I Body-Switched With an Evil Hag for 10 Years, and Now My Knight Ex-Fiance Who Never Wanted To See Me Again Can't Let Me Go Manga Reviews (P.6)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

恋愛ものと、謎解きが同時進行しているストーリー。片想いを拗らせて、入れ替わった悪女と婚約破棄出来ないでいる騎士。まだ序盤で迫ってはこないけど、やきもち焼き。なぜ入れ替わりが起こったのか、まだまだ謎は多いので楽しみです。

A story about romance and mystery solving going on at the same time. A knight who has relentless unrequited love and is unable to break her engagement with a bad woman who has been replaced. It's still early and it's not close, but yakimochi-yaki. There are still many mysteries about why the replacement occurred, so I'm looking forward to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

うっわ！面白くてちょっとゾクゾクした！

wow! It was so funny that I was a little thrilled!

This review contains spoilers. 伯爵令嬢セイディが７歳の心を持ったまま突然身体が入れ替わり30歳の奴隷になってしまい10年。ある日突然元の身体に戻ると10年間酷い悪女だった現実。戻ってきた時、婚約者のルーファスはセイディを10年見捨てずにいてくれたけれど我慢の限界で婚約破棄しているシーン。ルーファスは身体が入れ替わっていたというセイディを前に入れ替わる前の彼女との思い出や恋心を忘れられず複雑で更にだんだんと昔の様に見え動揺していく。セイティの他にも入れ替わりの人達もいてセイディはその1人ジェラルドと出会う。ほんとワクワクする展開。見た目も全然違うけれど同じ時代と場所で入れ替わりが沢山で伏線が多くあるようでドキドキする。原作の琴子先生の作品は見つけて試し読みもせず即購読するくらいに大好き。絵はものすごく好み。ぼてまる先生初読みですがキレイで見やすく表情もいい。ジェラルドは見た目も性格もドストライク。この先照れ顔がみれたら最高だなぁ。コマ割りが読みやすくすっとストーリーに引き込まれていくような流れもいい。本編123Pおまけ５P。ちょっと短く感じるけれど私は大満足。これからも追いかけます。原作は未読ですが読みに行こうと思っています。

This review contains spoilers. It's been 10 years since Sadie, the Earl's daughter, had a 7-year-old heart and suddenly changed her body and she became a 30-year-old slave. The reality is that she was a terrible evil woman for 10 years when she suddenly returned to her original body one day. When I came back, there was a scene where my fiancee Rufus hadn't abandoned Sadie for 10 years, but they annulled their engagement due to the limit of patience. Rufus can't forget his memories and love feelings with his girlfriend before Sadie, whose body had been replaced before, and it's complicated, and it seems even more and more like it used to be, and he becomes upset. In addition to Satie, there are also replacements, and Sadie meets Gerald, one of them. It's a really exciting development. It looks completely different, but it's exciting that there are so many changes and so many foreshadowing in the same era and place. I love it so much that I found the original Kotoko sensei's work and immediately subscribed to it without trial reading it. I really like the picture. This is my first time reading Botemaru-sensei, and she is beautiful, easy to see, and has a nice expression. Gerard has a strong appearance and personality. It would be great if I could see a shy face in the future. It's also nice to have a flow where the frame breaks are easy to read and you're quickly drawn into the story. Main story 123P bonus 5P It feels a bit short, but I'm very satisfied. I will continue to chase them. I haven't read the original story, but I'm thinking of going to read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

これからが楽しみ

I'm looking forward to the future

原作の琴子さんが大好きで、新刊が出ると原作を読みに行く、というルーティンが生まれています。読みやすく幸せな気持ちになる話が多いんですよね。特に盛り上がる話はないのですが。絵も綺麗なのでこれからが楽しみです。

I love the original story, Kotoko, and a routine of going to read the original story when the new book comes out has been created. There are a lot of stories that are easy to read and make you feel happy. There aren't any particularly exciting stories, though. The pictures are also beautiful, so I'm looking forward to the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

また新しい展開で

Also with new developments

ありそうでなかった新しいストーリー展開にドキドキします。早くいろいろな謎が明らかになりホッとさせて欲しいです。

I'm excited about the new, unlikely storyline. I hope that all kinds of mysteries will soon be revealed and that they will feel relieved.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

入れ代わり

replace

すっごく気になります！子供が大人の体に入って奴隷扱いされて10年も過ごすなんて想像できない！誰かの仕業だとしたら酷すぎます！続きを早く読みたいです！

It really bothers me! I can't imagine a child being treated as a slave for 10 years in the body of an adult! It would be too bad if someone did it! I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

これは！！

this is it!!

めちゃ好きな物語の予感とともに購入しました！買って正解。面白い！続きが待ちきれないです。早く出ないかな

I bought it with a premonition of a story I really liked! I bought it and got it right. It's interesting! I can't wait for the continuation. I wonder if it will come out soon

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

これは面白い

This is interesting

状況が最悪なことで、入れ替わりから10年ぶりに自分に戻れた主人公。まだ始まったばかりなので全くだが、端々にある入れ替わりを行ったゲスなものたちの身分と振る舞いが単純すぎるが思惑がね、誰に向けられたものだったのか。とっとと自分がはいってたであろうとこの者をさがしたほうが……とおもったんだが、それはやらないとこにもなんか思惑がありそうで。10年も虐げられても純なままでいる主人公がなによりも凄いw次の展開がはやくよみたい。

The main character was able to return to himself for the first time in 10 years after being replaced due to the worst situation. It's just getting started, so it's all, but the identity and behavior of the Guess people who made changes at every turn was too simple, but the speculation was directed at, and who was it directed at? At last, I thought it would be better to search for this person... but there seems to be some speculation about not doing that. Above all else, the main character who remains pure even after being oppressed for 10 years is amazing lol it looks like the next development will be clear soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 30, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

原作者様が好きで

I like the original author

This review contains spoilers. 試し読みして迷わず購入しました。どうしてこうなったのか訳も分からず、ルーファスもセイディも悪くないのに辛い思いをしていて。誰が信用出来るのか。と思いラノベに手を出してしまいました。コミカライズとラノベ、だいぶお話の流れが違い混乱しましたがラノベの方が序盤から人物像が分かりやすかったです。コミカライズも続きが楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. I tried reading it and bought it without hesitation. I had no idea why this happened, and both Rufus and Sadie were having a hard time even though it wasn't bad. Who can you trust? I thought I'd dabble in light novels. There were quite a few differences in the flow of the story between Comicalize and Light Novel, but it was easier to understand the characters from the beginning in the light novel. I'm looking forward to the continuation of comicalization.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 28, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

早く続きを！

Please continue soon!

This review contains spoilers. 絵が綺麗でとても読みやすく、セイディの変貌っぷりがよくわかります。体を乗っ取られたのが1人だけじゃないとは！まだまだ謎が多くて先が気になります。

This review contains spoilers. The pictures are beautiful and very easy to read, and you can clearly see Sadie's transformation. It's not just one person whose body has been taken over! There are still so many mysteries that I'm worried about the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

琴子先生のお話なので面白いです。が、絵が私は好みでないです。もっと女性を綺麗に書いて欲しい。なので話は好きですが熱量は低いかも。

It's an interesting story because it's Kotoko sensei's story. But I don't like pictures. I want women to be written more beautifully. So I like the story, but the calories may be low.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 30, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

セイディ達の体を入れ替えた犯人は、誰だ

Who is the culprit who replaced Sadie and the others

人の意識と体を入れ替えるなんて、ものすごく高い魔法だと思います。奴隷たちは入れ替わりのことを知っていたようだけど、一体どんな魔法使いがやったのでしょう。

I think it's extremely magical to replace a person's consciousness and body. The slaves seemed to know about the replacement, but what kind of wizard did it?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 14, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

これからの展開が楽しみ。

I'm looking forward to future developments.

This review contains spoilers. １巻の感想です。10年間体を乗っ取られて奴隷労働をさせられていたのにあんなに可愛くて可憐さを保ててるヒロインすごい。自分の体に戻れたはいいものの体を別人に乗っ取られている間に悪評がすごいことに。10年間婚約を破棄する事なくひどい扱いを受けても初恋の彼女を信じ続けていたルーファスがいい人と言うか気の毒というか。いまもヒロインへの想いは消えていないようなので応援したい。早く真実が伝わればな。同じ入れ替わり仲間だったはずのエリザの様子がおかしいのが気になりますね。これから入れ替わりの謎を解いたり事件やらたくさん起こりそうなので楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. These are my impressions of volume 1. The heroine who is so cute and keeps her pretty even though her body has been taken over and forced to do slave labor for 10 years is amazing. It was good that I was able to return to my own body, but the bad reputation was amazing while my body was taken over by someone else. I feel sorry or sorry for Rufus, who continued to believe in his first love girlfriend even after being treated badly without annulling their 10-year engagement. It seems that my feelings for the heroine haven't disappeared even now, so I want to support her. I hope the truth comes out soon. I'm worried that the appearance of Eliza, who should have been in the same replacement group, is strange. I'm looking forward to solving the mystery of the replacement and many incidents that will happen in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

5巻辺りから面白い

Interesting from around volume 5

1巻で離脱してる方も多いみたいで私もその1人だったのですが、5巻辺りから面白いという感想をお見受けしたので思い切って読んでみました。確かに面白くてヤンデレ好きには中々なストーリーかなと思います。初期のテンポが遅めだったのが勿体無いところですね。

It seems that there are many people who left after volume 1, and I was one of them, but I saw the impression that it was interesting from around volume 5, so I took the plunge and read it. It's certainly an interesting story, and I think it's a pretty good story for yandere lovers. It's unfortunate that the initial tempo was slow.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 29, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

え！むしろ面白くなってきたやん！

huh! Rather, it's getting interesting!

4巻ぐらいまではまぁ普通に、あまりないストーリーでおもしろいなーと思いつつそこまで繰り返して読まない＆とても続きが気になる感じでもなく。そして時が過ぎ久々みたら6巻まで出てて「ありゃ、もう2冊出てたかー覚えてないな、暇なとき読むか」と思い。そして深夜ベッドの中で1巻から読み直し、「はいはい、こんなだったわー」と未購入だった2冊を買い、最新刊を読んで、、、え！！！！！展開よき！そうだよ、ルーファス、己を信じろ！これからがおもろいやんか！となりました。発売待ち遠しいリストに急浮上しました。

Up to about 4 volumes, well, I don't read it over and over again while thinking it's an interesting story, and I don't feel like I'm really worried about the continuation. Then, when time passed after a long time, up to 6 volumes came out and I thought, “Well, I don't remember if 2 books have come out yet, do you read them in your spare time?” Then I reread it from volume 1 in bed late at night, bought 2 unpurchased books saying “Yes yes, it was like this”, read the latest edition... Eh!!!! Good development! Yes, Rufus, believe in yourself! The future is interesting! It became. It suddenly surfaced on a list that I can't wait for release.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 19, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

婚約者、よく10年間我慢したよ

My fiancé often put up with it for 10 years

悪女が入ったヒロインから酷い仕打ち受けてよく婚約者10年間耐えたなという印象。ヒロインの事それだけ好きだったんだなと。それも積もり積もってやっと婚約破棄宣言できたときに相手の中身が戻るという不運よ。ヒロインは前向きで愛らしいです。周りから愛されるのわかります。すれ違いはあれどやっと婚約者の誤解も解けてこれからって時にまた入れ替わり問題が…しかも今度は他の入れ替わり被害者の人も巻き込んで（というか自ら騒動を起こしたというか）大変なことに。早く問題が解決してヒロインと婚約者、二人幸せになっておくれと思います。珍しく元鞘応援できる作品。でも婚約者、縋ってはないと思いますがね。

The impression is that she was treated harshly by the heroine who included the evil woman, and that her fiancé often endured for 10 years. I think I loved the heroine that much. That also piled up, and when the engagement was finally declared annulled, it was unlucky that the other party's contents came back. The heroine is positive and adorable. I understand that people around you love you. After passing each other, the fiancee's misunderstanding was finally resolved, and from now on, there will be another replacement problem... and this time, other replacement victims are also involved (or rather caused an uproar themselves), which is a huge problem. I hope that the problem will be resolved quickly and that the heroine and her fiancé will be happy. It's a rare work where you can support Motosai. But I don't think my fiancee is mad.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

入れ替わりの謎解きが待ち遠しい

I can't wait to solve the mystery of the replacement

This review contains spoilers. 7歳のセイディが30歳の奴隷女と10年間も入れ替わってしまったのは何故なのか？続きが気になります。セイディが過酷な生活を送った後でも、元々の優しい性格のままで戻ってこれて良かった。酷い目にあったルーファスが入れ替わりを信じられないのは仕方がないけど、ちょっとキツすぎ。ジェラルドのほうが今やお似合いな感じ。

This review contains spoilers. Why was 7-year-old Sadie replaced by a 30-year-old slave woman for 10 years? I'm worried about the continuation. I'm glad that Sadie came back with her original kind personality even after living a tough life. It's unavoidable that Rufus, who had a bad time, can't believe the replacement, but it's a bit too tough. I feel like Gerald is a better match now.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

珍しいストーリー

An unusual story

This review contains spoilers. 10年も乗っ取られて悪女になっていたヒロイン。急に優しく可愛くなってヒーローは戸惑うよね。こういう展開大好きです

This review contains spoilers. The heroine had been taken over for 10 years and had become a villain. The hero is puzzled when he suddenly becomes so kind and cute. I love this kind of development

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 29, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

作者さん買い

Buy the author

原作琴子先生の作品はヤンデレ溺愛系が多いのですがこちらは婚約者の中身が魔法により入れ替わってしまっても10年間婚約破棄せずに待っていてくれた一途な話で切ないです

There are a lot of original works by Kotoko sensei in the Yandere series, but this is a sad story where she waited 10 years without annulling her engagement even if the contents of her fiancee were replaced by magic

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 28, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

犯人を見つけます

Find the culprit

This review contains spoilers. １０年間体を奪われてしまうのはかわいそうだと思った。どうしてそんなことが起こったのか感想を知りたい。困難も多そうだけど頑張って欲しい。

This review contains spoilers. I thought it would be a pity to be robbed of my body for ten years. I'd like to know your impressions on why that happened. There seem to be many difficulties, but I want them to do their best.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

10年

10 years

10年間も身体を乗っ取られるってどんな感じなんだろう。急に元に戻っても本人も周りの人たちも困るよね…過去をゆるしたり愛情を再確認したり心情の変化が見ものです。

What would it be like to have your body taken over for 10 years? Even if it suddenly goes back to normal, both the person himself and the people around him will be in trouble... The change in feelings such as forgiving the past and reaffirming affection is a sight to behold.

Helpful

Reviews for I Body-Switched With an Evil Hag for 10 Years, and Now My Knight Ex-Fiance Who Never Wanted To See Me Again Can't Let Me Go Manga