SARAH'S CHILD 2

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jan 03, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English
  彼には再度の地獄への恐怖もサラは初めての
  Is Sarah's first time to be afraid of hell again
  良かったね！、と最難関の最終トンネルをくぐった感のラストへの流れ。記憶が蘇って来て、過去の日々をなぞりそうになる恐怖心からなかなか抜け出しきれなかった彼。新しい日々の新しい人間関係や新しい住環境に身を置いたことによる、視点の転換を反映した脱出も理解できる。気づけて良かった。何がきっかけになるか、それは人に依るかもしれないがこれで十分の転換点と思える。彼は二度目だからこそ、気づけた。サラは星への願いを家族作りへのこだわりにより自力で実現させた。これまでは、ダブらせてしまって苦しかった彼が、ダブらせることで、反対にヒロインの状況に客観的想像力が持って行けた。いつの間にか、サラ版の結婚生活へ気持ちの比重がついていたのだろう。もう二人は大丈夫とひとまずは思える終わり方。彼はちゃんと父親になれる。あとの光景は想像できるので、これ以降の描写を省いたのはドラマツルギーとして大いに有りかと。これからもフラッシュバックはあるかもだが、ここを乗り越えたのは大きい。進まないように見えて進めてこれたのだ。サラは、精一杯父親を勤めようとする彼の努力を見ることが出来るだろう。夫も父も双方をキチンとやった彼なら今回も成れるからだ。サラを愛しているのであるし。実際、サラは自分のことしか考えないタイプではなかった。彼の苦しみを知りながらも、それでも、二人の子を失った彼の、自分との愛の証を願うわけで。このような経過を辿らなくでも、妻を愛するようには子を愛せない父親もいるのだ。そんなことを思い巡らすと、あれほど辛い死別の地獄を見た彼が再び誰かを愛せるようになってよかったねと思うし、流れ星への祈りが遂に届いたサラの胸中が、読み手のこちらの心にキューッと来る。解放された殯の昇華みたいに思えて、深く安堵してしまう。「私はダイアンじゃないわ。そう、ダイアンの代わりでもない。」この涙の反撃シーンは良かった。居場所の感じられなった二人に新しい居場所の主張が開始されている。一本調子に関係が良い方向に進められる訳じゃない。消化して近づき合っても、残る記憶がまだ苦しみの素。ぶつかって一歩、またぶつかって一歩と、亡妻への愛という壁を乗り越えても、亡くした子供達という壁を次は乗り越えねばならない。都度都度傷つくサラ。が、その都度彼も変化した。女の子誕生は作者の終わらせ方の意思と見た。

  That was great! Flow to the end with the feeling of going through the most difficult final tunnel. His memory came back to life, and he couldn't easily get out of the fear that made him look back on his past days. You can also understand escapes reflecting changes in viewpoints due to new relationships in new days and putting yourself in a new living environment. I'm glad I noticed it. What will trigger it may depend on the person, but this seems like a sufficient turning point. He noticed it because it was his second time. Sarah made her wish for a star come true on her own due to her commitment to family building. Until now, it was painful to let him do dubbing, but by making him dub, on the contrary, he was able to bring objective imagination to the heroine's situation. Before I knew it, the proportion of feelings was attached to Sarah's version of marriage. It ended in such a way that I thought the two of them would be fine for now. He can be a proper father. I can imagine the rest of the scene, so I wonder if it's mostly dramaturgy that left out the depiction after this. There may be flashbacks in the future, but it's great that we've overcome this. It seemed like it wasn't going forward, so it went ahead. Sarah will be able to see his efforts to serve as a father to the fullest. This is because if both my husband and father were good at it, I would be able to be this time too. I love Sarah, too. In fact, Sarah wasn't the type to think only about herself. Even though I know his suffering, I still hope for proof of his love with himself after losing his two children. There are also fathers who can't love their children the way they love their wives, even if they don't follow this path. Thinking about that, I think it's good that after seeing such a painful hell of bereavement, Sarah was able to love someone again, and the heart of Sarah, whose prayers for shooting stars have finally arrived, comes quickly to the reader's heart. It seems like the sublimation of a freed dragon, and I'm deeply relieved. “I'm not Diane. Yes, it's not a replacement for Diane.” This tearful counterattack scene was good. Claims for a new location have begun for the two, who have no sense of where they are. It doesn't mean that the relationship can move in a good direction when things get along. Even after digesting and getting close, the memories that remain are still a source of suffering. Even if you overcome the barrier of love for your late wife, one step after another, you must overcome the barrier of lost children one step at a time. Sarah gets hurt every time. But each time, he also changed. I saw the birth of a girl as the author's intention to end it.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Sep 25, 2012 (PST) | Translate to English
  涙?
  tears?
  ホロリときました。妻と子を喪った悲しみは、やすやすと越えられないと思います。サラにとっても大切な親友ですが、ロウムのそういった部分を受け止めたサラの愛情に感動しました。設定はありがちかもしれないけれど、たっぷりボリュームをもって描かれているからサラとロウムの細かい心理がよく分かって引き込まれました。サラの忍耐や優しさ、強さには感服しました。前編の三角関係でのロウムのヤキモチから、２人の新婚生活、サラの新しい仕事、周りの人の優しさ……最初から最後まで無駄の無いストーリーでした。幸せというのは、誰かに叶えてもらった訳ではなく、自身が願い続けて努力して得たものだという話です。前後合わせて☀５評価です。

  I was shocked. I don't think it's easy to overcome the grief of losing my wife and child. Sarah is also an important best friend, and I was moved by Sarah's love for accepting that part of Rowum. The setting may tend to be complicated, but since it was drawn with plenty of volume, I was drawn in because I understood the detailed psychology of Sarah and Roum very well. I was impressed by Sarah's patience, kindness, and strength. From Roum's excitement in the love triangle in the first part, to the newlywed life of the two, Sarah's new job, the kindness of the people around them... it was a story where there was no waste from beginning to end. It's a story about happiness not because someone made it come true; it was obtained by continuing to wish for one's own wishes and making an effort. The front and back together are rated ☀ 5.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Sep 21, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English
  原作の再現度高い
  The degree of reproduction of the original story is high
  This review contains spoilers. これなかなかヒロインにとってキツイ設定で、すごく上手く漫画化したと思いますとても再現度の高い良き漫画化だと思いますなんなら原作より良いかもしれないヒロインの私は元妻でもないしその代わりでもないという大コマが特に良かった

  This review contains spoilers. This was a pretty tough setting for the heroine, and I think it was made into a very good comic with a very high degree of reproducibility. If anything, it might be better than the original story, the large frame where the heroine, I'm not my ex-wife, nor is a replacement for her was particularly good

  Helpful