About a Love Song Manga Reviews (P.17)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ガラス瓶のなか。

In a glass bottle.

キラキラして見えますよね。星名さんにとって瀬戸くんがガラス瓶のなかのキラキラだった様に、この作品自体がガラス瓶の中身だったなぁ。淡々と過ぎて行くようで、もやもや揺れて最後は倒れて溢れてしまう想いにジーンとしました。正直このまま終わるの？って途中思ったのですが、この読後感！！キュンキュンしすぎてしまって、ちょっと！どうしてくれるの！？って感じでレビュー書いてます(笑)

It looks sparkling, doesn't it? Just as Seto was a sparkle in a glass bottle for Hoshina-san, this work itself was inside a glass bottle. It seemed like it was going by bluntly, and it felt like it was hazy and shaking, and at the end it fell down and overflowed. Honestly, is it going to end like this? I thought about it halfway through, but this is my feeling after reading it!! I was so excited, hey! What are you going to do!? I'm writing a review like that (laughs)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

全ては愛でした

It was all love

This review contains spoilers. とても楽しみにしていました。攻めの星名さんがどタイプで歳の差の設定も大好きなのですが、歳の差の恋愛模様がリアルに表されているなと感じました。大人×高校生でも付き合う展開のBLが多いと思うのですが、この作品はそうではなく好きだけど付き合わない、手放す選択をしている展開がよかったです。自分が瀬戸くんの立場だと辛いなと思いましたが、星名さんの気持ちも分かるしなと何度か泣きそうになりました。星名さんの手放す選択も全ては瀬戸くんを思っての行動で、作中でも何度か「愛」という言葉を目にしましたが本当に優しい愛でした。途中もどかしいと思ったのですが、読んだ後は「愛ってこんなんだよな」ととても満足感でいっぱいでした。年齢を重ねている人にこそ響くようなお話だったと思います。とても感動しました。あわよくば、2人が恋人になってからのその後や好きあってからの愛し合っているシーンが見たいです。

This review contains spoilers. I was really looking forward to it. The aggressive Hoshina is of any type and I love the age difference setting, but I felt that the love pattern of the age difference was realistically expressed. I think there are a lot of BLs where adults and high school students go out with each other, but that's not the case, and it was nice to have a development where they like it but don't go out with it and choose to let go. I thought it would be difficult for me to be in Seto's position, but I almost cried a few times because I understood Hoshina's feelings. All of Hoshina-san's choices to let go were actions with Seto in mind, and I saw the word “love” several times in the story, but it was really kind love. I thought it would be frustrating along the way, but after reading it, I was filled with a great sense of satisfaction, saying, “Love is like this, isn't it?” I think it was a story that only resonated with people who were getting older. I was very moved. If so, I want to see scenes where the two love each other after becoming lovers or after they have liked each other.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 04, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

良い

good

This review contains spoilers. 崖っぷちのバンドマンと、大学生だと思っていたけど実は高校生のお話です。絵は綺麗でかわいい系でした。いらない設定もあったような・・。エッチシーンは小冊子側だけですが　本編でアレぐらいがキュンキュンしていいと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story about the bandman on the edge of a cliff and what I thought was a college student but is actually a high school student. The pictures were beautiful and cute. Seems like there were settings I didn't need... The sex scene is only on the booklet side, but I thought it would be nice to get excited about that in the main story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 02, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

22歳はない

There is no 22 year old

遊び慣れた狡い攻めがキラキラなDKにハマってしまったけどヘタレ根性で怖くなって逃げようとする話。受けの高校卒業まではかなり良かったけどそこから22歳までの空白の４年間はなんなの？何の意味もなくまた待たせてたのか？最後にイラッとしてしまいました。でもエロ重視じゃないストーリーは高評価です。

It's a story about a cunning attack you're used to, and you're addicted to the sparkling DK, but they get scared due to disgusting guts and try to run away. It was pretty good until I graduated from high school, but what was the empty 4 years from there until the age of 22? did you keep me waiting again without any sense? I was frustrated at the end. But stories that don't focus on eroticism are highly rated.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 30, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

拗らせた攻めと真っ直ぐピュアな受けでした

It was a relentless attack and a straight, pure reception

This review contains spoilers. 「25時、赤坂で」が好きなので、こちらも読んでみました。煮え切らない攻めの星名に早く受け入れてー！とモヤモヤ?‍?1年で紅白出たり、それをステージから認識できる席で見れた受けの瀬戸くんなど、だいぶ御都合主義で現実的でないとこがちょいちょい気になりました?2人のモダモダも可愛いね?と思えば楽しく読めるかなと思います。小冊子で初♡があっさりだけど読めました。

This review contains spoilers. I like “25:00 in Akasaka,” so I read this one too. Quickly accept the star name of Unboiled Attack! and fuzzy?? I was a little bit concerned about places that were quite expedient and unrealistic, such as Kohaku appearing in 1 year and being able to see it in a seat where I could recognize it from the stage? Modamodas of the two are cute too, aren't they? If you think about it, I think it will be fun to read. I was able to read ♡ for the first time in the booklet, even though it was easy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ヘタレで誠実な星名がいい

I want a bad and honest star name

This review contains spoilers. 作者さんの他の先品から知り、購入して読みました。盛り上がりにはちょっと欠けるかなと思いますが、いい加減に生きてきた星名が瀬戸くんと交わったことで「愛」のかたちを掴み、そう思うから大切にして離れて行く。そういう愛もあるんだなぁと切なくなります。瀬戸くんと再び知り合ってもヘタレな星名と違って、瀬戸くんがまっすぐにアタックしてくるのが清々しいと思いました。お似合いの二人ですね。

This review contains spoilers. I learned about it from the author's other products, bought it, and read it. I think it's a bit lacking in excitement, but Hoshina, who has lived casually, grasped the form of “love” by interacting with Seto, and since she thinks so, she cherishes it and walks away. It makes me sad that there is love like that too. Even when I got to know Seto again, unlike Hoshina, who was disgusting, I thought it was refreshing that Seto would attack straight away. they're two good matches, aren't they?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 11, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトル回収

Title collection

This review contains spoilers. タイトル回収が美しすぎた〜、バンドマンの話だから、それ関連でこの題名なのかな〜と思わされていたのが大きなミスリードで、終盤にタイトルが回収された時は拍手喝采でした。ずっと一緒にいたいのも、大切にしたくて壊したくないから距離をとるのも、どっちも同じ「好き」だと思います。綺麗でした。

This review contains spoilers. It was a big mislead that the title collection was too beautiful, and since it's a bandman story, it made me wonder if this title was related to that, and there was applause when the title was collected at the end of the game. I think both wanting to be together the whole time and keeping a distance because you want to cherish them and don't want to break them. It was beautiful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

あのまま終わったら､､

If it ended like that...

１巻だけで終わり〜。だったら消化不良と喘息の発作が一度に襲って来て大惨事でした。２巻目、といっても小冊子ですが、良かった。寝られそうです。ですが夏野先生も人が悪い！というか４年も「お預け状態」は絶対に無い！！漫画だから1〜2ページで大人になるけど現実だと思うと攻めさんが可哀想過ぎて同情(泣)受けさんも可哀想過ぎて同情(泣)夏野先生、濃い恋愛物語に(この作品も違う意味で濃いですが)飽きましたか?編集者さんの意向ですか？それなら仕方ないけど､､､。

It's over with just one volume. Then indigestion and asthma attacks hit all at once, and it was a disaster. It's the second volume, but it's a booklet, but it was great. I think I'll be able to sleep. But Natsuno sensei is also a bad person! Or rather, there has never been a “checked in state” for 4 years!! Since it's a comic, you'll be an adult with 1 to 2 pages, but when you think of it in reality, the attacker-san is too pitiful and the tsuke-san is too pitiful and sympathizes (crying), Natsuno sensei, are you bored with the strong romance story (although this work is also strong in a different sense)? Is that the editor's intention? Then it can't be helped, but...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

作者様買いです

I'm buying the author

This review contains spoilers. 作者様買いです。絵が本当に好きです。お話の内容はほどほどかな。でも可愛い。別作品がとても好きだったので買いました。一巻と小冊子しかないため物足りなさは少しありますが2人が結ばれてよかったのと思います。もう少し恋人になった先を見たかったかな。

This review contains spoilers. The author is buying it. I really like the picture. I wonder if the content of the story is moderate. But it's cute. I really liked the other work, so I bought it. Since there is only one volume and a booklet, it's a bit unsatisfactory, but I think it was good that the two were united. Maybe I wanted to see where they became lovers a little more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

星名の書いた曲、聞いてみたい

I want to listen to a song with star names written on it

This review contains spoilers. 瀬戸くんが実は高校生だったとわかった時の星名の固まった顔が自分的には一番ツボです。年下だけどうーんと男前な瀬戸くんの想いが実ってホンマに良かった。

This review contains spoilers. The star-named face when I found out Seto was actually a high school student is the biggest pressure point for me. I'm really glad that Seto, who is younger but so handsome, has come to fruition.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

はぁ〜〜尊

Huh ~ Takeru

This review contains spoilers. 25時〜で先生を知りました。先生の作品は主人公が一途で、信じられないほど一途でそこがまた良いんですよね両想いです、はい付き合う！とかではなく、側から見てたら誰が見ても両片想いだしなんならお互い両想いなの自覚してるのに。それぞれの葛藤とか、揺らぎとか煩悩とか(笑)、きちんと描かれていてそこがまた作品とキャラクターの魅力になってるでもまさか昼のゆめの主題歌がand moreだったなんて！25時〜では出てなかったと思うので、また25時〜も読み返したくなりました。いつかまたこの2人にも会えるといいな…

This review contains spoilers. I met my teacher at 25:00. The main character in the teacher's work is Ichido, and unbelievably, that is also good, isn't it? Both feelings, yes, they go together! It's not like that, and when you look at it from the side, no matter who sees it, they have feelings for both, and if so, they're aware that they have both feelings. Each conflict, fluctuation, and worry (laughs) was properly drawn, and that is another appeal of the work and characters, but I can't believe the theme song for Daytime Dreams was And More! I don't think it came out at 25:00, so I wanted to reread it again at 25:00. I hope to meet these two again someday...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 15, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

小冊子のみ購入

Buy booklets only

購入するか迷い、レビューから多くの方が切望していた小冊子の方から購入。悪くはないけど私には絵柄含めあまりささらなかったので本編の購入は無し。作品が悪いのではなく、設定や好みの問題。BL読みたてだと楽しめるかもしれない。ある程度読んでいると、小冊子の中身はそれほど印象に残るものではなかった。ただ本編読んでいた人は楽しめるのかもしれない。

I wasn't sure whether to buy it, and I bought it from the booklet that many people had been longing for based on reviews. It's not bad, but it didn't matter much to me, including the design, so I didn't buy the main story. It's not that the work is bad, it's a matter of settings and preferences. You might enjoy reading BL fresh. After reading it to a certain extent, the contents of the booklet didn't leave that much of an impression on me. However, people who have read the main story may enjoy it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 12, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

先生の書く目が好き。目は口ほどにものを言うでしたっけ。そのとおり。いろんな感情をのせていてドキドキしてしまいました。年をとることが大人になるんじゃない。いつまでも大人になりきれないところがあってもいいじゃんと思って読みました。おもしろかったです。

I like the way the teacher writes. the eyes said as much as the mouth, didn't they? That's right. There were so many emotions on it that it made me feel excited. Getting older doesn't make you an adult. I read it because I thought it would be okay if there were places where I couldn't become an adult forever. That was interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 24, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ピュア

pure

This review contains spoilers. 『25時、赤坂で』より、こっちの方が好きです！展開遅すぎるし、ピュアすぎてすごく焦れったいけど、純愛で、はまりました！

This review contains spoilers. I like this one better than “25:00 in Akasaka”! The development was too slow, and it was so pure that I was really impatient, but it was pure love, and I fell in love with it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 29, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

じれったさがよい

It's good to be blocked

歳の差という程も離れていないんだけど、距離感に萌える作品。購入するか迷ってたけどめちゃくちゃ良いものと巡りあえた。

The age difference isn't that far, but it's a work that makes me feel a sense of distance. I was wondering whether to buy it, but I came across an insanely good one.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗ですね

The picture is beautiful

夏野先生の絵は本当に綺麗で読みやすいなと感じてます。こちらの作品も絵が綺麗で星5をつけてもいいなと思うのですが個人的にはお話の内容はサラッと読めちゃう印象だったので星4にしてしまってますが面白かったですね。

I feel that Natsuno sensei's paintings are really beautiful and easy to read. The pictures in this work are also beautiful, and I think it's okay to give it 5 stars, but personally I had the impression that the story was easy to read, so I set it to 4 stars, but it was interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

清く正しく美しきBL

Clean, correct and beautiful BL

This review contains spoilers. 夏野寛子先生のBLは絵がきれいで、心理描写もすごく丁寧で好感が持てる。また番外編はともかく本編はまったく濡れ場がない。ストーリーも淡々としていながら、逡巡する2人の心の揺れが繊細で、何度でも読み返したくなる。万人におすすめしたい。

This review contains spoilers. Natsuno Hiroko sensei's BL has beautiful pictures, and the psychological depiction is very careful, and I like it. Also, aside from the extra edition, there's no place to get wet at all in the main story. While the story is bland, the tremors of the two wandering hearts are delicate, and I want to reread it over and over again. I would recommend it to everyone.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

単話で読んでた作品

The work I was reading in a single episode

夏野寛子さんの作品が大好きで出たら必ず買いますが、失敗したという後悔はしたことありません。今作品の片方はいつもの作品と違って、少しダメな感じなのが新鮮で良かった。年の差もありですねと思わせてくれる作品。

I love Hiroko Natsuno's work, and I always buy it when it comes out, but I've never regretted that it was a failure. I'm glad that one side of this work is different from my usual work, and it feels a little bad. It's a work that makes me think that there is also a year difference.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

本編エロなし

No erotica in the main story

バンドマンとバイト先の学生の話。バイト先の学生がうぶでかわいい。話が面白いし絵が綺麗でしたが、エロあったらもっと良かったのにな。

A story about a bandman and a student at his part-time job. The students at my part-time job are naive and cute. The story was interesting and the pictures were beautiful, but it would have been even better if there was eroticism.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 20, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

なるほど…

I see...

賛否が分かれるのはなんとなくわかる気がしますねー。あたしはやっぱりちょっと物足りなかったかなぁ。一線を越えるシーンがなかったとしても「痛いのは今度…」のシーンの描写があればまた違ったのかもしれないけど…あそこすっ飛ばすのはなんか不自然だったかなぁ。でもやっぱり絵は綺麗で好きなので星は4つでしょうか。

I feel like I can somehow understand that the pros and cons are divided. I wonder if I was a little unsatisfied after all. Even if there wasn't a scene that crossed the line, it might have been different if there was a depiction of the scene “It Hurts Next Time...” but... I wonder if skipping it over there was something unnatural. But after all, the pictures are beautiful and I like them, so I think they have 4 stars.

Helpful

Reviews for About a Love Song Manga