VERMEIL IN GOLD: THE FAILING STUDENT AND THE STRONGEST SCOURGE PLUNGE INTO THE WORLD OF MAGIC

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Nov 14, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  涙なしでは
  Without tears
  This review contains spoilers. アニメは見るたびに泣いてましたね。最初の方は、いかにも男の夢というか都合がよくエロもたっぷり、に見えるのですが、話進んでいくとヴェルメイの過去とかアルトとの愛とか、もう涙なしでは見られない展開になっていきます。最初の方でやめないで読み進めて欲しいです。漫画も絵がすっきりしていて綺麗で読みやすいです。

  This review contains spoilers. I cried every time I watched anime. At the beginning, it seems like a man's dream, or rather convenient and full of eroticism, but as the story progresses, things like Vermey's past and love with Alto become developments that cannot be seen without tears anymore. I hope you don't stop at the beginning and read on. The pictures in the comics are also clean and easy to read.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jun 11, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  王道ファンタジーとは？
  What is royal fantasy?
  作画は良い、魅せるコマをしっかりと見せる。エロも少年漫画らしく本番は見せない、ショタの元ネタの鉄◯28号だって少年漫画。ショタは永遠の王道なのか？

  The drawing is good, and it clearly shows off the attractive frames. Erotica also seems to be a shonen manga, and the actual performance isn't shown; even Shota's original story, Tetsu ◯28, is a shonen comic. Is Shota the eternal royal road?

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English
  女性向け？
  for women?
  This review contains spoilers. 掲載誌や登場人物、表紙やサンプルのみを見ると、エロいおねえさんとかわいいショタが主役のおねショタ漫画で、一見男性向けに見えたのですが、読んでみたらファンタジーとバトル要素のあるラブコメで、ヒロインには暗い過去があり、主人公が成長してそれを救うお話でした。エロいシーンもありますが、主人公とヒロインの関係性や心理描写が中心になるので、どちらかといえば女性にウケそうな漫画だと思いました。エロいおねえさんや積極的な可愛い女の子が好きなので個人的にはとても楽しめましたが、そういう要素を苦手とする女性も多いので、女性にウケそうなのに女性ウケが悪そうで、かといって男性向けにも振り切れていないところでターゲット層が絞られてしまって、もったいないなと思いました。ヴェルメイさんがとても可愛くて、アルトはカッコよくて、二人がお互いを想い合うシーンはとても泣けました。続きが楽しみです。

  This review contains spoilers. When I looked only at the magazines, characters, covers, and samples, it was a Ne-Shota comic with an erotic sister and cute Shota in the lead roles, and at first glance it looked like it was aimed at men, but when I read it, it was a romantic comedy with fantasy and battle elements, and the heroine had a dark past, and it was a story where the main character grew up and saved it. There are also erotic scenes, but since the relationship and psychological depiction between the main character and the heroine are at the center, I thought it would be a comic that would be good for women. I personally enjoyed it a lot because I like erotic girls and aggressive cute girls, but there are many women who don't like such elements, so even though they seem to be good for women, women seem to be bad, and yet the target audience was narrowed down to places where they weren't completely swayed by men, and I thought it would be a waste. Vermey was so cute, Alto was cool, and the scene where the two had feelings for each other made me cry so much. I'm looking forward to the continuation.

  Helpful