<Chapter release>The Fake Alchemist Manga Reviews

Shinto

Report

Aug 20, 2026 (PST) | Total Reviews: 12

Very original ideas that make you go wow

This series may start off in a very common isakia way. But very quickly sets itself apart with very original ideas and insane themes that make you go wow that really just happen. I highly doubt anyone has read something with ideas quite like this. So strap yourself in and ignore any initial ichy feelings.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 27, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

大どんでん返しの繰り返し

The repetition of the big twists

ここまでの展開は大変面白かった。パラケルススの人の良さと、それに魅かれて仲間になっていくものたちの成長と、いい意味でのストーリーの裏切りがあり、目が離せない作品。この漫画の代金を支払う価値が十分にある作品です。

The developments up to this point have been very interesting. It's a work you can't take your eyes off of Paracelsus's goodness, the growth of those who are fascinated by them and the betrayal of the story in a good sense. It's a work well worth paying for this comic.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 25, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

凄いの一言！

That's an amazing word!

This review contains spoilers. 数多ある異世界転生作品中で1番好きかも！主人公がお人好しなんだけど、ちゃんと欲もあり、賢く立ち回りしたりしててバランスが良い。あと、なんと言ってもノラさん！こっちが主人公かと思うほどの存在感と頭脳プレー！惚れ惚れしますね^^凄い作品に出会えて嬉しいです！

This review contains spoilers. Maybe it's my favorite out of all the many Isekai Reincarnation movies! The main character is friendly, but he also has good greed, fights smartly, and has a good balance. Also, after all, Nora! It has such a strong presence and brain play that I think this is the main character! I'm in love with you ^^ I'm happy to have come across such an amazing work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 29, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

異世界もの

Something from another world

評価高かったので読みましたが結構おもしろい。早く続編が読みたいです。内容もですが絵のタッチも好きです。

The reviews were high, so I read it, and it was quite interesting. I want to read the sequel soon. As for the content, I also like the touch of the pictures.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 22, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

重厚なストーリー

A profound story

設定やストーリー展開が本当によく練られていて毎話ごとの情報量がとてつもない。鏡の世界編は切なかったけど、悪役の思考回路がサイコすぎて…正直めちゃくちゃ面白かった。鏡の世界編始まったばかりの時からは想像もつかない展開の続出でたまらなかった。ノラさんと主人公のイチャイチャシーンもっと下さい！?これからも楽しみに読みます！

The setting and story development are really well thought out, and the amount of information for each episode is tremendous. The World of Mirrors was sad, but the villain's thought line was so psycho... honestly, it was insanely interesting. From the time the World of Mirrors began, it was unbearable with a series of unimaginable developments. Please give me more flirting scenes with Nora and the main character!? I'm looking forward to reading it from now on!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 23, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

エルフの娘を早く治してあげて欲しい

I want you to heal the elven's daughter as soon as possible

主人公が買い取ったエルフの娘が、あまりにひどい状態なので、心が痛みます。主人公が少しずつでも彼女を直す努力をしてくれるのが嬉しいです。

The elven daughter that the protagonist bought is in such a terrible state that it hurts my heart. I'm happy that the main character makes an effort to fix her little by little.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 22, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

異世界転生物の緩さ＋ダークファンタジー

The Relaxation of Isekai Tensei: The Relaxation and Dark Fantasy

お話の入りは異世界転生物のよくあるやつなんだけど、そこからの展開が全然違いました。設定がしっかりしていて、厚みがある。主人公以外のキャラが一見普通に見えて、実に個性的。そこからくる展開が、何か、新しいものを見ている感じでした。1巻は序の口です。ジャンルは多分ダークファンタジー。でも、主人公がお人好しというか、チョロいというか。異世界転生物で有りがちな緩さと、奴隷ノアの出自からくるダークさが、いい塩梅で面白さに繋がっていると思う。3巻ノアちゃん最高。読むのが止められずに既刊5巻読了。少しハードなのが読める人ならおすすめです。

The beginning of the story is a common one from Isekai Tensei, but the development from there was completely different. The settings are firm and thick. Characters other than the main character look normal at first glance, and are really unique. The developments that came from there felt like I was seeing something new. Volume 1 is the beginning. The genre is probably dark fantasy. But I think the main character is friendly, or rather stupid. I think the looseness that tends to occur in Isekai Tensei and the darkness that comes from the origin of Noah the slave lead to fun with good salt. Volume 3 Noah is awesome. I couldn't stop reading and read the 5 volumes that have already been published. If you can read something a little hard, I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

木目細かい設定が凄い

The detailed wood settings are amazing

物語自体は今のところ地味な展開ですが、世界観と錬金術と呪術の設定が奥深く細かく考えられていて面白いです。その世界観の説明のための文字や台詞が多めな点は難点かと思いました。作画は丁寧で細かくキャラクターデザインも作風に合っていて好き。異世界転生物でチートスキルを貰ったけれど、簡単便利ではないところも良いし、能力で生成したものをどう使うかなどの商売の視点が描かれていて興味深い。

The story itself is a sober development so far, but it's interesting that the world view and settings for alchemy and magic have been thought out in depth and detail. I thought the point where there were so many characters and lines to explain that view of the world was a drawback. I like the drawing because the drawing is careful and detailed, and the character design matches the style. I got a cheat skill in Isekai Tensei, but it's interesting that it's not easy or convenient, and it depicts business perspectives such as how to use things generated by abilities.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

緻密な設定と伏線多数

Precise settings and lots of foreshadowing

ストーリー、人物設定、画力、蘊蓄、全てが揃った秀作。一話一話がチート異世界幼稚漫画の３巻分に相当するためじっくり読み進めることができ、コストパフォーマンスは星5です。何度読み返しても新たな気づきや人物像の魅力を再認識することができます。多数の伏線が散りばめられているため、これからどの様に展開するのかとても気になる作品です。

An excellent work that has everything: story, character settings, drawing power, and modesty. Each episode is equivalent to 3 volumes of Cheat Isekai Childish Manga, so you can read them carefully, and the cost performance is 5 stars. No matter how many times you reread it, you will be able to re-recognize a new awareness and the appeal of the person. There are many foreshadowing scattered around, so I'm very curious about how it will unfold in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 23, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが楽しみ

I'm looking forward to the continuation

ストーリーが細かいところまで作り込まれてて読めば読むほど新しい発見があります。ノラさんもめっちゃタイプですし、早く続きが読みたいです。

The story is detailed down to the smallest detail, and the more you read, the more new discoveries there are. Nora is also really my type, and I want to read more soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 07, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

ありがとう

thanks

この作品を書いてくれてありがとうございます。久しぶりに一気読みしてしまうほど面白かったですつづき、たのしみにしてます

Thank you so much for writing this work. It was so interesting that I read it all at once for the first time in a long time, and I'm looking forward to it

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 28, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

秀作です

It's an excellent work

続きか読みたくなる周作と思います。魔法や錬金術などの世界に興味がある人なら手に取ってみる価値があると思います。単純明快でサクサク読み進めるというより、じっくり世界観に浸って読み進めると良い作品だと思いました。

I think it's a Shusaku that makes you want to read more. If you're interested in the world of magic, alchemy, etc., I think it's worth picking it up. Rather than reading it simply and clearly, I thought it would be a good work to carefully immerse myself in the worldview and read on.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 15, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

入りはありがちな異世界転移もので、しかもちょいちょいグロいけど、熱い展開だし続きも気になります。単純な俺つえぇチート系じゃないのも相まってとても良い作品。ヒロインや登場する他の女の子も好感持てて良いですね。悪役もなかなかな悪役っぷりです。

It's an otherworldly transition that tends to happen, and it's also a bit gross, but it's a hot development and I'm worried about the continuation. Coupled with the fact that it's not a simple me cheat series, it's a very good work. It's nice that the heroine and the other girls who appear are likable too. The villains are also pretty villains.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

人は選ぶがいい異世界モノ

Things from another world are good for people to choose

This review contains spoilers. キャラデザと設定からして情けない主人公が頼もしい口リと一緒にかわいそうな境遇の美女を侍らせて気持ちよくなる作品かと思っていたけど途中から本領発揮し始めた。ヒロインの過去開示から戦闘に至るまでの描写が秀逸。世界観や人物に関する描写に関しても少し説明過剰な気はするがしっかりしている。それはそれとして作画の人が成人向け漫画を描いているので時折にじみ出るエ□をものともせず頭脳戦を楽しめる人にはすごい刺さると思う。

This review contains spoilers. I thought it would be a work where the character design and setting make a pitiful protagonist serve a beautiful woman in a poor situation along with her reliable voice, making you feel comfortable, but it began to show off in the middle. The depiction from the heroine's past disclosure to battle is excellent. I feel like it's a bit excessive to explain the worldview and depictions about people, but it's solid. As such, the animators draw comics for adults, so I think it would be really painful for people who can enjoy brain battles without worrying about the E□ that oozes out from time to time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

歌出はよくある死後異世界転生もの。主人公は今のところ弱い。強強転生チートではないのでそーゆーの好きな人には合わないかな。

Songs are often reincarnated in another world after death. The main character is weak at the moment. It's not a strong reincarnation cheat, so I wonder if it's suitable for people who like Soyu.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 25, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いが

It's interesting

This review contains spoilers. 気弱な転生主人公で奴隷やボロボロに傷付けられたエルフを救うのは好ましいが、青年漫画だからか性的な行為を受け入れて言われるがままヤッてしまうのが残念。そこはそういう目的ではないと毅然と断って誠意を示してくれたら、好感度が更に上がったのに。奴隷制度と性的な搾取は現実に切り離せない悪辣な問題。『奴隷ってそういう扱いをしても良いのだ』と読者に刷り込み兼ねないので、世界で行われている事が『悪しき事』だと理解するようなマンガにして欲しい。ただ、錬金術や呪術が織り交ぜられた物語自体は面白い。

This review contains spoilers. It is preferable to save elves who have been harmed by slaves or in tatters, who are the main characters in timid reincarnation, but it's a pity that they accept sexual acts, probably because it's a youth comic, and they get screwed when they say it. If they showed their sincerity by resolutely refusing that wasn't the purpose, their likability would have increased even more. Slavery and sexual exploitation are vicious issues that cannot be separated from reality. “Slaves can be treated that way” can be imprinted on readers, so I want the manga to make them understand that what is going on in the world is a “bad thing.” However, the story itself, which involves alchemy and magic, is interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

いい意味でエグい

Bad in a good sense

This review contains spoilers. パラケルススくんの優しさがすごいですね。こんな世界では私１日も生きて行けません。転生する時からめちゃくちゃ頭使わないとすぐおだぶつです。と言えるほどに命の軽い世界で、パラケルススくんは命を無駄にするなー！と懸命に生きています(めっちゃ狙われてるのに)魔術(禁術)、錬金術、呪術の差異をかいていて面白いそれにしてもスライムかわいいよショゴス…

This review contains spoilers. Paracelsus-kun's kindness is amazing. I can't live a day in this kind of world. If you don't use your head a lot from the time you get reincarnated, you'll soon be idle. In a world where life is so light, Paracelsus doesn't waste his life! I'm living hard (even though I'm being targeted a lot), it's interesting because it shows the differences between magic (forbidden art), alchemy, and sorcery, and even so, slime is cute...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

昔公開されてたラフ版から好きでした。

I've liked it since the rough version that was released a long time ago.

ラフ版ですら楽しく読めた作品が質があがって戻ってきてて本当に嬉しかったです。ラフ版の時より長く続いてくれると嬉しいな。

I was really happy that the quality of the work, which I enjoyed reading even in the rough version, improved and came back. I would be happy if it lasts longer than the rough version.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 13, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

はーっ

huh

This review contains spoilers. ３巻、いいとこで終わった〰️どうにかみんな助かって鏡の世界から抜け出せるといいな。でも、ドラゴンが！それと現世ではのらちゃんの腕が！ホントに良い風にいって欲しい。４巻いつ出るんだろ、、、

This review contains spoilers. Volume 3 ended at a good place 〰️ I hope everyone can somehow be saved and get out of the mirror world. But dragons! Also, Nora-chan's skill in this world! I really want you to have a nice breeze. I wonder when volume 4 will come out...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 07, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

これはいい作品になりそうです

this looks like it's going to be a good work

This review contains spoilers. 世界観ガッツリ作りこんでいて、自分にはちょっと難しいんですけど、これは面白いですよ。主人公は優秀ですけど、チートってほどでもない。攻撃力から言ったら弱い方です、ただとっても意思が強くて、どうにかして工夫して、強敵からみんなを守ろうとする所なんか、とても格好いいです。そして出てくる女キャラがみんな強くて頭が良く、と言っても男勝りの筋肉キャラとかじゃなくて、頭が良くてこれまた格好いいです。自分が知らないだけかもしれませんが、異世界モノは溢れているのに類似作品も思い当たりません。次がとても楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. I've made up a lot of worldview, and it's a bit difficult for me, but this is interesting. The main character is excellent, but he's not that much of a cheat. In terms of attack power, they are weak; they just have very strong intentions, and they try to protect everyone from strong enemies by devising ways, which is very cool. Also, the female characters that come up are all strong and smart, and even if you say, they're not muscular characters that are superior to men, they're smart, and this is also cool. Maybe it's just that I don't know, but even though there are so many things from another world, I can't think of similar works. I'm really looking forward to the next one.

Helpful

Reviews for <Chapter release>The Fake Alchemist Manga