Starting to Fall in Love for the First Time Manga Reviews (P.8)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

恋人編を是非！！！！

Be sure to check out the lover edition!!!

皆さん！番外編と言える同人誌版が販売停止します！急いで買いましょう！！あとがきで人気出たら恋人編を描きたいとのこと。絶対読みたい！！！！そう思わせてくれる作品です！ってか、親のジャマとかありそうだし蒼くんの嫉妬とか、まだ色々片付いて無い事あるでしょ？何で1巻で終わらせた？？雑誌の都合？表紙デザインもこんなに苦労されていると思うとファンとしては(T^T)(T^T)(T^T)。意識のすり合わせ、本当に大切です。事後の花って意味不明よデザイナーさん。

everyone! The doujinshi edition, which can be said to be an extra edition, will be discontinued! Hurry up and buy it!! If the afterword became popular, they said they would like to draw a lover edition. I definitely want to read it!!! It's a work that makes me think so! I mean, it seems like my parents are getting in the way, and there are a lot of things that haven't been cleaned up yet, like Ao-kun's jealousy, right? Why did you finish it with volume 1?? Why magazines? As a fan (T^T) (T^T) (T^T) (T^T), I think that cover design has also been difficult. Alignment of consciousness is really important. The meaning of flowers after the fact is unclear, designer.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

きゅんがヤバい

Kyun is dangerous

きゅんが詰め込まれすぎててしんどい…尊い…続編期待、是非恋人編を求む…！！鴇ちゃんかわいすぎ。こんな27歳おらんでよ。たからくんも見た目に反して真面目っつか誠実みある。(ホンマにいーでーか⁇)いやマジ続編お願いします。

Kyun is so packed up that it's tough... precious... looking forward to the sequel, be sure to ask for the lover edition...!! Hajim-chan is too cute. I'm not 27 years old like this. Contrary to his appearance, Takara-kun is serious and honest. (Really? lol) No, seriously, please give me a sequel.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 02, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ピュアピュアな鴇ちゃんは一家に一人必要！

Pure pure Ka-chan needs one person in her family!

This review contains spoilers. もう最高！！鴇ちゃん優勝！！鴇ちゃんは絶対的な癒しの存在、あ～激カワピュアピュア鴇ちゃんに会わせてくれて、マキネ先生ありがとうございます！！こういう無邪気でピュアな存在を描かせたらやはり先生はピカイチですね。他作品と比べても鴇ちゃんのピュアピュアさはダントツ！その裏では辛さや哀しさに加え、兄弟達を甘やかしてるようで、実は自分が必要とされてる心の拠り所を否定されたと感じている傷を抱えている。同様の傷を有するタカラくんが惹かれたのも当然。マキネ先生の作品はただ可愛いだけでなく、裏に孤独や闇や傷を抱えた設定が多く、今回もストーリーがより深くなってますね。でもでも、これだけは言わせてほしい。鴇ちゃんをタカラくんが独り占めするのはズルい！鴇ちゃんは一家に一人必要！あ～私の家にも居てほしい！あの鴇ちゃんが全ての家に居てくれたら、全世界が平和になるのに…この作品でいつでも鴇ちゃんに会って癒されると思うと本当にありがたい。今後もずっと読み続けます。とにかく、ぜひとも続編をお願いします！鴇ちゃんとタカラくんのラブラブなその後も見たいですが、鴇ちゃんの兄弟達のその後も見たい！蒼、翠、茜、藤、それぞれ本当に魅力的で可愛い。大事な大事な鴇ちゃんがタカラくんに取られた兄弟達の反応も見たいです！ぜひぜひ続編とスピンオフを切にお願いします！！

This review contains spoilers. That's already awesome!! Hajim-chan wins!! Thank you Makine sensei for letting me meet Aki-chan, who is an absolute healer, ah, super cute, Pure Pure!! If I were to draw such an innocent and pure being, the teacher would be impressive. Compared to other works, Ha-chan's pure purity is by far the best! Behind that, in addition to pain and sorrow, they seem to be pampering their siblings, and in fact, they have scars where they feel that they have been denied the base of their heart that they need. No wonder Takara-kun, who has a similar scar, was attracted. Makine sensei's works are not just cute, but there are many settings that harbor loneliness, darkness, and hurt behind them, and the story is even deeper this time. But let me just say this. It's a lie for Takara-kun to keep Ha-chan all to himself! Hajim-chan needs one person in her family! Oh, I want them to stay in my house too! If that chan stayed in every house, the whole world would be at peace... I'm really thankful to think that I can always meet Ka-chan and be healed in this film. I will continue to keep reading. Anyway, please do ask for a sequel! I want to see Hajim-chan and Takara-kun's lovey-dovey afterward, but I also want to see what happened after Hajim-chan's siblings! Aoi, Midori, Akane, and Wisteria are all really charming and cute. I also want to see the reactions of the siblings when Takara-kun took their precious, precious little girl! Please be sure to check out the sequels and spin-offs!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 02, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ピュア！

pure!

This review contains spoilers. 心が洗われましたー！家や弟達の為に高校を諦めて働くことをえらんだトキ君とと、母親が毒親すぎて、心が壊れそうになっているコウ君二人が、前を向いて歩き出そうとしているお話しです。父親が亡くなり、母親の心が壊れそうになっている姿をみて、家族の為に頑張っていたトキ君。家族の為に頑張っている事に対して苦痛ではなくて、でも、兄弟からみたら罪悪感で、兄弟のそんな気持ちを感じて申し訳ない気持ちになるトキ君にも切ない気持ちになります。コウ君は、弟の翠君から、トキ兄の話を聞いていて、ずっと会いたいと思っていて、会ったら更に思いが強くなって好きで好きで仕方なくなってる、そんなコウ君がトキ君の傍に居てくれて良かったです。強くグイグイいくんじゃなくて、傍にいてくれるコウ君が良きです。とにかくピュアなのが眩しいです！

This review contains spoilers. My heart was washed! It's a story about Toki-kun, who gave up high school and didn't want to work for his family and younger brothers, and Kou-kun, whose mother is so toxic that their heart is about to break down, face forward and start walking. Toki-kun was working hard for her family when she saw her father pass away and her mother's heart was about to break. It's not painful for her to work so hard for her family, but from her sibling's point of view, it's a sense of guilt, and it makes me feel sad for Toki-kun, who feels sorry for her siblings. Ko-kun has been listening to Toki's older brother stories from his younger brother Midori-kun, and I've always wanted to meet him, and when we met, my feelings became even stronger, and I liked him, and I couldn't help but like him, so I'm glad Kou was by his side. It's nice that Kou-kun is not strong and is there for me. Anyway, it's dazzling because it's pure!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

良いです！！！！

good!!!

初めての作者様。え、良い！！！！良すぎるんですが！絵も可愛いしストーリーもしっかり詰まってて面白いし兄弟たちみんなかわいい！！なぜ、なぜ続編がないのですか？？恋人編、でますよね？？？兄弟たちもだしてください。お願いします！

First time author. Eh, good!!! It's too good though! The pictures are cute, the story is well-packed and interesting, and the siblings are all so cute!! Why, why are there no sequels?? the lover edition is coming out, right??? Please bring the brothers out too. please!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

くうううっっ（悶）

Wow wow ()

可愛すぎるんだけど。ピュアッピュアなんだけど。個人的にトキちゃんの寝癖がたまらない♡これは絶対続編必要。既刊のは年明け販売終了になってしまうみたいだけど、もっとちゃんと長い恋人編出てくれないかな。お願いお願い！！一つ懸念、タカラのお母さんは二度と見たくないなあ。毒親なのは充分分かったから、どうか頑張るタカラの邪魔しないでもう出てこなくてよし！

It's too cute though. It's pure pure though. Personally, Toki-chan's sleeping habit is irresistible ♡ This definitely needs a sequel. It seems that sales of the one that has already been published will end at the beginning of the year, but I wonder if a longer lover edition will come out properly. please please!! One concern, I never want to see Takara's mom again. I know enough that they are toxic parents, so please don't disturb Takara who works hard so they don't come out anymore!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

初恋っていいよね(˘ᵕ˘ )♡

First love is good isn't it () ♡

初恋～～～って感じで好き♡ときちゃんが可愛いです！ストーリーには関係ないけどカバーイラストの会話が面白かったw

I like it because it feels like first love ♡ Toki-chan is cute! it has nothing to do with the story but the conversation on the cover illustration was interesting lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 19, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい…。

beautiful...

This review contains spoilers. まず絵が綺麗…。コマの振り方とか文章も綺麗で話がスッと入ってきます。「よるべない」って言葉が昔から好きなのですが(めっちゃ個人的笑)作中に出てきてときめきました（汗）是非続編を読みたくてレビュー書いた所存であります。

This review contains spoilers. First of all, the picture is beautiful... The way the frames are drawn and the sentences are beautiful, and the conversation comes right in. I've always liked the word “unbelievable” (so personal lol), but it came up in the story and I was thrilled (sweat) I definitely wanted to read the sequel, so I wrote a review.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 12, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛い

pretty

この作者さんの作品は大好きでたくさん読んでいます。その中で1番好きな作品です。切ない気持ちにもなるけど痛いと言うよりじんわり泣きたくなる。尊い、癒し、ピュア、鴇ちゃんが暖かくて可愛い。可愛すぎる。完結ってなってないから続きあるのかな？心待ちにしています。

I love this author's work and read a lot. Among them, this is my favorite work. It also makes me feel sad, but it makes me want to cry slowly rather than say it's painful. Precious, healing, pure, Ka-chan is warm and cute. It's too cute. It's not complete, so I wonder if there will be a continuation? I'm looking forward to it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

これはやばい

this is terrible

このレビュー数に高評価。全面納得です。何度泣かされたことか、、悲しい事があっての涙じゃなくて、嬉しさとか感情移入のさせ方が上手すぎて、幸せで泣くってゆう久しぶりの感覚。ほんと読んで正解です。続編希望！是非！！

Highly rated for this number of reviews. I'm totally convinced. It's been a long time since I've been made to cry, it's not tears because of something sad, and I'm so good at making them feel happy or empathized, that I'm happy and crying. I actually read it and it's correct. Hope for a sequel! By all means!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

尊い

Precious

鴇ちゃんが純粋無垢すぎて浄化されます。兄弟のために愛情深く頑張ってきた鴇ちゃんが優しい愛で包まれますように。ところで続きはどこですか？ショートストーリーでは物足りません！

Ka-chan is so pure and innocent that she is purified. May Ka-chan, who has lovingly worked hard for her siblings, be wrapped in gentle love. But where's the continuation? Short stories aren't enough!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

トキちゃん！最高！！

Toki-chan! awesome!!

ピュアピュア…が一番似合う作品ではないでしょうか?タカラ&トキちゃん！これからの展開はもちろん！兄弟皆の今後が気になりすぎます！！続編待ってます！！

Isn't Pure Pure... the work that suits you best? Takara & Toki-chan! Future developments, of course! I'm too worried about the future of all the siblings!! I'm waiting for the sequel!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 29, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

全力で推せる！

I can recommend it with all my might!

This review contains spoilers. 基本ハードボイルド＆エロス感溢れる作品が好みなのですが…鴇ちゃんだけは別腹です。こんなにエロス感皆無な作品で満足感を味わうのは初めてかもです。鴇ちゃんを通じて改めて純粋とは何ぞやと考えさせられた作品で、やっぱりBLが好きだと改めて思える作品でした。是非ともこの主人公の2人のこの先の幸せの型が見たいと切に願います。

This review contains spoilers. I like works that are basically hard boiled and full of eroticism... but only Uchi-chan is different. This is probably the first time I've experienced a sense of satisfaction with a work that has no sense of eroticism at all. It was a work that made me think once again about what pure is through Ka-chan, and it was a work that made me think again that I like BL after all. By all means, I sincerely hope to see the future forms of happiness between these two main characters.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 27, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

久しぶりに胸が弾け飛びました

My heart jumped for the first time in a long time

とにかく可愛い。可愛い以外の言葉が見つかりません！！お互いが初恋であること、とても素晴らしいですね。ただ恋愛するだけではなく、学校生活やお芝居のシーンもあってよりリアルに感じれる点もすごく良かったです。ぜひ！！ぜひ！！！！恋人編を！！！！！！！

Anyway, it's cute. I can't find any words other than cute!! It's so wonderful that they both have their first love. It wasn't just a love affair, but it was also really nice that there were scenes from school life and plays, so it felt more real. by all means! by all means!!! The Lover's Edition!!!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

さくーっ！と読めてしまった！

so cool! I was able to read it!

今回の先生のお話、なんか今までとパターンが違う！スラスラスラ〜と読めてしまって「え！もう終わり！？続きはまだ！？」ってなりました笑暮田先生のお話展開は大体暗い笑。結構じっとりくる内容が多いんだけど今回は「お？」「どうなる！？」「そして？」みたいな感じで内容にそぐわないかもだけどワクワクしながら読みました〜早く続きこーい！

The pattern of this teacher's story is somewhat different from what it used to be! I read it fluently and said, “Eh! it's over already!? More to come!?” that's it lol the development of Kuketa-sensei's story is mostly bleak lol. There's a lot of content that sits pretty slowly, but this time it's “oh?” “What's going to happen!?” “And then?” I felt like it might not fit the content, but I was excited to read it ~ let's continue soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

続篇読みたいです！！

I want to read the next one!!

This review contains spoilers. 絵がすごく綺麗でそれぞれのキャラクターの作り込みがホントに上手でストーリーに没入できました。主人公の性格の良さ、ほんわかした感じ、陰の部分など読んでるとグサグサ刺さってきてうるうるしてしまいました。家族や兄弟との絆が丁寧に描かれていて何度読んでも心が優しくなるストーリーです。告白されてからも変に構えず答えを出してくれたので、モヤモヤすることなく読めました。本当に良いお話なので、続篇を早く読みたいと思います。

This review contains spoilers. The pictures were so beautiful and each character was really well crafted, and I was able to immerse myself in the story. When I was reading the main character's good personality, the warm and fuzzy feeling, etc., it stung me right away and I was so excited. The bonds between family and siblings are carefully depicted, and it is a story that makes your heart feel kind no matter how many times you read it. Even after I confessed, they gave me answers without getting bogged down, so I was able to read it without getting confused. It's a really good story, so I hope to read the sequel soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

お兄ちゃん

older brother

This review contains spoilers. なんですかーっ？この可愛い生き物。優しい素敵なお兄ちゃまの初々しい恋。しかも年下イケメン彼氏って羨ましい！

This review contains spoilers. what is it huh? this cute creature. An innocent love between a kind and wonderful older brother. What's more, I envy younger handsome boyfriends!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

是非とも続編をよろしくお願いします！！！

Please be sure to check out the sequel!!!

This review contains spoilers. 私は今とてつもなく後悔をしています。なんでもっと早くこの作品に出会えなかったのか。とてつもなく乗り遅れてしまいました。まさか1年以上経っているなんて、、、。後悔はこれくらいにしておきます。もう、なんと言っても鴇ちゃん可愛すぎるんだよ！！！本当に何なんだこの可愛い生き物は！だよ！！！周りには惜しみなく与えるのに自分は受け取らない、というのはきっと傷だ、と言うのを見て、とても号泣してしまいました。次男の蒼くんに自由に生きていいと言っている辺りもやばかったけど、それ以上に涙が止まらなくなってしまいました。なんと言っても優しさの裏でそんなことを思っていたなんてっっっ！！でも、それを知ってたしかにな、と納得をしてしまった自分もいました。何をしたいかではなく、何をするべきかを選択していくのは、簡単だけど、簡単ではないと思います。それを理由とかなくただ当たり前、普通のことだと淡々とこなす日々は本当に虚無だと。自分でやりたいことが選択できないのは何も残らないとそんなふうに思ってしまいます。当たり前だと思ってやっていたことが突然なくなると、自分の価値は何なのかと思うほど、空っぽになってしまうと。もう、自分でも何を言っているのかわからないのでこの辺で終わりにします。言葉にできない気持ちになりました。とにかく、鴇ちゃんは可愛すぎな。ずっと尭良くんとお幸せに！！恋人編も是非とも見たいのでお願いします！！兄弟も好きなのでそこのお話しもよろしくお願いします！！！

This review contains spoilers. I have tremendous regrets right now. Why didn't I come across this work sooner? I missed my ride terribly. I can't believe it's been over a year... I'll leave my regrets to this point. No matter what I say, Ha-chan is too cute!!! What is this cute creature really! That's it!!! I cried so much when I saw them say that giving generously to others but not receiving it is surely a wound. The area where I told my second son, Ao-kun, that I could live freely was terrible, but even more than that, I couldn't stop my tears. After all, I can't believe they thought that behind their kindness!! However, I was also convinced that it was true that I knew it. Choosing what to do rather than what you want to do is easy, but I don't think it's easy. There's no reason for it, it's just natural, and the days of doing it bluntly when it's normal are really empty. If you can't choose what you want to do, it makes you think there's nothing left. When things you took for granted suddenly disappear, you feel so empty that you wonder what your value is. I don't even understand what I'm saying anymore, so I'll stop here. It made me feel like I couldn't put it into words. Anyway, Ha-chan is too cute. Stay safe and happy all the time!! I definitely want to watch the lover edition too, so please go ahead! My siblings love it too, so please share that story too!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 14, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

続編、切に望みます。

I'm looking forward to the sequel.

定期的に読み返して癒やされてます。二人寄り添って支えあって、言葉のやり取り、表情が心にグツと刺さります。

I am healed by rereading it regularly. The two of them snuggle up and support each other, and their exchanges of words and expressions really stick to my heart.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 11, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが読みたいです！

I want to read more!

This review contains spoilers. ふわふわドキドキするとてもいい作品でした！心の傷もあって、それに気づいた段階だけどこれから2人の関係が進むにつれて少しずつ癒されていくといいなと思います！絵も可愛くて、ほんとに可愛い作品です！

This review contains spoilers. It was such a nice work that was so fluffy and exciting! There was also a heartbreak, and I'm at the stage where I noticed it, but I think it would be nice if the relationship between the two progresses little by little from now on! The picture is cute too, and it's a really cute work!

Helpful

Reviews for Starting to Fall in Love for the First Time Manga