The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 14, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ゆっくりじっくり深まる両片思い…

Unrequited love between the two slowly and slowly deepens...

コミックス5巻まで読了。いつ読んでも原作に忠実に丁寧に描かれた良コミカライズ！コミックス初見だと先が読めなくてヤキモキしそうですが、原作でこの先の展開を知っていると、この恋に結び付くまでの心情変化を丁寧に描いた章が面白くて。他のレビューにもありましたが、コミックス6巻終わりで急展開…からの7巻8巻は大盛り上がり確実なのでこれからが更に楽しみ。

I've read up to 5 volumes of comics. No matter when you read it, it's a good comicalization that is carefully drawn faithfully and faithfully to the original! When I first saw the comic, it seemed exciting because I couldn't read the future, but when I knew about future developments in the original story, the chapter carefully depicting the changes in feelings leading up to this love was interesting. There were other reviews, but volumes 7 and 8 from the end of volume 6 of comics are definitely going to be very exciting, so I'm looking forward to the future even more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 25, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

切なすぎる

It's too sad

ヒロインが可哀想すぎる。好きな人に死んでくれと言われるだけでも辛いのに、そのまま何十年も1人ぼっちの世界で戦い続けるなんて、、、どうにかして幸せになってくれますように。あまりに悲しく切ないので、完結してから一気読みしたい。ハッピーエンドになる前提なんですけど。

The heroine is too pitiful. It's hard just being asked by someone you like to die, but I hope they somehow make them happy to keep fighting in a world all alone for decades... It's so sad and sad, so I want to read it all at once after I've finished it. The assumption is that it will have a happy ending, though.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 27, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せになってほしい

I want you to be happy

This review contains spoilers. 他人から悪く言われようと愛する人に尽くしてきたのに、妹の代わりに死地に行ってほしいという彼の願いを聞き入れ未開の地へ向かい、時を経てかつて愛した人と妹の息子と出会う話です。ウィスには幸せになってほしいと思いますが、どうしても心から幸せにはなれないのでは、という現状でやりきれないです。少しでもウィスの心の傷が癒えるような結末になることを願っています。小説版も好きですが、絵がきれいで登場人物の表情がわかりやすい漫画版も良かったです。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story about how you've done your best for someone you love, no matter how bad things are said by others, but you listen to his wish that he go to a dead place instead of his sister, head to an undeveloped place, and meet the person you once loved and your sister's son over time. I want Wise to be happy, but I can't do it with the current situation where I can't be truly happy by any means. I hope the ending will heal Wyss's heartbreak even a little bit. I like the novel version, but I also liked the comic version, which has beautiful pictures and makes it easy to understand the characters' expressions.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 15, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ふたりの世界

A world for two

This review contains spoilers. ひとりで戦い続けてきたイレーネが、少しずつ心を許すことが出来て良かった。このふたりが、これからどうなるのか、続きが気になります。

This review contains spoilers. I'm glad that Irene, who has been fighting alone, was able to forgive her heart little by little. I'm curious about the continuation of what will happen to these two in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

すごく綺麗！

So beautiful!

絵が綺麗だったので読んでみて、ドハマりしました。小説の内容をそのままコミックスにされており、変に変えられていないので安心して楽しめます。原作小説も最新刊まで見ましたが、家守先生の画で見たいシーンが沢山あるので、ぜひこのまま続いてほしい！！

The picture was beautiful, so I read it, and I was addicted to it. The content of the novel has been made into a comic as it is, and no strange changes have been made, so you can enjoy it without worry. I've watched the original novel until the latest edition, but there are a lot of scenes I want to see in Iemori-sensei's paintings, so I definitely want them to continue like this!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

恋愛の進展が丁寧に描かれていて胸に刺さる

The progress of the romance is carefully drawn and sticks to my heart

ヒロインもヒーローもすごく難しい状況に置かれている壮大なファンタジー。ヒーローはヒロインの嘘の悪評を聞いていた所からのスタートなので初めは好感度ゼロ…どころかマイナス。でもヒロインの中身の魅力でヒーローが着実に惹かれているのが良くて悶えます。何より恋愛の機敏がとても丁寧に描かれていて、感情移入して作品の世界にのめり込んでしまう…！現実が厳しくてハラハラはするけど、このまだまだ始まったばかりの恋…5巻までの段階では両片思い？の行方を見守りたいです。恋愛以外のストーリーもオリジナリティーあって面白いです

An epic fantasy where both the heroine and hero are in a very difficult situation. The hero started from where I was listening to the heroine's false notoriety, so at first they had zero likability... let alone negative. But it's nice that the hero is steadily being attracted to it due to the appeal of the heroine's content, which makes me cringe. Above all, the dexterity of romance is depicted very carefully, and I empathize and immerse myself in the world of the work...! The reality is so harsh that it's jarring, but this love that has just begun... is it unrequited love at the stage up to volume 5? I want to keep an eye on their whereabouts. Stories other than romance are also original and interesting

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

切なくてキュンとする

I'm sad and cringe

This review contains spoilers. まずは絵が美麗で、ノベルの世界観を崩すことなく魅力的にしています。ロイド、かっこよすぎる！ロイドがウィステリアに惹かれ、ウィステリアが愛した相手に嫉妬する様子にキュンキュンします。ロイドが、ウィステリアが愛した彼の父とそっくりであること、ロイドはウィステリアが自分の父を愛し、自分の母の身代わりになったことを知らないことがどう物語で展開されるかが気になります。ウィステリアは死の淵でずっと頑張ってきたので、ロイドにはウィステリアを最高に幸せにしてほしいです。ノベルから見るに先は結構長そうですが、楽しみにしています。

This review contains spoilers. First of all, the pictures are beautiful, making them attractive without breaking the novel's worldview. Lloyd is too cool! I'm thrilled that Lloyd is attracted to Wisteria and is jealous of the person Wisteria loved. I'm curious about how the story unfolds that Lloyd looks just like his father that Wisteria loved, and that Lloyd doesn't know that Wisteria loved his father and took his own mother's place. Wisteria has been working so hard on the brink of death, so I want Lloyd to make Wisteria the happiest. Seems like it's quite a long way from a novel, but I'm looking forward to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 15, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

読み応えある恋愛ファンタジー

A romance fantasy worth reading

試し読みできる部分で、あまりにも切なすぎて読むのを避けていましたが、クーポンがあったので購入しました。原作は読んでいません。読んだ結果、確かにずーーーっと切ないです。主人公が健気すぎるし、可哀想すぎてしんどい。本当にタイトル通りの展開で、これは主人公に対して酷すぎない…？？と思います。ただ、徐々に光が差してくるような、期待できる(したくなる)展開になってきて、続きが気になってたまらないです！ロイドの気持ちの変化も自然で、イレーネを！なんとかしてくれ！！と、ハッピーエンドになるよう、祈るように読み続けてます。手っ取り早くすぐに、ぎゃふん！すっきり！となる展開が良い場合は、おすすめできない作品です。また、底抜けに明るくって前向きで〜みたいな主人公をお探しの方も、合わない気がします。一方で、主人公たちが前に後ろにもだもだしながら進む、読み応えのある恋愛ファンタジーを探してる方には、おすすめできる作品です。

It's a part where you can try reading it, and I avoided reading it because it was too sad, but I bought it because there was a coupon. I haven't read the original. As a result of reading it, it's certainly been really sad. It's tough because the main character is too energetic and too pathetic. It really unfolds as the title suggests, and isn't this too bad for the main character...?? I think so. However, it has gradually become a development that I can expect (want to) look forward to, and I can't help but be curious about the continuation! The change in Lloyd's feelings was also natural, so Irene! Please do something about it!! I keep reading as if praying for a happy ending. quick, quick, huh! Refreshing! If the development is good, I can't recommend this work. Also, I don't feel like it's suitable for those looking for a protagonist who is downright bright and positive. On the other hand, I can recommend this work to those looking for a well-read romance fantasy where the main characters advance while slouching back and forth.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

毎回泣ける

I can cry every time

今回も本当に素敵なお話でした絵も綺麗でとても素敵ですあっという間に読み終わってしまう……完結まで一気読みしたいですこの先、このふたりはどうなるのか…ハッピーエンドは訪れるのか…

It was a really wonderful story this time too, and the pictures are beautiful and so wonderful, I'll finish reading it in no time... I want to read it all at once until completion What will happen to these two in the future... will there be a happy ending...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 30, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

絵も綺麗だしストーリーも過去一好きでした

The pictures are beautiful and I liked the story the most

絵が綺麗すぎて心が洗われます?‪ウィステリアが苦しい状況で心が壊れそうになってしまっても人にはとても親切なところとか、読者が苦しくなるほどまっすぐ一途なところが素敵で、辛い?何度も涙しました。間違いなく人生で一番好きなお話です‪‪❤︎‬買ってよかった✨

Are the pictures so beautiful that they wash your mind? Is it wonderful that Wisteria is so kind to people even when her heart is about to break in a difficult situation, or a place that is so straight forward that readers are in pain, is it wonderful, and painful? I cried over and over again. It's definitely my favorite story in my life ❤ ︎ I'm glad I bought it ✨

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 23, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

秀逸なコミカライズ

Excellent comicalization

最新巻まで一気に読んでしまったので今は続きを原作小説で読んでいます。原作の緻密な心理描写、情景描写が上手にコミカライズされていてどちらも楽しめます。ストーリーも面白くて先が読めず楽しみです。異世界・令嬢モノは主人公にあまりにも都合がいい話が多く興醒めする作品が多いのでこういう良作は貴重です。サルトとの掛け合いがとても好ましいですが実態が底知れなくてこれからますます楽しみです。

I read the latest volume all at once, so now I'm reading the continuation with the original novel. The precise psychological depiction and scene depiction of the original story are well comicalized, so you can enjoy both. The story is also interesting and I can't read ahead, so I'm looking forward to it. There are many stories that are too convenient for the main character in Isekai: The Young Lady Mono, and there are many works that are exciting, so good works like this are valuable. The interaction with Saruto is very good, but the reality is uncertain and I'm looking forward to it even more.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 18, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

切なすぎます

It's too sad

This review contains spoilers. これでもかと辛い目に合い続けるウィス…切なすぎます。こんな辛い状況を自分の両親が追い込んだと知ってしまったらロイドはどうなってしまうんでしょう?早くウィスを救って欲しい〜！！

This review contains spoilers. Wisu continues to have a hard time even with this... it's too sad. what would happen to Lloyd if he knew that his parents had driven such a difficult situation? I want you to save Wiss soon~!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

胸が痛すぎる…

My heart hurts too much...

しんどい…ずっとしんどい…はやくウィスを救ってくれ…?普通に泣いた…どうなるの…？救われるの…？1冊が秒で終わる…ウィスは悠久ともいえる時間を幽閉されてるのに……これロイドが全容知ったらどうなんの？破滅しそうここから入れる保険(happy　end)ってあるんですか…

it's tough... it's been tough all the time... please save Wiss quickly...? I cried normally... what will happen...? can you be saved...? One book ends in seconds... even though Wiss was imprisoned for an eternal time... what if Lloyd knew all of this? Is there an insurance (happy end) that seems like it's going to be ruined from here...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない…

sad...

This review contains spoilers. ずっと1人で戦い続けているヒロイン…切なすぎます(*´-`)サルトは何者なんでしょう？今後の展開が気になります!

This review contains spoilers. Who is the heroine who has been fighting alone all this time... it's too sad (*'-`) Saruto? I'm curious about future developments!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 08, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

とても切ない内容です。好きな人の為にここまで出来るのか…。ここまでしたのに報われない。人は一人で生きていけない、精神が壊れてしまう。あーどうかハッピーエンドで終わって欲しいと願う漫画です。

The content is very sad. I wonder if I can go this far for someone I like... I've made it this far, but I haven't been rewarded. People can't live alone; their minds are broken. Oh, this is a comic I hope it ends with a happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

新刊が遠い.....

The new publication is far away...

新刊が出るたびに最初の巻から読み直して気持ちを入れてじっくり読んでます　とにかく理性的過ぎる2人の間にいるサルトの発言がツボります単純に2人に結ばれて欲しいとかいう感想は持たずに、この物語の終着点がどこになるのかとても気になりますもちろん、なによりイレーネには報われて欲しい気持ちは読者のみなさん持たれるかとそのくらい自己犠牲が過ぎますそもそもサルトって本当に何者？そこがポイントなのかな新刊が出る度、次の新刊までが長いのを知っているので楽しみ半分ため息がでます(　ˊ̱˂˃ˋ̱　)

Every time a new issue comes out, I reread it from the first volume and read it carefully. Anyway, Saruto's statement, who is between the two people who are too rational, comes off. I don't have the impression that they simply want them to be tied together, and I'm really curious about where this story ends. Of course, the feeling that I want Irene to be rewarded above all else is that readers can have that self-sacrifice. Who is Saruto really in the first place? I wonder if that's the point every time a new issue comes out, I know it's a long time until the next new issue, so I sigh with half the fun ()

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

早く次！次！

Hurry up next! next!

コミック、小説どちらも購入しました。小説の4.5.6が好きで何度も読みました。一気に話しが進みます。はやくロイドが全て知ってほしいです。

I bought both comics and novels. I liked 4.5.6 of the novel and read it many times. The conversation progresses all at once. I want Lloyd to know everything soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ついつい何度も読み返してしまう作品

A work I just reread over and over

This review contains spoilers. 5巻迄読みました。人物の心の動きや変化が丁寧に描かれていて、どうしようもなく切なくなってしまいます。大切な人の為に自分を犠牲にしてしまう主人公を応援したくなります。初恋の人と似ている顔で、しかも姪っ子のロイドとは恋愛出来るのかどうか見守りたいと思います。主人公イレーネと宝剣サルトの会話に安心を感じています。ファンタジー世界の絵も綺麗です。年代が飛んだり、ストーリーが少し前後する構成ですが読み進めるとわかるので大丈夫かと思います。欲を言えば、歳をとった人物をもう少しイケメンに描いて貰えると嬉しいです。小説も少し読みましたが、初めては漫画から入りたいと思ってますので、巻が進むのを楽しみに待ちます。

This review contains spoilers. I've read up to 5 volumes. The movements and changes of the character's mind are carefully depicted, and it makes me helpless and sad. I want to support the protagonist who sacrifices himself for his loved ones. I have a face similar to my first love, and I would like to keep an eye on whether I can fall in love with my niece Lloyd. I feel relieved by the conversation between the main character, Irene, and Hoken Saruto. The pictures in the fantasy world are also beautiful. The ages have flown by, and the story is slightly back-and-forth, but as you read on, you'll understand, so I think it's fine. Speaking of greed, I would be happy if someone a little more handsome could draw an old person. I've also read a few novels, but I'd like to start with comics for the first time, so I'm looking forward to the volume progressing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

これは切なくて胸がギューってなる！

This is so sad that it makes my heart ache!

This review contains spoilers. 正直、タイトルは苦手だったので敬遠してました。でも、これは読んで良かった！！！いい意味で裏切られました。ヒロインのウィス。初めて好きになった人が、妹の方を…と思わせて、結局は彼もヒロインが！となる王道パターンを見事にくつがえし本当に失恋…どころかこともあろうにその大好きな人に妹の身代わりになってくれと言われるシーンは泣きました。何て残酷な現実なの…。。。この時点でかなり胸がギューーーーっとなりますが話のメインはここから！自身が生贄になった後、かつて大好きだった人は普通に妹と結ばれて幸せになり、子を授かります。そしてその息子が彼と瓜二つの姿で目の前に現れて…弟子にすることになり、そこから2人＋剣の奇妙な生活が始まります。何度も言いますが、読んでると何度も胸がギューーーーってなります！！番人としても強く成長し優しく凛とした女性らしさを持つウィス。いつもどこか儚げで、いつか壊れてしまいそうな健気な姿は、ロイドでなくても放っておけない！こんなヒロインと、密接に2人生活をしてしまえば好きにならないわけないじゃん。ロイドも、正直お父さんより性格が男らしくて思いやりもあり、家事も出来る超絶イケメン。個人的にはお父さんよりロイドの方が好きだなー。因みに…妹の息子ということは甥っ子。となるとまさか禁断の恋なの⁈と一瞬思いましたが戸籍上は甥っ子ですが、妹とは血のつながりがなかったので安心しました！！これから、ウィスとロイドがどう結ばれていくのか本当に結ばれるのか、楽しみで仕方ないです！！

This review contains spoilers. To be honest, I didn't like the title, so I shunned it. But I'm glad I read this!!! I was betrayed in a good way. The heroine Wiss. The first person I fell in love with made me think of my sister... and in the end, he too is a heroine! The scene where she brilliantly overcame the royal road pattern and was really heartbroken... let alone the scene where the person I loved asked me to take my sister's place, made me cry. what a cruel reality... It really boggles my mind at this point, but the main part of the story starts here! After being sacrificed themselves, people they once loved are usually tied to their younger sister, become happy, and have children. Then, his son appears in front of him and two melons... they become apprentices, and from there, the strange life of the two plus sword begins. I've said it over and over again, but reading it makes my heart ache over and over again!! Wiz has grown strong as a guard and has a gentle and dignified femininity. The healthy appearance, which is always somewhat ephemeral and seems to break someday, can't be left alone, even if you're not Lloyd! If you live closely with a heroine like this, there's no way you won't fall in love with them. Lloyd is also a transcendent handsome guy who honestly has a more manly personality than his father, is compassionate, and can do housework. Personally, I like Lloyd better than Dad. Incidentally... my sister's son is my nephew. When it came to that, I thought for a moment that it was Forbidden Love, but according to the family register, he is my nephew, but I was relieved that there was no blood connection with my sister!! I can't help but look forward to seeing how Wyss and Lloyd will come together in the future and see if they actually get together!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 02, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

せつない

It's annoying

絵が綺麗で引き込まれます。愛する人との別れや想い　孤独の世界でやっと出逢えた光。この先どうなるか楽しみでなりません。おすすめです。

The picture is beautiful and draws me in. Hikari was finally able to meet someone she loved in a world of separation and loneliness. I can't wait to see what the future holds. I recommend it.

Helpful

Reviews for The Person I Loved Asked Me to Die in My Sister's Stead Manga