Prince-Turned-Idol & the Knight Who Stans Him Manga Reviews (P.11)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

前世からやっとお互いに気持ちが通じ合う！

Our feelings for each other have finally come through with each other since our previous lives!

This review contains spoilers. 転生を何度もして、出会えるけど…なんか残念な感じからの…が面白かったです！今世ではお互いに前世の記憶あってよいタイミングで会えたので、サラッとくっついた感じはしたのですが、転生した回数からしたら全然サラッとじゃないから笑！やっと気持ちをお互いに伝えあえる感じが良かったです！1巻あまりにも純粋な感じだったので、まだ2巻に手を出せてないです…。

This review contains spoilers. I've been reincarnated so many times, and it was interesting that we met... but it was kind of disappointing...! In this life, we both had memories of our previous lives and we were able to meet at a good timing, so we felt like we stuck together smoothly, but based on how many times we've been reincarnated, it's not smooth at all lol! It was nice to finally be able to share our feelings with each other! Volume 1 felt so pure that I haven't been able to get my hands on volume 2 yet...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

面白い！クスッと笑える小ネタがいっぱい。そして、なんだか気持ちが暖かくなる優しい気持ちもいっぱい。みんなが思いやりがあっていい！

interesting! There are so many small stories that make me laugh. Also, there are plenty of gentle feelings that somehow make me feel warm. Everyone can be compassionate!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

優しいストーリーで安心して読める

A gentle story that you can read with peace of mind

二巻まで読みました。二巻は両思いになってからのストーリーなので、ヤキモキすることなくアマーいふたりの様子が描かれているように思いました。前世で関わった不明の現世キャラが出てきて興味深いです。

I've read up to 2 volumes. Volume 2 is the story after they have both fallen in love, so I thought it depicts two amorous people without feeling agitated. It's interesting that unknown real-life characters who were involved in previous lives have appeared.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

推せる

I can recommend

いや、オモシロイですよ。何度生まれ変わっても側にいて見守ってる騎士と前世の記憶が目覚めてない王子の今後が気になります。

No, it's funny. I'm worried about the future of the knight who is by my side and watching no matter how many times I've been reborn, and the prince, whose memories of his previous life haven't woken up.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 23, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

忠誠っぷり

Loyal

騎士の忠誠っぷりがよき。一話にあった転生の繰り返しが可愛すぎて購入を即決。ストーリーも間違いないし主役の2人が可愛くていいところしかなかった

A knight's loyalty is good. The repetition of reincarnation in episode 1 was so cute that I decided to buy it right away. There's no doubt about the story, and there were only nice places where the 2 leading actors were cute

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 23, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

転生を重ねて

Reincarnation over and over

This review contains spoilers. 守りきれなかった王子を想い転生を繰り返す元騎士。王子もまた、騎士と接点を持ちながらより近しい関係へと何度も転生し、元王子がアイドルで元騎士がドルオタというのが面白い。元騎士が一生懸命でほっこり笑えるところも。マネージャーへと転身した元騎士と元王子アイドルが恋人同士に。最初の出逢いから永い時を経て転生を繰り返し繋がっていた二人が晴れて恋人同士となるのは格別の感がある。気になる人物も出て来て転生を繰り返した二人のこれからが興味深い。

This review contains spoilers. A former knight who repeatedly reincarnates in love with a prince he couldn't protect. The prince also reincarnated many times into a closer relationship while having a point of contact with the knight, and it's interesting that the former prince is an idol and the former knight is a dorota. There are also places where former knights work so hard that I can laugh heartily. A former knight turned manager and a former prince idol become lovers. There is a special feeling that the two, who have been repeatedly connected to reincarnation after a long time since their first encounter, have settled down and become lovers. The future of these two people who have repeatedly been reincarnated is interesting because people they are interested in have also appeared.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

転生先のフィンリー様

The reincarnated Finley

This review contains spoilers. “転生先のフィンリー様”という言葉が気に入りました。“桃から生まれた桃太郎”のような感じです笑主人公は転生先のフィンリー様と会うと前世を思い出すということですが、思い出すのはフィンリー様と過ごした人生だけなんですよね、たぶん。犬と飼い主時代、おじいちゃんと孫時代などは思い出さない、消えて行った記憶…ということですよね。それはちょっともったいない気もしますね。めちゃめちゃ何度も一緒に過ごしたのに。前世とか再生とか好きなのでときめき、感動したのですが、アイドルとファンのときがピークでした。マネージャーになってからは一挙にときめき下降しました。アイドルとファンという、距離のある関係の方が私は夢があって好きです。アイドルとマネージャーでは現実的過ぎて、ただの人と人なので。生まれ変わりとか関係なく、一挙に普通のBLになっちゃったな〜という感じで残念です。フィンリー様時代の恋愛や、アイドルとファン時代の恋愛が見たいです。

This review contains spoilers. I like the phrase “the place where I was reincarnated, Mr. Finley.” It's like “Momotaro Born from Momo” lol It is said that the main character remembers his previous life when he meets Mr. Finley, where he was reincarnated, but the only thing he remembers is probably the life he spent with Finley. You mean memories that have disappeared without remembering the days of dogs and owners, grandpa and grandchildren, etc. I also feel like that's a bit wasteful. Even though we spent so many times together. I like previous lives and replays, so I was thrilled and moved, but my peak was when I was an idol and fan. Once I became a manager, my excitement went downhill all at once. I like the relationships between idols and fans that have a distance because they have dreams. It's too realistic for idols and managers; they're just people and people. It's a pity that it felt like it became a normal BL all at once, regardless of reincarnation or anything. I want to see the romance in the time of Finley and the romance between idols and fans.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 09, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ほぉ～

wow

プッシュ作品だったので読んでみたんですが、作者さんの一言読んでみて、『確かに❗』と。凄い眼がキラキラ?アイドルっぽい❗ってか、前世？前前世？面白そうな展開だなぁ。あと、カオナシに変身してしまった主人公(笑)ちょっとした一コマだったけどちょっと笑えた。

It was a push work, so I read it, but I read a word from the author and said, “Certainly ❗.” are your amazing eyes twinkling? Like an idol ❗, a previous life? previous life? That sounds like an interesting development. Also, the main character who has transformed into a Kaonashi (laughs) It was just a small scene, but it made me laugh a little bit.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

今世で推しを護り抜きます

I will defend my best in this world

転生を繰り返し、現在は会社員として元騎士の貴生。偶然アイドルとして活躍している洸が前世で護り切れなかった王子の生まれ変わりだと知って、今世では絶対に守り切ることを誓い彼の推しになる。より近くで護るために洸のマネージャーになった貴生。洸が自分にだけ見せる笑顔に、忠誠心以上の想いが募っていって……。

Takao has been reincarnated repeatedly and is now a former knight as an office worker. By chance, I learned that Ko, who is active as an idol, is the reincarnation of a prince he couldn't protect in his previous life, and I swear that I will definitely protect him in this life, and I recommend him. Takao became Hikari's manager in order to protect him more closely. Feelings that go beyond loyalty are raised in the smile that Ko shows only to himself...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

2人のペース

Pace for 2

転生前は王子&騎士、現代はアイドルなのにキラキラ感は少なかったです。恋愛も進みが遅くほっこり…という感じ？ほのぼのとしたのは良かった。

Before I was reincarnated, I was a prince and knight, and today I'm an idol, but there wasn't much sparkle. Love is progressing slowly and you feel relaxed...? It was nice that it was heartwarming.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

読みやすい

readable

転生して異世界ではなくて、転生して現代のアイドルとドルオタって設定が、まず面白いですよね。チロッと入ってくるコメディ要素が、何か雰囲気を良くしてくれます。読みやすくて良かったです。

First of all, the setting of reincarnated and not in another world, reincarnated with a modern idol and Dorota is interesting, isn't it? The comedic elements that come in quickly improve the atmosphere. It was nice that it was easy to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

まだまだ距離がもどかしい…

The distance is still frustrating...

This review contains spoilers. 後書きに作者様が記載されていたように、圧倒的進展までジリジリ待つことになります…もう少し転生前の2人の恋愛的要素とかあったら理解深まるな〜とは思ったものの、かわいい2人なのでまあ良し

This review contains spoilers. As the author was described in the afterword, we'll have to wait a long time until overwhelming progress... I thought my understanding would be deepened if there were a few more romantic elements of the two before their reincarnation, but they're cute, so that's fine

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

あんまりアイドルとか興味なくいままでスルーしてきましたが、おもしろかったです。まあ、アイドルなんで絵がキラキラしていてイケメン見ているだけで癒されました。BLですが転生もの。BLって懐深いなあ。

I'm not really interested in idols and I've been through until now, but it was interesting. Well, since they're idols, the pictures are sparkling, and I was healed just by looking at the handsome guy. It's BL, but it's reincarnation. BL is nostalgic.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 29, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

まだ

yet

1巻しか読んでませんが、思ってた以上に楽しく読めました。ラブコメ？な感じでテンポ良く話が進んで、あっという間に1冊終わりました。何度も転生するのに中々対等になれないじれったさは新しかった。ただ、続刊があるのに早々に想いが通じ合ったのは残念。もう少し引っ張って両片想いを見たかった感も。1巻はキス止まりなので、2巻に期待。早く購入したいです。

I've only read volume 1, but I enjoyed reading it more than I expected. romantic comedy? I felt like the story progressed at a good tempo, and I finished one book in no time. The feeling of not being able to be equal even though they have been reincarnated over and over again was new. However, it's a pity that our feelings quickly came through even though there was a sequel. I also felt like I wanted to pull it a little further and see the love between the two. Volume 1 stops kissing, so I'm looking forward to volume 2. I want to buy it soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 24, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ほのぼの

Heartwarming

2巻＋同人小話読了。マネージャー（転生騎士）×アイドル（転生王子）。ほのぼの？なので安心して読めます。

I've read volume 2+ doujinshi. Manager (Reincarnation Knight) x Idol (Reincarnation Prince). heartwarming? So you can read it without worry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

続き読みたい！！

I want to keep reading!!

前世騎士と王子輪廻転生もの。騎士の視点で描かれて行きます。目が覚めたら王子の側にいたものの最初は四葉のクローバから始まって動物、人間とゆっくり幾度の時代を経てようやく現代へ。この丁寧さが私は好きです。王子を認識すると前世の記憶が戻ってくる騎士（本庄）はエリート順風満帆な人生を過ごしつつも何か物足りない焦燥感を抱えていて、画面に映るアイドルユニットの洸君を目にして、記憶がよみがえり自分の描けていた部分をオタ活で補いますが、王子は暗殺された過去があるのでもっとそばで守りたいとマネージャーに。ここから二人が対面しやり取りがはじまるのですが。話の運び方とかテンポが良いので楽しめますし、輪廻ものなので情や心残りからの切なさがありました。涙2巻は読みたかったラブラブ編。かわいい❤❤❤SUYA～に////ニヤケーーでした。そして、いいところで！！！と言っても引っ張るような終わり方ではないのですが早くつづきが読みたいです。そして、初読みの先生です。表紙は何度か見かけていましたがアイドル＆オタものってことでスルーし続け、友人の勧めがきっかけで試し読み。即購入。タイトルが悪いよな、転生ものならもっとラノベみたいな感じのタイトルにすればよかったのでは？しかしながら、そのギャップで切ないシーンではより泣かされました。絵もとてもきれいで先生の他の作品も読んでみたいと思います。

A knight and a prince reincarnated in a previous life. It is drawn from a knight's point of view. When I woke up, I was on the prince's side, but it first started with a four-leaf clover, slowly passed through many eras with animals and humans, and finally moved to the present day. I like this politeness. The knight (Honjo), whose memories of his previous life come back when he recognizes the prince, has an unsatisfactory sense of impatience while living an elite smooth sailing life, and sees the idol unit Ko-kun reflected on the screen, his memory comes back to life, and he makes up for the part he was able to draw with otaku activities, but since the prince has a past where he has been assassinated, he tells his manager that he wants to protect him even more. This is where the two meet face to face and the exchange begins. The way the story unfolds and the tempo are good, so I can enjoy it, and since it's a reincarnation thing, there was a sense of sadness and remorse. Volume 2 of Tears is the lovey-dovey edition I wanted to read. It was cute ❤❤❤ SUYA~///grinning. And in a nice place!!! That said, it doesn't end in a way that pulls you down, but I want to read the continuation quickly. Also, I'm a first-time reading teacher. I had seen the cover a few times, but it kept going through because it was an idol and otaku, and I tried reading it on the recommendation of a friend. Buy it now. The title is bad, so if it's reincarnation, wouldn't it have been better if the title was more like a light novel? However, that gap made me cry even more in sad scenes. The pictures are also very beautiful and I would like to read the teacher's other works.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い転生

An interesting reincarnation

This review contains spoilers. めちゃくちゃ転生しまくりやん笑。その度に、いつかは、出会える。ゲド、王子様は覚えていないから、ちょっと寂しいですね。アイドルに王子様を発見、ドルオタからのマネージャー。めっちゃ近づけたゲド、なかなか〜。近くでみてるだけでも幸せ〜。伝わってきます。そしてついに恋人〜キャー。転生前の侍従関係だった事も〜。良かったねぇ。

This review contains spoilers. they're insanely reincarnating lol. Every time, one day, we'll meet. Ged, I don't remember Prince, so I'm a little lonely. A manager from Dorota who discovered Prince as an idol. Ged, who got so close, was pretty close. I'm happy just looking at it up close. It's coming through. And finally, sweetheart ~ Kyah. I also had a chamberlain relationship before I was reincarnated. that was great.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗

The picture is beautiful

美男子！眉目秀麗！眼福でした。過去世との繋がりがうまくできていて、しっかりストーリーが組み立てられています。

A beautiful man! Beautiful eyebrows! It was a blessing. The connections to past lives are well established, and the story is well structured.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

転生アイドルもの！

Reincarnation idol stuff!

This review contains spoilers. 前世で王子に支えていた騎士が、今世でアイドルをしている転生した主を見つけ、ドルオタになるという珍しい設定です。えぴも面白いし、王子の目もキラキラしてて綺麗でずっと読めてしまいそう！

This review contains spoilers. It's a rare setting where a knight who was supported by a prince in his previous life finds a reincarnated lord who is an idol in this life and becomes a dorota. Epi is also interesting, and the prince's eyes are sparkling and beautiful, and it seems like I can read it the whole time!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 28, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

1巻読んで。

Read volume 1.

This review contains spoilers. 転生作品ですが転生してるキャラみんな前世を覚えてるという珍しい展開。ずっと守るという強い意志がオタクと共存しちゃってるのがクスっと笑えておもしろかったです。まだ2人やっとくっついたところでえち展開は2巻なのかな？機会があったら読んでみたい。

This review contains spoilers. It's a reincarnation film, but it's a rare development where all the characters who have been reincarnated remember their previous lives. The fact that the strong will to protect coexists with otaku all the time was laughable and interesting. I wonder if the two of them are still in volume 2 when they finally stick together? I'd like to read it if I get a chance.

Helpful

Reviews for Prince-Turned-Idol & the Knight Who Stans Him Manga