I Body-Switched With an Evil Hag for 10 Years, and Now My Knight Ex-Fiance Who Never Wanted To See Me Again Can't Let Me Go Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛い〜

cute~

ずっとハラハラドキドキさせられます?入れ替わり…現実的に考えると辛いけど漫画ならではでサクサク読めます。

it makes me feel so excited all the time? Replacement... it's hard when you think about it realistically, but it's unique to comics, so I can read them quickly.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

物語の山場はこれからです！

The end of the story is yet to come!

This review contains spoilers. 3巻読了。ヒロインの鈍感な性格を際立たせる為の表現や、ヒーローの前髪が気になって今ひとつの印象だったのですが、3巻終わり、大きな変化があります。これで完結に向かっていくのかと思っていたのですが、原作を読んでびっくり！これから大きな、予想もしなかった波乱が起きます。前半の緩い進行に少し侮っていました。10年の身体の乗っ取りと並行して、王都の重要な出来事が裏に隠されていて、その部分でもお話に奥行が感じられました。原作、おもしろかったです。コミカライズも幾多の場面で改変があるようですが、原作の間延びを補うような完結な表現に「解り易い」と寧ろ好感が持てました。

This review contains spoilers. I've read volume 3. I was interested in the expressions to accentuate the heroine's insensitive personality and the hero's bangs, so I had an impression now, but now that volume 3 is over, there have been major changes. I was wondering if this would come to an end, but I was surprised to read the original story! Major and unexpected turbulence will occur from now on. I was a little underestimated by the slow progress in the first half. In parallel with the takeover of the body in 10 years, important events in the royal capital were hidden behind the scenes, and I felt the depth of the story even in that part. The original story was interesting. It seems that comicalization has also been modified in many situations, but I was rather impressed by the complete expression that made up for the delay in the original story, saying it was “easy to understand.”

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

原作既読ですがイメージ通りでした！

I've read the original story, but it was just as I had imagined!

原作を読んでますが、絵がイメージ通りだったので読みました！表情が何より可愛くて、テンポよく進むのでコミカライズしてよかったなって思います！

I'm reading the original story, but the picture was just as I had imagined, so I read it! The expression is cuter than anything else, and the tempo progresses well, so I'm glad I comicalized it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

This review contains spoilers. おもしろいよね。転生とかはすごいよくあるけど、これは物語がはじまったときに、からだが入れ替わりから戻るってね。

This review contains spoilers. It's interesting, isn't it? Reincarnation is really common, but when the story starts, the body returns from being replaced.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 07, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ありきたりに飽きてしまった方におすすめ

Recommended for those who are bored with the mundane

This review contains spoilers. 10年間身体を乗っ取られていたヒロインが、すっかり悪女と成り果てた元の身体に突然戻るところから始まるストーリーですが、7歳にして大人の女性の身体と入れ替わり、長年奴隷として働かされ極貧生活を送ってきたというのに全く荒んでしまうことなく、昔のままのピュアで思いやりがあって可憐で天使のような「セイディ」のままなのがすごいな〜と思いました。私がもし同じ状況に立たされたら、速攻で心が荒んで腐った人間になってしまいそうです(汗)。ここからの展開としては、ヒロインが少しずつ周りの信頼を回復していき婚約者の心を取り戻すというのがお決まりだと思うのですが、本作の面白いところは奴隷時代の乗っ取られ仲間に出会ったり、乗っ取られの謎を紐解いていくというユニークなストーリー展開がそれと並行して進んでいく事だと思います。ありきたりのラブストーリーには飽きてしまった方でも楽しめる捻りの効いた作品で、とてもおすすめです！

This review contains spoilers. It's a story that begins where the heroine, who had been taken over for 10 years, suddenly returns to her original body, which had completely turned into a bad woman, but I thought it was amazing that she was replaced by the body of an adult woman at age 7, worked as a slave for many years and lived in extreme poverty without being rough at all, and she remained as a pure, compassionate, and pretty, angelic “Sadie” as she used to be. If I were to be in the same situation, I would probably go hasty and become a rotten person with a rough heart (sweat). As a development from here on, I think the rule is that the heroine gradually regains the trust of those around her and regains her fiancé's heart, but I think the interesting thing about this work is that the unique story development of meeting friends who were taken over during the slave era and unraveling the mystery of being taken over progresses in parallel with that. It's a twisty work that even those who are tired of ordinary love stories can enjoy, and I highly recommend it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ルーファス

Rufus

ルーファスがイケメンで一途で優しい！同じ苦難を支え合ったジェラルドも良いけど、やっぱりルーファス良い！貴族の子供と大人の奴隷の身体の複数人もの入れ替わりが謎で続きが気になります！

Rufus is a good-looking guy and so kind! Gerald, who supported each other through the same hardships, is also good, but Rufus is good after all! The replacement of multiple people in the bodies of an aristocrat child and adult slaves is a mystery and I'm curious about the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

小説から好きな作品

Favorite works from novels

This review contains spoilers. 以前小説を読みとても面白く、マンガをたまたま見つけたので読みました。小説だと登場人物の入れ替わりが分かりにくかったのですが、マンガだと一目瞭然でイメージしやすく理解出来ました。イラストも丁寧に描かれていて良かった。これからストーリー後半に向けて盛り上がっていくと思いますので続きも楽しみにしています！

This review contains spoilers. I read a novel before and it was very interesting, and I found a manga by chance, so I read it. The changes in characters were hard to understand when it was a novel, but when it was a manga, it was obvious at a glance and easy to imagine and understand. It was nice that the illustrations were also carefully drawn. I think we'll be excited for the second half of the story from now on, so I'm looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い!!今までありそうでなかった!!

interesting!! That wasn't likely until now!!

面白すぎてびっくりしました!!続きが気になり過ぎて、新刊出たら速攻購入してます。入れ替わりの物語ですが、話が停滞することもなくどんどんと真相に近づいていきます。どんな組織的な事が関係しているのか、これからどうなっていくのか、恋の行方も気になります!!今後の展開が楽しみすぎて何度も読み返しています。

I was surprised that it was so funny!! I was too worried about the continuation, and I bought it as soon as the new publication came out. It's an alternate story, but the story never stagnates and we get closer and closer to the truth. I'm curious about what kind of organizational matters are involved, what will happen in the future, and the whereabouts of love!! I'm looking forward to future developments so much that I've reread it over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

先が気になる展開…！

I'm worried about the future...!

中身が入れ替わってしまったことで悪役令嬢の汚名が着せられているところからスタート。これからどうなるんだろう、の連続があって面白かったです。星5でお願いします。

It starts with the stigmatization of the villain daughter because the contents have been replaced. It was interesting that there was a series of questions about what will happen in the future. 5 stars, please.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

イイ、面白い

That's good, interesting

展開が早いですが、練り上げられたストーリーに引き込まれます。この先が楽しめる高揚感もイイ。サスペンス感もあり、ラブもあり溺愛感半端ないヒーロー素敵です。続編待ち遠しいです。

It unfolds quickly, but you'll be drawn into a well-crafted story. The feeling of elation to be able to enjoy the future is also nice. A hero with a sense of suspense, love, and a sense of infatuation is wonderful. I can't wait for the sequel.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 30, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ハマる！

I'm addicted to it!

This review contains spoilers. ルーファスが信じてくれて良かった！他の子達も早く元の身体に戻って欲しいけど、まだなんか起こりそう...早くみんなが幸せになりますように！

This review contains spoilers. I'm glad Rufus believed it! I want the other kids to get back to their original bodies as soon as possible, but something still seems to happen... I hope everyone will be happy soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 29, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ヤバイ！どんどん面白くなっていく！

dangerous! It's getting more and more interesting!

よくある転生モノかなと思って読み出したら、全然違ってました！10年、身体を乗っ取られていたって設定が、今までなかった気がする…。ラブものなのかと思いきや、めちゃめちゃミステリーだし、ファンタジーなのかもだし、とにかくドキドキしながら3巻読みました。早く続き読みたい〜！ストーリーも複雑で面白いけど、絵もステキです。セイテイとルーファス2人ともずっと見てたい。何度も読み返してます。新刊早くお願いします〜！

I thought it was a common reincarnation thing, and when I read it out, it was completely different! I feel like there hasn't been a setting where my body was taken over for 10 years until now... I thought it was a love thing, but it was really a mystery, maybe it was fantasy, and anyway, I read 3 volumes with excitement. I want to continue reading soon~! The story is complicated and interesting, but the pictures are wonderful too. I've always wanted to watch Seitei and Rufus. I've reread it over and over again. Please publish the new publication soon~!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 20, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

一途

Itto

ルーファスの一途さにキュンキュンします。進展は遅くムズムズしますが絶対最後まで読み進めたくなるお話です。

Rufus is so excited. The progress is slow and frustrating, but it's definitely a story that makes you want to read it until the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 22, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

めちゃくちゃ面白い！この一言に尽きる！

It's insanely interesting! That's all there is to it!

貴族のご令嬢といえば、異世界転生や虐げられていたヒロインが王子と結ばれるシンデレラストーリーが多いように思いますが、今作はそのどれとも違う全く新しいものでした。めちゃくちゃ引き込まれました！めちゃくちゃ面白いです！めちゃくちゃ気になるところで２巻が終わってしまったので、続き早く読みたくて仕方ないです。

Speaking of the nobility's daughter, I think there are many Cinderella stories where the heroine who was reincarnated in another world or is oppressed is tied to a prince, but this work was completely new and different from any of them. I was so drawn in! It's insanely interesting! Volume 2 ended when I was really worried, so I can't help but want to continue reading it quickly.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 26, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

長ったらしい前髪

long bangs

前髪が殆ど顔に被っていてよく前が見えるなという二人ですがお話は好きでした。2巻までではなぜ貴族の子供たちが謎の奴隷と入れ替わっていて、戻ったのかがわかりませんがその10年間入れ替わった奴隷がやりたい放題やっていて戻ってきたらという話だったのでなかなか珍しい入れ替わりで良かったです。横顔が幼く見えて大人に見えない時が多くありました。

They are two people who have bangs almost all over their faces and can't see their front very well, but I loved the story. Until volume 2, I don't know why the children of the aristocracy were replaced by mysterious slaves, and I don't know why they returned, but it was a story about slaves who were replaced for 10 years doing whatever they wanted and coming back, so I'm glad it was a pretty rare replacement. There were many times when my profile looked so young that I couldn't see it as an adult.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 20, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗で

The picture is beautiful

主人公が可愛くて好きです。なんにも悪い事してないのにみんな酷いよ！すべての誤解を解いてくれないと、かわいそうでみていられない。

The main character is cute and I like it. They're all terrible even though they haven't done anything wrong! If you don't clear up all the misunderstandings, I can't feel sorry for you.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ワクワク(o^^o)

Excited (o^^o)

面白い！テンポよくお話が進むからめっちゃ引き込まれる。入れ代わった元の人たちって近くにいるのね。黒幕はどういう人たちなんだろ。貴族が関わっているのは確実ね。そして、味方が誰なのか。婚約破棄されたルーファスは今のところ一人蚊帳の外みたい。元に戻ったヒロインと結ばれるまでいくつもの山場がありそうね。楽しみ！

interesting! The story progresses at a good tempo, so I'm really drawn in. The original people who were replaced are close by, aren't they? I wonder what kind of people are behind the scenes. There is no doubt that aristocrats are involved. And who is on your side? Rufus, whose engagement was annulled, seems to be alone out of a mosquito net so far. It seems like there will be a number of mountain ranges until they are united with the heroine who has returned to normal. I'm looking forward to it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻まで

Up to 2 volumes

貴族の子供たちが奴隷と入れ替わってしまい10年間も虐げられてきたけど、ある日突然元に戻って～というお話。10歳やそこらの子供がいきなり30歳ぐらいの大人の中身になって奴隷として働かされるなんて苛酷過ぎです。逆に子供の中に入った奴隷の大人は、やりたい放題で悪名高くなってしまってます。だから入れ替わって元に戻っても周りから冷遇されちゃって…気に毒でならんわ…。主人公セイディと元婚約者のルーファスとの行く末も気になるけど、入れ替わりの謎がとっても気になる！早く続き出ないかなぁ。ちょっとコメディな所もあり、ミステリーさもあって面白いです。

It's a story about children of aristocrats being replaced by slaves and oppressed for 10 years, but then one day they suddenly went back to normal. It's too harsh for a 10 year old or so child to suddenly become part of an adult about 30 and made to work as slaves. Conversely, slave adults who have become children have become notorious for doing whatever they want. So even if they were replaced and returned to normal, they were treated coldly by people around me... I don't mind... I'm also worried about the fate of the main character Sadie and her ex-fiance Rufus, but I'm really curious about the mystery of their replacement! I wonder if more will come out soon. There are also places that are a bit comedic, and there are mysteries, so it's interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

入れ替わり系ストーリー

Alternate stories

ですが、よくあるお話しとはちょっと違う‼︎というのをなろうで読んで知っているのでコミカライズではどう表現しているのか？とワクワクして読みました。結果→→→当たり！絵も綺麗だし読みやすい。まだ1巻のみで2巻を読んで無いので今後ストーリーがどう進むか(なろう通りなのか？)楽しみです。凄くよく出来たストーリーなので出来れば端折らずに最後まできっちりと描いて頂ければありがたい。

However, since I read and know ‼ ︎, which is slightly different from common stories, how do you express it in comicalize? I was excited to read it. Results → → → hit! The pictures are beautiful and easy to read. I've only read volume 1 and haven't read volume 2 yet, so how will the story unfold in the future (is it Naro Street?) I'm looking forward to it. It's a really well-made story, so if possible, I'd be grateful if you could draw it all the way to the end without breaking.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

とても素敵なお話

A very nice story

This review contains spoilers. とても素敵なお話です。彼は、彼女を待ち合続けて乗っ取られた体にやっと彼女がもどってきたと思ったらもう、婚約破棄を言い渡した後だった。でも、小さな頃と変わらない表情や仕草が昔を思い出させゆらいでいる彼。早く二人がハッピーになりますように。

This review contains spoilers. It's a very nice story. When he thought that she had finally come back to the body that had been taken over by continuing to wait for her, it was already after announcing the annulment of the engagement. However, his facial expressions and gestures, which are the same as when he was little, are wobbly reminding me of the old days. I hope both of them will be happy soon.

Helpful

Reviews for I Body-Switched With an Evil Hag for 10 Years, and Now My Knight Ex-Fiance Who Never Wanted To See Me Again Can't Let Me Go Manga