Mr. Arthur Rutherford's Very Late First Love Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 26, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

手首のテーピング

Wrist taping

This review contains spoilers. 目立つし、リストカットの傷痕かと思われるような。仕事の面接なら、せめて長袖シャツを着るとか、隠そうよ。

This review contains spoilers. It's conspicuous, and it seems like it's a wrist cut scar. If it's a job interview, at least try to hide it by wearing a long-sleeved shirt or something.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

不憫受け

Accept the pity

This review contains spoilers. 不憫受けが好きな方は絶対に好きだと思います！スパダリ攻めと不憫受けのカップリングは最高ですね、、、攻めは初め、受けのことはタイプじゃないなどといって、からかおうとしていましたが、受けにどんどんはまっていって、好きになっていってるのがすごく良かったです。小説の方も読みたいなと思いました！

This review contains spoilers. I think people who like feeling sorry will definitely like it! The coupling between attacking Spadari and receiving pity is amazing... at the beginning of the attack, I was trying to make fun of receiving by saying they weren't my type, etc., but it was really nice that they became more and more addicted to receiving, and they fell in love with it. I wanted to read the novels too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

王道に振り切っている

I'm shaken off by the royal road

他の方も書いていましたが、ラストは少し駆け足感があります。２巻に分けでもよかったかな？と思いますが、王道に振り切っていて気持ちがよい。スパダリ大好きだし、今日はラブラブなお話が読みたい気分だったので、キュンキュンさせてもらい大満足でした。相変わらずねね先生の絵は上手くて最高だし、友達の大智くんと秘書のエミーもよいスパイスになっていたと思います。シリーズ化しているようなので、この先も楽しみです。

Other people also wrote it, but there is a slight sense of urgency at the end. Could it have been split into 2 volumes? I think, but it feels good to be swept away by the royal road. I love Spadari, and I felt like reading a lovey-dovey story today, so I was very satisfied that it made me cringe. As always, Nene Sensei is good at drawing and I think my friend Daichi-kun and his secretary Emmy were good spices. It looks like it's being made into a series, so I'm looking forward to the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

王道

The royal road

This review contains spoilers. スパダリとちょっと地味めアラサー男子の王道ラブストーリー。30歳で支社長(実力主義？)のアーサーと、元高校教師のトキ。お互いゲイというところ好きな設定でした。経験豊富だが恋は初心者なアーサー。何もかもはじめましてなトキ。お互いアラサーでそんな事あるのかーいって思うけど、その王道展開にキュンとできるかどうかが分かれ道ですね。私は先生の美麗な作画で少しずつ恋が進んでいくのがたまりませんでした。サブキャラの大智とエミーも存在感抜群。無駄なキャラがいなくてスッキリとまとまっているのが好きでした。

This review contains spoilers. A classic love story between Spadari and a slightly sober Arasa boy. Branch manager at age 30 (meritocracy?) Arthur from and Toki, a former high school teacher. We both liked the fact that they were gay. Arthur is experienced but new to love. Nice to meet you all, ibis. We both wonder if there is such a thing in Alasaa, but whether or not we can do it with ease is the road that divides the road. It was irresistible for me to see my love progress little by little due to my teacher's beautiful drawing. The subcharacters Daichi and Emmy also have an outstanding presence. I liked the fact that there were no useless characters and they were neatly organized.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

This review contains spoilers. 原作のファンです。コミックスも出たと知り、即購入しました。続くと思ったら一巻で収まったんですね。これはこれで、最後まで読めたので嬉しい。小説のイメージを損なう事なく、漫画にしてくれた事に感謝。

This review contains spoilers. I'm a fan of the original story. I learned that comics had also come out, so I bought them right away. When I thought it would continue, it would fit in one volume. I'm happy that I was able to read this to the end. Thank you for making it into a comic without damaging the image of the novel.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

思わず勢いで買った1冊

One book I bought with momentum

なんの情報もなく試し読みから即購入。めちゃくちゃ良かった！絵も綺麗だしアーサーの興味ない感じからの溺愛に向かう加速スピードえぐかった笑。秘書も友達もいい人だし超ハピエン！えちえちも幸せたっぷりで最高でした！！

I bought it right away from the trial reading without any information. That was insanely good! The pictures are beautiful, and Arthur's acceleration speed from feeling uninterested to doting on him was amazing lol. My secretary and friend are nice people and I'm super happy! Echiechi was also full of happiness and it was great!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ついにコミックス化！！！

It's finally being made into a comic!!

書籍でずっと好きだったラザフォードシリーズ！全シリーズが好きすぎてとてもキュンキュンくるので何度も何度も繰り返し読んでいました。そのシリーズがついにコミックスになって発売されたなら買うしか無い！絵もとても綺麗でコミックスにしなければならないので細かな内容は省かれている所もありましたがそれもまた良し！他の書籍シリーズもコミックス化していただきたいなぁと思いながら読んでおりました！

I've always loved the Rutherford book series! I liked all the series so much that I was so excited that I read them over and over again. If that series is finally released as a comic, I have no choice but to buy it! The pictures are also so beautiful that they have to be made into comics, so there were places where the details were omitted, but that's good too! I was reading it while thinking that I would like the other book series to be made into comics too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

究極のスパダリ攻めを堪能出来ます

You can enjoy the ultimate spadari attack

皆んな大好き王道の不憫受け、シンデレラストーリーです、小説読破済、漫画の分冊出た時から纏まるの待ってた、小説の挿絵よりも若くなったアーサーと反対にトキは少し成長してて、これはこれでお似合いって思いながら、好きな場面が漫画で見れて感無量です、アーサーの表情とか、トキが本当に好きなんだなって、小説読んでコミカライズも良く読むんですが、何か一番小説に忠実で没入出来た作品でした。

It's a Cinderella story, in response to the pity of the royal road that everyone loves, and I've been waiting to get together since the novel came out; in contrast to Arthur, who is younger than the illustrations in the novel, ibis has grown slightly, and while I think this is a good match, I can see scenes I like in comics, and I really like ibis, I really like Arthur's facial expressions, etc., and I read Comicalize a lot, but it was the work I was most faithful and immersed in the novel.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻に分けてじっくりでも良かった！

It was nice to split it into 2 volumes and take your time!

This review contains spoilers. 鮭田ねね先生の作画や表現が大好きなので即購入。美しい2人にうっとりです……さすが！！！！可哀想なトキと、初恋に戸惑うアーサー。トキの友人と、アーサーの秘書。主要人物みんな美しかった。ただひたすらに眼福です。ストーリーは1冊にまとめるためか、サクサク進みます。個人的には2冊に分けてじっくり描いても良かったのでは…？と思いましたが、お互い惹かれていく様子も描かれていてスッキリ纏まっていました。アーサーが感情爆発してふいにトキに近付くのとかドキドキしたし、こっち見ながら手首にキスはダメだって！！あんなの、惚れる！！！！！！！カッコよすぎ！！！！最後は気持ちも通じあってバカップル全開でしたね。ご馳走様です(合掌)トキはかなり過酷な過去を背負っていますが、これからの未来は明るいと思える結末で本当に良かった。幸せになってね！！

This review contains spoilers. I love Nene Sakeda's drawings and expressions, so I bought it right away. I'm fascinated by these two beautiful people... as expected!!! Poor ibis and Arthur are puzzled by their first love. Toki's friend and Arthur's secretary. All of the main characters were beautiful. It's just a blessing to my eyes. The story progresses quickly, probably because it is being put together into one book. Personally, wouldn't it be okay if I split it into 2 books and draw carefully...? I thought, but it also depicted how they were attracted to each other, so it was neatly organized. I was so excited that Arthur suddenly got close to the ibis when his emotions exploded, and they said it's no good to kiss my wrist while looking at me!! I'm in love with that!!!!! that's too cool!!! At the end, my feelings got through, and the couple were at their full throttle. Thank you for the meal (Gasshou) The ibis has a pretty tough past, but I'm really glad that the ending made me think the future is bright. Be happy!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

新作‼️待ってました?

new work ‼️ have you been waiting for it?

This review contains spoilers. ようやく単行本になったのですね⤴️エミーが綺麗で優秀すぎる✨️大智君はなぜ、あんなに優しいのでしょう。小説だと大智にも♥な人が現れるので、そこも単行本で見られると嬉しいです?★楽しみだ?トキとラザフォードがお似合いすぎて感動ですトキが度々危険な目に合うので心配でしたが?ようやく安心して過ごせますね。大智君の対応が適切で迅速で良かったですラザフォード頑張れ！しっかりしろ！！（笑）早く続きが読みたいです

This review contains spoilers. It's finally become a book ⤴️ Emmys are so beautiful and excellent ✨️ why is Daichi-kun so kind? If it's a novel, someone ♥ also appears in Daichi, so would you be happy to see that in the book too? ★ Looking forward to it? I'm moved that ibis and Rutherford are such a good match I was worried because ibises are often in danger? I'm finally able to spend my time feeling safe. I'm glad Daichi's response was appropriate and quick, Rutherford, good luck! stay firm!! (Laughter) I want to read more soon

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

金髪スパダリ☓黒髪受けに間違いなし！

Blonde Spa Dali ☓ Definitely a black hair recipient!

This review contains spoilers. 素晴らしい！！まさに美！美！美！で終始キラキラしてたんだがwスパダリ好きには堪らんよ！黒髪不憫受けは最高よ！！買う前から期待大だったけど！期待以上の大満足です！涙小説のシリーズ通り漫画もどんどん出して欲しいですっ！！2人の行く末を見届けさせて！

This review contains spoilers. great!! Exactly beautiful! beauty! beauty! It was sparkling from beginning to end, but W Spadari lovers can't stand it! Being sorry for black hair is awesome!! I had high expectations even before I bought it! I am more than satisfied than I expected! I want more and more comics to be released as per the Tearful Novel series!! Let me see where they both go!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 24, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

スパダリが可愛い

Spadari is cute

作者買いです。買っちゃうよね…絵が綺麗すぎて。お話も良かった。ただ他の方も書いてあるように少しお話を急ぎすぎな感じはあったかな。でも、最後まで安心して読めたので良かった。

I'm buying the author. I'm going to buy it... the picture is so beautiful. The story was good too. However, I think there was a feeling that I was in a bit of a hurry to talk like someone else was writing it. But I'm glad I was able to read it with peace of mind until the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 19, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

確かに

surely

This review contains spoilers. 遅すぎる初恋なんだろうな。トキはつらい経験をした後、職場を退職してそのリハビリとしてアーサーへ日本語を教えることになるけど、アーサーの好みではなかったから自分の気持ちに気が付くまで時間が掛かるし、伝えていないからこそ帰国命令が出れば離れなきゃいけないしでヤキモキ、、、、またもや、時がピンチに陥ってしまうけど助けることができたのに、気持ちは伝えられずでモヤモヤそれでも最後は気持ちが両想いであって良かった。大智・エミーの存在が有難いよね

This review contains spoilers. I wonder if it was my first love too late. After having a painful experience, Toki retired from work and taught Japanese to Arthur as rehabilitation, but since it wasn't Arthur's favorite, it took time until she realized her own feelings, and since she hadn't told them, she had to leave if an order to return home was issued, and she was agitated... once again, time was in a pinch, but I was able to help her, but I was able to help her, but at the end it was a blur. I'm thankful that Emmy Daichi exists

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 19, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が魅力的で、ストーリーにも興味が持てる

The pictures are fascinating, and I'm interested in the story

ライトノベルを先に購入してストーリーが好みだったのですがイラストが自分には合わず、反面コミックスの絵が魅力的だったのでライトノベルの２巻以降を読み進めていくのに、想像を膨らめ楽しみたいと思ったのでコミックス版も読んでみました。ライトノベルに比べるとページ数のためか、詳細な内容が削られている部分があり、アーサーがトキに恋心を抱くまでが少々雑になっているように私は感じましたが、絵が魅力的で個々のキャラに愛着が持てるのがとても良いです。30歳で多くの恋愛経験をしているはずのアーサーが、初めてともいえる本気の恋をするまでや、トキが巻き込まれている事件の行方にドキドキしながら読み進めていけます。

I bought the light novel first and liked the story, but the illustrations didn't suit me, and on the other hand, the comic pictures were attractive, so I continued reading volume 2 of the light novel and beyond, but I wanted to expand my imagination and enjoy it, so I also read the comic version. Compared to light novels, there are parts where the details have been cut down, probably because of the number of pages, and I felt that the time until Arthur had a crush on ibis was a bit cluttered, but it's very good that the pictures are attractive and I am attached to the individual characters. Arthur, who is supposed to have had many romantic experiences at the age of 30, can be read on with excitement until he falls in serious love, which can be said to be his first time, and the whereabouts of the incident involving an ibis.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 18, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

王道のBL

The royal BL

This review contains spoilers. 画もとても綺麗で、話もうまくまとまっていて面白かったです！話自体はスパダリと可愛い系の最終的に溺愛になるＢＬによくある王道の話でしたが、キャラクターがよくて楽しく読めました。アーサーが単なるスパダリではなく初恋ゆえにちょっとポンコツなところが良かったです。トキも可愛いの代表みたいなキャラで良かったです。ただ、ジムのトレーナーのくだりは必要なかったのでは？なんて思ってしまいました。

This review contains spoilers. The pictures were very beautiful, and the story was well-organized and interesting! The story itself was a classic story often seen in BL where Spadari and Kawaii eventually became lovers, but the characters were so good that I enjoyed reading it. It was nice that Arthur wasn't just Spadari, but a little lackluster because of his first love. I'm glad that ibis is also a representative character of cute people. However, wasn't there a need for a gym trainer's job? That made me think.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 17, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろかった

That was interesting

攻めの初恋が遅いからか、めっちゃ愛が重くてよかった！絵柄が好みで買ったけど、内容も良くて読みやすかった〜はじめて日本人同士じゃない物語を読んだけど意外とありだなーって思える作品でした！

I'm glad that love is so heavy, probably because the attacking first love is slow! I bought it because I liked the design, but the content was good and easy to read. It was the first time I read a story where people weren't Japanese people, but it was a work that surprised me!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 12, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

好き！

I like it!

アーサーラザフォード氏の〜シリーズは原作も大好きで、それをこれまた大好きな鮭田先生がコミカライズされるなんて嬉しすぎて何度も読んでいます！残念なのは二巻完結だということ！（二巻目は番外編ですし）番外編だけとは言わずできればこの先のトキとアーサーの甘々生活も鮭田先生の美麗コミカライズで読みたいです！何卒よろしくお願いしますっっ！！

I love the original story of Arthur Rutherford's ~ series, and I'm so happy that my favorite Sakeda-sensei is comicalizing it so many times! Too bad volume 2 is complete! (Volume 2 is an extra edition, and if possible, I'd like to read The Sweet Life of Toki and Arthur in the Future with Sakeda Sensei's Beautiful Comicalization without saying that it's just the extra edition! Thank you so much for your cooperation!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 08, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

作画がいい

Drawing is good

原作未読です。コミカライズの感想としては、まず作画の作者者の作画なこと、ですね。そうでなければ読むことなかったです。秘書エミーさんの画像化と気遣いっぷりが素敵〜

I haven't read the original story. My first impression of Comicalize is that it was drawn by the author of the drawing. Otherwise I wouldn't have read it. The images and care of the secretary Emmy are wonderful ~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

アーサー格好良い

Arthur is good looking

絵が美しいです。百戦錬磨？のアーサーが、初恋って、意外で可愛かったです。ストーカー被害で痛痛しい場面もありましたが、ハピエンなので、読後感は良かったです。

The picture is beautiful. a hundred battle refinement? Arthur's first love was surprisingly cute. There was also a painful scene due to being stalked, but since it's happy, I felt good after reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 26, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

王道ラブストーリー♩

A classic love story ♩

This review contains spoilers. ねね先生の作品はホントに画がキレイ！顔はキレイなのにブツがリアルというギャップがまた良きです?時広とトキを掛けてるのもステキだし、トキ自身がとってもチャーミングでした。遊び人だったアーサーが惹かれていくのも分かるよ。そしてダイチもステキ！

This review contains spoilers. The pictures in Nene sensei's works are really beautiful! Is the gap where the face is beautiful but the stuff is real again good? The one with Tokihiro and the ibis was also wonderful, and the ibis itself was very charming. I also understand that Arthur, who was a playboy, was attracted to him. And Daichi is wonderful too!

Helpful

Reviews for Mr. Arthur Rutherford's Very Late First Love Manga