The Perfect Sinner

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 25, 2011 (PST) | Translate to English
  これも一つの形
  This is also one shape
  最初読んだ時は、夫の歪んだ愛情が気持ち悪くて、マディのことも表面的な感情でしか見られなかったのですが……。再び読んで、ラスト、マディの晴れやかな表情にすべてを納得させられました。疑念も抱かず、２人で障害を乗り越え、幸せ・喜び・あたたかさ……愛に満ちた結婚生活は当たり前なようで、素敵で、理想的。でも一方マディ達のように、過ちとともに生きて、時間を重ねて作り上げていく夫婦の形も強さに満ちて自然で納得させられるものがあります。夫が本当に歪んでいるので、生理的にダメな方はやめた方がいいと思います。ただハッピーな話が読みたい方にもオススメできません。

  When I first read it, my husband's distorted love was disgusting, and I was only able to look at Maddie with superficial feelings... After reading it again, I was completely convinced by Maddie's radiant expression at the end. There are no doubts, the two overcame obstacles, and a marriage full of happiness, joy, warmth... seems commonplace, wonderful, and ideal. But on the other hand, like Maddie and the others, the shape of a married couple who live with mistakes and build up over time is also full of strength and is natural and convincing. My husband is really distorted, so I think it's better to stop being physiologically bad. However, I also don't recommend it to those who want to read happy stories.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 03, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English
  闇が深い
  The darkness is deep
  このファミリーちょっと怖いです。コミックを読んで面白いと思ったものは小説でも読みたいのですが、この作品は小説がないので残念です。

  I'm a little scared of this family. I want to read comics that I thought were interesting, even novels, but it's a pity that there are no novels in this work.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Mar 23, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English
  少しずつ夫婦になっていく未来
  A future where little by little they become husband and wife
  This review contains spoilers. 他のレビューを読んで借りようか迷った作品です。結果的に借りて良かった！他の方が言われてる通り、夫の残酷さにドン引きます。いくら周りに恵まれてても、夫の死を切実に望んでしまうレベルだと思いますが、そうならない辺りがマディの優しさと純粋さと複雑な愛ゆえなのかな。立場が逆転してからはいい気味だと思って、少し溜飲が下がる。夫への愛と憎しみと、夫の余りの豹変ぶりに信じていいのか…と葛藤するマディの気持ちが伝わってきます。終わり方も私は好きです。夫がやっと暴れまわるきかんぼうを卒業して大人になって、お互いに信頼を取り戻して夫婦としてやり直そう…と模索している感じが出ています。愛する子供もいるし、見守ってくれて支えてくれる大家族の親戚もいるから、短気に片付けられないし、向き合える。分かりやすいロマンスみたいに単純じゃないし綺麗事ばかりじゃない。そんなお話でした。確かに好き嫌い分かれそう。

  This review contains spoilers. I read other reviews and was at a loss as to whether to borrow it. I'm glad I borrowed it as a result! As others have said, I'm taken aback by my husband's cruelty. No matter how blessed they are, I think it's a level where they desperately want their husband to die, but I wonder if Maddie's kindness, purity, and complicated love is that not the case. After the position was reversed, I thought it would be a good feeling, and my drinking went down a bit. It conveys Maddie's feelings of conflict between her love and hate for her husband and whether it's okay to believe in her husband's sudden changes... I like the way it ends. There is a feeling that my husband has finally graduated from Rampage and become an adult, regaining mutual trust, and trying to start over as a married couple... I have children I love, and I also have relatives in large families who watch over and support me, so I can't clean up in a short time, and I can face it. It's not as simple as an easy-to-understand romance, and it's not all pretty. That was the story. There certainly seems to be a split between likes and dislikes.

  Helpful