My Beautiful Man Light Novel Reviews (P.36)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

以外と？軽いお話かな？

other than that? Is this a light story?

2巻まで拝読しての感想になります。ドラマ化もされているようなので、有名作家様だし、、ちょっと重い内容かな、、。なんて思っていたのですが、割とコミカルで少女マンガ路線でした。小説の言葉の選び方などは、さすがというか1巻なんかは静かな湖面に水滴が落ちるような柔らかさを感じたのですが。2巻からは、うーん。。軽くなりすぎてて、業界のゴタゴタなのに、彼の親戚に頼む？とか、昔の俺みたいだから。とかそんなことアル？みたいな設定の現実離れ感がすごくて挫折しました。恋愛面も2巻はあまりドキドキがなく、距離が平行線で残念でした。最後はスパダリになりそうな予感はするのですが、、。

This is my impression after reading up to 2 volumes. It seems that it has also been made into a drama, so he's a famous writer... and the content is probably a bit heavy... I was wondering, but it was a rather comical girls' manga line. As for how to choose the words for the novel, I felt that volume 1 was as soft as water droplets falling on a quiet lake surface. Starting with volume 2, hmm... It's getting too light, and even though the industry is messy, do you ask his relatives? or because it's like who I used to be. or something like that, Al? I was so frustrated that the sense of separation from reality in a setting like that was so great. Volume 2 of the romance side wasn't very exciting either, and it was a pity that the distance was parallel. I have a feeling it's going to be Spadari at the end, but...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

4.3☆

4.3 ☆

評価の高い人気作品でも、好みが非常に偏っているため空振りの多いわたしですが、この作品は間違いなく読みやすく面白い、イラストも作品に合っていて良いですね。普段はラブストーリーが主な作品を好んで読まないのですが、絵が綺麗だったり雰囲気が美しかったり、キャラの個性が強い作品なんかは好きです、この作品はしっかりとしたキャラクターが確立していて濃い、見てて楽しい、可愛い等の感情がどんどん溢れて増えていきます。恋は妄想、拘りと執着が強くて人嫌いなのに人たらしな部分もある自分ワールドの住人ウザキモ可愛い奴隷体質なオタク×実は繊細で乙女なのにプライド高く勝気なお姫様みたいに不器用でくそ可愛い高飛車イケメンってところでしょうか。全然違う二人。でも最終的にはどっちも変な人という感想です。1巻は平良から捉えた世界と清居から捉えた世界が見える、2巻は二人の感情やキャラの詳細が見えて、3巻はヒューマンドラマのような展開に。正直言うとくっつくまでがとても面白く5☆後は続編的な感じに読みました。全体的な評価は4.3☆

Even for popular works with high ratings, I have a lot of empty feelings because my tastes are extremely biased, but this work is definitely easy to read and interesting, and it's nice that the illustrations match the work. Normally, I don't like to read works that are mainly love stories, but I like works where the pictures are beautiful, the atmosphere is beautiful, and the characters have strong personalities, and this work has well-established characters and is full of emotions such as being strong, fun to watch, and cute. Is love a delusion, stubbornness, and obsession, and even though they hate people, a resident of my own world, an otaku with a cute slave constitution x actually a clumsy, damn cute, and good-natured Takabisha handsome guy like a delicate maiden with a high pride and selfish temperament. They are two completely different people. But at the end of the day, I have the impression that they are both strange people. Volume 1 shows the world captured from Taira and the world captured from Kiyoi, volume 2 shows the emotions and details of the characters of the two, and volume 3 unfolds like a human drama. To be honest, it was very interesting until they stuck together, and after 5 ☆ I read it like it was a sequel. The overall rating is 4.3 ☆

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

ドラマから知りました。ドラマのキャスティング、映像や話の構成が最高でした。原作が、やはりおもしろいと思います。

I learned about it from dramas. The cast of the drama and the structure of the video and story were excellent. I think the original story is still interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 22, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

最高です！

It's awesome!

ドラマを見てから、原作を読みました。ドラマとは展開が異なるところも多々ありますが、2人の詳しい心情がわかりとてもよかったと思います。

After watching the drama, I read the original story. There are many places where the development is different from the drama, but I think it was great to understand the detailed feelings of the two.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

斜め上いく作品

Works that go up diagonally

This review contains spoilers. 面白かったです。内容もですが、所々で爆笑しました。作者様の思考や発想がすごい。話にぐいぐい引き込みながら笑いも取るとか神作品と大人気なのわかります。あらすじからはそんなに惹かれなく積本し、購入後１ヶ月位経って読みましたが三冊一気読みしました。攻にぐいぐい来られて仕方なく相手してたはずの受が、いつの間にか攻にベタぼれで自分から歩み寄ってでも一緒にいようとする健気さがたまりません。そしてふと気づいてコンナハズジャナイと自分との葛藤(笑)ページ数もあってお得でした。ただ…私にはもどかしさを感じるところが多かったのも事実なので残念ながら☆５にはならず。せっかく受がくっつきに行っても斜め上いく攻が自分理論でしょっちゅう肩透かしさせるんですよね。神と崇めるのではなく、もっと自分を同じ人間として受け入れてほしい、思考を寄せてほしいと願う受の清居に共感し深く同情してしまいました。

This review contains spoilers. That was interesting. As for the content, I burst out laughing here and there. The author's thoughts and ideas are amazing. I understand that it is a divine work that draws in a lot of laughter while drawing in the story and is very popular. I wasn't really attracted to it from the synopsis, and although I read it about 1 month after purchase, I read all three books at once. I couldn't help but be against them because they came so hard on the attack, but before I knew it, they were so stubborn to the attack that they tried to stay together even when they walked up from themselves is irresistible. Then I suddenly noticed the conflict between Konna Hazu Janai and myself (lol) and it was a great deal because of the number of pages. However... it is also true that there were many places where I felt frustrated, so unfortunately it wasn't ☆ 5. Attacks that go up obliquely even if the reception sticks together makes you completely clear your shoulders with your own theory, doesn't it? Instead of worshipping God, I sympathized with Uke no Kiyoi, who wanted him to accept himself more as the same person, and to give me his thoughts, and I felt deep sympathy for him.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

最高すぎる♡♡

It's too awesome ♡♡

This review contains spoilers. 一軍と底辺の関係性が交わり始まるストーリーがすごく好きすぎてほんとに大好きです。変わった愛の表現だけどすごく愛を感じる。

This review contains spoilers. I really love the story that begins when the relationship between the first army and the bottom intersects so much that I really love it. It's an unusual expression of love, but I feel so much love.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

一巻のみの評価

Evaluation of only one volume

すごく読みやすい文章で、情景が浮かぶようでした。挿絵が美しい…。攻めもイケメン。文章から思い描いていたのとは違ったけど。作者さんのあとがきの気持ち悪い攻めが好き以下略には、わかる…と大きく頷きました。ただ2、3はあらすじ見た感じ興味を惹かず、購入する気にはなれませんでした。

It was a very easy sentence to read, and it seemed like a scene came to mind. The illustrations are beautiful... The attackers are also handsome. It wasn't what I had imagined from the sentence though. I liked the author's afterword's disgusting attack, and I nodded loudly, saying I understand the abbreviation below... However, when I saw the synopsis of 2 and 3, I wasn't interested, and I didn't feel like buying them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 16, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい！

It's interesting!

This review contains spoilers. ドラマきっかけで、原作である小説を読ませていただきました。おもしろかったです！物語が進んでいくにつれて変化していく2人の関係性にぐっと来ました。ネガティブな平良くんに共感を覚えることもありました。また、清居くんに対する愛情の深さには毎度びっくりしますし、尊敬します笑。清居くんの内面も話が進むごとに出てきて、可愛らしいなと思いました。今後どのように物語が展開されていくのか、楽しみです！

This review contains spoilers. The drama triggered me to read the novel, which is the original story. That was interesting! I've come a long way to the relationship between the two that changes as the story progresses. There were times when I felt sympathy for the negative Teiyokun. Also, I'm always surprised by the depth of his love for Kiyoi-kun, and I respect him lol. Kiyoi-kun's inner world also came up as the story progressed, and I thought he was cute. I'm looking forward to seeing how the story unfolds in the future!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ずっと気になってた

I've always been interested

美しい彼はドラマから見てきて原作が気になって遂に買ってしまいました笑ドラマに出てきた2人を想像しながら読むのがとても楽しかったです

I watched The Beautiful Man from the drama and finally bought it because I was curious about the original lol it was so much fun to read while imagining the 2 people who appeared in the drama

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 14, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

重いとか執着とかじゃない。爽やかな信仰

It's not heavy or obsessive. Refreshing Faith

This review contains spoilers. 日頃から、推しなどに対して信仰心を強く持つ人が読んだら、頷きっぱなしの漫画だと思います。底辺ぼっちの攻めが、カースト上位の超絶美形受けに、宗教の如く陶酔していくお話です。試し読みで即買いでした。3/2くらいまで止まることなくズンズン読んでしまいました。とにかく文章の表現が的確で、魅力的です。何の違和感もなくストンと収まるので、どんどん濃厚な彼(攻め)の世界に入って行けました。超絶美形の受けが放つ「きも」ほど痺れる言葉はありません…彼をあまり気持ち悪いと思えなかったのは、個人的なものでしょうか…（笑）受けのことをどのくらい好きかという表現の中で、さっきまで受けを写していた水溜りにすら胸を痛ますことが出来る攻めは、情緒が決壊していて最高だと思いました。悲しくはありませんでした。程よく胸が痛むところもあり、あとはハッピーエンドなので、安心して読めますよ。

This review contains spoilers. If people who have a strong sense of faith in recommendations etc. read it on a daily basis, I think it's a comic that just keeps nodding. It's a story about Attack on the Bottom, where people take transcendental beauty from higher caste levels and become as euphoric as religion. It was a trial reading and I bought it right away. I read it all without stopping until about 3/2. Anyway, the expressions in the sentences are accurate and appealing. I settled in without any sense of incongruity, so I was able to enter a more and more intense world of him (attack). There's no word as numb as “Kimo” by Kakeru no Aesthetic... I wonder if it's personal that I didn't think he was so displeased... (laughs) In the expression of how much you love Kakemu, an attack that can hurt even the puddle of water that had been pictured until a moment ago, I thought it was awesome because the emotion had broken down. I wasn't sad. There are places where my heart hurts moderately, and the rest is a happy ending, so I can read it without worry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

凄く好きです

I really like it

テレビでドラマやっていたのですが、その後購入させて頂きました。内容は違う所もありましたが、小説も凄く良かったです。何回見ても飽きないし、楽しめます。

I was doing a TV drama, but then I bought it. There were places where the content was different, but the novel was also really good. You won't get bored no matter how many times you watch it, and you can enjoy it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

早く続きが読みたくなる

It makes me want to read the continuation soon

This review contains spoilers. まずは最初の一巻だけ購入しました。ですが、すでに続きが読みたくなってきてしまいました。ドラマ化された分はまだ見ていないのですが、ドラマを見た友人から原作を勧められてとても読んでいて面白いと思ったので、ドラマを見ているかどうかに関わらず読んでみてほしいです。正反対で相容れないような二人がなぜか惹かれ合うのがもだもだしますが甘くて最高です。

This review contains spoilers. First, I only bought the first volume. However, I've already started to want to read more. I haven't watched the drama adaptation yet, but a friend who watched the drama recommended the original story and thought it was very interesting to read, so I want you to read it regardless of whether you're watching the drama or not. For some reason, two people who are diametrically opposite and incompatible are attracted to each other, but it's sweet and awesome.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

読みごたえがあっていいです。

It's nice that it's good to read.

ドラマがきっかけで気になり、購入しました。漫画派なので小説はあまり読まないのですが、文字だけでもお互いのことが本当に好きなんだなということが伝わってきて良かったです。ページ数が多くて読みごたえがありました。

I was interested in the drama, so I bought it. I don't read many novels since I'm in the manga group, but I'm glad it conveyed that they really like each other with just the letters. There were so many pages that it was worth reading.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

美人な受け

A beautiful reception

美人で強気なのに、不器用でなんだかんだ振り回されちゃってる受けが可愛いです。読みやすいので、bl小説一作目にもピッタリかと思います！

Even though she's beautiful and aggressive, she's clumsy and has been swayed in some way so cute. It's easy to read, so I think it's perfect for my first BL novel!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いです

It's interesting

面白いです。でも、所々伸びてる感じがする気もしますけどまあーなんとなくそこは乗り越えることができる。ずっと読みたい気もするから不思議に面白いです。

It's interesting. But I also feel like it's growing in places, but well, somehow we can overcome that. I also feel like reading it all the time, so it's strangely interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

楽しみすぎて

I'm having too much fun

少し前に話題になりましたよね！安めだったので買い増した！まだ読み切ってはいませんが、とても面白い作品の匂いがプンプンしています笑

It became a hot topic a while ago! It was cheap, so I bought more! I haven't read it through yet, but it smells like a very interesting work lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 18, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ひねくれ一途な恋

Perverse Kind of Love

ドラマにハマり、原作を読みたくて購入しました。攻めのぶkつとんだ思い込みが面白い。他の作品も読んでみたいです。

I was addicted to the drama and bought it because I wanted to read the original story. The assumption that they are aggressive is interesting. I'd like to read other works.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろかった！

That was interesting!

This review contains spoilers. ある作家さんがハマったとおっしゃっていて興味がわいたので読んでみました。すごく面白かったです。１巻を寝る間も惜しんで読みました。私はカップルになるまでのお話が好きなので１巻で大満足して燃え尽きたんですが、また時間があれば２巻以降読みたいなと思います。

This review contains spoilers. A writer said he was addicted to it, and I was intrigued, so I read it. It was really interesting. I spared reading volume 1 while I was sleeping. I like stories about how they became a couple, so I was very satisfied with volume 1 and burned out, but if I have time, I would like to read volume 2 and beyond.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

読みやすい

readable

初めてラノベ読みました。スクールカーストのお話だったので苦手だなと思いつつ、試し読みが面白かったのと、ラノベ初心者にも読みやすそうな雰囲気を感じて購入。クーポンあると敷居が低くなりますね、ありがたいです。すっきり読みやすい文章でスッと話が入ってきました！完成度の高い作品だと感じました。本当に攻めが気持ち悪くて（でも好き）、作者様の思いがしっかり伝わります（笑）受けもカッコよくていいですね。学校モノ、芸能界モノがそもそも好みじゃないんですが、シリーズ続けて読み進めてしまう面白さがありました！個人的なツボとは少し違いますが、面白く読みやすくおススメです。この先生の他の作品も読んでみようと思いました！

I read a light novel for the first time. It was a school caste story, so while thinking I wasn't good at it, I felt that the trial reading was interesting and that the atmosphere seemed easy to read even for light novelists, so I bought it. If you have a coupon, the threshold will be lowered, so I'm thankful for that. The sentences were clear and easy to read, and the conversation came right in! I felt that it was a work with a high degree of perfection. The attack is really disgusting (but I like it), and it really conveys the author's thoughts (laughs), and it's nice that the reception is cool. I didn't like school stuff or entertainment stuff in the first place, but it was fun to keep reading the series! It's slightly different from personal pressure points, but I recommend it because it's interesting and easy to read. I thought I'd read this teacher's other works too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

１巻はキツイけど2巻以降はキモウザが逆襲

Volume 1 is tough, but after volume 2, Kimouza Strikes Back

１巻の前半はイジメの描写がつらくて、なんで受けが攻めにこんなに一途になっちゃうんだろうと入り込めなかったのですが、２巻以降じわじわと清居の良いところも分かってきて、何よりキモウザに周りがブンブン振り回されてくのが良いです。清居くんと師匠なんて翻弄されまくりで気の毒(笑)ハマったらぜひ短編集も読んでほしいです！エターナル！と、呟きたくなりますよ、たぶん。

In the first half of volume 1, the depiction of bullying was difficult, and I couldn't get in wondering why the attack was so aggressive, but after volume 2, I gradually came to understand Kiyoi's good points, and above all else, it's good that Kimouza swings around me. I feel sorry for Kiyoi-kun and his mentor being at the mercy of them (lol), I definitely want you to read the short stories too! eternal! It makes me want to mutter, probably.

Helpful

Reviews for My Beautiful Man LightNovel