Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga Reviews (P.32)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ハピエンです！

It's Happien!

This review contains spoilers. 別れから始まり、他の人とのハピエンはよくあるけど、別れた彼と復縁してハッピーエンドで終わるって新しい！言葉にするってなかなか難しいけど、言葉にして相手に伝えることって本当大切だなって考えさせられる作品でした。

This review contains spoilers. It starts with a break up, and I often have happy relationships with other people, but getting back together with the guy I broke up with and ending with a happy ending is new! It's quite difficult to put it into words, but it was a work that made me think that it's really important to put it into words and convey it to the other person.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 21, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

This review contains spoilers. 別れたあとのお話から始まるので、切なかったです(*´；ェ；｀*)心理描写が丁寧なので、じっくり読めました！

This review contains spoilers. It starts with a story after we broke up, so it was sad (*'; e; `*) The psychological description was careful, so I was able to read it carefully!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

め〜っちゃ良かったです

That was really good

This review contains spoilers. 美容師攻め×小説家受け、4年付き合って喧嘩後の破局BLです。破局といってもお互いに未練タラタラずるずる引きずるタイプのお話なので、当て馬もなく大きな事故や事件もなく、日常のようなゆったりとした雰囲気で進みます。最初から最後までお互いに心の深いところで受け入れ合っていて、感情をぶつけ合っても決定的に嫌いになることは決してない2人なのでしょう。両方とも自身を省みることができるタイプですし、なにより4年も一緒にいて培った信頼と愛情が深いのだと思います。感情豊かな攻めもマイペースな受けも、両方の心情描写が細かく丁寧に描かれており、台詞がなくてもちゃんと起伏が伝わってきます。絵のタッチが柔らかいのかトーンの使い方なのか、破局というテーマとは反対に物語全体が柔らかく穏やかな雰囲気を持っていました。いい塩梅だなと思います。えちは意外と多めでしたが、絵柄の影響か結構爽やかに感じられました。重たくなくて読み進めやすく、初心者から読めるおすすめの一冊です。

This review contains spoilers. It's a breakup BL after attacking the hairdresser x being a novelist, and after 4 years of dating and fighting. Even though it's a catastrophe, it's a type of story where they both feel sorry and sloppy, so it progresses in a relaxed atmosphere like everyday life, with no hitting horses, no major accidents or incidents. They are probably two people who have accepted each other from the bottom of their heart from beginning to end, and they definitely never dislike each other even when their emotions collide with each other. They are both types who can reflect on themselves, and above all, I think they have a deep sense of trust and love that they have cultivated after being together for 4 years. Both emotional attacks and self-paced reception are depicted in detail and carefully, and the ups and downs are conveyed properly even without dialogue. Contrary to the theme of catastrophe, whether the touch of the picture is soft or the way the tone is used, the whole story had a soft and peaceful atmosphere. I think it's a good shio-plum. There was a surprisingly large amount of edging, but I felt quite refreshed, probably because of the pattern. It's not heavy, easy to read, and I recommend this book even for beginners.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 02, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かったー！

That was interesting!

This review contains spoilers. 受けも攻めも人間味があって良かったです。攻めの気持ちもわかるし、受けの気持ちも分かります。攻めがスパダリではないので(個人的には十分尽くしてると思うけど)スパダリがマイペースな受けを甘やかすのが好きならうーんとなるのかもしれません。受けにも攻めにも悪いところはあって、でもだからと言って本当に嫌いになれるわけでもなく、4年という月日の思い出があったり、社会人(ある程度歳を重なると)の時の流れであったり。自分が同じ経験をしているわけでもないのですが、共感しました。なぁなぁにしたと思う人もいるのかもしれませんが、そんな全てを白黒はっきりというのが全てではないというか、キャラクターの人間味がしっかりどちらもあり面白かったし、ジーンとしました。最初に良いレビューも悪いレビューも見てから購入しましたが、買って良かったです。

This review contains spoilers. I'm glad they had a human touch in both receiving and attacking. I understand the feeling of attack, and I also understand the feeling of receiving. The attack isn't Spadari (I personally think they've done enough), so if Spadari likes to indulge his self-paced reception, it might be hmm. There are bad things about both receiving and attacking, but that doesn't mean I really don't like it, and I have memories of 4 years, and it's the flow of time as a working person (when you get older to a certain extent). It's not like I've had the same experience, but I sympathized with it. There may be people who think that was a no-brainer, but it wasn't all about having everything clear in black and white; the characters had a strong sense of humanity in both, which was interesting, and I chose Gene. I bought it after first seeing both good and bad reviews, and I'm glad I bought it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

良い

good

こういうカップルたくさんいそうだな思ってることははっきり言った方がいいよねー、尽も桐生も我慢せずにさ

It seems like there are a lot of couples like this, so it's better to say clearly what you think, don't put up with it, neither Jin nor Kiryu

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 15, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

今後も幸せでいろよ

Stay happy in the future

This review contains spoilers. 2人のイチャイチャラブラブシーンがとにかく自分は好きだった！なんだかんだお互いのことわかってたりで可愛かった！自分はこんな儚い感じの漫画好きじゃないと思ってたけど試し読みしてたらついつい買っちゃってた他の人にもぜひ読んでほしい！

This review contains spoilers. I just loved the flirtatious love scene between the two! Somehow they understood each other and it was so cute! I thought I didn't like comics with such an ephemeral feel, but after trial reading, I just bought them, and I definitely want other people to read them too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

1巻で一旦完結。2巻は温かい世界。

Volume 1 will complete it once. Volume 2 is A Warm World.

ちょっとデトックスで泣きたい気分だったので、切ないストーリーとやらで評判の本作を購入。付き合い初めは甘くても慣れてくると当たり前になり、雑になり、好きなのになんで？って、許せたこともイライラしてしまう多くの世の中のCPがぶつかる壁。あるあるの共感性が有るが泣く程でもなかった。しかし、温かみの有る優しい絵柄で人物の表情も豊かで揺れる感情の表現が上手く共感して応援してしまうキャラクターも魅力的だ。そして一冊完結なのにストーリー展開も、お互いの目線切り替え、過去の思い出などを上手く散りばてて「上手い！」感心した。CPは2人とも一途で、世話焼き女房攻め×若干拗らせマイペース受け。なさる描写は白抜き、ノーマルで自然な感じ。2025.9月2巻おめでとうございます。2巻は安心して2人の絆の尊さにひれ伏しながら、温かい世界を満喫。ほっこりした。

I had a bit of detox and felt like crying, so I bought this work, which has a reputation for being a sad story. The relationship is sweet at first, but once you get used to it, it becomes commonplace, it becomes messy, and you like it, so why? It's a wall where many CPs in the world collide even when they were able to forgive and get frustrated. Aru Aru was sympathetic, but she didn't even cry. However, the characters have warm, gentle designs, and the expressions of the characters are rich, and the expressions of fluctuating emotions well sympathize with and cheer for them are also attractive. Also, even though one book was completed, the story development also changed each other's perspectives, and past memories were scattered nicely, and “good!” I was impressed. The CP was taken at their own pace by both of them, attacking the caretaker wife x being slightly relentless. The depiction is blank, normal, and natural. Congratulations on the 2025.9/2 volume. Volume 2 is about enjoying a warm world while bowing down to the preciousness of the bond between the two with peace of mind. I'm relieved.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 17, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

他人と一緒にいるということ

Being with someone else

This review contains spoilers. 自分以外の人と暮らすということは当たり前に難しくてわかり合おうとするのは無理な話。好きだからというお花畑な気持ちだけではやっていけない。妥協や我慢はつきもの。そんなリアルを描いている作品だと思いました。耐えられないから離れる、でも好きだからまた絆されて信じて戻っていく。でも完璧に信じたわけではなくまたそうやって繰り返していくんだろう、その度にまたぶつかり合って出て行って三度目はなかったりまた戻ったり、、永遠なんて保障はどこにもないけどそれでも一緒にいるよと綺麗事だけではない感じがとてもよかったです。

This review contains spoilers. Living with someone other than yourself is naturally difficult, and it's impossible to try to understand each other. You can't do it just by feeling like a flower garden because you like it. Compromises and patience are necessary. I thought it was a work depicting that kind of reality. They walk away because they can't stand it, but since they like them, they are bonded again, believe, and go back. But I didn't completely believe it, and they probably repeated it over and over again, and every time they bumped into each other, went out and didn't go back again, and there was no guarantee of eternity, but even so, it was very nice to feel that it wasn't just about being beautiful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 24, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

共感できるからこそ…

Precisely because I can empathize...

This review contains spoilers. 長年付き合ってきたとか、結婚してる人だったら大多数あるよなーーっていう心情。確かに自分側だけから見たらもうこの辺で終わりにしないと…とも思うし、愛情が無くなったわけではなく情もあるし…あんなに可愛いくズルく？誘われたらズルズルなるなーって見てて、そんな状況でも2人は可愛くて、もうそのまま戻ったらいいやんってもどかしくなるのですが… でも最後のちゃんと対話をする言葉で伝えるところからの…盛り上がりは最高でした！

This review contains spoilers. I have a feeling that the majority of people who have been in a relationship for a long time or are married have it. Certainly, if I only look at it from my side, I think I have to end it around here... and it's not like my love is gone, I have feelings... so cute, cheat? I watched it like they would cheer if invited, and even in such a situation, the two were cute, and it would be frustrating if they just went back in time... but from the last point where they conveyed it in words where they had a proper dialogue... the excitement was amazing!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

表題がいきてくる

The title comes

This review contains spoilers. 別れたのに、づるづるしている二人。お互い好きだけど、どうしてもつらくなって別れを選ぶことはままあること。あの電車でのシーンとか結構寂しい気持ちになりました。普段は去る者追わずの灯衣が、サッカーのチケットもって、デートに誘うところもだけど、試合が終わるときに自分たちの関係もという緊張感がたまらなかった。でも、復縁できてよかったなあと思います。お互い本音でぶつかって、なおそうとしてできるなら、そのほうがいいし。番外編も楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. The two are hanging out even though they broke up. We both love each other, but we still have to choose to break up because it gets difficult no matter what. That scene on the train made me feel pretty lonely. Normally, the lantern doesn't chase those who leave, has soccer tickets, and there are places where they invite them out on dates, but the tension in our relationship was unbearable when the game was over. But I'm glad we got back together. If we can do it by bumping into each other with real intentions and trying to fix it, then that's better. I'm also looking forward to the extra edition.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

いい題名だなー

that's a great title

This review contains spoilers. 誰かを理解することも理解してもらうことも難しくて、もういっそ諦めてしまった方が楽なのに、それでも諦めたくないと思う感情は、愛以外の何物でもない。正直最初は、そんなに未練タラタラなら戻ればいいじゃん！とか、4年一緒に居て価値観が合わないのならもうダメなんじゃ？とか戻っても大丈夫なのか？とか思ってたんですけど、別に大丈夫じゃなくてもいいんですよね。恋人やましてや家族でさえも、所詮は人それぞれの感受性を持った他人同士。衝突しないように〜、なんて逆に健全じゃない。いろんな愛の形はあると思うけど、衝突しても一緒にいたい、相手を理解したいって思うことはその1つだと思った。星5じゃないのは別にBLじゃなくても良かったなと思ったからです。

This review contains spoilers. It's difficult to understand and get someone to understand, and even though it's easier to give up, the feeling that you don't want to give up is nothing other than love. Honestly, at first, if you're that sorry, you should go back! or, if we've been together for 4 years and our values don't match, then it's no good anymore? is it okay to go back or something like that? I was wondering, but it doesn't have to be okay. After all, lovers and even family members are different people with their own sensitivities. Not to collide — on the contrary, it's not healthy. I think there are many forms of love, but I thought wanting to be together and to understand the other person even when they collide is one of them. The reason it wasn't 5 stars is because I thought it didn't have to be BL.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

言葉にしよう、どっちもね

Let's put it into words, both

マイペースな小説家・桐生と同棲して4年の尽、いつの間にか一緒にいてもさみしくてイライラしてばかりで…。言葉にしないと伝わらない、やっぱり言葉にしてほしい…BLとは関係なく普遍的な悩みだなと思いながら読んだ。絵柄の柔らかさや表情が好きな作家さん。いつもスパダリばかりじゃ現実的じゃないから、たまにはこんな（ある意味ダメな）2人もいい。仲直りエッチできるうちはまだ大丈夫！

It's been 4 years since I lived with Kiryu, a self-paced novelist, and before I knew it, I was lonely and frustrated even when we were together... If you don't put it into words, it won't be conveyed, I want you to put it into words after all... I read it while thinking that it's a universal problem regardless of BL. The artist likes the softness and expression of the designs. It's not realistic if it's always just spadari, so sometimes two people like this (in a sense bad) are good. While we can make up and have sex, it's still fine!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

良かったぁ。

That was great.

This review contains spoilers. 何やかんやありますが最後は二人素直に気持ち伝えられて復縁！良かった！とっても現実的なお話でリアル。何度も読んでじわじわくる作品。

This review contains spoilers. There are a few kettles, but at the end, the two honestly conveyed their feelings and got back together! That was great! It's a very realistic story and real. It's a work that slowly creeps in after reading it over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

2人の気持ちが分かりすぎる

I understand the feelings of the two too much

別れから始まる作品は初で、新鮮でした。2人の気持ちが、あ～分かる!てなって胸が痛くなった。別れても、お互い忘れられなくて‥切なくて涙が出ました。最後はハッピーエンドで終わってスッキリ！！

It was my first work that began with a break up, and it was fresh. I understand how they both feel! Tena made my heart ache. Even after we broke up, we couldn't forget each other... I was so sad that I burst into tears. It ended with a happy ending at the end and I was so refreshed!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 12, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

最終話手前まで…

until before the final episode...

This review contains spoilers. 最終話手前迄、胸が苦しいです。最後はハッピーエンドやと思い、気持ちを奮い立たせて、読んでたけど、別れるための努力みたいなのが、辛すぎて、最後は勿論元鞘です！分かってて、久々読み返したけど、辛かったです。1話売だったら、途中で買うのやめてる作品です。

This review contains spoilers. My heart aches until just before the final episode. I thought it was a happy ending at the end, and it inspired my feelings, and I was reading it, but the effort to break up was too painful, and of course the end is Genshaya! I understand, and I reread it after a long time, but it was hard. If episode 1 was sold, it's a work I stopped buying halfway through.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

うんうん

Yeah yeah

とても身近な、共感できるお話でした。少し切ないけれど、すーっと読んでいくことが出来ます。ただ、もっと深い内容を好む方にはちょっと物足りないかもしれないです。本当にさらっと自分の身の回りにもあるお話っていう感じです。最後はほんわかした気分になれます！

It was a very familiar story that I could relate to. It's a bit sad, but I can read it quickly. However, it may be a bit unsatisfactory for those who prefer deeper content. I really feel like it's a story that's all around me. It makes me feel warm and fuzzy at the end!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

好きが溢れ過ぎたら

If there are too many likes

好きが、いっぱい募ると不安もいっぱいになる。好きだから些細なことが不満になる。好きだから、イロイロ考え想う。長い時間を共に生きるって、こんなものかなと思える作品でした。

When you recruit a lot of likes, anxiety also fills up. I like it, so I'm dissatisfied with trivial things. I like it, so I think about Iloilo. It was a work that made me think it would be like to live together for a long time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 07, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かったです

That was interesting

長くつきあっているとこうゆう事もあるよな~って感じるお話でわりとサラッと読めちゃいますが読みやすく面白かったです。

It's a story that feels like this happens when you've been in a relationship for a long time, and it's pretty easy to read, but it was fun and easy to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 28, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

別れから。。

From parting ways..

This review contains spoilers. 別れから始まるストーリーが斬新で新鮮。そして慣れた頃って甘えもあってだんだんすれ違ってしまうんですよね。そこらへんがリアルで切なかったです。

This review contains spoilers. The story that begins with a break up is novel and fresh. Also, when you get used to it, they are spoiled, so you gradually pass by each other. It was sad because everything was real.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 07, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

言葉にして伝える事。

Convey it in words.

This review contains spoilers. 読み終えて、言わなくても伝わる。わけはなく、コミュニケーションとる努力が必要だなと、改めて思う。尽は、取る前に放棄したけど、マイペースな桐生の方が、歩み寄って良かった。

This review contains spoilers. I've finished reading it, and it can be conveyed even if I don't say it. There's no reason, and I think again that an effort to communicate is necessary. I gave up on it before I took it, but I'm glad Kiryu, who is self-paced, came close by.

Helpful

Reviews for Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time Manga