SICILIAN'S SHOCK PROPOSAL

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 03, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English
  良い！
  good!
  今回も豪華ですよ。ハーレクインの豪華さに溢れた絵柄で引き込まれますよ〜

  It's gorgeous this time too. You'll be drawn in by Harlequin's gorgeous pattern~

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Nov 21, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English
  親の敵であっても
  Even if it's a parent's enemy
  相手の幸せを思って動くルカ。日本なら大正時代の頃の服装が素敵。もともと狩野先生の作品は服が素晴らしいので期待を裏切らない。イタリアっぽさも人物の中に見えるようだ。シチリアの海の描写も、地中海の海に見えた。島の様子も、行ったことはないが、そうなのだと思わせる、申し分のない舞台装置と感じる。小さいときから互いに好きな二人だが、親が、そして、環境が、また、親のしていることを通じて社会の人たちが、二人を順調に歩ませてはくれない。親を選べない悲しい現実、しかしそんな境遇だから、出会えた二人。好きなのに、周りに辛いことが多すぎる。友人が涙が出るほどいい人で、互いに貧しさの中にも、ひねくれないで、汚れたお金が動く世界に、二人は汚されないような生き方をして、尊い感じで救われる。さっぱりとした気持ちの友情が辛さを支える。ルカはルカのせいではないのに、罪を背負う決意をして、切ない。ヒロインも、ルカが好きなのに、親に申し訳が立たず飛び込めなくなる。しかし、二人が愛し合っていれば乗り越えられるのだ、と。「メイドを拾った億万長者」と繋がる作品。HQの先生の中ではバタ臭さがよく出せる先生なのでたっぶり雰囲気を味わった。

  Luca moves thinking about her partner's happiness. In Japan, clothes from the Taisho period are wonderful. Originally, Kano sensei's work did not disappoint because the clothes were wonderful. The Italian-like character also seems to be visible in the characters. The depiction of the Sicilian Sea also looked like the Mediterranean Sea. I've never been to the island, and I feel that the stage setup is perfect, making me think that's the case. They have been fond of each other since they were little, but their parents, the environment, and the people in society through what they do don't let them walk smoothly. The sad reality of not being able to choose parents, but the two were able to meet because of such circumstances. Even though I like it, there are too many painful things around me. Their friends are such good people that they burst into tears, and even in the midst of mutual poverty, they live a way of life where dirty money moves without being perverse, and they are saved with a sense of dignity. A refreshing friendship supports the pain. It's sad that Luca made up her mind to bear the crime even though it wasn't Luca's fault. The heroine also likes Luka, but she doesn't feel sorry for her parents and can't jump in. However, if the two love each other, they can overcome it. This work is connected to “The Billionaire Who Picked Up His Maid.” Among HQ teachers, they are teachers who often smell like butter, so I really enjoyed the atmosphere.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Mar 20, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English
  良かったけど
  It was good but
  This review contains spoilers. ヒーロー側、ヒロイン側、どちらの事情と気持ちも交互に描かれるので、「なんで？」とイライラすることなく読めます。気骨があって優秀なヒーローは実に格好いいし、真っ直ぐで気丈なヒロインも良い。ただずっとお互いの気持ちを隠しギスギスしてるせいで、読後のハッピー感はあまりなかったかな…。相思相愛になるのはやっとラスト6Pのところだし、仲睦まじげに暮らしてる描写はなく、着飾って並んで歩いてるカットが一つだけ。もっと子供たちに囲まれてるとか食卓を囲んでるとか、ちゃんと家族になれてるところが見たかった。

  This review contains spoilers. The circumstances and feelings of both the hero side and the heroine side are drawn alternately, so “why?” I can read it without getting frustrated. Heroes who are brave and excellent are actually good-looking, and so are heroines who are straight and strong. It's just that they've been hiding their feelings from each other all this time, so I wonder if there wasn't much happiness after reading it... It's finally time for them to fall in love with each other in the last 6P, and there's no depiction of them living together seriously, and there's only one cut where they walk side by side dressed up. I wanted to see them being more comfortable with their families, such as being surrounded by children and surrounding the dining table.

  Helpful