School Rumble

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Nov 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  当時
  At that time
  当時、非常にヒットした作品です。わたくしも楽しみに読んでおりましたアニメ化されました作者さんは、その後何故かガンガンに移籍したようですが。。。

  It was a huge hit at the time. It seems that the author, who was made into an anime, which I was also looking forward to reading, moved on for some reason after that...

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jun 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  ラブコメの金字塔
  The gold standard of romantic comedy
  This review contains spoilers. ラブコメマンガの金字塔のようなマンガで連載されていた当時はとても楽しみに読んでいました。これぞおもと思える好いでの作品でした。気に入っているのでとにかく面白いです。また続きがあったらいいなと思える作品です

  This review contains spoilers. I was really looking forward to reading it at the time when it was serialized in a manga that looked like the epitome of romantic comedy comics. This was a really nice work that I could think of. I like it, so it's really interesting. It's a work that I think would be nice if there was a continuation

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jan 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English
  面白い、しかしモヤモヤ
  Funny, but fuzzy
  This review contains spoilers. 当初はショートギャグ漫画だったのだが、登場人物のキャラが確立していった中盤から青春群像劇×複数の恋愛が交錯する展開になり、無類の面白さを発揮するように。キャラ付けや人物配置、展開などのレベルが高く、次の話が待ちきれなくドンドン買ってしまう魔力がある。ただ惜しむらくは、広げ過ぎた周辺人物の話などが放っておかれてしまい、最終回まで読んでも回収されずにモヤモヤが残ってしまう点。まぁあの流れの中で描ききるのは難しかったかもしれないが、魅力の一つであっただけにハマった人ほどモヤモヤが残ってしまうであろう。物語の核心の一つの八雲⇄播磨⇄沢近も中途半端な描写になってしまっているが、こちらは結論づけるとファンの論争が起こりそうなので、これで良かったのかもしれない（笑）（追記）スクールランブルZで作者的な結論が描かれていたことを確認。個人的には満足した。しかしあれは本篇で書くべきでは…。編集部とあまり上手くいってなかったのか。

  This review contains spoilers. At first, it was a short gag comic, but from the middle when the characters were established, it developed into a youth group drama with multiple romances intersecting, showing unrivaled fun. The level of character addition, character arrangement, development, etc. is high, and it has the magic power to make people buy it all the time because they can't wait for the next episode. Unfortunately, the stories of surrounding people that have spread too far are left alone, and even if you read until the final episode, they are not collected, leaving a mess. Well, it may have been difficult to draw in that flow, but the more people who are addicted to it just because it was one of the attractions, the more fuzzy they will remain. Yakumo Harima Sawachika, which is one of the core of the story, is also a half-hearted depiction, but fan controversy is likely to occur when this is concluded, so maybe this was good (lol) (postscript) I confirmed that an author's conclusion was drawn in School Rumble Z. Personally, I was satisfied. But I shouldn't write that in the main story... didn't you get along very well with the editorial department?

  Helpful