Sister and Giant: A Young Lady Is Reborn in Another World

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  ヤベー匂いのダークファンタジー
  Dark fantasy with a bad smell
  This review contains spoilers. 百合の香、醸すストーリー、隻腕ヒロインに、広島弁の巨人。登場人物達が皆、刹那的で破滅型。どこか、松本次郎の作品の様な設定、好みです。

  This review contains spoilers. A lily incense, brewing story, a talented heroine, and a giant in the Hiroshima dialect. The characters are all instantaneous and ruinous. Somehow, the setting is like Jiro Matsumoto's work, and I like it.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jul 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English
  強烈なアンチテンプレもの
  Strong anti-template stuff
  まりみてっぽい設定の姉妹関係を絡めた異世界転生もの、という、一見するとアイディアだけの量産異世界ものに見える。しかし、読み進めていくにつれてその印象はいい意味で違和感と裏切りで塗り替えられていく。こうなるだろうというテンプレがことごとく否定されていく展開に鳥肌が立ち、期待通りにその信条を、仁義、誇りを貫いていく展開に熱くなる。主人公姉妹やその周囲は微笑ましく尊く描かれている反面、この異世界の社会システムは差別・踏みにじられる弱者・喰いものにされる異世界チート等、ダークファンタジー的な世界観で満たされている。異世界転生ものとしてトップクラスに面白い逸品。

  At first glance, it looks like a mass-produced otherworldly thing with only an idea, called an Isekai Reincarnation involving a sister relationship with a Marimite-like setting. However, as I read on, that impression was repainted by a sense of incongruity and betrayal in a good sense. I get goosebumps at the development where all of the templates that say this is going to happen are denied, and I get heated by the development where they stick to that belief, humanity, and pride as expected. On the other hand, the main character sisters and their surroundings are depicted with a smile and dignity, but this otherworldly social system is filled with a dark fantasy worldview, such as the weak who are discriminated against, trampled upon, and otherworldly cheats. A top-class and interesting gem as being reincarnated in another world.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Dec 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English
  ハイファンタジーの世界に転生のような
  It's like being reincarnated in a high fantasy world
  This review contains spoilers. 2巻目にして興味深い設定も盛り込まれ、なかなかどうして引き込まれます。例えばご都合主義の俺強い系異世界モノだと他の作品で類を見ない能力を持つ主人公とその主人公を取り巻く環境（ハーレム等の人間関係含む）にフォーカスが当たりがちですが、この作品では異世界転生者は稀ながら存在するものとして、転生先世界が彼らをどう扱うのか、その辺の設定がきちんと作りこまれた上でストーリーが展開されています。SF作品で作りこみの弱い設定を見ると不快感を覚える人も多いかと思いますが、私は異世界系でも同様に作りこんでいてほしいと思う側なので、その点この作品はとても好印象でした。続巻も確実に買います。

  This review contains spoilers. Interesting settings are also included in the second volume, and why is it so drawn in. For example, the focus is on the protagonist who has unrivaled abilities in other works and the environment (including human relationships such as harems) that surround the protagonist with unparalleled abilities, but in this work, the story unfolds after setting how the reincarnated world treats them properly. I think there are many people who feel uncomfortable when they see a poorly crafted setting in a sci-fi film, but I'm on the side of the side where I want them to be made in the same way in other worlds, so I had a very good impression on this work in that respect. I will definitely buy the next volume.

  Helpful