Starting to Fall in Love for the First Time Manga Reviews (P.29)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

見守り続けたい、、、！

I want to keep watching...!

This review contains spoilers. とーーーっも純粋で初い。ほんとに、はじめて、はじめましたでした！！！！鴇ちゃんの今まで弟たちのためにって頑張ってきたけど、初めて本音で弱くなれたシーンはグッときました。尭良くんの抱えてる事情も前向きになれるきっかけが出来良かったです！お泊まりの無意識なでなでオプション可愛すぎます?2人の恋人編が読みたいです♪

This review contains spoilers. Wow, this is pure and the first time. Really, it was the first time I started!!! I've been working hard for my younger brothers until now, but the scene where I was weakened by real intentions for the first time was amazing. It was nice to have an opportunity to be positive about the circumstances that Takayaka-kun is having! the unconscious sleepover option is too cute? I want to read The Two Lovers Edition ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

たまらん

unbearable

鴇ちゃんのかわいさ優勝です。こんな嫌味なくいい子に仕上がることってなかなかないなぁ。何回も読んでまいます。もちろん続編希望！すぐに読みたいです！

Ka-chan's cuteness won the championship. It's not easy to be such a good kid without being disgusted. I've read it over and over again. Of course I want a sequel! I want to read it soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

尊みｯｯｯｯ!!!!!

awesome lol!!!!

辛い環境のなかで…！！よく頑張ってたね…！！感動です…。あんな小さい体で可愛い顔で。すごいですよ。ぜひとも幸せになって欲しいです‼

in a difficult environment...!! You've been doing your best...!! I'm impressed... With such a small body and a cute face. That's amazing. I definitely want them to be happy ‼

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

きゅんきゅんです！

It's Kyun Kyun!

先生の作品は即買いなのですが、仕事が辛くて今マキネワールド食らったら倒れるかもと思って保留にしていたのですが、我慢できず買ったらまさかの展開！！優しい世界！！いつも通りキャラ達は重さのあるバックボーンなのですが、でも優しい！癒やされました。。。続き本当に観たいです！！

I bought the teacher's work right away, but work was hard and I thought it might collapse if I ate Makine World now, so I put it on hold, but I couldn't stand it and bought it, then it just unexpectedly unfolded!! Kind world!! As always, the characters are heavy backbones, but they are kind! I was healed... I really want to watch more!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

続編希望！

Hope for a sequel!

先生の作品を色々と読んでいますが、『つむぎくんのさきっぽ』と並んでお気に入りになりました。27歳の鴇ちゃんと19歳の尭良くんの恋人編、楽しみに待っています。

I've read a lot of his works, and it became my favorite along with “Tsumugi-kun's Sakippo.” I'm looking forward to the lover edition between 27-year-old Ka-chan and 19-year-old Takaya-kun.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

あとがきw

afterword lol

27歳が可愛すぎて泣く仲良し兄弟も良き❤性格が滲み出る顔って、あるんですねこの2人の出会いはもう必然なんだと思いました恋人編⁉ハイ、熱望してます、待ってます！

The 27-year-old is so cute and the good friends and siblings who cry are also good ❤ they have faces that exude personality, I thought an encounter between these two was inevitable, lover edition ⁉ Hi, I'm eager, I'm waiting!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ピュア！

pure!

This review contains spoilers. 鴇ちゃん、かわいいけど大人(精神的に)。尭良くんはイケメンで実はピュアボーイ。鴇ちゃんは家族にすごく愛されているけど、今まで大変なことが多かった。尭良くんは家族からのある意味歪んだ愛情？によって辛いことが多かったけど、翠くんとの出会いで鴇ちゃんに出会えてよかった。鴇ちゃんと尭良くんの二人のピュアラブが最高です。是非とも「恋人編」を描いて欲しい！

This review contains spoilers. Ha-chan is cute but an adult (mentally). Takaya-kun is a good-looking guy and is actually a pure boy. Hajim-chan is very loved by her family, but things have been difficult a lot up until now. Is Takaya-kun's affection distorted in a sense from his family? There were a lot of difficult things because of that, but I'm glad I met Minori-chan when I met Midori-kun. The pure love of the two, Hajima-chan and Takaya-kun, is the best. I definitely want you to draw “Lovers Edition”!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

最後の…

The last one...

最後の表紙の…先生、担当さんとデザイナーとのやり取りが面白かったです。□鴇ちゃんとの家族感がもーなんとも！次男くん、なんかもう少し出て来そうですね。笑今後の恋人編に期待！

The interaction between... the teacher, the person in charge and the designer on the last cover was interesting. □ What a sense of family with Tsu-chan! Looks like the second son is coming out a little more. lol I'm looking forward to the future lover edition!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

鴇ちゃん、大優勝。

Ha-chan won a big win.

This review contains spoilers. 27歳に見えないけど、どこまでもみんなのお兄ちゃん。自分を犠牲にしてるつもりは無かったのかも知れないけど、家族の為に頑張ってた人。鴇ちゃんはみんなに安心や癒しをたくさん与えていた人だと思う。それが、27歳で好きなように生きていいなんて言われてすごく戸惑うと思う。そんな時、出会った尭良くん。尭良くんも毒親に苦しんでいて、鴇ちゃんに癒された人。鴇ちゃんにとっても初めての友達で家族ではない誰かに気持ちを聞いてもらえる人が出来てよかった。２人が出会えてよかった。寄り添っていける人が出来てよかった。幸せそうな２人を見たいので続編をお願いします。

This review contains spoilers. He doesn't look like 27 years old, but he's always everyone's older brother. A person who may not have intended to sacrifice himself, but was working hard for his family. I think Tsuga-chan was a person who gave everyone a lot of peace of mind and healing. I think it's really confusing to be told that you can live whatever you want at age 27. At that time, I met Takaya-kun. Takaya-kun was also suffering from toxic parents and was healed by Ka-chan. I'm glad that Haku-chan is also her first friend and someone other than her family can listen to her feelings. I'm glad the two met. I'm glad I found someone I could snuggle up to. I want to see two happy people, so please give me a sequel.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

続編希望

Hope for a sequel

This review contains spoilers. 表紙が綺麗で試し読みから即購入しました！個人的にピュアなBLがとても好きで、特別な存在という関係から恋人同士になる、こういう続編があれば是非読ませていただきたいと思います！

This review contains spoilers. The cover was beautiful and I bought it right away after the trial reading! Personally, I really like Pure BL, and if there is a sequel like this where they become lovers due to a special relationship, I would definitely read it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

めっちゃドキドキした〜！！

I was so excited!!

立ち読みで気になり購入しました！鴇ちゃん、かわいい〜！27には見えない〜笑終始鴇ちゃんのかわいさにキュンキュンしました！続きをぜひ！！

I bought it because I was interested in standing reading! Ha-chan is so cute! It doesn't look like 27 ~ lol I was amazed at how cute Ka-chan is from beginning to end! Be sure to continue!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

癒し?

healing?

This review contains spoilers. 絵が綺麗で好みで購入。兄弟思いで慕われている鴇ちゃんが可愛すぎる！愛さない人はいないかと！たからくんも鴇ちゃんにはとても心を許しているのがよくわかりたまらなく良いです！続きみたい！！

This review contains spoilers. The picture is beautiful and I bought it as I like. Ka-chan, who is loved by her siblings, is too cute! I wonder if there's anyone I don't love! It's irresistibly good to understand that Takara-kun is also very forgiving of his heart! it looks like it's continuing!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ぜひ！ぜひ！！続編希望！！！

by all means! by all means!! Hope for a sequel!!!

超個人的な話なのですが、私、高校2年になりたての頃に父親を癌で亡くしてまして。私は父親の最期を看取れたのですが中学3年だった弟は間に合わなかったのです。弟は待望の長男で父に可愛がられていたので、父も弟もお互いどんな思いだったろうと未だチクリとした傷です。だからトキちゃんの他の兄弟への「自分は父親との思い出が多い罪悪感」とかすごい刺さって涙がポロリ。そしてタカラの母親が子供を自分の思うように動かしたい毒親だってのも、また私の母親とソックリで。家族を支えるため中卒で働いて自分の事は後回しだったので、トキちゃんの27歳からの青春スタートです。タカラの母親と、タカラ目当てでトキに近づくJK以外のキャラがすごく良く（語彙力）、心象風景が押し付けられる事なくだけどさりげなくて、あー皆んな生きてるんだなー、、、、とじんわり心地良かったです。トキちゃんがいちいちホント可愛くて強くて、そりゃあタカラは心撃ち抜かれるよな笑。タカラがまた綺麗で（ここはカタカナではない漢字で）。相変わらず絵が素敵。ストーリー的にはお互い初恋だけあってキス止まりでしたがそれでいい。なんかこう…胸がいっぱいになりました。なんだよー初恋同士でこんなピッタリの相手が見つかるのかよーーと甘酸っぱくて羨ましい。そして、後書きというかもはや短編になってる暮田さんと担当さんの攻防戦、めちゃ笑いました。暮田さんが「恋人編を描けるようお祈りを」と後書きでおっしゃってました。ぜひぜひ、自分の初めてと空っぽを埋めていくトキちゃんと、俳優として頑張るタカラ、そして仲が深まっていく2人を壁になって見守りたいので続編お願いします！！！！！（トキちゃんの兄弟もいいキャラいっぱいなので、そっちも気になる…。）

It's a super personal story, but I lost my father to cancer when I was just in my second year of high school. I was able to take care of my father's death, but my younger brother, who was in the 3rd year of middle school, couldn't make it in time. My younger brother was the long-awaited eldest son and was loved by his father, so no matter what kind of feelings both father and younger brother had for each other, it still hurts. That's why Toki-chan's other siblings were so stabbed, like “I have a lot of memories with my father,” and it made me burst into tears. Also, the fact that Takara's mother is a toxic parent who wants to move her child the way she wants is also alone with my mother. I worked as a junior high school graduate to support my family and put my own affairs on the back burner, so Toki-chan started her youth at age 27. Takara's mother and the characters other than JK who approach the ibis for Takara were really good (vocabulary skills), and the imaginary landscape was imposed on them, but it was casual, and ah, everyone is alive... it was so gentle and comfortable. Toki-chan is really cute and strong one by one, and well, Takara's heart is shot through lol. Takara is beautiful again (this is in kanji, not katakana). The picture is as nice as ever. In terms of story, they only had their first love for each other, so they stopped kissing, but that's fine. Something like this... my heart is now full. It's so sweet and sour that I'm envious that Hatsukoi can find such a perfect partner. Also, I laughed a lot at the afterword, or rather the battle between Mr. Kureta and the person in charge, which had already been made into a short story. Mr. Kureta said in the afterword, “Please pray so I can draw the lover edition.” By all means, I want to keep an eye on Toki-chan, who fills in the emptiness with her first time, Takara, who works hard as an actor, and the two people who are deepening their relationship as a wall, so please do a sequel!!!! (Toki-chan's siblings are also full of good characters, so I'm curious about that too...)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

もう可愛いすぎる！！

It's already too cute!!

This review contains spoilers. お互いの初恋で、キュンキュンがとまらないです！！鴇ちゃんは、27歳に見えないくらい可愛すぎて、でも芯の強い人で自分が家族の為に…って頑張って。鴇ちゃんの、やらされていた訳でもなく、必要とされるのが嬉しい気持ちも、自由を与えられて寂しくなる気持ちもすごく分かるよ。マキネ先生の、一筋縄でいかない家族とのエピソードが入ってくるのが好きです。ちょっと辛くなるんだけど、その分幸せが後に感じられるのが良いです。ほんとに後半で鴇ちゃんが恋に気付き、あーもう終わっちゃった！となり全然足りません！！まだまだ、お互いのはじめてをみたいです！ぜひ、恋人編よろしくお願いします！！

This review contains spoilers. It's our first love for each other, and we can't stop freaking out!! Ka-chan is so cute that she doesn't look like she's 27, but she has a strong core, so do your best... for your family. I can really understand Ka-chan's feeling of being happy to be needed, and the feeling of being given freedom and feeling lonely. I like the fact that Makine sensei's episode with his family is not straightforward comes in. It gets a little painful, but it's nice to be able to feel that happiness later. It was really in the second half that Ha-chan realized she was in love, and ah, it's over! and it's not enough at all!! We're still looking forward to seeing each other for the first time! By all means, thank you for your love edition!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

かわいいお話❗️

A cute story ❗️

This review contains spoilers. イケメン芸能人(かけだし)×弟育て終わったお兄ちやんの初恋の話。受けも攻めも暮田さん感マンテンで可愛かったです！でもまだキスまでです！皆さんぜひ購入して続編を書いてもらいましょう！

This review contains spoilers. A story about the first love between a good-looking entertainer (kedashi) x older brother who has finished raising his younger brother. Both receiving and attacking were so cute with Kureta-san's strong sense! But it's still time for the kiss! Be sure to buy it and have them write a sequel!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

尊い、これは近年稀に見る尊さ

Precious, this is a preciousness rarely seen in recent years

This review contains spoilers. 鴇ちゃん優勝！私も読みながら何度も叫びましたよ！！ただお兄ちゃんみがそうやって培われていったのかと過去を思うと切ない。そして色々抱えてもがいているイケメンと出会って、お互いがピースのようにうまくハマって必要としあって愛を育んでいく過程がもう愛おしいです。暮田マキネ先生の、痛々しいほど献身的な受けは大好物ですが、今回はいつもの闇アリ感なく、天使です。特別天然記念物指定です。ありがとうございます。純愛なもんでこの一冊キスしかしてないです。それでも大満足です。だけども早めに続編よろしくお願い致します。

This review contains spoilers. Hajim-chan wins! I screamed over and over while reading it too!! However, it's sad to think about the past, wondering if my older brother was cultivated that way. Then, I met a handsome guy who is struggling with various things, and the process where they both fit in and need each other like pieces and nurture love is already adorable. Kureta Makine sensei's painfully dedicated reception is my favorite food, but this time I'm an angel without the usual sense of darkness. It is designated as a special natural monument. Thank you very much. I've only kissed this one book because of pure love. Still, I am very satisfied. But thank you for the sequel as soon as possible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

癖（ヘキ）のひとつにドンピシャ

Don Pisha is one of my habits (bad luck)

This review contains spoilers. 誰しも癖（ヘキ）というものをお持ちだと思います。例に漏れず私にもいくつかありまして、以下のジャンルやタグに非常に弱いのです。①両片想い①歳下ワンコ×美人上司①清潔感のある長髪男子そして、①大家族の長男的立ち位置の子が頑張っちゃうお話。この作品はコレ！まさに長男！私は試読から鴇ちゃんにメロメロです。新刊だったけど待てずに買わせる魅力が、この鴇ちゃんから溢れてるんですよ…。それも、ただ人の為に頑張ってるだけじゃないのがまた良い。ちゃんと自分の為に、自分本位で自己満足な行為なんだと鴇ちゃん自身が思っていたこと。周りが良かれと思って労い、思いがけず手にした自由を重荷に感じていたこと。そういった繊細で、単純じゃない心の動きを丁寧に描いてあってとても良かった。尭良くんの方は親との関係もあり、もうちょっと複雑で波乱がありそうに思います。心因性のアレも心配…。そこで多分、皆さん同じく思っていらっしゃるのは、「続編の熱烈待機」ですよね。なんとかしてあげて、この２人！しかもなんたって海王社。どうか期待通りにヨ・ロ・シ・ク！ところで、何に一番笑ったかって、最後のおまけ、「単行本のカバーイラストができるまで」の、暮田先生と担当さんのやりとり（笑）。Take1はまだ理解できた。Take2、Take4に至っては、担当さんコレわざと？って、声出して夜中に笑ってしまった。暮田先生のツッコミも最高。花の咲き方で「事後」かどうかわかるとは…BL作品の編集、デザインの現場はかなり面白そうです。作家先生は大変ですね。

This review contains spoilers. I think everyone has a habit (habit). As an example, I have a few, and I'm very weak against the following genres and tags. It's a story about ① Unrequited Love ① A Younger Dog x A Beautiful Boss ① A Long-Haired Boy With A Sense Of Cleanliness, And ① A Child Who Stands Like The Eldest Son In A Big Family Does Their Best Work. This work is this! Exactly the oldest son! I've been smitten with Ka-chan since the trial reading. It was a new issue, but the appeal of making you buy it without having to wait is overflowing with Ko-chan... Also, it's good that they don't just work hard for people. Ka-chan herself thought that it was an act of self-centered and complacency for herself. I felt burdened by thinking that people around me would be good, and the freedom I had unexpectedly acquired was burdensome. It was so nice that it carefully depicted such delicate and unsimple movements of the mind. Takaya-kun also has a relationship with his parents, so I think it's a bit more complicated and turbulent. I'm also worried about psychogenic things... So what everyone probably feels the same is “eagerly waiting for the sequel.” Do something for them, these two! What's more, it's Nanta Kaiousha. Yo-lo si-ku, as expected! By the way, what made me laugh the most was the final bonus, the exchange between Professor Kureta and the person in charge of “Until the cover illustration for a book is made” (laughs). I was still able to understand Take1. When it comes to Take2 and Take4, did the person in charge do this on purpose? I laughed out loud in the middle of the night. Kureta-sensei's tsukkomi is also amazing. You can tell if it's “after the fact” by the way the flowers bloom... the editing and design scene of BL works seems pretty interesting. Being a writer is tough, isn't it?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

表紙が良い?

is the cover good?

絵がとてもうまくて、見やすくし、良かったです。主人公が、めっちゃくちゃかわゆくて、キュンキュンでした。(ﾉ≧▽≦)ﾉ

The picture was very nice and made easy to see, which was great. The main character was super cute and had a blast. ()

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

続編読みたい！！！

I want to read the sequel!!!

最高な純愛でした！自然と涙が出ました。絵も本当に綺麗。キスのみなのに、驚くほどの満足感。何度も読み返します！恋人になった後の2人を是非見たいです！！

It was pure love at its best! I naturally burst into tears. The picture is really beautiful too. Even though it's just a kiss, it's surprisingly satisfying. I read it over and over again! I definitely want to see them two after they become lovers!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

初々しいけど、涙も…

It's fresh, but tears too...

でます！作者さん買いです。鴇ちゃん、27歳だなんて詐欺でしょ笑　でも、すごく素敵な話でした。兄弟盛りだくさんで、それぞれのキャラが大好きです。家庭環境の事とか、ちょいちょい切なくて涙出ました！私もたくさん売れて、恋人編が出るのを待ってます〜！！

it will come out! The author is buying it. Ha-chan, being 27 years old is a scam lol, but it was a really nice story. There are lots of siblings, and I love each character. I burst into tears because I was a little sad about my home environment! It sold a lot too, and I'm waiting for the lover edition to come out!!

Helpful

Reviews for Starting to Fall in Love for the First Time Manga