THE AMNESIAC BRIDE

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Mar 20, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English
  どちらもタフガイでカッコイイ
  They're both tough guys and cool
  ありきたりのＨＱとは路線が違う。ハピエンの後の２人の生活はどんなだろうとコミックシティーハンターを思い出した。勿論内容は全く違うものだが、身を置いて居る世界は近似値があり、一般的な家庭とは縁遠そうな幸福に寂しくもあるが得られた愛情の喜びもある。記憶が無い事でゼロからのスタートが、２人を変えたことは言うまでも無いが、本来の２人ならこうはならなかったか？というとなんだかそれも違って やっぱりこうなったのではと思わせる可愛らしさが２人にはある。ただ、ヒーローゼーンの裸体には素晴らしい筋肉のそれは見受けられずヒロインホイットのセリフにあるような素晴らしさは伝わらなかったが(笑)それでも、彼女のガン捌きにはホレてしまいました。

  The route is different from the usual HQ. I was reminded of Comic City Hunter, wondering what life would be like for the two after Happien. Of course, the content is completely different, but there are approximate values for the world we are in, and there is also happiness that seems far from a typical family, and the joy of love that was obtained even though it was lonely. It goes without saying that starting from zero due to lack of memory changed 2 people, but wouldn't this have happened if they were the original 2 people? If that is to say, they are also somehow different, and they have a cuteness that makes you think they just turned out like this after all. However, I couldn't see any of the amazing muscles in Hero Zane's naked body, and the splendor in the heroine Hoyt's line wasn't conveyed (laughs), but even so, I was horrified by her handling of cancer.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Feb 01, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English
  最後の最後までハラハラ
  Harahara until the very end
  最後の最後までハラハラでしたが、最後に職業が分かって、それでかぁと納得できてよかったです。それに記憶喪失になったおかげで二人が異性としてお互いを意識し、ハッピーエンドになったので記憶喪失に感謝！？？ですね。

  It was jarring until the very end, but at the end I understood the occupation, and I'm glad I was so convinced. Also, thanks to memory loss, the two became aware of each other as opposite sex, and it had a happy ending, so I'm thankful for the loss of memory!?? Right.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jan 04, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English
  氷を溶かした記憶喪失
  Amnesia that melted ice
  ストーリーは面白く出来ているが、絵にこなれた描写が少なくぎこちない。滑らかに見えないのが読んでいて上等のサスペンスを感じさせず、どこか冷めた雰囲気で二人のシーンにラブ成分発散が足りず、謎の謎めきかたも中途半端。巻き込まれ感少なく、といって主体性も記憶喪失故に発揮できず、で、彼とハネムーンを楽しみたいにしてはドレス以外では ただ悩める迷子状態のヒロイン。彼の断片的説明も表情に力が弱い。表紙も二人が見つめあっていない。男性が余所に目が行っている。もっとメインの人物二人を豊かに動かし、表情を見せて欲しい。職業柄それは、許されない場面でも、肉の感じが生き生きと躍動する感じがもっと伝わってくるとよいのに。カジノシーンはもう少し派手さも欲しい。人物絵のコマが平面的。静止画的。コマの形状が工夫されており目先の変化を出しているのに、そこにストーリーの機動力を強く乗せていない。勿体ない。特に114頁の一番下の右側、判りづらい。緊迫のピストル登場の絵も、もう少し演出が入っている方が盛り上がったのでは？彼の、ヒロインに対する事故前の心の内面もさらさら披露し過ぎな気がした。ヒロインのビフォアを言葉より絵で見たかった。男性はビジュアルでもっとアピールして欲しかった。55&61頁以外は。コミカライズ物を読むのは、お話を文字を追うより時間短縮で軽いから読むのではなく、コミックしか描写出来ない、視覚的な表現で字面を超えたものを見たいから。もっと沢山描いて登場人物達の硬さを取り除き、細かいところも筆を入れて、メインキャラ二人の表情を多様に見せて、彼の顔の造形をもっとカッコ良くして欲しい。4.0未満の3.5以上で切り上げにして４星という事で。

  The story is interesting, but there aren't many good depictions in the pictures, and it's awkward. The fact that it doesn't look smooth is reading and doesn't make me feel superior suspense, the atmosphere is somewhat chilled, and the love element doesn't dissipate enough in the scene between the two, and the mysterious way they solve the mystery is also half-hearted. The heroine is in a lost state where there is little sense of involvement, but she is unable to demonstrate her independence due to loss of memory, and if she wants to enjoy a honeymoon with him, she is simply worried about anything other than her dress. His fragmentary explanation is also weak in expression. The two didn't look at each other on the cover either. The man's eyes are on the rest. I want them to move the two main characters more richly and show their facial expressions. Because of the occupation, it would be nice if the feeling of the flesh comes to life even in situations where it is not allowed to be conveyed even more. I want the casino scene to be a little more flashy. The frame with the portrait is flat. Still image. The shape of the frame has been devised to show immediate changes, yet the mobility of the story is not strongly added to it. that's a shame. In particular, the bottom right side of page 114 is hard to understand. Wouldn't the picture in which the tense pistol appeared would have been more exciting if it had a little more production in it? I felt like he was showing off too much of his inner feelings for the heroine before the accident. I wanted to see the heroine before in pictures rather than words. Men wanted more visual appeal. Other than pages 55 and 61. I read comicalized stuff not because I read a story because it takes less time and is lighter than following the characters, but because I want to see something that goes beyond literality with visual expressions that can only be depicted in comics. I want them to draw a lot more to remove the hardness of the characters, brush the details, show off the expressions of the two main characters in a variety of ways, and make the shape of his face even cooler. It means 4 stars when rounded up to 3.5 or more, which is less than 4.0.

  Helpful