩むことになる花さんを想像して今から楽しみなわけです(笑)元よりこんなイケメンに囲まれて女子高ライフ送ってた山田花ちゃんが羨ましい！でも本物の花ちゃんが幸せだと思ってたとは限らない…事故にあった時の主人公のように、消えてしまいたいと思ってた可能性もあることが今後のポイントかなと思っています。次巻が今から待ち遠しいです。

I bought it because I was curious about the synopsis of 28 Years Old Becomes a High School Girl. Since only 1 volume has been released, there are a lot of worrisome elements, and I have the impression that there is still a long way to go. In this film, the story begins where when you fall down the stairs, you end up in a different person's body. Where on earth did Yamada Hana, who is a real high school girl, go to her consciousness? How does this story itself end? There are a lot of things I'm worried about. The main character, who became Yamada Hana, is actually 28 years old, and she was a woman living in modern society who was disgusted with life itself because she wasn't blessed with a boss or a boyfriend. Suddenly, she lived her life as a high school girl, and while being confused, she was unwittingly excited and swayed by a handsome (originally) younger (originally) person who is a resident of Ikutasou, and while being bewildered, I can sympathize with the protagonist's thoughts and live a high school girl life from a 28-year-old perspective, and I'm thrilled. I also want to become Hana and live together with them (laughs), but there are a lot of issues that aren't about being in love, such as whether the purpose of wanting to return my body to the real Hana will be fulfilled. Even if I fall in love, it's not my original body, and there's no way I can make a lover other than my real Hana... what do I do with various things? I'm worried about the future. I'm excited to hear that the kind Haruki is being nice and close the distance, and even so, I'm curious that she seems to know some secrets about the real Hana. But even more than that, I was amazed to see how Hana's classmate Haruchika-kun is surprisingly kind, and has an eccentric yet straight personality, and I fell in love with it when I saw how Hana is working hard in a positive way now for Hana. I was taken aback by the aggressiveness at the end of volume 1. Nai Nai Nai, they're high school boys, right?! wouldn't it be a crime if I were my true self?! this is Hana's body isn't it?! Imagine Hana, who will be troubled from volume 2, and I'm looking forward to it now (lol) I envy Yamada Hana, who has been living a girls' high school life surrounded by such handsome guys since before! But I don't necessarily think the real Hana was happy... I think the point for the future is that there is also a possibility that she wanted to disappear, like the main character when she had an accident. I can't wait for the next volume.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 13, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

どうなるんだろう？とハラハラ

What's going to happen? and harahara

これって最後どうなるんだろう？とハラハラしました。ヒロインが陰気な性格のようなスタートで共感できるか不安だったけど、前向きな素敵な人で、応援する気持ちで読み進めました。元彼もそんなにひどい人じゃなかったし、それぞれの思いが通じてよかった！

What will happen at the end of this? I was so excited. I was worried about whether I could sympathize with the heroine's brooding start, but she is a wonderful, positive person, and I read on with a feeling of support. My ex-boyfriend wasn't that bad either, and I'm glad our thoughts came through!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

おおお

Oooh

すごく良かったです。どういう話なのか？？っていう感じでスタートしましたが、最後までテンポある進み方で面白かったです。

It was really good. What kind of story is this?? It started with that feeling, but it was interesting because it progressed at a tempo until the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

楽しめる

I can enjoy

This review contains spoilers. 何が起こるのか気になって仕方なかったです。楽しめました。人の繋がり、生き方、価値観…それぞれ違ってて良い。自分が自分を認めれます様に。

This review contains spoilers. I couldn't help but wonder what was going to happen. I enjoyed it. Human connections, ways of life, values... it's good that each one is different. May I acknowledge myself.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

最初は面白い

It's funny at first

はじめの方はとても面白いです。色々な伏線がはられるので、それを考えるのも楽しい。ただ、４巻目辺りから恋愛部分がほとんど同じストーリーになってるので星はひとつ減らしました。

The beginning is very interesting. There are many kinds of foreshadowing, so it's fun to think about them. However, since the romance part is almost the same story from around volume 4, the number of stars has been reduced by 1.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 12, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

どうまとまるのかな。こうまとまるのかな？

I wonder how it will come together. I wonder if it will come together like this?

面白いですよ。ただ、読めば読むほど、ややこしくなってきました。謎と過去に恋愛もあり、読み応えある分、体力使います。でも花さんつっこみ上手だし、男子2人は意外とぐいぐいで、やり取り楽しかったです

It's interesting. However, the more I read it, the more complicated it became. There are also mysteries and love affairs in the past, and I use my physical strength as much as I can read it. But Hana was good at sticking around, and the two boys were surprisingly good-looking, so it was fun to interact

Helpful

Reviews for Which Hana? Manga