The day before Christmas Eve, Felicia runs into the last person on earth she'd expect to see... It's Gideon, her ex from high school. They starred in the school play together as Romeo and Juliet, and the two of them were deeply in love once. Neither of them has any plans for Christmas, so they agree to spend the day together. It's as if they're sweethearts again, and Felicia feels swept away by a wave of old feelings. They share a passionate kiss, but then Gideon pulls away abruptly. Felicia can't help but wonder...what is he thinking?