Broken Betrothal: My Beloved Was Bewitched Manga Reviews (P.5)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

おなじ気持ち

The same feeling

絵柄ストーリーともに大変良いです。下手に捻らずまっすぐ気持ちが良いです。メイドさんの独白が1巻の最後にありますが同じ気持ちです。

Both the design and story are very good. It feels good straight without twisting poorly. The Maid's Monologue is at the end of volume 1, and I feel the same.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

これは

This

This review contains spoilers. 魅力の魔法というか、あの父親のせいだよねー！！早くギャフンと言わせてほしいです！主人公は可愛らしくて真っすぐで、幸せになって欲しいです！殿下の最後の言葉が気になります！！

This review contains spoilers. The magic of charm is probably because of that father!! I want them to say Gafn soon! The main character is cute and straight, and I want her to be happy! I'm curious about His Highness's last words!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

キュンキュンドキドキ

Kyun Kyun Doki Doki

This review contains spoilers. pixivから見てましたが、絵からもうすきで惹かれて、ストーリーと絵が絶妙にマッチ！！お金出して保管していたいくらいで購入。別ＢＬかかれてる漫画家さんだからのエロさと美しさなのか本当に素敵だと私は思っています！シエナのいい子さと、王子の隠している事もはやく明らかにしてほしい〜！親友キャラもいいけど、サリーめっちゃ好き！あとがきの次男坊が扱い口調最高（笑）はやく続きが楽しみです!

This review contains spoilers. I was watching it on pixiv, and I was drawn to the picture because I liked it, and the story and picture matched perfectly!! I bought it because I wanted to pay money and keep it. It's a manga artist with a separate BL, so I think it's really wonderful, probably because of its eroticism and beauty! I want them to quickly reveal how good Sienna is and what the prince is hiding! My best friend character is good too, but I really like Sally! The second son in the afterword was handled in a great tone (laughs) and I'm looking forward to the continuation soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

王子の熱愛がひしひし感じれます

I can really feel the prince's love

This review contains spoilers. 買って正解でした。他の方も書いているように、3人に幸せになって欲しいと思うストーリーです。王子はヒロインへの愛が強いからたぶん魔法にかかってなくてヒロインも婚約破棄されても王子を信じて待っているのかな？魔法で操る娘は生きるために悪い父親の操り人形になってしまいこの娘もかわいそうな娘だと思います。最後はこの娘は下男と一緒に母親のもとへ戻れて、王子とヒロインはハッピーエンドになれるんだろうと信じなから２巻の発売を待っています。

This review contains spoilers. I bought it and it was the right answer. As others have written, this is a story where I want 3 people to be happy. The prince has a strong love for the heroine, so it's probably not enchanted, and the heroine believes in the prince and waits even if her engagement is annulled? A daughter manipulated by magic becomes a puppet of a bad father in order to live, and I think this girl is also a poor girl. At the end, this daughter was able to return to her mother with her younger son, and the prince and heroine are waiting for volume 2 to be released because they believe they will have a happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ドキドキ！

It's exciting!

王子が策士っぽくてかっこいい！ヒロインも健気で芯があって良い子！応援したくなるー！敵役の令嬢も憎めなくて、幸せになってほしい！キャラクターの関係が複雑で、ドキドキしました〜！

The prince looks like a schemer and is so cool! The heroine is also a good girl who is healthy and has a strong heart! I want to cheer! I don't hate my enemy daughter, and I want her to be happy! The relationships between the characters were complicated, and it was exciting!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

気になる…！！！

I'm curious...!!!

This review contains spoilers. まず絵が綺麗で大優勝?続きがめっちゃ気になるーーー！メインキャラ全員が幸せになってほしい！ヒロインの優しさと賢さが本当素敵です?ヒーローの色々含んだ動きもヒロインだから気づける絆みたいなの見せつけられますが、はよ解決して幸せになってくれぇって思います☘そして悪役も救ってほしい。今後が楽しみ！早く続きが読みたい〜！

This review contains spoilers. First of all, the picture was beautiful and it was a big win? I'm really worried about the continuation! I want all of the main characters to be happy! Is the heroine's kindness and cleverness really wonderful? I can also show off the hero's various movements like bonds you can notice since she's the heroine, but I think they'll resolve it quickly and be happy ☘ and I want the villain to be saved too. I'm looking forward to the future! I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 02, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

表紙に惹かれて

Attracted by the cover

魔法をかけられた側はもちろんのこと、魔法をかけた側も辛くて悲しい思いを抱えてたのではないかと…。この時代は地位と名誉ばかりで人権が乏しいものね読みごたえありそうだ。

I think not only the side that was cast the spell, but also the side that cast the spell had painful and sad feelings... This era is full of status and honor, and human rights are scarce, doesn't it seem worth reading.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 19, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公のひたむきさ！

The main character's single-mindedness!

This review contains spoilers. 美しい絵に惹かれて購入。主人公の優しさには救われましたが、物語としては彼を信じているだけの印象があり、もう少しハラハラする展開があれば、より引き込まれたと思います！

This review contains spoilers. I was attracted to the beautiful picture and bought it. I was saved by the kindness of the main character, but as a story, I have the impression that I just believe in him, and if there were developments that were a little more distressing, I think I would be drawn in even more!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

3巻完結が良いです

It's good that volume 3 is complete

みんながハッピーになるお話でした。イモージェンがどうなるかに気を揉みましたが、幸せになるまでの過程が描かれていて、主人公との仲も元に戻ってGoodです。一つだけ気になるのは、ライリーの兄、王太子がまったく登場しなかったのが不思議でした。なぜでしょう？

It was a story that made everyone happy. I was worried about what would happen to Imogen, but it depicts the process leading up to happiness, and the relationship with the main character has returned to normal, which is good. The only thing bothering me was that it was strange that Riley's older brother, the Crown Prince, didn't appear at all. Why is that?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 07, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

サクサク3巻完

Complete volume 3 of Crisaku

絵柄が好みだったので読んで良かったものの、1巻が山だったかなと思うくらいストーリーの起伏は少なかったです。ジャンル少女漫画に驚きなくらいにはTL感ありました。少ない巻数で読後感良い作品探してる人におすすめです。

I liked the design, so I'm glad I read it, but there were so few ups and downs in the story that I thought volume 1 was a mountain. There was such a sense of TL that I was surprised by the shoujo manga genre. It is recommended for people looking for works with a small number of volumes and a good feeling after reading them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 19, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

もったいない

That's a waste

ストーリーはしっかりしているのですが、早足過ぎて、深みを感じられませんでした。ヒロインの切なさも、一瞬で。もったいないなぁ、と思いました。

The story is solid, but it was too fast to feel the depth. The heroine's sadness was instantaneous. I thought that would be a waste.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 10, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

あぁぁぁぁぁシエナ尊い?‍♀️?

ahhh huh sienna is precious? ♀️?

This review contains spoilers. これでハッピーエンド？ですかね？本当に終始シエナが天使で女神で可愛くて尊い！カイリーも幸せになれて良かった(´；ω；｀)ネイサンにもお相手が出来て良かったですが…勝手に私はネイサンは拗らせまくって独身貫いて、いつかシエナたちの娘が産まれてそこで結ばれてくれたらなんて妄想してました(笑)

This review contains spoilers. is this a happy ending? Right? Really Siena is an angel, goddess, cute, and precious from beginning to end! I'm glad Kylie was happy too ('; omega; `) I'm glad Nathan had a partner... I had a delusion that Nathan relentlessly stayed single, and I had a delusion that one day Siena's daughter would be born and they tied up there (lol)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

サブキャラ達が気になる

I'm curious about the subcharacters

作画が本当に綺麗で、ヒーローとヒロインの話もとても綺麗にまとまっていてハッピーエンドで良かったなぁと思うのですが、個人的にはアーセムとカイリーのエピソードをこの美しい作画でもっと読んでみたかった…！

The drawing was really beautiful, and the story of the hero and heroine was so beautifully organized, and I think I'm glad it had a happy ending, but personally I wanted to read more episodes of Asem and Kylie with this beautiful drawing...!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 18, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

確かに婚約破棄を言い渡されたけど

It's true that they were ordered to annul their engagement

This review contains spoilers. 全くの杞憂だった。もうちょい魅了状態ひっぱってくれた方が面白かったかなー。初っ端から安心して読めてしまったので、ハラハラ不足…

This review contains spoilers. It was completely unfounded. I wonder if it would have been more interesting if they left me a little more fascinated. I was able to read it with peace of mind from the beginning, so there's a lack of harassment...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 17, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった。

That was great.

This review contains spoilers. 最初は、イモージュンの事を『何なんだこの女』って思いながら読んでいたんだけど、読んでいくうちに何だか可哀想に思えてきて…少し感情移入してしまった。特に記憶をなくした後からは余計に。物語としては綺麗に終わってたし絵も綺麗で読んで良かった。

This review contains spoilers. At first, I was reading Imojun while thinking “what is this woman,” but as I read it, I felt kind of sorry... I empathized a little bit. Especially after I lost my memory. As a story, it ended beautifully, and the pictures were beautiful, so I'm glad I read it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 02, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

また、1巻のみ

Also, only 1 volume

最初はシエナがかわいそすぎから入ってもー他の人か？あの親友か！？と思っていたら…でもないんか…いやハッキリしろー！！どーゆーことよ！とか思いながら読んでます。絵も好きだし、ある話ではありますが、面白いです。まだ、1巻だけなので2巻も買います。

Even if Siena is too pitiful at first — is she someone else? that best friend!? If you think about it... but... well, be clear!! Whoa whoa! I'm reading it while thinking something like that. I also like pictures, and although it's a story, it's interesting. It's still only 1 volume, so I'm going to buy 2 volumes as well.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公が健気すぎる

The main character is too energetic

This review contains spoilers. 主人公がいい子すぎて、絶対に幸せにしてください案件です。裏切られてからの、信じてる...なんていい子すぎる

This review contains spoilers. The main character is too nice, so please make them absolutely happy. Believing after being betrayed... what a nice kid

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 04, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

気になる

worrisome

This review contains spoilers. 絵が似ていて主人公の区別がつきづらいですが、内容は好きです陛下の一途な愛素敵続き楽しみにしてます

This review contains spoilers. The pictures are similar and it's hard to tell the main characters apart, but I like the content, His Majesty's Unwaited Love Is Wonderful, and I'm looking forward to the continuation

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

2巻で完結でいいのでは⁉︎

Wouldn't it be nice to complete it with volume 2 ⁉ ︎

This review contains spoilers. 絵が綺麗で、美男美女のカップルのお話。色っぽいシーンも絵が綺麗だし甘くて素敵でした。ストーリーはある程度先が読めちゃったかなと。あ、これ王子魔法にかかってないやつじゃんって結構前半で気づいたし、あとあと考えたら婚約破棄までする必要なくなかったか？と思いました。でもやっぱり溺愛系はいい。甘々な第二王子良かったです。まだ続くみたいだけど2巻でスパッと完結した方がいいだろーと思いました。

This review contains spoilers. This is a story about a beautiful, beautiful couple with beautiful pictures. The pictures in the sexy scenes were beautiful, sweet, and wonderful. I think I was able to read the story ahead to a certain extent. Oh, I realised this was pretty much the first half that Prince wasn't enchanted, and when I thought about that later, wouldn't it be necessary to even annul the engagement? I thought so. But after all, doting is good. The sweet Second Prince was nice. It seems like it's still going on, but I thought it would be better to finish it quickly with volume 2.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

よいです

That's good

This review contains spoilers. ずっと気になってました。配信分購入。なんとなくはじめから魅了かかってるのか？と思いましたが、やっぱりそういう事だったんですね。父親に脅され悪役やらされてたイモージェン、キツイ顔つきでしたが吹っ切れたらとても素敵な女性。ようやく目覚めました。ちょっと様子がおかしいって所でアレ？と思ったけど、続くようで良かったです。公爵令息や侍女、みんな素敵なキャラクターばかりです。今後も楽しみです。

This review contains spoilers. I've always been curious about it. Buy the streaming portion. Are you somehow fascinated from the beginning? I thought, but that's what happened after all. Imogen, who was threatened by her father and made to be the villain, is a very nice woman with a tough face but when she gets carried away. I finally woke up. the situation is a little strange, is that it? I thought, but I'm glad it seems to continue. The duke's reign and handmaiden are all wonderful characters. I'm looking forward to the future.

Helpful

Reviews for Broken Betrothal: My Beloved Was Bewitched Manga