Koimonogatari Manga Reviews (P.5)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 05, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

に、2巻じゃ終わらない・・だと・・

and if volume 2 doesn't end there...

2巻で終わるかと思ったら終わらなかった・・。ストーリーはかなりリアルに迫っていると思います。当事者でない自分は陰でこうやって萌え散らかすだけで終わりますが、当事者にとって葛藤や悩みはきっとずっと続くんだろうなと思ったらとても切ない。現実では犬や猫など動物と結婚した人さえいるので、好きな相手が同じ人間の同性なんてごく普通ではないかと思いますけどね私は(ｷﾘｯ

I thought it would end with volume 2, but it didn't end... I think the story is pretty realistic. I'm not involved, and it ends up just making a mess behind the scenes, but it's very sad for the parties involved to think that conflicts and worries will surely continue for a long time. In reality, there are people who even married animals such as dogs and cats, so I think it's quite normal for someone I like to be of the same sex as the same person (lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

リアルなお話です

It's a real story

This review contains spoilers. いつもbl読んでわきゅーんってしたりするけど、今回のお話はなんかほんとにリアルでした。凄く苦しかった。けど、ちゃんと味方になってくれる人たちもいて…自分自身のLGBTQについての考え方とかも色々考えさせられました。2巻最後でよーやく恋心きたか！？と思ったらまさかの後輩君からの告白！3巻どーなるんですか…気になりすぎます。土井と佐倉くんのいとこは100回心の中で殺しました←

This review contains spoilers. I read BL all the time, but this story was really real. It was really painful. However, there are also people who are on my side... It made me think a lot about my own way of thinking about LGBTQ. Has Koishin finally arrived at the end of volume 2!? When I thought about it, it came as a surprise confession from a junior! What's going to happen with volume 3... I'm too worried. Doi and Sakura-kun's cousin killed 100 times in their hearts ←

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ライトなようで、、、

It looks like a light...

This review contains spoilers. 田倉先生の作品が好きでこちらが気になったため購入しました。本作は田倉先生も仰っている通りゆっくりゆっくり恋が進んでいくお話でした。吉永くんの内心で、特に2巻は読んでいて胸が痛くなりました。唯司がどんどん吉永くんに肩入れしていっているのが伝わってきてこれが愛になっていくのかなと感じさせられました。今はまだビーエルと言うよりブロマンスと言う感じですが3巻で完結と言うことで3巻発売をこれからの2人の関係性に期待しながら待ちます。

This review contains spoilers. I liked Takura-sensei's work, and I was interested in this, so I bought it. As Takura sensei said, this was a story about love slowly progressing slowly. From Yoshinaga-kun's heart, my heart ached when I was reading volume 2 in particular. It was conveyed that Yuiji was taking more and more shoulders with Yoshinaga-kun, and it made me feel that this would become love. Right now, it's still more like a bromance than BL, but since it's completed in 3 volumes, I'm waiting for volume 3 to be released while expecting the relationship between the two in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 01, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

早く次がよみ

Read the next one soon

リアルにある思春期の悩みが性に関係ない無く書かれていて、それぞれの気持ちが凄くわかる内容で、感動しました。続きが早く出て欲しい

I was moved by the fact that real adolescent worries were written regardless of gender, and I was moved by the content that really understood each feeling. I want the continuation to come out soon

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 06, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

感動しました！！

I'm moved!!

人の気持ちを繊細に描いていて、読んでとても共感できて、あたたかくなれて、前向きになれました

It delicately depicts people's feelings, and I was able to sympathize with it very much when I read it, made me feel warm, and positive

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 03, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

リアルだと思う

I think it's real

This review contains spoilers. これはかなりリアルなお話だと思います。高校生にして既にマイノリティとして生きていくことの難しさにもがいている吉永くんだけど、理解してくれる友だちの大切さも描かれています。3巻ではこれから恋愛に発展していく様子が描かれるのかな。2巻までではまだ恋愛にはなってないけど、なんとなくそんな予感がする終わり方だったので3巻が楽しみです。ストーリー重視の方にオススメします。私は読んで良かったと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. I think this is a pretty real story. As a high school student, Yoshinaga-kun is already struggling with the difficulties of living as a minority, but it also depicts the importance of friends who understand him. I wonder if volume 3 will depict how it will develop into a love affair from now on. Up to volume 2, we haven't turned into a relationship yet, but I'm looking forward to volume 3 because it was a way of ending that kind of premonition. I recommend it to those who focus on the story. I thought I was glad I read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 27, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

丁寧なストーリー

A polite story

思春期ならではの真っ直ぐさや悩みとか丁寧に描かれていて引き込まれました。

I was drawn in by the careful depiction of the straights and worries unique to adolescence.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 03, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

まだラブじゃないけど

It's not love yet

This review contains spoilers. 今まで読んでいたBL作品は主人公の周りがBLを肯定してる世界観で繰り広げられていたのでこれは読んでみてビックリです。これがリアルな世界観なのかはわかりませんが不安定なハートの吉永くんが心配で心配で読み進む感じです。2巻ラストも続きが気になる終わりだったので次は楽しいことが増えるといいです！

This review contains spoilers. The BL works I've been reading until now unfold in a worldview where people around the main character affirm BL, so I was surprised to read this. I don't know if this is a realistic view of the world, but it feels like Yoshinaga-kun, who has an unstable heart, is worried and reads on. I was worried about the continuation at the end of volume 2, so I hope there will be more fun things next time!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

これは

This

すごいなんかズドンってくる。読んだことないよ。この感じは。うっかり表紙で高校生のさわやかBLかなと思ってました。ジャンルのくくり、年代関係なしで魅了される作品じゃないかなと思います。

Something amazing is coming up. I haven't read it. this feeling. I inadvertently thought it was a refreshing BL for high school students on the cover. I think it's a work that fascinates people regardless of genre or age.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 16, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

良いです！

That's good!

BLですが、今の所エッチぽいのはなしです。でも、それでも大満足なお話です。男子高校生が、自分の性癖に向かい合って周りの助けもあって成長していくお話ですが、リアルにありえる話しで読んでて切なくなりました。2巻で嫌な奴が出てきてイライラしました。完結ではないので、早く3巻が読みたいです。

It's BL, but nothing is naughty so far. But it's still a very satisfying story. It's a story about a male high school student confronting his own proclivities and growing up with help from those around him, but I was sad to read it because it was a realistic story. I was frustrated when someone I didn't like came up in volume 2. It's not complete, so I want to read volume 3 as soon as possible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 14, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

心理描写が素敵です

The psychological depiction is wonderful

This review contains spoilers. 未完結です（泣）マイノリティに悩む大和、偶然知ってしまったけど、ありのままの大和を受け入れる唯司。二人を取り巻く環境はとても温かい。そして、高校生ならではの悩み、現代的な『いじめ』。新キャラが2巻ラストにでてきて、どうなっていくのか…作者さま、ぜひとも続きを書いていただきたいです。どーなっちゃうのーーー。

This review contains spoilers. It's unfinished (crying) I learned about Yamato, which is suffering from minorities, by chance, but only accepts Yamato as it is. The environment surrounding them is very warm. Also, a problem unique to high school students, modern “bullying.” The new characters come out at the end of volume 2, and what will happen... I definitely want the author to continue writing. what's going to happen...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 01, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

そうだよね…

that's right...

This review contains spoilers. 読む前は高校生同士の恋がいろいろありながらもサクッと上手くいくってお話なんだろうなぁと思っていました。でも、読んでみるとそんな単純な展開ではなかった！同性しか好きになれない生きづらさ、学校での周囲との関係性とかがなんともリアルで考えさせられる内容でしたし、むしろそれが新鮮でした。これからどうお話が進むのか楽しみにして待ちます。

This review contains spoilers. Before I read it, I was wondering if it was a story about how many types of love between high school students go well and quickly. But when I read it, it wasn't such a simple development! The content was so real and made me think about how difficult it is to live that only people of the same sex can like, and relationships with my surroundings at school, and it was rather refreshing. I'm looking forward to seeing how the story progresses from now on.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 28, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

物凄いイイ！　※未完のまま休載8年(泣)

Terribly good! ※Unfinished, suspended for 8 years (crying)

This review contains spoilers. と、いうか好みでした！あらすじ読まないで購入して読み始めたから、初っ端からあれ？って感じで想像とは違う感じに話が転んでビックリ(笑)でもこういうお話しって入り込む！BLというジャンルだけど、そうじゃないっていうか…裏表紙にも書いてあったけど、普通の高校生プラスその中に同性愛者がいるっていうお話しだから、男女の恋愛もあり、同性愛（ゲイ）の葛藤もあり、そして仲間との友情の大切さもあり、、、あぁもう深いというか人間模様を表してるし、学校という小さな空間だけどそれが全ての高校生達の動きがあるあるでリアルだった。今じゃメディアでは当たり前になってるけど、現実的に同性愛を受け入れる人ってやっぱ少ないのかなぁ～。自分が両性愛者だし、周りに同性愛者がいたし、BLは大好物だし、そういう環境が小学校から身近にあったからキモいと思う気持ちが全然分かんないけど、少しでも生きやすい世界になったらいいなぁと思う。と、いうか！まだまだ続くのですね！早く３巻発売されないかなぁー！待ち遠しいーーー！！！追加もう3巻発売を待って8年、、、まだ続きがない(泣)のみ×しばも休載してるし、作者様が長期お休み中みたいですね。3巻完結予定って1巻時に書いてあったのでずっとずっと楽しみに待っているのですが、悲しい、、、(泣)作者様はお元気なのでしょうか、、、

This review contains spoilers. I mean, I liked it! I didn't read the synopsis, I bought it and started reading it, so right from the beginning? I was surprised that the story turned in a different way than I had imagined (lol), but this kind of story got in! It's a BL genre, but that's not the case... it was also written on the back cover, but since it's a story about normal high school students plus there are homosexuals in it, there is also romance between men and women, there is also homosexual (gay) conflict, and there is also the importance of friendship with peers... ah, it's already deep, or rather shows a human pattern, and it's a small space called school, so it was real. It's now commonplace in the media, but I wonder if few people realistically accept homosexuality after all. I'm bisexual, I have homosexuals around me, BL is my favorite food, and since I've been close to that kind of environment since elementary school, I don't understand the feeling of feeling gross at all, but I think it would be nice if the world became even a little easier to live in. I mean! It's still going on! I wonder if volume 3 will be released soon! I can't wait!!! It's been 8 years since I've been waiting for 3 additional volumes to be released... there's still no continuation (crying), and it looks like the author has been on hiatus for a long time. The schedule for volume 3 to be completed was written at volume 1, so I've been looking forward to it all this time, but sad... (crying) I wonder if the author is doing well...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 25, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

青春そして良き友

Youth and good friends

のみ×しばが大好きで、こちらも買ってみました！現実こーゆう高校生がいるんじゃないかと思いますってくらいスーッと馴染むお話しです。うん、実際いると思いますね、でも周りはこんな理解者ばかりじゃないんじゃないかなぁと、考えさせられる作品です。まだ１巻なのでどーなっていくのか続きが楽しみです♡

I love Nomi x Shiba, and I bought this one too! It's such a familiar story that I think there are high school students in reality. Yes, I think they actually exist, but it's a work that makes me think that not all people around me understand this. It's still volume 1, so I'm looking forward to seeing what happens ♡

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

まさかの重森が

What happened to Shigemori

全然出てこないのに、たった2ページ？に心掴まれちゃった。すごい人だ！と。お話は高校生の友情と葛藤で、心理描写がとても上手く描かれていて、こんな高校時代を過ごせたら、こんな友達がいてくれるなら、人生救われる人がたくさんいるんだろうな、BLとしてだけでなく、人生の勉強になったような。ん十年前に高校生だったけど、一言一言にはっとさせられる作品。続きが楽しみです

Even though it doesn't come up at all, only 2 pages? I was taken by my heart. He's an amazing person! and. The story is about the friendship and conflict of high school students, and the psychological depiction is very well drawn, and if I could spend my high school days like this, if I had friends like this, there would probably be a lot of people who could save my life, not only as a BL, but also as a study for life. Hmm, I was in high school ten years ago, but it's a work that amazes me with every word. I'm looking forward to the continuation

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

今までに無い感じ

A feeling like never before

This review contains spoilers. アオハルな感じの友人から恋人へ…かと思いきやそうでもない？！先が読めるような読めないような?早く続きが読みたいけど、2巻が出たのが１巻から3年⁈そして2巻が2018年に出てるけど、3巻はいつかなぁ楽しみに待つしか無いかな?

This review contains spoilers. I thought it was going from being an Aoharu friend to a lover... but isn't it?! like you can read ahead like you can't read? I want to read the continuation soon, but volume 2 came out 3 years after volume 1 and volume 2 came out in 2018, but I wonder when volume 3 will be and look forward to it?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

現実っぽいかなぁー

I wonder if it's realistic

久しぶりに現実味に溢れるBLでした。表紙絵で勝手にイメージしてた学園BLとは違って良い意味で期待を裏切ってくれたお話でした。甘いだけのお話ではないです。けど周りの友達が、凄い良い人ばかりで、心が救われる思いでした。ただ大和君の不器用さは、愛しさが込み上げました。彼の幸せを願わずにはいられないです。

It was the first BL full of reality in a long time. It was a story that disappointed my expectations in a good sense, unlike the school BL I had imagined on the cover picture. It's not just a sweet story. However, all of my friends around me were really nice people, and I felt that my heart was saved. However, Yamato's clumsiness was filled with love. I can't help but wish him happiness.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが読みたい

I want to read more

登場人物それぞれの心の葛藤が繊細に描かれていて、感情を揺さぶられます。恋愛だけじゃなく、友情や家族全てにおいて、人が人を大事に思うことに涙してしまいました。

The emotional conflicts of each character are delicately depicted, and their emotions are shaken. It made me cry that people care about people not only in love, but in all of their friendships and families.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

どんな結末になるのか

What kind of ending will it be

これは何回も読み返してますゆうじと結ばれて欲しいのですが、これは全くラストが読めないー B Lならではの、様々な心情が描かれています。エチもキスもないけど本当にオススメしますーこのなんとも言えない感情、そう沢山の作品では味わえない。私は次が気になって仕方のない作品が、自分の本当に求めてるストーリーなのかなって、漫画の惹かれる一部…っというか。当たり前なんだけど、何言ってるからよくわからないんだけど^_^;そう何も進んでないような2人だけど、かなり変化してます！同性を好きになると言うこと、好きって言うこと…じれったい恋模様ー！はよ次〜(*´∇｀*)

I've reread this over and over again and I want it to tie in with Yuji, but I can't read the last one at all — it depicts various feelings unique to BL. There's no etiquette or kiss, but I really recommend it — I can't enjoy this indescribable emotion in so many works. I wonder if the next work I can't help but wonder if it's the story I'm really looking for, and it's a part of comics that I'm attracted to... Of course, I'm not sure because of what they're saying ^_^; they're two people who don't seem to have progressed at all, but they've changed quite a bit! Saying that you fall in love with the same sex, saying you like them... it's a secret love pattern! Haya next~ (*'｀*)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

This review contains spoilers. 高校生の恋愛物語だと思い購入しました。が、、良い意味で裏切られました。登場人物ほんとにほぼ良い人たちばっかり。心の葛藤も細かく書かれていて、人の心情ってほんとそんな感じなんだろうなと。ただ、土井にはすごく腹がたちました。が、現実にもやっぱり居るんだろうなと思ったら悲しくなったり、、エロいシーンはないので、そういうのを求めてる方にはおすすめしないですが、、すごくおすすめなマンガです。

This review contains spoilers. I bought it because I thought it was a high school romance story. But I was betrayed in a good way. The characters are almost all really nice people. The conflict of hearts is also written in detail, and I wonder if people really feel like that. However, I was really angry at Doi. However, it makes me sad when I think that they actually exist... there are no erotic scenes, so I don't recommend it to those looking for that kind of thing, but it's a highly recommended manga.

Helpful

Reviews for Koimonogatari Manga