The Executed Sage Who Was Reincarnated as a Lich Started an All-Out War Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

良い

good

This review contains spoilers. 気がついたら最新刊まで読んでしまう程面白い。魔王さまの人間だった頃の優しさと賢さもそのままで、でも矛盾していることをしなくては進めないことも全て背負っていくその覚悟の先がどうか報われてほしいと願ってる

This review contains spoilers. It's so interesting that if you notice it, you'll even read the latest edition. The kindness and cleverness of the Demon Lord when he was a human remains the same, but I hope that the future of being prepared to carry everything that cannot be progressed without doing contradictory things will be rewarded

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

7巻まで読みました。リッチ（骸骨）が主人公ということであまり期待していなかったけどとても面白い。敵も強くなってきましたがこのまま無双を続けてほしいものです。

I've read up to 7 volumes. Rich (skeleton) is the main character, so I wasn't expecting much, but it's very interesting. The enemies are getting stronger, but I want Warriors to continue like this.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

間違ってはいない

There's nothing wrong

This review contains spoilers. 内紛(このマンガでは人類同士の争い)をなくすためには強大な敵に向かってまとまる(まとめる)というのは支配者からすると間違ってはいない。(某国も同じ手法ですよね？)ただ、犠牲になる市井の人間からするとたまったものではないのですがまあそれは▪▪▪7巻のおまけ小説みたいな展開だったら、主人公はもっと良かったのか？最後までどーなるか期待は膨らみます。

This review contains spoilers. In order to eliminate internal feuds (disputes between humans in this manga), it is not wrong from the point of view of rulers to unite (consolidate) against a mighty enemy. (Some countries use the same method, right?) However, from the point of view of Ichii people who are sacrificed, it's not an accumulation of things, but if it developed like a bonus novel in volume ▪▪▪ 7, would the main character be better? Expectations are high as to what will happen until the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

非常に思想的に偏った読み方をしてみると

If you try to read it in a very ideologically biased way

異世界物の良い所の一つに様々な思いを込めてもスルーされる事にある。原作者の意図が明確に掴める訳ではないが、侵略を受けた国のいろいろな種族が力を合わせて仲良く街づくりをしている姿にメッセージ性を感じる。帝国はあの国だろうか、エルフの国は資源豊富なかの国だろうか。それとも、私の読み方は間違っているのだろうか？

Even if you put a variety of thoughts into one of the good things from another world, it can get passed through. It's not like I can clearly grasp the original author's intention, but I feel the message is that the various races in the invaded country are joining forces to create a city on good terms. Is the empire that country, or is the country of the elves rich in resources? Or am I reading it wrong?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

キャラよし、テンポよし、笑いもあり

Good characters, good tempo, and laughter

ダークな展開の中にも、仲間キャラたちは個性があり好感をもてるし、笑いもあり暗い雰囲気も中和されます。後、テンポよく話が進むので読みやすく中弛みが今のところないです。オーバーロードとか好きな人に合うと思います。

Even in the dark development, fellow characters are unique and likeable, and the dark atmosphere is neutralized by laughing. Afterwards, the story progresses at a good tempo, so it's easy to read, and there's no slack in the middle so far. I think it's suitable for people who like Overlord.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ダークヒーロー的な感じです。

It feels like a dark hero.

This review contains spoilers. 勇者と戦ったかつての賢者が、勇者ともども人間の都合で汚名をきせられ殺され、怨みからアンデッドとしてよみがえる。そして、新たな魔王として、侵略を開始。なかなか面白いです。きれいごとではない、人間の醜さからみると、魔族のほうがわかりやすいのかもしれません。今後どうなっていくか楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. A wise man in the past who fought against the brave is stigmatized and killed by human convenience, and is revived as an undead from grudge. Then, as a new demon king, he begins his invasion. It's pretty interesting. It's not pretty; from the point of view of human ugliness, demons may be easier to understand. I'm looking forward to seeing what happens in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 24, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる作品

Works I'm worried about continuing

出だしから、えぇ！？？と驚きがあり、（タイトル通りだな…と後から気付くわけだけど）強敵がしっかり描かれているので、読みごたえもあって続きが気になってしまう漫画です。

right from the start, huh!?? There was a surprise (I realized later that it was as the title suggests...), and the strong enemies are clearly drawn, so it's a comic that is hard to read, and I'm worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

せつない

It's annoying

冒頭からチートを得てその後までもずっとせつない主人公の思いつまらない転生モノとかだとその切なさを忘れがちなのにこの作品はチートを発揮しても強い従者ができてもとにかくずっとせつないいつか彼が報われる日がきますように

I get a cheat from the beginning and it's easy to forget that sadness when it's the protagonist's unimaginable reincarnation or something, but even if this work shows up a cheat, even if a strong follower forms, it's always a long time, so I hope someday the day will come when he will be rewarded

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

なんだか考えさせられるな〜

Somehow it makes me think ~

正と悪、だけでは語れない話です。勇者が女の人だったのに驚きましたが、賢者の一途な想いがリッチにしたんだと思うと切なくなりました。絵も綺麗で、読み応えがあります。

It's a story that cannot be told with just good and evil. I was surprised that the brave man was a woman, but it made me sad to think that the wise man's unwavering feelings made him rich. The pictures are also beautiful and easy to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い?

interesting?

This review contains spoilers. 魔王討伐後に勇者の力を恐れた人間に殺される元勇者の物語なんですが、序盤から引き付けるストーリーで、骨のイラストも緻密でかなり良きでした。内容も単純な復讐物にはせずに運命に逆らうストーリーにした点もハマりましたね。また、この世界では人間が汚いので容赦なく汚物を消毒しているのでスカッとしますね?ｽｯｷﾘ３巻で正義と悪の正面衝突があるのですが、どちらも負けて欲しくない心境になる戦いは面白いですね。魔王は一度正義の道を通っているので『その道はこの世界じゃ通用しないよ？』と知っているのですが、そんな事言えるわけもなく、結末も良い感じでした。悪役と正義との戦いがどうなるのか、まだまだ先が楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story about a former hero who is killed by a human who feared the power of the brave after defeating the demon king, but it's a story that attracts people from the beginning, and the bone illustrations are also precise and pretty good. I was also addicted to the fact that it was a story about defying fate without making it a simple revenge. Also, in this world, humans are dirty, so they are mercilessly disinfecting filth, so it's refreshing, isn't it? There is a head-on clash between justice and evil in volume 3, and the battle that makes you feel like you don't want either of them to lose is interesting. The demon king has gone through the path of justice once, so “that path doesn't work in this world, does it?” I know, but there's no way I can say that, and the ending felt good. I'm still looking forward to seeing what the battle between the villain and justice will turn out.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 19, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

悪から始まる秩序と平和

Order and Peace Beginning with Evil

レビューの高さから気になり読んでみましたが、無事好きな作品の一つとなりました。共に歩んだ勇者へのリスペクト、必要悪としての道を歩むことへの切なさ、人間の性弱説について描かれたテーマに惹きつけられるモノがありました。レビューの時点で4巻まで出ていましたが、4巻目は特にお勧めです♪

I was curious and read it because of the high reviews, but it became one of my favorite works. There were things that attracted me to the themes depicted about respect for the brave men who walked together, the sadness of walking the path of necessary evil, and the theory of human weakness. At the time of the review, up to 4 volumes had been released, but I especially recommend volume 4 ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

新しいジャンル

New genres

テンポ良く進み、話もしっかりしているので読みやすいです。新しいジャンルで、勇者(賢者)が自分達が倒した魔王後の新たなる魔王になるというお話。なろう系っぽいが、黒い部分が多く成年漫画的ジャンルになるのかな？ｈはなくて、人に奨めやすいのも〇。

The tempo progresses well, and the story is solid, so it's easy to read. In a new genre, it's a story about a brave man (wise man) becoming a new demon king after the demon queen they have defeated themselves. It looks like a naro series, but I wonder if it will become an adult comic genre with a lot of black parts? It doesn't have h, and it's easy to recommend it to people.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 07, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

魔王なりの真理がスゴい

The demon king's truth is amazing

異世界勇者で、不遇ものというカテゴリもあるようですが、成り上がるそれとは一線を画すもの。まぁー骸骨ばっかりで画がうまいのかよくわかりませんが、とりあえず黒い、台詞の吹き出しからして黒い笑でもしっかり描かれており迫力もあります(人物は少し苦手なのかな…些末なことですが)。魔王側の理屈で考えて実行します。昔のRPGではなかった積極的な魔王。どこか儚く切ない雰囲気もありつつ理想に邁進する姿には惹き付けられました。評価が良かったので読み始めましたが、これは展開が気になる！オススメ

There also seems to be a category called Isekai Hero and Unlucky, but it's something that sets it apart from that that that that makes up. Well, I'm not sure if the picture is good because it's just skulls, but for the time being, it's black, and even with a black laugh, it's very impressive (I wonder if people aren't good at it... it's trivial). I will think about it according to the logic of the devil's side and execute it. An aggressive demon king who wasn't an RPG in the old days. I was attracted to the sight of them pushing forward with ideals while also having a somewhat ephemeral and sad atmosphere. The reviews were good, so I started reading it, but I'm curious about the development! recommended

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

3巻目

Volume 3

1巻から読んでます。なろう、ざまぁ系とは違い深く読める。主人公の世界への憎しみがあり戦闘時の画も汚くなくいい。

I've been reading since volume 1. Unlike the Naro and Zamaa series, it can be read in depth. There is hatred for the main character's world, and it's nice that the battle pictures aren't dirty either.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 04, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

大人向け

for adults

かなり深い哲学を感じる。最後は魔王様が倒され、成仏して勇者様と再会する、という結末になるだろうけど、そこまでの道のりも葛藤も想像するだけでワクワクする。魔王様なりの平和の在り方をどう形作るのか。思想の帰結がどうあっても、我々現実の世界平和にも対応するのひとつの答えになるように思う。シャア然り、マジメな悪は、いつの時代もカッコいいな。

I feel a pretty deep philosophy. At the end, the demon king is defeated, and the ending will be where they attain Buddhism and be reunited with the brave man, but it's exciting just to imagine the journey and conflict up to that point. How does the demon king shape the way peace exists in his own way? No matter what the consequences of our thoughts are, I think it will be one answer that responds to our real world peace. Serious evil, like Char, is always cool.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 28, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

人間の愚かさを知れ

Know the stupidity of humans

This review contains spoilers. 魔王討伐後その力を恐れられた女性勇者は人間に殺された。魔王を倒すほどの力を持つ人間は人間の世界には要らないのだ。甘んじて其れを受け入れた勇者の傍には彼女を愛した賢者が常い居た。闇に落ちた賢者はアンテッドのロードと成り世界を粛清して行く、彼女の意思を引き継ぎ世界の平和の為絶対の悪へとなる為に。圧倒的な画力と書き込みでアンテッドの大群と人間との戦争を描くダークファンタジーが此処に始まった、面白いぜ。

This review contains spoilers. After defeating the demon king, female brave women who were feared for their power were killed by humans. The human world doesn't need people who have enough power to defeat a demon king. There was always a wise man who loved her beside the brave man who was content and accepted her. The wise man who fell into darkness becomes Lord of Unted and purges the world, in order to take over her intentions and become absolute evil for world peace. This is where the dark fantasy, which depicts the war between the Hordes of Unted and humans with overwhelming drawing power and writing, began here, which is interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がきれい

The picture is beautiful

絵がきれいで読みやすい。エロが無いのところも良いです。続きが読みたくなります。

The pictures are beautiful and easy to read. It's also good that there's no eroticism. It makes me want to read more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 07, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

愛する人の意志を継ぐため魔王になる

Become a demon king to inherit the will of someone you love

This review contains spoilers. 魔王を倒し平和な世界になるはずだったのに、その力を恐れられ、無実の罪を着せられ処刑された賢者がアンデットとなり甦る。アンデットの賢者は魔王として復活し、人類共通の敵となることで世界の平和を保とうとする。生前愛した人の意思を尊重するために(涙)思いの外、深く良いテーマ。設定。絵が好みではないのでそこだけ残念。でも、好きなマンガですわ！

This review contains spoilers. It was supposed to defeat the demon king and become a peaceful world, but a wise man who was feared for his power, charged with an innocent crime and executed, becomes undead and revived. The wise man of the Undead revives as a demon king and tries to maintain world peace by becoming a common enemy of all humankind. It's an unexpectedly deep and good theme to respect the intentions of people I loved during my lifetime (tears). settings. I don't like pictures, so that's just a shame. But it's my favorite manga!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 07, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが楽しみです。

I'm looking forward to the continuation.

This review contains spoilers. 魔王を討伐した女勇者と賢者(主人公)が、２人の力を恐れたゲスな国王の謀略で悪人に仕立て上げられて処刑され、主人公だけがアンデット化して復活、魔王という驚異が無くなったせいで人間同士で争うようになったのなら、自分が魔王になって必要悪になろうと、人類相手に戦争をする話しです。序盤でゲス国王やその他大勢への復讐は完了するので、すっきりと次のステップへ入って行けるのは良かったです、主人公も処刑された恨みから人類抹殺とかではなく、人類どうして争わないように必要悪としてあろうとしてるところが良いです。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story about the heroine hero and the wise man (protagonist), who subdued the demon king, being made into villains and executed in a plot by a dangerous king who feared the power of the two, and only the main character undead and revived, and if humans began to fight with each other because the wonder of the demon king disappeared, then they go to war against humanity in order to become a necessary evil person. Revenge against King Guess and many others is completed in the early stages, so it was nice to be able to move into the next step cleanly, and it's good that the main character is not about annihilating humanity out of a grudge against being executed, and it's good that they are trying to be a necessary evil so that humanity doesn't fight for some reason.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

あえての悪人

Dare to be the villain

This review contains spoilers. 勇者として魔王を倒したのにその後力が強すぎるためかふざけた処刑をした人間達命を失ったが何の因果がリッチとして生まれ変わり悪の魔王になり世界の均衡を保つため抵抗勢力を次々と倒していく面白いのはただ平和にするだけじゃ意味がないから巨悪を演じ平和を保つ他の話にはない斬新さ?

This review contains spoilers. Even though they defeated the demon king as a hero, the humans who carried out playful executions lost their lives, but what cause and effect are reincarnated as rich, become the evil demon king, and defeat resistance forces one after another in order to maintain balance in the world. What's interesting is that just making peace has no point, so they play great evil and maintain peace is a novelty not found in other stories?

Helpful

Reviews for The Executed Sage Who Was Reincarnated as a Lich Started an All-Out War Manga