SILENT KNIGHT

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jun 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English
  キャヴェンディッシュ家シリーズ
  The Cavendish Family
  This review contains spoilers. シリーズものなのでガイの両親や兄が出てきますが、他作品を知らなくても楽しめます。喋らない修道士見習い＆お喋りなお姫様が恋に落ちる過程が面白いし、殆どのHQヒーローの「ぼくを誘惑してるんだな魔女め！」みたいなモノローグにはムカつくんですが（ヒロイン何もしてないし）なぜか微笑ましく可愛かったです。騎士だったので強いし、でも久しぶりなのでちゃんと訓練もして、ヒロインを不安にさせない配慮もできてと、流石の優秀さ。顔知らない騎士を好きになるってどうなんだ？とは思いましたが、顔より立ち振る舞いに人間性って出ますもんね。良いお話でした。もうちょっと生えかけのトンスラとかを楽しみたかった気が…。笑

  This review contains spoilers. Since it's a series, Guy's parents and older brother will appear, but you can enjoy it even if you don't know any other works. The process of the unspoken monk apprentice and talkative princess falling in love is interesting, and almost all of the HQ heroes “You're Seducing Me, Witch!” I'm annoyed by a monologue like that (the heroine didn't do anything), but for some reason it was smiling and cute. She was a knight, so she was strong, but since it's been a long time, she trained properly, and was able to take care not to make the heroine feel uneasy, which is amazing. How about falling in love with a faceless knight? I thought so, but humanity comes out more in how you act than your face. That was a good story. I feel like I wanted to enjoy the almost grown tonsura a little more... lol

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jun 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English
  よみほでしたが…
  It was Yomiho, but...
  This review contains spoilers. ヒロイン＆ヒーローのキャラも面白いし、なによりストーリー展開が面白く、その上、ヒストリカルに大切な衣装や建築物の描き込みが素晴らしくて、とてもお得な気分になった読後感でした。この後購入しようかと思っているほど、お気に入りになりました。

  This review contains spoilers. The heroine and hero characters were also interesting, and above all, the story development was interesting, and on top of that, the depictions of historically important costumes and buildings were wonderful, and I felt like it was a great deal after reading. I loved it so much that I thought I'd buy it later.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Dec 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English
  あの頭トンスラって言うんだぁ‼
  That head is called tonsura ‼
  中世ものは野蛮だけど妙にしきたりがあってそれがドラマを作り出している。今回は天使と見まごうトンスラ（で残念な）ヒーロー（修道士：実は見習い）の存在が良かった。ヒーローはヒロインの誘惑（彼女は意識的ではなく）に負けないように沈黙の誓いをさせられるのだけど、それが逆にセリフではなく真実の心の声で描かれるから感情移入しやすかった。ヒロインも中世女子らしくたくましくって共感する。騎馬試合も正々堂々たる懲悪にも（多分逆もありだろうけど）役立つんだなと思った。HQで歴史勉強それだけ原作がしっかりしている上、作画先生（私買いです）の力量がモノ言っているんだよね。

  Medieval stuff is barbaric, but it has strange conventions, and that creates dramas. The presence of a hero (monk: actually an apprentice) who looks like an angel (sorry) was good this time. The hero is made to swear silence so as not to succumb to the heroine's temptations (she's not conscious), but on the contrary, it was easy to empathize because it was depicted with the voice of a true heart rather than lines. I also sympathize with the heroine because she is strong like a medieval girl. I thought it would be useful for horse-riding matches and fair punishment (maybe vice versa). Studying history at HQ The original story is so solid, and the ability of the animation teacher (I bought it) speaks for itself.

  Helpful