The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga Reviews (P.4)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

原作も読みたくなる面白さ！

It's fun that makes you want to read the original story too!

絵が綺麗で好みだなと思って読み始めたら、期待以上にキャラの表情とかが魅力的でストーリーも先が読めない面白さで引き込まれました！色々なしがらみがありながらも、3～4巻でヒーローくんがヒロインにグイグイ行くのが最高。原作も既刊全て買い揃えたので読みます！

I thought the pictures were beautiful and I liked it, and when I started reading it, I was drawn in by the fact that the expressions of the characters were more attractive than I expected, and the fun of not being able to read the story ahead! Even though there are a lot of stories, it's great that Hero-kun quickly goes as the heroine in volumes 3 to 4. I also bought all of the original stories that have already been published, so I'm going to read them!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない！

that's sad!

This review contains spoilers. 次が待ちきれなくてライトノベルに手をだしましたが、漫画だとどう表現されるのか楽しみです。とにかく2人の関係か切ない！真実を知ったあとどうなるのか、、、でも結ばれてほしいです！

This review contains spoilers. I couldn't wait for the next one, so I started working on a light novel, but I'm excited to see how it will be expressed in comics. Anyway, the relationship between the two is sad! What will happen after knowing the truth... but I want them to tie the knot!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

絵が綺麗で繊細！主人公には是非とも幸せになってもらいたい！じゃないと報われなさすぎて悲しい！早く続きが読みたくなる作品です！

The picture is beautiful and delicate! I definitely want the main character to be happy! If not, you won't be rewarded, so sad! It's a work that makes you want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

良きです

It's good

タイトルのインパクトがあり、お試しで読んでみました。絵がとても綺麗だし、設定が面白い！切なくも甘くて、苦しい。この先の展開が気になるので、早く続きが読みたいです?ヒロインに幸せになってほしいです。

The title had an impact, and I tried reading it. The pictures are so beautiful and the settings are interesting! Even though it's sad, it's sweet, and painful. I'm worried about future developments, so I want to read the continuation soon? I want the heroine to be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

早く先が知りたい

I want to know the future as soon as possible

This review contains spoilers. 主人公ウィステリアが失恋して異界にいかなければならない話で、国宝の剣とあっさり行っちゃって、え？終わり？かと思いきや、失恋相手の息子が異界にくるとゆー、とんでも話でした！可哀想な話だから、とにかく早く早く2人がくっついてほしくて、でも絶対くっつけなさそうだから、ほんとにこの先どーすんの？みたいな。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story where the main character, Wisteria, is heartbroken and has to go to a different world, and she easily goes away with the national treasure sword, huh? the end? Unexpectedly, it was a ridiculous story when my heartbroken partner's son came to another world! It's a sad story, so anyway, I just want the two of them to stick together quickly, but they never seem to stick together, so what are we really going to do next? It's like that.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

よきです

That's good

絵がキレイで、出てくるキャラクターもかっこいいしかわいいです！世界観がよく作り込まれていてのめり込みます

The pictures are beautiful, and the characters that appear are cool and cute too! The view of the world is well designed and I'm immersed in it

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せになって

Be happy

This review contains spoilers. 最初はなんて残酷なストーリーと思って。躊躇してました。でもやはり、買ってしまいました。絵がとにかく美しい。ストーリーも時々場面が変わったりしますが比較的読みやすいです。内容はとにかく切ない。イレーネ。お願いだから幸せになって。読み進めていくうちに、プライドは自分が幸せになるために他人を犠牲にして、そして、罪の意識はあるものの、イレーネに関する捻じ曲げられた事柄を正すこともせず、自分勝手だと思うようになってきました。そして、ロイドの本心はいかに。ロイドがイレーネが苦しんでいる本当の理由を知った時どうなってしまうんだろうと思います。イレーネが少しでも救われますように。(﹡´◡`﹡ )

This review contains spoilers. What a cruel story I thought at first. I was hesitating. But after all, I bought it. The picture is just beautiful. The story also changes scenes from time to time, but it's relatively easy to read. The content is just sad. Irene. Please be happy. As I read on, I began to think that pride was selfish because she sacrificed others in order to make herself happy, and even though she had a sense of guilt, she didn't correct the twisted things about Irene. And what about Lloyd's true intentions. I wonder what will happen when Lloyd finds out the real reason why Irene is suffering. I hope Irene can be saved even a little bit. ('`*)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

レビューで買うのやめてたけど…

I stopped buying it due to reviews, but...

This review contains spoilers. 買ってよかった！今割引中やし、悲恋とか好きちゃうけど、レビューに書いてたみたいな、可哀想すぎるとか、スッキリ感無いとか、嫌いな人は…ってので買うのやめてたけど、4巻まで読んでの感想は、シンデレラストーリー好きな人には大丈夫。1巻で義理の妹に国から、異世界みたいなとこ行けと命令が出て、義理の親とか、好きな人(義理の妹と好き同士)に、妹の代わりに行ってくれと頼まれ、行ったら1人っきりで、二度と帰ることない世界なのに行く事に。それを哀れに思った、国の宝(喋る聖剣)が一緒に行くことに。それから20何年か経って、元の世界では、主人公聖剣盗んで、追放なった事になってて、家族達も、その話を受け入れてて…｡そして親の代わりに行ったこと知らない、父にクリソツな息子が、皇女にプロポーズする為に、聖剣取り返すと意気込み、主人公の元に…｡そして向こうで2人っきりの世界(聖剣もいるから3人？)で、恋愛っぽくなってく。主人公は行った時から歳とらずやから、同じ歳くらいに見える。恋愛に発展するとこで、プロポーズの為が引っかかってくるし、母親が本当は行くはずやった事とか知らんし、父の事好きやった事も知らんし、でも恋しだしてるし…｡色んな葛藤ありやけど、イチャイチャにしか見えない4巻楽しめた。小説のネタバレで見たけど、この後元の世界に2人とも帰ってから…｡という発展みたいやけど、そこが見たい。スッキリするとこもおりまぜて欲しい。家族も酷いけど、皇族も、敵みたいになるやろーしコレからが楽しみな感じです。

This review contains spoilers. I'm glad I bought it! It's on sale right now, and I like it, but as I wrote in the review, I stopped buying it because it's too pathetic or not feeling refreshed... but my impression after reading up to 4 volumes is fine for people who like the Cinderella story. In volume 1, my sister-in-law gave me an order from the country to go to a place like another world, and my parents-in-law or someone I liked (sister-in-law and like-minded people) asked me to go in place of my sister, and when I went, I was all alone, and I decided to go even though it was a world I would never return to. Feeling sorry for that, the national treasure (speaking sacred sword) decided to go with them. Twenty years have passed since then, and in the original world, the main character's Seiken was stolen and banished, and the family accepted the story... and his son, who didn't know he had gone in place of his parents, is enthusiastic when he takes back his sword in order to propose to the princess, and to the main character... and a world with only 2 people over there (3 people since they also have a sacred sword?) So, it starts to look like love. The main character hasn't been old since he went, and he looks like he's about the same age. As it developed into a love affair, the proposal got caught up, I didn't know that my mother was actually supposed to go, and I didn't know that my father liked it, but I'm starting to fall in love... There are various conflicts, but I was able to enjoy volume 4, which only seemed like flirting. I saw it in a spoiler for the novel, but it seems like it developed after both of them went back to their original world... but I want to see that. There are also places that make you feel refreshed, so I want you to mix them up. The family is terrible, but the royal family is also going to be like enemies, so I'm looking forward to this.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

これはイイ！

this is good!

異世界ものはいろいろ読みましたが、大体いじめられているヒロインが幸せを掴んで大勝利！ってストーリーが王道ですが、コレは意地悪な人が一人もいなくて、それぞれ大切なものを守るために何かを犠牲にして、その苦しさを抱えながら生きている。まぁ、ヒロインが幸せになって、他のキャラも幸せになるんじゃないかな～とは分っているけど、4巻の時点ではまだ全員がもがき足掻いている…。その心情の描き方が丁寧で久し振りにホロリと切なくなる漫画です。めっちゃオススメ！早く続きが読みたいな～！

I've read a lot of things from Isekai, but the heroine, who has been bullied for the most part, has grasped happiness and won a big victory! The story is royal, but there isn't a single mean person in this, and they each sacrifice something to protect something important, and they live with that pain. Well, I know that the heroine will be happy and the other characters will be happy too, but as of volume 4, everyone is still struggling... It's a comic that depicts that feeling so carefully that it's been a long time since I felt so sad. I really recommend it! I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 24, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

みんな美しい…

everyone is beautiful...

This review contains spoilers. 小説からやってきました。義理の甥と伯母、という関係でヒロインが可哀想なまましばらく進んでいきます。なので可哀想なのがダメな方は合わないかと。内容は原作そのままで、原作よりも漫画のがテンポよく進むのでストレスなく読み進められます。ヒロイン、ヒーローどちらもキレイで見ていて癒されます。まぁ、内容はじれじれもだもだ、ヒロインに優しくない世界なのでストレスもある一定はたまりますが…。

This review contains spoilers. I came from a novel. The heroine progresses for a while while feeling sorry due to the relationship between her nephew in law and her aunt. So I don't think it would be a good fit for those who are sorry but bad. The content remains the same as the original, and the manga progresses at a better tempo than the original, so you can read on without stress. Both the heroine and the hero are beautiful to watch and be healed. Well, the content is mixed up, and since it's a world that isn't kind to the heroine, it's definitely stressful...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ライトノベルでも読んでます

I also read light novels

ライトノベルでも読んでるので先の展開を知ってます。その度に「おめーの父親だよ（怒）」となるので、読んでる方には一緒に突っ込んで頂きたいです。say「テメーの父親だよ！」

I've also read light novels, so I'm aware of future developments. Every time, it becomes “That's my father (angry),” so I'd like those reading it to dive in with me. Say “I'm Teme's father!”

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ガスパージャとベン

Gasparja and Ben

愛する人からの冷酷で浅薄な提案。それは自分の存在さえも否定されるかのような思いがするのだろう。だが、この世の底のような感情をもたらすその仕打ちは、何やら突き抜けた爽快感があるのもまた否定できない。

A ruthless and shallow proposal from a loved one. It probably makes me feel as if even my existence is being denied. However, there is also no denying that the treatment, which brings about feelings like the bottom of this world, has a sense of exhilaration that penetrates somewhat.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない・・・

it's sad...

好きな人に妹の代わりに新でくれと言われる・・・なんて切ない物語でしょうしかも罪人とか魔女扱いとか一途な思いから好きな人と妹の未来のために自分の命を差し出したのに、そんなことになっているなんて・・・幸せになってほしいけど、主人公にとっての幸せが何か、私には思いつかない・・・

It's a sad story where someone I like asks me to do a new one instead of my sister... and even though I offered my life for the future of my favorite person and sister out of whim, such as being treated as a sinner or witch... I want them to be happy, but I can't think of any happiness for the main character...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

意外と良かった

Surprisingly good

タイトルが辛すぎて、ずっと読まずにいた作品。覚悟して読んだからかもしれないけど、思ったよりひどくなくて、読み進められました。救われてほしい。

The title was so painful that I didn't read it for a long time. Maybe it was because I was prepared to read it, but it wasn't as bad as I thought, and I was able to read on. I want them to be saved.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がとても綺麗

The picture is so beautiful

This review contains spoilers. 絵が美麗で読み始めました。続きが気になり原作も一気に読んでしまいました。イレーネとロイドには本当に幸せになってほしいです。イレーネに対してロイドの態度が8話以降で明らかに変わるので特にいいです。元の世界にいた頃よりロイドが楽しそうです。無自覚なのがもどかしいですが。イレーネも可愛いとカッコいいが両立していて素敵です。残酷な仕打ちを受けて孤独な未明の地にずっといても優しさを失わず相手を慮れるイレーネは本当にすごいし魅力的な女性だと思います。戦闘シーンもカッコいいです。この美麗な絵で原作全部見たいです。

This review contains spoilers. The picture was beautiful and I started reading it. I was curious about the continuation, and I read the original story all at once. I really want Irene and Lloyd to be happy. Lloyd's attitude towards Irene clearly changes from episode 8 onwards, so it's particularly nice. Lloyd seems to be having more fun than when he was in his original world. It's frustrating to be unaware, though. Irene is also cute and cool, but they are both wonderful. I think Irene is a really amazing and attractive woman who has been treated cruelly and can treat her partner without losing her kindness even when she is in a lonely wee dawn place all the time. The battle scenes are cool too. I want to see all of the original works with this beautiful picture.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

ランキングの上位にあったので購入して読みました。初めは、ヒロインが可愛そうで....。でも頑張ってるヒロインを応援したいし、今後幸せになって欲しいなと思って読んでいます。絵もキレイで好きです。

It was at the top of the ranking, so I bought it and read it. At first, the heroine seemed cute... But I'm reading it because I want to support the heroine who is doing her best, and I want her to be happy in the future. The pictures are beautiful and I like them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

続きを求め原作を読まずにはいられなくなる

I can't help but read the original story in search of the continuation

心にずっしりと残る重さ切なさですが、絵が綺麗で可愛いのと続きが気になるのとで一気読み！コミック3,4巻でヒロインと弟子(初恋の人の息子)との距離がどんどん近づいてドキドキが加速……?一応は伯母と甥の関係ですが、血の繋がりはなくて本当に良かった。この二人で幸せになってほしいです。原作小説は4巻以降がとても良かったので、コミックから知った人にもぜひ読みに行くことをおすすめします?❤

It's heavy and sad that sticks so much in my heart, but I read it all at once because the picture is beautiful and cute and I'm worried about the continuation! The distance between the heroine and her apprentice (son of the first love person) gets closer and closer in comic volumes 3 and 4, and the excitement accelerates...? For the time being, it's a relationship between my aunt and my nephew, but I'm really glad they weren't related by blood. I want these two to be happy. The original novel was very good after volume 4, so I definitely recommend that people who know it from comics go read it? ❤

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

大失恋、のち新たな出会いからの両片想い

Unrequited love from a great heartbreak and later a new encounter

主人公が恋した人の息子が最初の1,2巻頃は生意気だけど、主人公の優しさに触れて3巻以降は態度軟化してるし何なら惚れ始めてるのが良いですね！

The son of the person the protagonist fell in love with is cheeky around the first volume 1 or 2, but after being touched by the main character's kindness, his attitude softened after volume 3, so it's nice that they started falling in love!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ウィスタリアに幸あれ！

Good luck to Wisteria!

今、1番続きが読みたい漫画です！初めましての作家様であとストーリーに魅了されて一気読み！待ちきれずラノベも一気読み！（笑）絵が綺麗でストーリーは切なすぎて、胸がギュッてしめつけられるような感覚になるけど、ロイドとの関係性に徐々に変化が生じて、心身ともに2人の距離が近くなっていくのが読んでてドキドキします！2人の世界シーンがたくさん見たいです！早くコミックがラノベに追いつきますように‼︎ただ一つラノベを読んで思ったのが、ラノベの作画の方がキャラに合っていて、コミック版も担当してくださったらすごく嬉しかったなと思ってしまったのですが、そう思ったのは私だけでしょうか‥。

Right now, the most continuous manga I want to read! Nice to meet you, I was fascinated by the story and read it all at once! I can't wait and read the light novels all at once! (Laughter) The pictures are so beautiful and the story is so sad, it makes me feel like my heart is tightening, but it's exciting to read that the relationship with Lloyd gradually changes, and the distance between the two becomes closer both mentally and physically! I want to see lots of world scenes between them! I hope comics catch up with light novels soon ‼ ︎ The only thing I thought after reading the light novel was that the light novel drawing suited the characters, and I was really happy if they were also in charge of the comic version, but I wonder if I was the only one who thought so...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

やきもき

yakimoki

ウィステリア（ヒロイン）が、初恋の人に、（遠まわしでもないけど）自分の好きな子の身代わりに生きて帰れない場所へ人身御供で行ってくれ。みたいに言われて、絶望しながらも、望みをかなえる為に向かった先が、隔絶された世界（危険な異界）で、、、、。月も太陽も無い世界…（自分的に）常に薄暗い曇りっぽいイメージの世界で、言葉を話す剣（宝剣サルティス）がよりどころで23年も生きて来て、って、、、いや、深層面で心おかしくなるなんて、当たり前でしょがー！！体調面なんかは、瘴気や自身の力で何とかなってたかもだけど。。。精神面は、重度の鬱になってそうだわ。もう、出だしから色々とやきもきしてしまう作品でした。WEB小説の方で、内容は知ってましたが改めてコミカライズという分かりやすく見やすい状態で読むと、、、うわあ～……とクるものがあります。絵も綺麗なので、引き続き読んでみようと思いました。

Wisteria (heroine) lives in place of her favorite child (although not far away) and goes to a place she can't return to as a human sacrifice to her first love. I was told something like that, even though I was hopeless, the destination I headed to to make my wishes come true was an isolated world (dangerous alien world)... A world with no moon or sun... in a world with an image that is always dim and cloudy (in my own way), it's natural that the sword that speaks words (Hoken Sartis) has lived for 23 years, and... no, it's natural to go crazy on a deep level!! As for my physical condition, I think I was able to do something about it with miasma or my own strength... On the mental side, it seems like I'm getting severely depressed. It was a work that made me feel a lot of excitement right from the start. It's an online novel, and I know the content, but when I read it again in a comicalized state that's easy to understand and read, I get... wow... The pictures are also beautiful, so I thought I'd keep reading them.

Helpful

Reviews for The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga