A SCANDALOUS PROPOSAL 2

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Sep 27, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English
  相手が何者であろうと好き
  I like them no matter who they are
  やー夢心地で読みました。HQですからね、こうでなくちゃ。愛あればなんだって乗り越える、この力強さ。ヒロインのたくましさ！彼を助けるときのヒロインのかっこよさ。絶対に死なせたくない気持ちが本当に素晴らしかったし、その力は、これまでの彼女の人生を肯定するものであるだけに、読んでいて、無一文となろうともしっかりと生きてきた姿勢がよく出ていて、感動しました。ここが好きなので書いておきます。「エヴァン、私もよ。あなたになにがあろうと あなたがどんなになろうと あなたがあなたである限り(愛しているわ)」ジャンルがヒストリカルものなため、華やかな貴族社会や、社交界デビューなど、麗しい上流社会描写もさしはさみながらの、愛情深く強い精神力をもつ女性エミリーの波乱の愛の物語。時代からいって女一匹生きるのは大変だったとき、ギリギリとはいえ職業を軌道に乗せてしっかりと自活していたエミリー。その時期に出会った二人。深く愛し合った二人が、間に立ちはだかる、もの・人・出来事を乗り越え結ばれる。そこまで好きな人となかなか巡り会うものではないし、ましてや、結ばれるなど、この世のいくつもない奇跡でしかないことを、HQ世界では究極の理想の愛の形としてここで見せよう、といわんばかりに提示。幸福にたどり着くまでに二人が乗り越えた試練は、大河ドラマ並みにスケールがありますが、物語進行と共に、最初は冷たく思えた家族も人の子なのだという要素も消化、盛り沢山の試練が終息する頃は二人の蕀の環境(家族や友人)が居心地よく変化して、安心して本を閉じることができます。遅れて届いた手紙のところも揺さぶられました。彼の本心を、彼が死を覚悟した状況で知らされるわけですが、それでも婚約者のいる彼は名乗ってきてのことじゃない。エミリーには差出人を認識できる。HQって、他の一般コミックより、遥かに子持ちの再婚に夢を持たせてくれる方面のストックが豊富でそこもいいところなんですよね。結婚に失敗したとか、死別したとか、そういうところも含んだ再婚ややり直しジャンルの開拓が、HQ以外だと余りに進んでなさすぎて、ここでこれほどきらびやかにやってくれるとスカッとします。星合男子好きの私は、前編のほうが、そっちの魅力、つまり、男性の美しさが発揮されてる、とは思いましたけど。

  Wow, I read it with a sense of dreaming. It's HQ, so it has to be like this. With love, you can overcome anything, this strength. The heroine's strength! The heroine's coolness when it comes to helping him. The feeling that I never wanted her to die was really wonderful, and since that power affirms her life up until now, I was moved by the attitude that she had lived well even when she was penniless while reading it. I like it here, so I'll write it down. “Evan, me too. Since the “No Matter What Happens to You, As Long as You Are You (I Love You)” genre is historical, it's a story of turbulent love between Emily, a woman who is affectionate and has strong mental strength, while showing beautiful depictions of high society, such as a glamorous aristocrat society and her social debut. From time to time, when it was difficult for a woman to live alone, Emily kept her occupation on track and supported herself well, albeit at the last minute. The two met around that time. Two people who are deeply in love are united by overcoming things, people, and events that stand in their way. It's not easy to meet someone you like that much, let alone be connected, and that it's nothing but a number of miracles in this world, so I'm going to show it here as the ultimate ideal form of love in the HQ world. The trials they overcame until they reached happiness are on a scale similar to that of taiga dramas, but as the story progresses, the elements that seemed cold at first are also digested, and by the time many trials are over, the environment (family and friends) of the two changes comfortably, and by the time the many trials are over, the environment (family and friends) of the two changes comfortably, and you can close the book with peace of mind. The letter that arrived late was also shaken. His true intentions are revealed in a situation where he was prepared to die, but even so, he, who has a fiancee, isn't calling himself by name. Emily can recognize the sender. HQ has far more stock than other general comics, in areas that make people dream about remarrying when they have children, and that's a good thing too. The pioneering of remarriage and restarting genres, which include things like failed marriage or being widowed, hasn't progressed too far outside of HQ, and it's amazing when they do it so glittering here. I like Hoshi Gai Danshi, so I thought the first part showed that appeal, that is, the beauty of men.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Sep 04, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English
  良かった
  good
  This review contains spoilers. ヒーローも素敵だし一目惚れしちゃうところも可愛い！ヒロインも未亡人ながら綺麗で、お互い想い合っていても色々なしがらみでうまくいかない…すごく切なくなりました。最後は心から良かったと思いました。

  This review contains spoilers. The heroes are wonderful, and the place where you fall in love at first sight is cute too! The heroine was also a widow but she was beautiful, and even though they had feelings for each other, things didn't go well... it was so sad. I was really glad at the end.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 12, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English
  大長編だけど
  It's a big long film
  読み応えありました！前編後編、高いけど読んだ方がいいです。ハッピーエンドで良かった〜！！ヒーローの家族が良識ある人でよかったです。自分のことしか考えない婚約者がラストで去っていったとこは、妹や母親にgood jobと言いたいですね（笑）

  It was a great read! Part 1 part 2 is expensive, but it's better to read it. I'm glad it had a happy ending~!! I'm glad the hero's family are sensible people. When my fiancé, who only thinks about myself, left at the end, I'd like to say good job to my sister and mother (laughs)

  Helpful