Goodbye, Red Beryl Manga Reviews (P.3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

泣ける

I can cry

ラスト、すごく良かった。この終わりかた、全て納得です。絵も綺麗だし、大満足です。

Last one was really good. I agree with everything about this way it ended. The picture is beautiful and I am very satisfied.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 03, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

あぁ...血さえも艶美しい！

Ahhh... even blood is luscious and beautiful!

ノスタルジックで絵が美しいのはもちろん(昔っぽさや表情の描き分け方もスゴい)昭和感がなんとも良い雰囲気で、ストーリーも全体的にとっても色っぽい引き込まれる素敵な作品でした！メガネ萌えにも...たまらん...登場人物がとにかく美しくて、シリアスなだけではなくコミカルな部分もあり最後まで楽しく読めました！大満足な作品でした！

Not only is it nostalgic and the picture is beautiful (the way the old fashions and expressions are drawn is amazing), the Showa feeling was so nice, and the overall story was very sexy and drew in a very sexy way! Megane Moe too... it's irresistible... the characters are just beautiful, and not only are they serious, but they also have comical parts, so I enjoyed reading them until the end! It was a very satisfying work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

和重が美しい

Kazushige is beautiful

This review contains spoilers. 将門が言う通り和重が美しいです！お前さん、とか、古い言葉が妙に似合う、、、娘まで看取って寂し過ぎるけど、昭彦が事故だけど吸血鬼になって良かったね！と思います。昭彦も本当は願ってたんじゃないかな。あのときならなくてもゆくゆくは昭彦も吸血鬼になる！って言ってたと思う。それにしても現代の2人は格好良過ぎ！

This review contains spoilers. As Masakado said, Kazushige is beautiful! You, old words strangely suit... I'm so lonely taking care of my daughter, but I'm glad Akihiko had an accident but became a vampire! I think so. I think Akihiko was really hoping too. Even if it wasn't that time, eventually Akihiko would become a vampire too! I think I was saying that. Even so, these two people are too cool today!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 24, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

良い！

good!

This review contains spoilers. 1巻から3巻まで一気に読みました！吸血鬼いいですね！昭彦と和重が良い方に向かって良かった。将門と師夏は大丈夫なのかな。

This review contains spoilers. I read volumes 1 through 3 in one go! Vampires are nice! I'm glad Akihiko and Kazushige are on good terms. I wonder if Masakado and Morinatsu are okay.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 05, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった♡

That was great ♡

This review contains spoilers. 最初の出会いが衝撃ですね（笑）まさか鉄の棒が貫通してるなんて…あれでビックリして意識を失わず、助けた挙句、通い妻みたいになってる。段々と絆される吸血鬼の和重が振り回されてる感が可愛い(*´ｪ`*)彼氏に人間としての死を迎えて欲しかったけど、やはり助けようとした子を庇って重症して和重の中で今じゃ～ない!!の想いと死んで欲しくない想いで結局、吸血鬼にしてしまった。後悔の念はあるけど、幸せな時間

This review contains spoilers. My first encounter was shocking (laughs) I couldn't believe that an iron rod had penetrated... I was so surprised that she didn't lose consciousness, and after saving her, she became like a commuting wife. The feeling that the vampire Kazushige, who is gradually being bonded with each other, is cute (*'`*) I wanted my boyfriend to die as a human being, but after all, I protected the child I tried to help and became seriously ill, and it's not now in Kazushige! I ended up turning them into vampires because of their feelings and the feeling that they didn't want them to die. I have regrets, but it's a happy time

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 04, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

2度読み返して納得

I reread it twice and I'm convinced

This review contains spoilers. 吸血鬼モノということで、重苦しい感じかな？と思いきや、そんなことはなく、ほどよくシリアスとコミカルな感じが合わさっており読みやすかったです。一度読んだときハピエンが好きなので、こういう終わり方で良かったと思いつつも、なんとなく、あのまま二人の信念を貫き通して死別でも良かったのではと思っていました。でも、二度目に読み返したときに、和重が色々な葛藤を持っていた中で、昭彦を吸血鬼にしてまで生きさせたいし、ともに生きたいと思うまでに昭彦への想いをつのらせていたと思うと切なくなりました。そして、そこまで思われることで、幼い頃からの念願、人に必要とされるという昭彦の思いも報われてるなと感じました。やっぱりこの終わり方がベストですね。いい作品でした。

This review contains spoilers. Since it's a vampire thing, does it feel heavy? Unexpectedly, that wasn't the case, and it was easy to read because it had just the right amount of serious and comical feelings. Once I read it, I liked Happien, so even though I was glad it ended this way, I somehow thought it would have been okay if the two of them penetrated their beliefs and were widowed. However, when I reread it for the second time, I was sad to think that Kazushige had various conflicts, and that he wanted Akihiko to live until he became a vampire, and that he had feelings for Akihiko until they wanted to live together. Also, by being thought up to that point, I felt that Akihiko's long-cherished wish from an early age and his desire to be needed by others were also being rewarded. After all, this is the best way to end. It was a great work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 14, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

流石ですね～！

That's amazing!

いや～本当に素晴らしい作品に出会えて嬉しかった！昭和に合わせて描き方を変えてるのが凄い！そして人物の色気も凄い！眼の描き方とか美しくてうっとりしました。内容は吸血鬼ものですが、色々と考えさせられる内容でだいぶ重みがありました。やっぱり、悠久の時間を過ごすのに伴侶は必要なのではないでしょうかね・・・独りでは生きていかれないですよ・・・それは、いくら有限の生がある人間も同じですけどね。私個人的には吸血鬼＝エド〇ーとアラ〇のＣＰなのですが、和重と昭彦はお互いに心が移ろわない感じがするので、末永～くエロく（たまにドＳ）幸せに暮らしていそう・・・。将門様と師夏も妖しく魅力的なＣＰでした。こっちのほうが儚げな美しさでしたね～ホントの「永遠の少年」！

Well, I was happy to come across such a wonderful work! It's amazing that they changed the way they draw according to the Showa era! Also, the character's sex appeal is amazing! I was fascinated by how beautiful the eyes were drawn. The content was about vampires, but it had a lot of weight because it made me think about various things. After all, isn't it necessary to have a partner to spend an eternal time... you can't live alone... that's the same for people who have a finite amount of life. Personally, it's a CP of vampires = Ed 0- and Ara 0, but since Kazushige and Akihiko don't change their hearts, it seems like they're living an erotic (occasionally Do-S) happy life for a long time... Masakado and Morinatsu were also strangely fascinating CPs. This one had an ephemeral beauty, wasn't it? a real “eternal boy”!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

泣きました。

I cried.

こういうお話って同性だからとかの葛藤ではない別の次元での葛藤があって、すごく切なかったです！しかもハッピーエンドって何だろう？と考えさせられます！

This kind of story was really sad because it wasn't a conflict of the same sex or something, and there was a conflict on another dimension! What's more, what is a happy ending? It makes me think!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 09, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

永遠って

Eternity

不老不死に憧れるけど、愛する人をずっと見送るのは切ない。子供のうちに吸血鬼になってしまうとそのままだしね。何とも吸血鬼の切なさの詰まった話でした。ハピエンです。

I yearn for immortality, but it's sad to see someone I love forever. If you become a vampire while you're a kid, that's just the way it is. It was such a story filled with the sadness of vampires. This is Happien.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 18, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

やっと読みました

I finally read it

いままでちょっとスルーしてたことを後悔。読めて良かった（泣）みちのくアタミ先生の描く男性の色っぽさ、品の良さ、ストーリーの中に感じる人間性とかがすごく好きです。

I regret having gone through a bit until now. I'm glad I was able to read it (crying) I really like the sexiness of the men drawn by Michinoku Atami sensei, the good quality, and the humanity I feel in the story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

終わっちゃったよ～

It's over ~

１巻、２巻と読み続けて、どうなって完結するんだろう、吸血鬼になるのかならないのか。ドキドキしながら完結を待っておりました。みちのくあたみせんせいの作品は、ハピエンばかりなのでそこのところは心配はしていなかったのですが。。最後まで呼んでみての感想は、良かった！です。これが一番いい終わり方なんだろうな～と思いました。エチといちゃいちゃがもっと欲しかったな～。

Continue reading volumes 1 and 2, and I wonder how it will end, whether they become vampires or not. I've been waiting for the completion with excitement. Michinoku Atami Sensei's works are all Happien, so I wasn't worried about that... The impression of inviting them until the end was great! That's it. I thought this would be the best way to end it. I wanted more flirting with Etsi.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

もうー。

that's enough.

This review contains spoilers. 吸血鬼…あまり手を出した事の無いジャンルでした。意外にもすんなり読めましたし、吸血鬼ならではの葛藤が切なくて感動しました。色々あってハッピーエンドでしたが、色々が無かったら…って考えると違う形になってるいたかも…絵も私は好きだ部類です。

This review contains spoilers. Vampires... it was a genre I hadn't dabbled in much of. Surprisingly, it was easy to read, and I was moved by how sad the conflicts unique to vampires were. There were a lot of things and it had a happy ending, but when I thought about it... it might have had a different shape... I like pictures too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 06, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

一緒にいて欲しいと願うばかり。

I just want them to stay with me.

吸血鬼ものが好きなので、気になっていた作品。どうなるのか、どう生きて来たのか、3巻ですから読みごたえもたっぷり。黒髪と金髪も味わえる、二人が本当に美しいです。

I like vampire stuff, so I was interested in this work. What will happen and how have you lived since it's 3 volumes, there's plenty to read. They are both really beautiful, who can enjoy black hair and blond hair.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

江戸から現代まで跨いだ吸血鬼物

Vampires spanning from Edo to the present day

昭和中期あたりを中心にしているのかな？と思いながら読みました。この作者さんは高い画力があるので以前からこの作品も気になってました。３巻まで読むと、身勝手っぽく思えた始祖？の吸血鬼も色々あったのかなと思えました。主役の２人は終始いい人と言うか、善良でお人好しで、これは生きるの大変だったろうなと。人を傷付ける事なく生きようと努力する受けが、最後まで格好よく美人さんで惚れました。奥さんと娘さんも最後まで傍にいてくれるくらいに、この人を大好きだったんだろうなと、納得の人格者でした。主役の２人は何十年経っても相変わらずラブラブでエッチしてて微笑ましい。生きづらいのと不幸せはイコールじゃないってセリフに、確かにそうだよねと感慨深くなりつつ読み終えました。続編あるなら、始祖と少年の２人が許し合える物語か、始祖の過去とか読みたいです。少年を思わず助けた経緯も過去と関係してる？情と共依存で繋がっている始祖と少年の関係が愛に変わる日とか来るのかな？気になりますね。

I wonder if it's centered around the middle of the Showa era? I read it while thinking. This artist has a high drawing ability, so I've been interested in this work for a while. The founder who seemed selfish when you read up to 3 volumes? I was wondering if there were a lot of vampires. The two leading actors are said to be nice people from beginning to end, or they are kind and friendly, and this must have been difficult to live. I fell in love with this good-looking, beautiful woman until the end because she made an effort to live without hurting people. He was convinced that his wife and daughter probably loved this person to the extent that they stayed by their side until the end. The two leading actors are still lovey-dovey and have sex even after decades have passed, and it makes me smile. I finished reading it while feeling deeply moved by the line that hard to live and unhappiness don't equal, and that's certainly true. If there's a sequel, I'd like to read a story where two people, the founder and the boy, can forgive each other, or the ancestor's past. Are the circumstances of helping the boy unwittingly also related to the past? Will the day come when the relationship between the ancestor and the boy, which is connected by affection and codependency, will change to love? I'm curious.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 03, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ノスタルジックな時代を生きる吸血鬼達

Vampires living in a nostalgic era

是非3巻まとめて読んで下さい。人間の昭彦と吸血鬼の和重、吸血鬼将門と半吸血鬼の師夏、それぞれのストーリーが江戸時代から平成まで描かれてます。特に3巻が彼らの過去と未来が分かり、面白かった！画力の高さで絵を眺めるだけでも感動ですが、さらに時の流れが良かった。って、自分が昭和世代だからかな。。。

Please read all 3 volumes at once. The stories of the human Akihiko and the vampire Kazushige, and the vampire Masakado and the half-vampire Moronatsu are each depicted from the Edo period to Heisei. Volume 3 in particular showed their past and future, which was interesting! I'm impressed just looking at the pictures because of my high drawing power, but the flow of time was even better. Maybe it's because I'm in the Showa generation...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 02, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

作者様

The author

大好きな作家様です。とにかく絵がきれいで二人とも美しい。非現実的なお話だけど、日常が描かれていて、時代も感じられてさずがな内容でした。

This is my favorite writer. Anyway, the picture is beautiful and both of them are beautiful. It's an unrealistic story, but it depicted everyday life, and the content made me feel the times were strange.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

耽美だ…

it's aesthetically pleasing...

作家さん買いでしたいつもの作品での感じではなく作品の内容に合わせて耽美な雰囲気になって全体的にすごくエロティックですメイン二人の関係性もいいんですが、サブキャラの関係性もすごくすごく素敵ですエロの方もすごくいい…本当に好きです修正は白発光なので少し残念…

It's not like the usual work I bought by the artist, and the overall atmosphere is very erotic, and the relationship between the two main characters is also very nice, but the relationship between the two main characters is also really wonderful, and the erotic one is also really nice... I really like it; the correction is white light emitting light, so it's a bit disappointing...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ジュリー!!

Julie!!

This review contains spoilers. 昭彦がっっ!!昭彦がっっ!!みちのく先生が1巻のラストのキャラ紹介で言われたように沢田研二さんのヘアスタイルがモデルとあったら、昭彦がジュリーにしか見えなかった.(;^_^Aまさかの2017年まで続くとは…これからもずっとラブラブラブな2人でいて欲しい。つか、みちのく先生も続編描きたいって言われたように、続編希望です!!いやあ、昭彦!!ジュリー!!古き良き時代だなあ（*'∀'人）♥*+

This review contains spoilers. Akihiko!! Akihiko!! As Michinoku sensei said in the character introduction at the end of volume 1, if Kenji Sawada's hairstyle was modeled, Akihiko would only look like Julie. (; ^_^A No wonder it will continue until 2017... I want these two people to stay lovey-dovey forever from now on. As Michinoku sensei also said she wanted to draw a sequel, I hope for a sequel! Hey, Akihiko! Julie!! Those are the good old days (*' 'people) ♥ *+

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

よい

good

私的に内容がむずかしいなって感じ。もちろん1〜3巻続いてるので読み応えはあるんでしょうけど、出だしの小林家の墓が気になる

Personally, I feel like the content is difficult. Of course, there are 1 to 3 volumes in a row, so it's probably worth reading, but I'm curious about the Kobayashi family's tomb at the beginning

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい…

beautiful...

This review contains spoilers. 作者さん買いです！ずっとお気に入りに入れてままでしたが、突然読みたくなって購入！もっと早く読めばよかった…と後悔するほどに良かったです～！！！昭彦を吸血鬼にさせたくない和重、和重を一人にしたくない昭彦“遺す者”と“遺される者”というちょっとだけ考えちゃいましたね。終わりがある方が良いのか、終わらない方が良いのか。なので、ラストの和重の選択は良かったと思います。最初の墓参りのシーンはそういうことかー！！！みたいになります。他の作品もそうですが、みちのくアタミ先生は作画が美しいのですが、こちらの作品の2巻の昭彦の表紙は特に凄く美しい…この表紙見ながら飯2杯はいけるんじゃないですかね美しさでは昭彦の上が私的には、将門の美しさ。さすが長生きしているだけあって色気が違う。美しい。いつか続きが読めるなら、将門のスピンオフが読みたいです！

This review contains spoilers. The author is buying it! I kept it in my favorites for a long time, but I suddenly wanted to read it and bought it! I wish I had read it sooner... it was so good that I regretted it!!! I just thought for a moment about Kazushige, who doesn't want Akihiko to become a vampire, and “the one left behind” by Akihiko who doesn't want to leave Kazushige alone. Is it better to have an end, or is it better not to have an end? So, I think Kazushige's last choice was good. I wonder if that was the first grave visit scene!!! It becomes like that. As is the case with other works, Michinoku Atami sensei's drawing is beautiful, but the cover of volume 2 of this work is particularly beautiful... Isn't it possible to have 2 cups of rice while looking at this cover? In terms of beauty, Akihiko's superior is personally Masakado's beauty. As expected, they just live a long time, so their sex appeal is different. beautiful. If I can read more someday, I'd like to read Masakado's spin-off!

Helpful

Reviews for Goodbye, Red Beryl Manga