The Impregnable Demon King's Castle and the Expelled Black Mage of the Hero's Party Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

５巻のあと不安になりましたが

I became uneasy after volume 5

６巻もちゃんと面白かった！よかったよかった。これからも買い続けて行く作品です。絵がキレイ。

Volume 6 was really interesting too! That's good, that's good. This is a work I will continue to buy. The picture is beautiful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

文句なく面白い！

It's fun without complaint!

周りに見下されるけど実はとんでもない実力者ってホント好きです。でも主人公とその親友の勇者はとっても優しくて真の強さを持っているって本当素敵です。次は新展開ですね、これからも楽しみです?

I really like powerful people who are looked down upon by people around them but are actually ridiculously powerful. But it's really wonderful that the main character and his best friend, Yūsha, are so kind and have true strength. Next is a new development, so are you looking forward to it from now on?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

良いかもです!!

Maybe it's good!!

黒魔法良いですね～自分も目立つ側より縁の下の力持ち的な人でありたいと思うので、レメ的なキャラ大好きです。早く次の新刊出ないかなー・・・待ち遠しいです

Black magic is good, isn't it? I also want to be an unsung and powerful person rather than stand out, so I love leme-like characters. I wonder if the next new publication will come out soon... I can't wait

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

5巻までの感想

Impressions up to volume 5

This review contains spoilers. 5巻までで第1章が完結した感じかな。しかしこの手の話でこんなにカッコいい勇者を見たことがない。人類の勇者と魔物の勇者の双方がカッコいい。第十階層の激闘は見事なシナリオだったけど5巻ラストで大見得を切って魅せるレメもカッコいい。円満な大団円にも見えるけどアルバ辺りは「カッコつけやがって」っと僻み根性に火をつけそうな気がする。全体を通して深くなりすぎず浅くなりすぎず、重すぎず軽すぎずでちょうど良い。性別に関わりなく楽しめると思う。6巻が待ち遠しい。

This review contains spoilers. I feel like Chapter 1 is complete with up to 5 volumes. However, I've never seen such a cool hero with this kind of story. The hero of humanity and the hero of monsters are both cool. The fierce battle in the 10th tier was a spectacular scenario, but the lame, which has a great advantage at the end of volume 5 and is fascinating, is also cool. It looks like an amicable group of people, but I feel like the area around Alba seems to ignite their seclusion and guts by “putting parentheses on it.” It's perfect throughout, not too deep, not too shallow, not too heavy, and not too light. I think you can enjoy it regardless of gender. I can't wait for volume 6.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ええやん

Yeah

This review contains spoilers. なかなか面白いと思います。こういうのを1回読んでみたかったので全部読んでみようと思いましたいいと思います

This review contains spoilers. I think it's pretty interesting. I wanted to read this kind of thing once, so I think I'll read them all

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 12, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ひとつの完成形ではないでしょうか

Isn't it one complete form

This review contains spoilers. 実力不足を問われ、勇者パーティーを追われるパターンの作品としては、ひとつの完成形ではないでしょうか？元いたパーティーは落ちぶれ、追われた主人公ばかりが成功するざまあ展開ばかりの傾向がある中、本作では双方を立たせることに成功しています。悪者はおらず、それでも薄っぺらくならないという難しいチャレンジをしていて、とても好感が持てます。ざまあは嫌いではありませんが、行き過ぎると元いたパーティーが気の毒になるという、読者の不満に応えてくれていると思います。精神世界だから負けても死なない、悪者は居ないのは甘すぎて嫌だと思う向きもありますが、中にはこういう作品があってもいいと思います。ゲーム系の作品だとこういうのもありますが、ゲームじゃないのもひとひねりあって良いです。

This review contains spoilers. As a work with a pattern where people are questioned about their lack of ability and chased from the Hero Party, isn't it one perfect form? The original party fell apart, and while there is a trend where only the main character who was chased succeeds, they succeeded in making both sides stand in this game. There are no bad guys, and even so, they're taking on the difficult challenge of not being flimsy, and I really like it. I don't dislike Zama, but I think it responds to readers' dissatisfaction that they feel sorry for the original party if they go too far. Since it's a spiritual world, there are people who think that they don't die even if they lose, and that they don't like that there are no bad people, because it's too sweet, but I think it's okay to have works like this among them. There are things like this when it comes to game works, but it's also nice that they're not games, with a twist.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

最高です…

It's the best...

最新刊６巻最高です…！最後のバレやばいですね、こういうの大好き大興奮しました。次どういう展開になるのか、楽しみにしています。

The latest 6 volumes are the best...! The last revelation was terrible, I loved this kind of thing and was very excited. I'm looking forward to seeing what the next developments will be.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 07, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

一気読み！

Read it all at once!

一巻読んでたら面白くて5巻まで大人買い！w続きが気になる〜内容も一捻りあって飽きないし展開も良い！買って損なし＾＾

Reading one volume was so interesting that adults bought up to 5 volumes! I'm worried about the continuation ~ the content is twisted and I never get tired of it, and the development is good! There is no loss in buying it ^^

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

秀作です。

It's an excellent work.

数多の類似作品の中でも出色の出来です。追放成り上がり系は一回読んでお終いなのが常ですが、この作品は何度も読み返せるだけの物語性を内包しています。登場人物の描き方も一線を画しています。男女関係も安易にエロ方面に走らず、慎まやかな恋慕が主体です。追放された主人公と追放した勇者が最初から最後まで親友同士なのは読んでいて気持ちいいものですね。

It stands out among many similar works. I usually finish reading Outcast Rising once, but this work contains enough storytelling to be reread over and over again. The way the characters are drawn is also completely different. Relationships between men and women do not easily run in the erotic direction, and humble love is the main focus. It feels good to read that the banished protagonist and the banished brave man are best friends from beginning to end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いです!

It's interesting!

This review contains spoilers. 職業が黒魔道士でパーティ仲間に認められず辞めちゃのですが、魔王側にスカウトされ働くという内容で、魔王側の方々はチョイ変態な方もいて面白いです。展開の速度は気になる感じではなかったので次が気になって読んじゃいました。カシュが可愛く癒やされてます(笑)

This review contains spoilers. My occupation is a black mage and I quit because I wasn't recognized by my party mates, but the content is that they are scouted by the Demon Lord's side and work, so it's interesting that the people on the Demon Lord's side are also perverts. I didn't feel worried about the speed of development, so I was curious about the next one and read it. Kashu is cute and soothing (laughs)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いですが裏山死刑です

It's interesting, but Urayama is the death penalty

This review contains spoilers. 巨乳美人とロリ美少女に言い寄られ、理解のあるイケメン親友やロリ上司、モフモフな同僚、etcに囲まれて、どんだけ善行をつむとこんな人生を歩めるのか考えたくなるお話です

This review contains spoilers. It's a story where you're approached by a beautiful woman with big breasts and a beautiful loli girl, and you're surrounded by understanding good-looking best friends, loli bosses, fluffy colleagues, etc., and it's a story that makes you want to think about how much good deeds you can live such a life

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

主人公応援したくなるし、ストーリーも気になる。早く続きを読みたいな〜

I want to support the main character, and I'm curious about the story. I want to read more soon~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

１巻はプロローグ

Volume 1 is a prologue

This review contains spoilers. 作画は丁寧。ちゃんと骨格やパースも整っていて背景も誤魔化してない。好き嫌いはあるでしょうが、勢いだけの作画ではないため、まるで一枚絵を見ているみたいで私には贅沢で好感を覚えました。物語はレビュータイトル通り、１巻はプロローグです。マンガタイトルの立ち位置についたところで終了。２巻以降からいよいよ本編がスタートといったところです。これを「テンポが遅い」か「進め方が丁寧」と感じるかは人それぞれでしょうが、私はこの物語の根幹部分であると思うので後者と感じました。今後は、１巻で描かれた主人公の内面や環境を比べながら２巻以降の主人公の活躍を見ていくことになるかと。楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. The drawing is meticulous. The skeleton and perspective are properly prepared, and the background hasn't been misled. There are probably likes and dislikes, but since it's not just about momentum, it's like looking at a single picture, and I felt that it was luxurious and liked by me. As the review title suggests, volume 1 is a prologue. It ended when I got to where the manga title stood. I think the main story will finally start from volume 2 onwards. Whether this is a “slow tempo” or “careful way to proceed” is probably different for each person, but since I think it is the root part of this story, I felt that it was the latter. From now on, I think we'll look at the protagonist's activities from volume 2 onwards while comparing the inner world and environment of the protagonist depicted in volume 1. I'm looking forward to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

小説から来ました(^^)d

I came from a novel (^^) d

This review contains spoilers. 勇者パーティーを追い出される話はよくありますが、そのなかでも秀逸だと思います。小説の後半に親友二人が戦う場面がありますが、胸が熱くなる展開で、ちょっと泣きました。コミカライズ、楽しみにしてましたので、次出たら必ず読みたいです(*^^*)

This review contains spoilers. There are many stories about people being kicked out of the Brave Party, and I think it's excellent among them. There is a scene in the second half of the novel where the two best friends fight, but the development made my heart heat up, and I cried a little bit. I was looking forward to Comicalize, so I definitely want to read it the next time it comes out (*^^*)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 13, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

勇者を目指す黒魔法使いの物語

The story of a black wizard who aims to become a hero

This review contains spoilers. ダンジョン攻略がエンターテイメント化され、神に与えられたジョブによって職業が決まる世界で幼い頃勇者を目指した少年。しかし与えられたジョブは黒魔法師だった。幼なじみと共にパーティーを組むもパーティーメンバーから解散を通告されてしまう。それでも夢を諦め切れなかった彼は別の意味での勇者を目指すー。癖のあるファンタジーで従来のファンタジーに飽きている方にはオススメしたい本です。

This review contains spoilers. A boy who aimed to become a hero when he was young in a world where dungeon capture was made into entertainment and his occupation was determined by jobs given to him by God. However, the job I was given was a black wizard. They formed a party with their childhood friends, but the party members notified them of their dissolution. Even so, he couldn't give up on his dream, and he aims to be a hero in another sense. I would recommend this book to those who have a habit of fantasy and are tired of conventional fantasies.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

追放された先で

At the place where they were banished

「勇者」になる黒魔道士のお話。よくある追放ものかと思いきや、追放した側の勇者にもスポットライトが当たっていて2人の「勇者」の対比がおもしろいです。

A story about a black mage who becomes a “hero.” I thought it was a common banishment, but the spotlight was also on the hero on the banished side, and the contrast between the two “brave men” is interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 20, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

黒魔術‥

Black magic・・・

パーティを追放された黒魔術士が敵側である魔王軍にスカウトされ活躍する話。ざまぁ系だけど嫌なやつが少なく元パーティとも信頼があり何かと裏で協力してる、勇者が強いのが当たり前でやられる前提である魔王軍がバフ、デバフや戦略で勝利しイメージを覆していく。アバターの戦闘で誰も死なないし負けてもやり直せるフラットな世界観なので平和にストーリーを楽しめる漫画ですね。

A story about a black magician who was banished from a party and played an active role after being scouted by the demon army on the enemy side. The Demon King's Army, which is based on the assumption that it is a matter of course that has few dislikes but is trusted by the former party and cooperates behind the scenes, and that it is natural for the brave to be strong, wins with buffs, debuffs, and strategy, and overturns the image. It's a comic where you can enjoy the story peacefully because it's a flat world view where you can start over even if no one dies or loses in avatar battles.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 28, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻目の途中まで読んだ感想

Impressions of reading it halfway through volume 2

斬新な展開で面白いです。世界観はピンと来ませんが、ダンジョン攻略がスポーツみたいなもので、ダンジョン攻略中継をスポーツ観戦感覚で観ている世界といった感じでしょうか。大筋はタイトル通りです。敵対する悪役側に就くというのが斬新で、続きが気になります。

It's a novel development and it's interesting. The view of the world doesn't come right, but dungeon capture is like sports, and I think it's a world where you watch a dungeon capture broadcast as if you were watching a sports game. The general point is as the title says. Being on the side of a hostile villain is novel, and I'm worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 27, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

深みがある作品。ペラペラな展開かなぁと思いきや、読み進めていくと深みがあることに気づき、面白くなってくる。

A work with depth. I thought it was a fluent development, but as I read on, I realized that there was depth, and it became interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 20, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

読みやすい！

Easy to read!

追放モノの中でも絵が上手く読みやすい作品です！主人公のレメが誠実で損しちゃうくらいに優しい人なので好感が持てます。女の子たちも可愛いくて、主人公への好感が高いのでハーレムっぽくなっても嫌な感じがしません。追放元のパーティーでリーダー&幼馴染も嫌な奴しゃなくて、ライバルになっていく感じもストレスなく読めました。続きが気になります

It's a work that has good pictures and is easy to read, even among banished things! I like the main character, Reme, because she is sincere and kind enough to lose money. The girls are cute too, and they have a high affinity for the main character, so I don't feel bad even if they look like a harem. There were no bad leaders and childhood friends at the party I was banished from, and I was able to read the feeling of becoming rivals without stress. I'm worried about the continuation

Helpful

Reviews for The Impregnable Demon King's Castle and the Expelled Black Mage of the Hero's Party Manga