REINVENTING MARY/BLACKMAILED BY THE SHEIKH

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jun 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  面白いけど勿体ない
  It's interesting, but it's unfortunate
  This review contains spoilers. 天野先生らしさがギュッッと詰まった素敵な二作品でした。でもどうして短編なのか！127ページとか129ページで読みたいよー！とジタバタします。特に後半のシークものは話そのものはきっちりしっかり伝わってくるし何も「端折られた感」もなく完璧ですが、長尺で読みたーい！こんなに面白いのにもう終わるの悲しいー！となりました。でもこれが天野先生の初のHQだったんですね。ここから始まる天野ワールドにファンはメロメロになって行ったんですね。読めて嬉しい！でも短ーい！

  This review contains spoilers. They were two wonderful works that were tightly packed with Amano sensei's personality. But why a short story! I want to read it on page 127 or 129! I'm jittery. In particular, the story itself in the second half of the game is perfectly conveyed, and there is no “broken feeling” at all, but it's perfect, but I want to read it over a long period of time! It's so funny, but it's sad that it's already over! It became. But this was Amano sensei's first HQ. The fans went dumbfounded at Amano World, which began here. I'm happy to read it! But it's short!

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Mar 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English
  マーガレットとラシードに助演賞?✨を
  Best Supporting Actress for Margaret and Rashid? ✨
  ２話ものと知らずに読み始め、えっ？！終わり？？と思ったら次のお話が....題名が二つちゃんとあるのにね?副題と思ちゃった上に電子書籍で頁の厚みわからん??１話目はシンデレラ物語としてはお品がよくマイルドなお作で、天野先生の作画じゃなかったらサラサラと終わってしまうような...天野先生の作画でも....でしたが。２作目はシークもの、短いながらも山あり谷ありで短いながら楽しめました。HQには短編の佳作があるからこうしてコミカライズしてくれると嬉しいな♪♬って感想?

  I started reading episode 2 without knowing it, huh?! the end?? when I thought about it, the next story... even though it has two proper titles, right? I thought it was a subtitle and don't you understand the thickness of the pages in the e-book?? The first episode was an elegant and mild film for a Cinderella story, and it seemed like it would end smoothly if it wasn't Amano sensei's drawing... even though it was Amano sensei's drawing... The second film was a seek, and although it was short, there were mountains and valleys, so I was able to enjoy it even though it was short. HQ has excellent short films, so it would be nice if they comicalized it like this ♪♬ do you think?

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jun 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  短編２作
  2 short films
  This review contains spoilers. シンデレラへの招待はヒロインのビフォーアフターにヒーローがすぐに気がついたのが高得点。プリンスにさらわれてはヒーローが独りよがりの感情だけで突っ走った感じ。

  This review contains spoilers. The invitation to Cinderella was a high score because the hero immediately noticed before and after the heroine. After being kidnapped by Prince, it felt like the hero ran wild with nothing but feelings of being alone.

  Helpful