The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga Reviews (P.6)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

白影の紫の服の表紙ありがとう！

Thank you for the cover of Shirakage's Purple Clothes!

This review contains spoilers. 原作でもかなり好き、というか見たかったシーンが最新4巻に描かれていて、イレーネの表情がとても良かった。切ない！儚い！美しい！！大満足です！！原作が長くなりそうなお話なので、どこまで描いてもらえるかわかりませんが、コミカライズと原作両方の力でファンも増えてるようなので、しばらくは続いてくれると信じてます！原作4巻まではなんとか描いてほしいなー。追記…５巻読了。SSの白影の話をコミカライズして下さってありがとうございます！表紙にもなって、カラーで見れて嬉しい〜。

This review contains spoilers. Even in the original story, scenes I liked quite a bit, or rather wanted to see, were depicted in the latest 4 volumes, and Irene's expression was very nice. that's sad! It's ephemeral! beautiful!! I am very satisfied!! It's a story where the original story seems to be getting longer, so I don't know how far it can be drawn, but it seems like the number of fans is increasing due to the power of both comicalization and the original story, so I believe it will continue for a while! I want them to somehow draw up to 4 volumes of the original story. Postscript... I've read volume 5. Thank you for comicalizing the story of SS Shirakage! It's also on the cover, and I'm happy to see it in color.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

異世界没入＆せつなくてとても良い

Immerse yourself in another world and it's so good

絵が美しいですよね。そして異世界感がすごい、この世界に入りたい。ひさしぶりに、魔法使いたいと思いましたw主人公が一途でとても切ない、心が締め付けられます。最後には幸せになってくれることを、願っています。

The picture is beautiful, isn't it? And I want to enter this world where the sense of being different is amazing. After a long time, I wanted to be a wizard w the main character is so sad and my heart is tightened. I hope they will be happy in the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

残酷すぎる…

too cruel...

This review contains spoilers. 恋した相手は義妹のことを愛していて、主人公は告白もしてないのに振られた上、死ぬと分かっている場所に彼女の代わりに行けと言われる。義母も義父も義妹も主人公に良くしてくれていたので、虐げられて行った訳ではないけど、精神も肉体も強いわけでもない普通の令嬢が死と隣り合わせの場所に独りで行かされ、生きる為に強くなったのだと思うと切ない。しかも、恋した人の息子が現れたことで自分が居なくなった後に義妹と彼に子供ができたことを知る。自分は老いることもなく、孤独に生きてるのに。偉そうな剣が話し相手として居るけど、人の温もりさえ忘れるほどの長い孤独。それなのに自分は聖剣を盗んだ魔女だと言われてるっていう。ほんとに主人公が報われなさすぎる。代わりに行かせた男を恨んでもいいくらいなのに…主人公の幸せだけを願います。彼女を生贄にして自分だけ幸せになった奴なんて地獄に落ちれば良いのに…と思ってしまう。みんな、優しすぎるのよ…

This review contains spoilers. The person she fell in love with loves her sister-in-law, and the main character is swayed even though she hasn't confessed, and is told to go to a place she knows she's going to die in her place. My mother-in-law, father-in-law, and sister-in-law were all nice to the main character, so it's sad to think that an ordinary daughter who wasn't oppressed, but she was made to go alone to a place next to death and became stronger in order to live. Moreover, since the son of the person I was in love with appeared, I learned that my sister-in-law and him had children after I was gone. Even though I'm living alone without getting old. I have a bossy sword as my conversation partner, but I've been lonely for so long that I even forget the warmth of people. Nevertheless, it is said that she is the witch who stole the Holy Sword. The main character really hasn't been rewarded too much. Even though it's okay to hate the man who made him go in his place... I just wish for the main character's happiness. It makes me think that the guy who sacrificed her and made only himself happy should go to hell... they're all too kind...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

どんな思い

What kind of thoughts

本当にどんな思いで23年も過ごしてきたのだろうかと思うと胸が痛くなる。サルティスだけが知ってるイレーネの23年。サルティスがロイドに「正気のままでいられると思ったのか？」と言った時は泣けた。ロイドはもうきっとイレーネの事が、イレーネもロイドの事が....でもロイドがお父さんがイレーネにした事を知ったらと思うと。知る時はくるんやろうが。ここまでも辛いのにまだまだ波はやってくるのか...涙涙の後はハッピーエンドを期待します！

My heart aches when I think about what kind of thoughts I have really spent 23 years with. 23 years of Irene that only Sartis knows. Sartis asked Lloyd, “Did you think you could stay sane?” I cried when I said that. I'm sure Lloyd is already talking about Irene, and Irene is also talking about Lloyd... but I think it would be nice if Lloyd knew what her father did to Irene. I'll do it when I get to know it. Even though it's been so hard, are there still more waves coming... I'm looking forward to a happy ending after tears!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

悪人はいないけれど

There are no bad people

4巻まで読了。一癖も二癖もある人は出てきますが、どストレートな悪人は出てきていません。だけれどもこんなに悲しい話だなんて…ヒロインが報われる道はあるの？！と先が気になって仕方がありません。たくさんのファンタジーを読んできましたが、初めて原作ノベルを読むべきでは？と思っています。こんなに不幸なまま終わりませんよね？ね？

I've read up to 4 volumes. There are people who have one habit or two, but no straight villains have come out. But it's such a sad story... is there any way for the heroine to be rewarded?! I can't help but be worried about the future. I've read a lot of fantasy, but shouldn't I read the original novel for the first time? I think so. It won't end so unhappy, right? right?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

残酷で切ないのに、こんな面白いなんて…

It's so cruel and sad, yet so funny...

1巻ではこれでもかというほどヒロインが残酷な境遇に突き落とされた後、恋した人の息子が出てきてモヤモヤするんですけど。彼のヒロインへの態度が軟化する2巻終盤以降、互いを意識しはじめる両片想い？が育ちつつあるのが良いんですよねー。はぁ、胸に甘い痛みが。で現時点でコミック4巻まで出てますが、原作読んできたらその先のストーリーが何倍も面白くて良かったので、コミック5巻以降にも期待してます！特にコミック7巻以降が見所盛りだくさんのはず…刊行ペースはゆっくりめですが、唯一無二の面白さで絵もきれいなので首を長くして待つ甲斐があると思います。

After the heroine is thrown into such a cruel situation in volume 1, the son of the person she fell in love with comes out and it's confusing. After the end of volume 2, when his attitude towards the heroine softens, they begin to be aware of each other? It's good that it's growing up, isn't it? Huh, I have a sweet pain in my chest. So far, up to 4 volumes of comics have been released, and once I read the original, I'm glad that the story beyond that was many times more interesting, so I'm looking forward to volume 5 and beyond! There should be plenty of highlights, especially after volume 7 of the comic... The pace of publication is slow, but it's uniquely interesting and the pictures are beautiful, so I think it's worth waiting a long time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない、、

I'm sad...

軽い気持ちで1巻を読んでみたら切なくもとても面白くてどんどん読み進めてしまいました。絵もとても綺麗で、早く続きが読みたいです！

I read volume 1 with a light feeling, and even though it was sad, it was so interesting that I continued to read more and more. The pictures are also very beautiful, and I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

切なさが止まらない

I can't stop being sad

初めは題名から察してストーリーが先読み出来るなと思っていたのですが、想像を超える悲しさ、切なさ…読み進めるとまさかの展開で、泣きそうになります。主人公の気持ちに同調してしまい、読んだ後に切なさが込み上げてくる一冊。

At first, I guessed from the title and thought I could read the story ahead of time, but the sadness and sadness beyond my imagination... as I read on, it unexpectedly unfolded, and I almost cried. It's a book that attaches to the protagonist's feelings, and a sense of sadness creeps up after reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

切なくて泣けます。

I'm so sad that it makes me cry.

This review contains spoilers. ウィステリアがプライトの願いを拒否し、ローザが未明の地へ行っていたとしたらロイドがこの世に存在することもなく出会わなかったウィスとロイド。ウィスがその身を捧げた故に愛し合うようになる運命的な二人。ロイドがウィスの思い人が自分の父親だったと知ったら、ウィスのロイドへの思いはブライトへの思いの代償行為なのかと悩みそうですね。それでも二人は幸せになってと願わずにはいられません。まだまだ原作も未完ですが、原作もコミックもそれぞれに素晴らしいのでどちらも読んでほしいです。

This review contains spoilers. Wisteria refused Prait's wish, and if Rosa had gone to the wee hours of the morning, Lloyd would never have existed in this world and Wyss and Lloyd never met. They are two fateful people who fall in love with each other since Wiss gave up their lives. When Lloyd finds out that the person Wyss loves was his own father, he seems to wonder if Wyss's feelings for Lloyd are a compensatory act for his feelings for Bright. Even so, I can't help but hope the two of them will be happy. The original story is still unfinished, but both the original story and the comic are wonderful, so I want you to read both.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 04, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

コミカライズのロイドが本当カッコいい…！

Lloyd from Comicalize is really cool...!

This review contains spoilers. ウィステリアの美しさ（＆可愛さ）もまた溜息もの…！おぼこいウィステリア（中身43歳）が男の色気ムンムンのロイドにオタオタアワアワするシーンも割合サクッと軽めに描かれているので読み手が共感性羞恥に陥る心配も原作よりは薄めで安心。ロイドも原作より表情豊かだし（ところでロイドって…結局童貞…？どっちなの？よくわからん）。原作も読んでいるのでこのコミカライズの絵であんなシーンやこんなシーンを早く読みたくて仕方ない！（意識朦朧ロイドに襲われキスとかベンジャミンの家でロイドがウィステリアを横抱きにしてべったりとか主に糖度高目のシーンねーーー！樹液の湖で2人でザブン！も良いね良いね！）はぁ、この先ロイドにもウィステリアにも苦しい試練が訪れるだろうから読者の心の安寧のためにもその分もっとイチャイチャが必要ですよ、ホント。あ、後ザマァ展開でブライトがウィステリアの事に気付く時グッサグサに心刺されて欲しいわー、勿論ロザリーにも。そして今度はブライトたちがロイドやウィステリアに選ばれなかった側になって欲しい。最終的に大団円になるにしても途中のザマァ！は必須かと。とにかくこのコミカライズが大好きなので最終巻まで追い続けます！

This review contains spoilers. The beauty (& cuteness) of Wisteria is also breathtaking...! The scene where Obscure Wisteria (inside, 43 years old) is smitten with a man's sex appeal is also drawn in a quick and light ratio, so there are fewer worries about the reader falling into empathic shame than the original story, so I'm relieved. Lloyd is also more expressive than the original (by the way... is Lloyd... a virgin after all...? which one is it? I'm not sure). I've also read the original story, so I can't help but want to quickly read such scenes and scenes like this in this comicalized picture! (Mostly scenes with high sugar levels, such as being attacked by an unconscious Lloyd and kissing or Lloyd hugging Wisteria at Benjamin's house! Zabun for 2 at Lake Sap! That's good too, that's good!) Huh, there are going to be painful trials for both Lloyd and Wisteria in the future, so more flirting is necessary for readers' peace of mind, really. Oh, I want them to be stabbed in the heart when Bright notices Wisteria later, and of course Rosalie too. And now I want Bright and the others to be on the side that wasn't selected by Lloyd or Wisteria. Even if it ends up being a large group of yen, it's still on the way! I wonder if it's essential. Anyway, I love Comicalize, so I'll keep watching until the last volume!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

一気買いしてしまうおもしろさ

The fun of buying them all at once

きちんと背景が描かれているので、ロイドがなぜイレーネに惹かれているのかも納得できるから、余計にイレーネの境遇に涙してしまいます。聖剣の皮肉が、よいスパイスになって、ウジウジした暗いだけじゃない話になっているのも、面白く切なく読めるので、おすすめです

The background is drawn properly, so I can understand why Lloyd is attracted to Irene, so it makes me cry extra about Irene's circumstances. The irony in Seiken is a good spice, and the story is not just plain dark and messy, but I also recommend it because it's interesting and sad to read

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

なんともせつない、、

it's so annoying...

ストーリーが残酷で切ないですね！今後の展開も気になる！絵も上手いしいい漫画ですね！続きを早く読みたいです！

The story is so cruel and sad! I'm also curious about future developments! It's a nice comic that's good at drawing too! I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

確かに泣けたー！

It certainly made me cry!

皆さんのレビュー通り切なくて泣けます！４巻の冒頭かなり泣けました！急にぐいぐい来ましたね。ちょっとこれから一筋縄ではいかないというか、登場人物も多いだけに大変な予感ですね。でも情熱をもって救ってあげてほしい。

As per everyone's reviews, I'm so sad that it makes me cry! I cried quite a bit at the beginning of volume 4! It came all of a sudden, didn't it? I have a hard feeling that things won't be easy from now on, or rather, there are so many characters. But I want them to save them with passion.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

焦れる

I'm impatient

原作も好きですが、絵がー、とにかく好きだわー。イメージに合うし、細かいところまでよく描かれていて癒されるし、焦らされます、ありがたいわ。

I like the original story, but I love the picture... anyway. It fits the image, and the details are well drawn, so it's soothing and impatient, I'm thankful for that.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

コミックも原作も最低4巻まで読んでほしい

I want you to read at least 4 volumes of both the comic and the original

コミックは1～2巻の序章を踏まえた上で、2巻ラスト→3巻から恋愛的見どころシーンが続いてゆきます！原作でも好評だった切なくも美しいシーンの数々が、コミックのきれいな絵で完璧に表現されていて胸熱です。原作小説はまだ完結まで先がありそうですが、コミックと比べるとかなり進展してはいますし面白さは保証できるので原作も是非読んでください！

The comic is based on the preface of volumes 1 to 2, and romantic highlight scenes continue from the last volume 2 → volume 3! The many sad yet beautiful scenes that were popular in the original story are perfectly expressed with beautiful pictures in the comic, and I'm excited. It seems that the original novel still has a long way to go until completion, but compared to comics, it has progressed quite a bit, and fun can be guaranteed, so be sure to read the original story too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

続きを早く読みたい！

I want to read more soon!

主人公が愛ゆえに理不尽に生け贄となって恐ろしい世界で孤独に戦ってるなんて哀れで切なすぎます。男主人公よ、早く彼女を救って～

It's too pathetic and sad that the main character is unreasonably sacrificed because of love and is fighting alone in a horrible world. The male protagonist, save her soon~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

切なすぎて心が苦しいです…

It's so sad and my heart hurts...

主人公の置かれている立場が切なすぎて…誰も悪くないからこそ苦しいです…。聖剣のおかげで23年も1人で耐えてきたのに、想い人とそっくりな人(息子)が現れたら心が揺らいじゃいますよね…。もう本当に主人公には幸せになってもらいたいです。絵も美麗でストーリーもとても良くて次巻が待ちきれません。早く2025年になってほしいです。

The position the protagonist is in is so sad... it's painful because no one is at fault... Thanks to Seiken, I've endured 23 years alone, but my heart is shaken when someone (son) who looks just like the person I love appears... I really want the main character to be happy already. The pictures are beautiful and the story is so good that I can't wait for the next volume. I hope it will be 2025 as soon as possible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

何度読んでも泣けてくる。

It makes me cry no matter how many times I read it.

ずっと読んでるうちから涙が止まらない。あまりにも可哀想すぎる。好きな人に頼まれたかって二度と帰れないのに行ってしまうなんて、どんなけなんだよー?続きが気になるよー?

I couldn't stop crying as I read it all this time. It's just too pathetic. What kind of trouble would it be if someone you like asked you to go back and never go back? you're worried about the continuation, aren't you?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

二人の揺らぐ心がスリリング

Their flickering hearts are thrilling

出会いから徐々に変化しつつあったロイドとイレーネの心情が、ここに来て加速的に変化している様に、読者としては胸が高鳴る。

As a reader, the feelings of Lloyd and Irene, which had been gradually changing since they met, are changing at an accelerated pace since they came here, which excites my heart.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

どっぷりハマっています

I'm really addicted to it

アラフィフのおばちゃんが、こんなに少女マンガにどっぷりハマるとは思っていませんでした。毎巻号泣しています。イレーネにはどうしても、どうしても幸せになってほしいと願っています。

I never thought Alafif's aunt would be so addicted to girls' manga. I cry every volume. I really want Irene to be happy no matter what.

Helpful

Reviews for The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga