Would You Like to Be a Family? Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 07, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

血のつながりがない家族

Family without blood ties

This review contains spoilers. 受けが親友の子供を引き取ったため全員血のつながりはないけど素敵な家族だった普段子供が出てくるとか子育てものは読まないけどこれは良かった出てくる子供のもりがやんちゃですごく可愛い攻めと子どもで受けを取り合う構図好き3人でいる時の空気感、一緒に過ごしていくうちに家族になっていく家庭が良かった3作品収録だったのでどれもストーリーが駆け足に感じたので、表題作だけで1冊欲しかった2作品目は黒髪年下高校生×メガネ大学生3作品目は大学生同級生ものでワンコ×黒髪クールかな？と思うけど描写がなかったのでどっちともとれる感じ

This review contains spoilers. Since they took in the child of their best friend, they weren't all related by blood, but I don't usually read child-rearing stuff, but this is good, the kid that comes up is a playful, very cute attack and composition where they like receiving with children, the atmosphere when 3 people are together, and a good family where they become a family as they spend time together, so I felt like the story was running fast for all of them, so I felt like the story was running fast, so it's the second work I wanted for 1 book just by writing the title Is the third film by Kurohaired Younger High School Student x Megane University Student by a college student's classmate, so is Dog x Black Haired Cool? I think, but since there was no depiction, I feel like I can take either

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ほんわか

It's warm

表題作の子育てBLもその他の作品も全てほんわかしている中にも、ピリッと切なさが入っていて、じわりとくるお話ばかりでした。表題作、もりが大学生になるぐらいまで見ていたいです。こんな良作を読みホで読ませてもらってよいのですか！？

There was a tangy sense of sadness in the title, the child-rearing BL, and all of the other works, and all of them were stories that slowly crept in. I want to watch the title work until Mori becomes a college student. Is it OK for me to read such a good book in hobo!?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 01, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

家族愛

family love

タケは高校生の時にゲイを好きな相手にバラされてから人と距離を取るようになるが、会社の同僚のマサキに色々誘われるようになるが、マサキにはモリという息子がいて、、、小山先生らしくほんわかした中に切ない事情を組み込んで家族の形を描いてます。表題の他2作品収録されています。

When he was in high school, he began to keep a distance from people after being disregarded by his favorite gay partner, but Masaki began to be invited in various ways, but Masaki has a son named Mori... and he depicts the shape of a family by incorporating sad circumstances into the warm, fuzzy situation like Koyama sensei. In addition to the title, 2 other works have been recorded.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

明るい！

bright!

初めての作家さんでした！とにかくポジティブ思考？で全体的に明るい印象でした☆3つとも凄く応援したくなるお話しで楽しかったです。

It was my first time as a writer! Positive thinking anyway? Overall, it was a bright impression ☆ All three were fun stories that really made me want to cheer them on.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

表題作、好き

I like the title work

This review contains spoilers. 表題作含む3作品+表題作の描き下ろし。どの作品もふんわりとした雰囲気でサラリと終わります。その中で表題作は新しい家族になる話。まず、難しいことを考えると親子の成り立ちが難しいのではないかと思うがそんなことは置いておいて。ヤキモチ焼きのもりが可愛くて、それに同等に対抗するタケも良い。マサキは心が広いのだな。もっと眺めて楽しみたい3人だった。描き下ろしのその後のその後も見たいものだ。

This review contains spoilers. 3 works including the title work+drawing of the title work. Every work has a soft atmosphere and finishes smoothly. Among them, the title story is about becoming a new family. First of all, when you think about difficult things, I think parent-child relationships may be difficult, but leave that aside. Yakimochiyaki's forest is cute, and bamboo shoots are equally good against it. Masaki has a big heart, doesn't he? There were 3 people who wanted to enjoy watching more. It's something I want to see even after I've drawn it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

シングルファザー受

Single father

This review contains spoilers. 無口、恋愛トラウマあり×シングルファザー先輩頑な攻にぐいぐいいく先輩に次第に心開いていく描写が丁寧で、息子含むやり取りもよかったです。個人的にはその後もあるとよかったかな。後半は短編も収録されてます。絵はかわいい感じです。

This review contains spoilers. The depiction of quiet, romantically traumatized x single father senpai gradually opening up to his stubborn attack and gradually opening up to his senior was careful, and the exchange involving my son was also good. Personally, I think it would have been nice if there was one after that. A short film was also recorded in the second half. The picture is cute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 23, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

かわいい家族

cute family

誰１人血は繋がっていないけど心が通いあった素敵な家族になってよかった！ちょっと感情の流れというか描写がわかりずらいところもあったけどストーリーがよかったです。他短編も入ってますが面白かったです。

I'm glad it's a wonderful family where no one is related by blood, but we have a close heart! There were places where it was a bit difficult to understand the flow of emotions, or rather the depiction, but the story was good. There are other short films included, but they were interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 20, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ほのぼの

Heartwarming

ほんわかあったかい家族のお話、絵柄にも合っていて優しい雰囲気です。短編もいいんですが、表題作まるまるで読めたらもっと良かったな。全体的にあっさりめなので物足りない人もいるかもね。

It's a warm, fuzzy family story, and it has a gentle atmosphere that matches the design. Short stories are good too, but it would have been even better if I could read it as if I could write a title. Overall, it's so easy, so there may be people who aren't satisfied.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

短編

short story

短篇３作品＋描き下ろし収録。どれもほのぼのした作品ですが、短いので気持ちの変化の表現が少し物足りない印象でした。私は心理学のお話が一番好きでした。

Includes 3 short stories and illustrations. All of them are heartwarming works, but since they are short, I had the impression that the expression of changes in feelings was a bit unsatisfactory. I loved talking about psychology the most.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 23, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

作家買いです

I'm buying an artist

短い話なのが残念ですが、作品は面白いです。ぜひ続編を出してください

It's a pity that it's a short story, but the work is interesting. Please release a sequel

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 22, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

うーん、惜しいかな

Hmm, I wonder if it's a pity

3カプ入った短編集です。なので、どれも物足りなさが否めません。全部、ほのぼの可愛いお話なんですが、短編集ならではの急展開、中途半端な終わりで物足りないですね。一つ一つのストーリーで、踏み込んで欲しかったですね。良かったのに、ちょっと残念でした。

This is a short story with 3 capsules. So, it's undeniable that none of them are satisfactory. All of them are heartwarming and cute stories, but the rapid development and half-hearted endings unique to short stories are unsatisfactory. I wanted them to dive into each story one by one. It was good, but it was a bit disappointing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 23, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったです

I'm glad

表題作は、ほのぼのしたところもあり良かったですが、主人公の性格もあって淡々と進み、今一つ盛り上がりに欠ける感じがあります。あと相手がゲイでもないのにすんなり受け入れすぎで本当に好きなのかという思いも拭えず。子供のやきもちは可愛らしかったです。表題作の他に２作。「くまのきもち」は主人公がまっすぐな高校生で可愛くて好感が持てましたが、相手には少し不信感が。それが残念。「はじめての～」は普通によかったと思います。

The title work was nice because it was heartwarming, but due to the personality of the main character, it progressed slowly, and there is a feeling that it lacks excitement right now. Also, even though my partner wasn't gay, I easily accepted it so easily that I couldn't get rid of the thought that I really liked it. The kid's yakimochi was cute. In addition to the title work, there are 2 other works. The main character in “Kumano Kimochi” is a straight high school student who was cute and I liked him, but I was a little distrustful of his opponent. That's too bad. I think “First Time!” was usually good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 25, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ほっこり系

Relaxed

可愛い感じのお話三編。表題作の社会人カプ、高校生×大学生カプ、大学生カプ。描き下ろしに表題作の数年後のお話。えちはありますが朝ちゅんな感じで雰囲気だけ。むしろないほうが自然じゃないかな？と感じるストーリー。深いストーリーって訳ではありませんが、ちゃんと物語があり、全体的に可愛い感じでほっこりします。

Three cute stories. The title work's working person cap, high school student x college student cap, college student cap. It's a story drawn a few years after the title work. There's something wrong with it, but it feels like it's morning, just the atmosphere. Wouldn't it be more natural not to have one? A story that makes me feel like it. It's not a deep story, but it has a proper story, and the overall feeling is cute and makes me feel relaxed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 27, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ほのぼの家族系

Heartwarming family

家族系ほのぼのストーリー。すごく暖かい気持ちで読めます！キャラ設定も、絵も好きです！始まり方も終わり方も良かった！ただちょっと本自体のページ数が少ない気がしました！(^^)

A heartwarming family story. I can read it with a very warm feeling! I like the character settings and the pictures! The way it started and ended was great! I just felt like the number of pages in the book itself was a little small! (^^)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 09, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

気持ち的には3.5ぐらいです

Feelily, it's about 3.5

This review contains spoilers. とっても可愛い！家族ものらしい、読んでほっこりです！ただ、良くも悪くもほっこり系って、今一つ物足りない感じがしてしまう、、、。他収録の2.3組のお話も、あと1話くらい欲しいなぁって思ってしまって、、、。絵のタッチや性格はすごい好みなので、☆4にしましたが、☆3.5くらいの感じです。割引されていれば、オススメしますが、定価だと少し手が出づらいかもしれません、、、。

This review contains spoilers. It's so cute! It's like a family thing, so I'm relieved to read it! However, for better or worse, I feel that one is unsatisfactory right now... I thought I'd like to have about 1 more episode of the 2.3 group stories recorded elsewhere... I really like the touch and personality of the picture, so I chose ☆ 4, but it feels like ☆ 3.5. If it's discounted, I recommend it, but if it's at full price, it might be a little hard to get your hands on...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 11, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

家族系好き

Family lover

家族系好きで買いました！スラッと読めるかな、イラストわあまり好きじゃないけど内容わ気に入りました！

I bought it because my family loved it! I wonder if I can read it easily; I don't really like the illustrations, but I liked the content!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 09, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

家族もの好きです

I like family stuff

初めての作家さんでしたが、家族ものが好きなので読んでみました。表題作の他に短編が２つ入ってましたが、どれも良かったです。個人的にはもちろん表題作ですが。絵柄はあまり好みではないのですが、あっさりしてたので、読みやすかったです。

It was my first time writing, and I read it because I like family stuff. There were 2 short stories in addition to the title work, and they were all good. Personally, of course it's the title work. I don't really like the design, but it was so light that it was easy to read.

Helpful

Reviews for Would You Like to Be a Family? Manga