Prince-Turned-Idol & the Knight Who Stans Him Manga Reviews (P.4)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ジャケ買いでした

I bought a jacket

This review contains spoilers. あまりにも美しかったので～本編の洸くんはもう少し幼い感じがしましたが。表紙はどちらかと言うと前世のフィンリー様に近いような。それにしても、ウィリアム１回目の転生が四ツ葉のクローバーて！めちゃくちゃ笑いました。あと、グッズの値段がいちいち書いてあることにも。前世叶わなかった想いが叶って、洸くんが意外と積極的なのが良い。前世は相当我慢してたんだな…輔と圭太くんも何やら…な感じだし、圭太くんはおっとりしてるけど堅実に夢を実現しそうな強さを感じる！まだまだデュマから目が離せません！

This review contains spoilers. It was so beautiful... I felt like Hiro-kun in the main story was a little younger. The cover is rather close to Finley from his previous life. Even so, William's first reincarnation was Yotsuba Clover! I laughed insanely. Also, the price of the goods is written one by one. Feelings that didn't come true in previous lives have come true, and it's good that Hiro-kun is surprisingly aggressive. They put up with it quite a bit in their previous lives... it feels like Suke and Keita-kun are doing something... and even though Keita-kun is easygoing, I feel strong enough to steadily make his dreams come true! I still can't take my eyes off Dumas!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

優しい転生

A gentle reincarnation

This review contains spoilers. 追いかけて追いかけて何度も入れ違いのような転生を繰り返し、ようやく同じ時代に人間として出会い、アイドルオタからマネージャーになってしまう本庄さんの行動力と愛が深い！祖父と孫の転生の最期のくだりは涙ものでした。柔らかく優しい絵柄とお話がマッチしていてとても好きなお話です?

This review contains spoilers. Mr. Honjo, who chased after and repeated reincarnations as if they were mistaken over and over again, finally met as a human in the same era, and went from being an idol otaku to a manager, has a deep sense of action and love! The final story of my grandfather and grandson's reincarnation was tearful. It's a story you really like because the soft and gentle design matches the story?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

電子コミック大賞2025

eComic Awards 2025

This review contains spoilers. ＢＬ部門にノミネート中間発表の上位５作品に入っていた作品で私は別の作品に投票済みでして表紙の絵は大変美しいけど王子様すぎて好みじゃないと決めつけて読んでませんでしたが、上位に入った作品で唯一読んでなかったので試しに読んで見ようと・・・・はい、ぴったりハマりました笑

This review contains spoilers. It's a work that was in the top 5 works nominated for the BL category, and I've already voted for another work, and the picture on the cover was so beautiful, but I decided that I didn't like it and didn't read it, but it was the only work that came in the top and didn't read it, so I tried reading it... yes, I was totally addicted to it lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

微笑ましい

Smiling

時を超える忠誠心が半端ないwww 攻めがドルオタからマネージャーになっていく行動力と、アイドルらしからぬ受けの純粋さがとにかくピュアで見守りたくなる2人でした！！

They were two people whose loyalty transcends time is endless, and their ability to act and change from Dorota to manager, and the purity of reception, which is not typical of idols, just made me want to watch over them!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 04, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

前世の

Of a previous life

This review contains spoilers. ウィリアムとフィンリーが、悲しい別れをしたので、今世の生まれ変わりのシチュエーションが絶妙でした。王子様が、今世ではアイドルでキラキラしていて、ピッタリな感じに私もファンになってしまいました。イラストが、とても美しくて爽やかでした。

This review contains spoilers. William and Finley had a sad break up, so the situation of their reincarnation in this world was exquisite. The prince is sparkling as an idol in this world, and I have become a fan because of the perfect feeling. The illustrations were so beautiful and refreshing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 04, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

This review contains spoilers. あの頃から両片想いだったのに伝える機会がなかったのが寂しいね…。でも今世で巡り会えて良かったです！続きも楽しみにしてます！

This review contains spoilers. I'm sad that I haven't had a chance to tell them even though I've had an unrequited love between them since that time... But I'm glad we met in this world! I'm looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

何度生まれ変わっても貴方を守る！

I will protect you no matter how many times you are reborn!

This review contains spoilers. 貴生の、何度も転生して（人間以外のものにも！）そのたびに必ず洸の側に付き従って見守っていたというのが第一話冒頭で超超ダイジェスト描写でありましたが、もうあそこで私は心を掴まれました！まさにこれこそが騎士！洸も、途中まで天然ぽやぽやな可愛いアイドルかと思っていましたが、まさかまさかの、貴生よりもずっと大胆でちゃんとしっかりした王子でした！ユニットの他の2人もとっても良い子で、箱推ししたいです。1巻の最後で気持ちを伝え合い、2巻の最後でようやく初えっちですがあまりに2人のやりとりが尊いので全然「遅い」とは思いませんでした。3巻は陽くんが何か波乱を巻き起こす予感？早く続きを読みたいです！

This review contains spoilers. Takao's reincarnated over and over again (even to something other than a human!) It was depicted in Super Super Digest at the beginning of the first episode that they always followed Hikaru's side and watched over there, but that already captured my heart! Exactly, this is the knight! I also thought Ko was a naturally sweet and cute idol until halfway through, but no way, he was a much bolder and more solid prince than Takao! The other 2 people in the unit are also very nice kids, and I want to recommend the box. They shared their feelings at the end of volume 1, and it was finally their first time at the end of volume 2, but since the exchange between the two was so precious, I didn't think it was “slow” at all. Do you have a feeling that Yo-kun will cause some turbulence in volume 3? I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

笑えるけどキュンもある

It's funny, but there's also Kyun

1巻のみ読了。貴生のオタクぶりに笑わされたけどちゃんとキュンとするところもあるし洸も可愛いし。2巻も楽しみ。

I've only read volume 1. Takao made me laugh at me for the first time as an otaku, but there are places where I get really excited, and Ko is cute too. I'm also looking forward to volume 2.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

前前前前世

Previous Previous Life

転生ものBLはそこまで好きじゃないけど、これは好き。絵も綺麗、登場人物が優しい。可愛いいい設定が面白い。見守り具合がすごい。早く2巻読みたいです！少し我慢中です。コミック大賞3割引クーポン対象。

I don't like Reincarnation BL that much, but I like this one. The pictures are beautiful, and the characters are kind. The cute and nice setting is interesting. The way they are watching is amazing. I want to read volume 2 soon! I'm putting up with it for a bit. Eligible for the Comic Award 3 discount coupon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

絵とストーリーが最高に合ってます

The picture and story are a perfect match

転生するストーリーの中で、優しくて、素直でハッピーなんじゃないかと思うくらい癒やされます。話と話の間の小さくて可愛らしい絵も癒やされますし、ずっと、癒やされ続けていたいです。

In the story of reincarnation, I am so healed that I think they are kind, honest, and happy. The small, cute pictures between the stories are also soothing, and I want to continue to be healed for a long time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ドル活BL

Dollar Katsu BL

This review contains spoilers. ドル活したオタクがまさかの転生騎士という事態には驚きと推しの子のご得な転生展開なので流行りなのかなと思われます。生みの親はアイドルではなく普通の親なのですがギフテッドのごとく知識無双をしていて耳年増なので菊一文字宗春をもって刺し貫かれます。

This review contains spoilers. I was surprised by the situation where the otaku who made use of the dollar was suddenly a reincarnation knight, and I think it's popular because it's a bargain reincarnation development for recommended children. The creator is not an idol, but a normal parent, but like Gifted, they have no equal knowledge and are getting old, so they are stabbed through with Kikuichimonji Muneharu.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ストーリーがおもしろい

The story is interesting

This review contains spoilers. BL読まない方なのですが、これは覗き見してみたらストーリーが面白くてハマってしまいました！元騎士さまの転生ストーリーがめっちゃ面白い。四葉のクローバーは笑いました。笑BLだけどドロドロしてなくておすすめです。エロなくても全然いい！

This review contains spoilers. I don't read BL, but when I took a peek at this, the story was so interesting that I was addicted to it! The reincarnation story of a former knight is really interesting. The four-leaf clover laughed. lol it's BL but it's not muddy and I recommend it. It's totally fine even if it's not erotic!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

キュンすぎ

Kyunsugi

This review contains spoilers. 前世がある設定とか関係性に深みが出て大好きなのですが、しっかりとそこにフィーチャーしていて変化する関係性がすごく丁寧に描かれていて素敵でした?（一巻エロなしOKした編集部と物語としてプラスとなる判断した先生がすごい！）流転してようやく互いのもとへ辿り着いた二人を全力で応援します！！！！

This review contains spoilers. I love it because the depth of settings and relationships in previous lives comes out, but it was wonderful that the relationships that were firmly featured there and that changed were drawn so carefully? (The editorial department that was OK with no eroticism in volume one and the teacher who decided it would be a plus for the story are amazing!) I will do my best to support these two people who have gone out of their way and finally made it to each other!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

転生を繰り返し

Repeated reincarnation

This review contains spoilers. 今生で結ばれる二人。王子フィンリーを守れなかった騎士のウィリアム。その記憶をもったままリーマンとして生きている貴生。推しアイドルの洸がフィンリーと気づき、今度こそは守ると誓い、マネージャーに。お互い秘めた想いがあったのに、伝えられず死別。だからこそ、想いが通じ合い、体をつなげたときの涙がぐっときました。それにしても、洸の積極的なところがかわいい。なんとか自分をおさえて、アイドルに負担をかけないようにしている貴生が今生でも騎士にみえます。続きが早く読みたい作品です。

This review contains spoilers. Two people united in this life. William is a knight who couldn't protect Prince Finley. Takao lives as Lehman with that memory. The recommended idol Hikari noticed Finley, vowed to protect him this time, and became the manager. Even though they had hidden feelings for each other, they couldn't be conveyed and they were widowed. That's why my feelings came through, and my tears filled me so much when we connected our bodies. Even so, Kou's aggressive side is cute. Takao, who has managed to hold back himself and not put a burden on his idols, looks like a knight even in this life. The continuation is a work I want to read as soon as possible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

冒頭、腹痛い（笑）

At the beginning, my stomach hurts (laughs)

This review contains spoilers. えー、最初何が起きているのかちょっと分かりませんでした！だって…転生先が四葉のクローバーって！意識のある四葉のクローバーってやだなぁ（笑）後、圭太のツッコミがいちいちツボ（笑）もう（笑）が止まりませんでした！そこだけでも読む価値ありますが、真骨頂はその後のお話です！一途な本庄がとてもよかったです！（おまけみたいな感想になっちゃった！(ﾟ´Д｀ﾟ）

This review contains spoilers. Well, I had no idea what was going on at first! Because... the place of reincarnation is a four-leaf clover! After that, I don't like four-leaf clovers when I'm conscious (lol), Keita's tsukkomi had pressure points one by one (lol) and couldn't stop (lol)! That alone is worth reading, but the real truth is what comes after that! Hitotsuna Honjo was very nice! (I had the impression that it was a bonus! ('｀°)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

輪廻転生、深い愛！

Reincarnation, deep love!

何度生まれ変わってもそばにいる！的な深い愛情がベースにある輪廻転生ストーリーです。絵が綺麗で感情も丁寧に描かれているので、とても読みやすい。1巻はキス止まりなので、ぜひ2巻までは読んでもらいたいところ。さらにお話は続くので、続巻も楽しみにしています。

No matter how many times you're reborn, they'll be there for you! It's a reincarnation story based on a deep love like that. The pictures are beautiful and the emotions are carefully drawn, so it's very easy to read. Volume 1 stops kissing, so I definitely want you to read up to volume 2. Furthermore, the story continues, so I'm looking forward to the next volume.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

異色の転生もの

A different kind of reincarnation

騎士と王子が転生して、ドルヲタとアイドルになってる設定からしてまず面白い！転生前の2人の関係があまりにも切ないので今世では幸せになってほしい気持ちでいっぱいです。ゆっくり深めていく関係がとてもよいです。

First of all, it's interesting starting from the setting where the knight and prince are reincarnated and become Dorota and idols! The relationship between the two before their reincarnation was so painful, so I'm filled with the feeling that I want them to be happy in this life. A relationship that slowly deepens is very good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

待望の続刊です。

This is the long-awaited sequel.

進展したよー。よかったよー。長い間の両片想いがやっと実った。でもやっぱり、真面目な騎士でちゃうよね。新キャラ登場も気になるし、続くそうなので楽しみ。

progress has been made. That was great. The long-standing love between them has finally come to fruition. But after all, he's a serious knight, isn't he? I'm also worried about new characters appearing, and it seems like they'll continue, so I'm looking forward to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった～?

that was good~?

ストーリーも、絵も、とってもキレイで、見やすくて良かったです。(ﾉ≧▽≦)ﾉ続きが、気になりすぎます。(*≧ω≦)

I'm glad that the story and pictures were so beautiful and easy to read. () 〇 I'm too worried about the continuation. (*≥ω≤)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ほわほわ〜

Whoa whoa

たまにはね、ほんかわなお話を欲していたのでしょうね。染み渡りました。すごい吸収力でした。心が満たされてます。ゴロンゴロンしちゃいました。とはいえ、前世関係やらアイドルですからねーハラハラと続きが気になるのです。

Once in a while, they probably wanted a real story. It has seeped in. It was a great absorbent. My heart is satisfied. It made me go on and on. Nonetheless, I'm worried about past life relationships and the continuation since they're idols.

Helpful

Reviews for Prince-Turned-Idol & the Knight Who Stans Him Manga