The Man, the Ring, the Wedding

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jan 08, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English
  過去と決別する 確執を乗り越えていく愛
  Breaking up with the past, overcoming feuds, love
  綺麗な絵で、HQならこういうこと、という期待に応えて収まりがしっくりくる。室内の装飾的な描写にアメリカ-モダンよりヨーロッピアンクラシックな感じが漂って、ストーリーの中心の舞台であるホテルが、存在感がある。丁寧な表現をされているので、放置されていた古いホテルを改修して甦る過程とその結果のオープニングセレモニーの光景が、薄っぺらな脇役でない。登場人物の人物の描かれたコマにも心配りがあり、HQによくある雑にこなした感じがここではしない。絵がきれいだということがどれ程このジャンルのコミックには重要かがよく解る。真面目すぎて、少しくだけようとした場面で一ヶ所(81頁)、そこまで崩すことが必要とは思えなかった。その一本調子に変化を持たせるならば、カメラアイの意外性や映し出される物の(指輪は十分です)選択に関する遊びがあった方が寧ろ良かったように思う。

  It's a beautiful picture, and it fits perfectly in response to expectations that HQ would do something like this. The decorative depictions of the interior have a European classic feel rather than American-modern, and the hotel, which is the central setting of the story, has a strong presence. Since it is carefully expressed, the process of renovating and reviving an old hotel that had been abandoned and the scene of the opening ceremony as a result is not a flimsy supporting role. There are also concerns about the frames drawn by the characters, and the sloppy feeling common in HQ isn't here. I can clearly understand how important beautiful pictures are in this genre of comics. It was so serious that I didn't think it was necessary to break it down that far in one place (page 81) in a scene where I was just trying to do it a little bit. If I were to change that state of affairs, I think it would have been better if there was a game about the unexpectedness of the camera eye and the choice of the object to be projected (the ring is enough).

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Mar 12, 2011 (PST) | Translate to English
  ❤
  ❤
  運命と愛と生きていく為の思いが絡んでいく様がどきどきします。こんな愛があれば、生きていけますね❤

  It's exciting to see fate, love, and thoughts for living intertwined. If you have this kind of love, you can live ❤

  Helpful