Starting to Fall in Love for the First Time Manga Reviews (P.21)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

お兄ちゃんっ…

older brother...

苦労してきたお兄ちゃんがやっと報われてくれるようなお話だと思いました。27歳には見えないんだろうなという見た目の可愛さと、健気さがとツボですぐ好きになりました。弟くんの兄好きな感じもいいですし、なにより出会いからの距離感が好き…。表紙からもですがとにかく可愛くて癒されます。

I thought it was a story where my older brother, who had been struggling, would finally be rewarded. I immediately fell in love with it because of how cute it looked, and how healthy it was, and pressure points, that I probably wouldn't look like a 27-year-old. The feeling that my younger brother likes my older brother is also nice, and above all, I like the sense of distance from when we met... Even though it's from the cover, it's just so cute and soothing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

シーズン2爆裂希望！！！！

I hope season 2 explodes!!!

凄く､凄く良かった！！！！キュンキュンきました！！！！萌え悶えました！！！！何この可愛い27才は！！！！鴇ちゃん撫でくり回したい位可愛かった！！！！そして！全く擦れてない芸能人の尭良くん｡続編を！！！！続編をお願いしたいです！！！！余談ですが最後の方の担当さんとのやり取りが面白かった！！！！(*´艸｀*)

That was really, really good!!! it's here!!!! I'm in agony!!! What is this cute 27 year old!!! Ka-chan was so cute that I wanted to stroke her around!!! and! An entertainer with no friction at all, Takaya-kun. A sequel!!! I'd like to ask for a sequel!!! As an aside, the interaction with the person in charge at the end was interesting!!! (*'｀*)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

お兄ちゃん、とにかくかわいい

My older brother is just cute

This review contains spoilers. 27歳で高校入学した、お兄ちゃん。ちょっと似たシチュエーションのコミック、他にもあったような気がするな〜と思いながらも、すぐに引き込まれました。お母さん、自分さえよければいいのかよ…これからは自分の人生を生きて、というのさえ、それまで家族ひとすじだったお兄ちゃんには「家族の願い」なんだよね…あんな毒親（母）環境で育ってきたにも関わらず、お兄ちゃんがほんとピュアで泣けます。ほんとの、自分だけの幸せ見つけて欲しいと願いながら読みました。オススメです！

This review contains spoilers. My older brother entered high school at age 27. Even though I felt like there were other comics with slightly similar situations, I was immediately drawn in. Mom, should I just be good with myself... even living my own life from now on is a “family wish” for my older brother, who had always been a family member... Despite growing up in such a toxic parent (mother) environment, my older brother is really pure and makes me cry. I read it while hoping that I could really find my own happiness. I recommend it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

いやいやいや！

No, no, no!

作者様買いです！先生！物足りないなんてないですよぉ〜！！鴇ちゃん可愛い！頑張り屋、素直、お兄ちゃん！ピュアが嫌味じゃなくキュンです！タカラ君も良き！兄弟の絡みもまだ見たいし恋人編行きましょ！楽しみに待ってます！

The author is buying it! teacher! there's nothing that isn't enough!! Hajim-chan is cute! Hard working, honest, big brother! Pure isn't disgusting; it's awesome! Takara is good too! I still want to watch Sibling Entanglement, so let's go to the lover section! I'm looking forward to it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

メチャクチャよかった

That was insanely good

This review contains spoilers. 初めての作者さんだったんですが、表紙に惹かれて読んでみたらメチャクチャよかったです！絵柄もそうですが、鴇ちゃんは可愛いし、尭良はカッコイイし、2人の優しくてあたたかい雰囲気だったり、初々しさだったり…。読んでて胸がきゅーんとしました。鴇ちゃん兄弟のものすごい仲の良さもホント素敵です。幸せになってほしい人たちがいっぱい。読み終わったばかりですが、すぐ続編ほしいくらいです。恋人編をぜひともお願いしたい！期待して待ってます！

This review contains spoilers. It was my first time to write it, and I was fascinated by the cover and was so glad I read it! As is the case with the design, Ka-chan is cute, Takayoshi is cool, and the two of them have a kind and warm atmosphere, and they are fresh... I was thrilled when I read it. The incredible closeness between the Hajim-chan siblings is also really wonderful. There are lots of people who want them to be happy. I've just finished reading it, and I want a sequel soon. I definitely want to ask for the lover edition! I'm looking forward to it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 08, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

めっちゃほわほわする

I'm so fuming

This review contains spoilers. なんだこれ心がポカポカする……優しいお話だ……。すごくピュアで、絵柄も可愛くて、でも内容が深くて惹き込まれました。一気に読んでしまった。続きめっちゃ読みたいです。続いて欲しい！！

This review contains spoilers. Why is this heartwarming... it's a kind story... It was so pure, and the design was cute, but the content was so deep that I was drawn to it. I read it all at once. I really want to read more. I want it to continue!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 07, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絵がきれい！

The picture is beautiful!

お話ももちろんいいのですが絵柄が大好き！小動物みたいな受はかわいさを濃縮したみたいなフワフワ感でこれはみんな好きになっちゃうよ！攻め様はとにかくめちゃくちゃかっこいい･･･ふとした瞬間の憂い顔とか最高に素敵で、失礼ですが暮田先生てこんなにお上手だった！？て思ってしまいました。何度も読んでます。買ってよかった！

Of course the story is good, but I love the design! Everyone will fall in love with the squishy feel like they've concentrated their cuteness! Attack-sama is just insanely cool... his sad face at an accidental moment is so wonderful, and it's rude, but Kureta sensei was this good!? That made me think. I read it over and over again. I'm glad I bought it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絶対続編欲しい

I definitely want a sequel

This review contains spoilers. ここにきて暮田先生のこんなにも初々しい作品が見れるなんて！毒気が一切ない…ピュアっピュアな恋〜！（悶える）ちょっと人生諦めモードの顔が良い俳優の尭良と、27歳にして高校に通う全面癒し系の鴇ちゃんの初恋話。中学の頃に父親が他界してから4人の弟と母親を支えるべく自分のことは後回しにして頑張ってた鴇ちゃんが、やっと自由になったので兄弟達に背中を押されてやりたい事をしだすんだけど、急に手を離れていく家族にどこか寂しさや孤独を抱く微少な感情の揺れが切ないです。こういう描き方相変わらず上手いな〜と、ただの初恋ピュア話じゃないところがグッときますね！甘えられる事が苦でもないし、頼られるのも好きだから無理してるわけではなけど…「寂しい」って尭良に言えたのは鴇ちゃんにとって最大の甘えではないかと。兄弟一同思うであろう感情が私にも乗り移ってくる…鴇ちゃんを大事にしてやってくれ〜！笑。兄弟達が鴇ちゃん取り合いっこしてるのも和むし可愛い。尭良は絶対スパダリになりますので、続編でその部分を読みたいと願うばかり。そしてキスから先も、いつか…期待。あと、カバーイラストについて、担当さんと先生がやりとりしてる解説が笑っちゃいました。担当さんとデザイナーさんが先生の表紙に異議申し立てしてるところがおかしくて「初恋とは…？」と困惑しつつ押されてる先生がツボでした。

This review contains spoilers. I can't believe I can see Kureta-sensei's works so fresh when you come here! There's no poison at all... pure pure love~! This is the first love story between Akira, an actor who has a good face in the (agony) mode of giving up on life, and a completely healed girl who goes to high school at age 27. Since her father passed away in middle school, Ka-chan, who put herself on the back burner and did her best to support her 4 younger brothers and mother, is finally free, so the siblings push her back and start doing what she wants, but the slight trembling of feelings of loneliness and loneliness in a family that suddenly leaves her hands is sad. It's amazing that this isn't just a pure Hatsukoi story because they're still as good as ever in this way of drawing! Being spoiled isn't a pain, and I don't overdo it because I like being relied upon... I think being able to say “I'm lonely” to Jingliang is probably the greatest indulgence for Ka-chan. Feelings that all my siblings would have felt are being transferred to me too... take care of Ka-chan! lol. The fact that the siblings are fighting over Ka-chan is also so cute. Akira will definitely be Spadari, so I just hope to read that part in the sequel. And even after the kiss, I hope someday... Also, the explanation exchanged between the person in charge and the teacher about the cover illustration made me laugh. The fact that the person in charge and the designer are objecting to the teacher's cover is strange and “what is first love...?” The teacher, who was puzzled and being pushed, had pressure points.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ピュア～

Pure~

あまずっぱい………いまどきめずらしいくらい(？)ピュアなお話でした。2人の関係はまだまだこれからだと思うので、続き楽しみです！！

so awful... so rare these days (?) It was a pure story. I think the relationship between the two is still a long way off, so I'm looking forward to continuing it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ぴゅあっぴゅあ！

PURE PURE!

ぴゅあっ！ものすっごくぴゅあです！ぴゅあっぴゅあの、きらっきらです。鴇ちゃんが可愛すぎて癒されました。兄弟たちとの場面も可愛らしくて好きでした。あとがきの初恋についての件で最後に笑わせてもらいました笑

huh! It's sooo cute! PURE PURE, it's sparkling. I was healed by the fact that Ha-chan was so cute. I also liked the scene with my siblings because it was so cute. The afterword about first love made me laugh at the end lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

大人と青年の初めてがたくさんて3150

There are a lot of firsts for adults and adolescents 3150

This review contains spoilers. とても良い作品でした！！鴇ちゃんの感情めっちゃ私個人としては大好きです。頼られるのが嬉しいとかすごくわかるなと。わたしもこんな優しい大人になりたいと思いました。たからくんとの関係もベリグｯｯでした！今後どのようなお話が広がるのかを考えるともう妄想が止まらないです。とても素晴らしい作品を作ってくださってありがとうございました。また、次の恋人編が公開できるよう応援しています(_ _)

This review contains spoilers. It was a very good work!! As a person, I really love Kaku-chan's emotions. I really understand how happy it is to be relied upon. I also wanted to be such a kind adult. My relationship with Takara-kun was amazing too! I can't stop being delusional when I think about what kind of stories will unfold in the future. Thank you so much for making such a wonderful work. Also, I'm supporting the next lover edition so that it can be released (_ _)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

すごくピュアっピュアな可愛いお話し。

It's a very pure, pure, cute story.

This review contains spoilers. 鴇ちゃん可愛いすぎて、小石川兄弟可愛いすぎて可愛いが詰まったピュアな初恋BL。ジャンル少女漫画でもいいぐらい。攻めであろうタカラくんも見た目(翠が思ってる顔)に反してピュアなキャラで見た目とのギャップも良い。一見似合わない感じの2人だけど心に傷を持ってるからより惹かれたのかな。鴇ちゃんにはピュアピュアでいて欲しい。H要素が必須な方には向かないですね登場するキャラがみんな可愛いので小石川兄弟愛とのシーンをもっと絡めた今後の2人のお付き合いも見ていきたい！

This review contains spoilers. A pure first love BL filled with Ka-chan is too cute, and the Koishikawa brothers are too cute. It's enough even if it's a girls' manga genre. Takara-kun, who is probably attacking, is also a pure character contrary to her appearance (the face Midori thinks), and there is also a good gap between her appearance. They are two people who don't seem to be a good match at first glance, but they are probably more attracted to them because they are traumatized. I want Aki-chan to stay pure pure. It's not suitable for those who need the H element, right? All of the characters that appear are cute, so I'd like to take a look at their future relationships involving more scenes with Koishikawa Brotherly Love!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

特定保護生物決定！

Specific protected organisms decided!

This review contains spoilers. 作者様買いではありますが、X(twitter)で見かけて以降待ちに待った単行本。期待を裏切らないマキネ先生、そして最高でした。鴇ちゃんと尭良くん、それぞれの空いていたところを埋めていけるような出会いに自然と涙が。可愛いだけじゃなかった。それと、2人の可愛さに忘れそうになりますが、お母さんや小石川さんに少し苛立ったことも事実。お父さん亡くなって大変なのは仕方ない…そこで鴇ちゃんに頼りすぎず、子供産んだなら一緒に踏ん張れよ…と。小石川さん、お母さんとそういう関係になるなら、再婚したからじゃなく、もっと早くに鴇ちゃんを気づかってほしかった…都心の大邸宅、お金持ちじゃん。…そういうストーリーなので仕方ないにしても気になってしまって。だからこそ鴇ちゃんと尭良くんの初恋を見守りたい！そこで『シーズン2・恋人編』を是非に。即買いします。

This review contains spoilers. The author bought it, but it's a book I've been waiting for since I saw it on X (Twitter). Makine sensei did not disappoint, and it was awesome. Naturally, tears came from the encounter between Ka-chan and Takaya-kun, who were able to fill their vacant space. It wasn't just cute. Also, I almost forgot how cute they were, but it's also true that I was a little irritated by my mother and Koishikawa-san. It can't be helped that it's going to be difficult since Dad passed away... so don't rely too much on Ka-chan, and if you have a child, stand up together... If Koishikawa-san were to have that kind of relationship with her mother, I wanted them to notice Ka-chan sooner, not because they remarried... they are rich in a large mansion in the center of the city. ... it's that kind of story, so I was curious even if I had no choice. That's why I want to keep an eye on Ka-chan and Takayaka-kun's first love! So be sure to check out “Season 2: Lovers Edition.” I will buy it right away.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

もっとください

More please

好きな作家さんが推していたので読んでみた。読んで良かった、かわいい、初々しい、キュンとした。鴇ちゃん、27歳ってウソでしょ。現役高校生でいける。家族がみんな仲良しで、鴇ちゃんの事が大好きっていうのは嬉しいが、もう少し昔の苦労話もほしいかな。読み終わって、続きはないのか？って思っているところに、作家さんと担当者さんの話…おもしろすぎる。全部持ってかれた。続きがほしいです。

My favorite writer recommended it, so I read it. I'm glad I read it, it was cute, fresh, and amazing. Ha-chan, being 27 years old is a lie, isn't it? I can go if I'm an active high school student. Everyone in the family is on good terms, and I'm happy that they love Hajim-chan, but I also want stories about hardships from a little longer ago. Have you finished reading it and there's no continuation? To the point where I think, the story between the writer and the person in charge... is too interesting. They took everything. I want it to continue.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ととと尊い

and to is precious

本当に尊い、ぜひ続編希望というか絶対でて！お願いします！久しぶりにBL漫画で泣きそうになりました、こんな作品をありがとうございます！心が洗われる〜！！！

It's really precious, I definitely hope for a sequel! please! It's been a long time since I almost cried with a BL comic, thank you so much! My heart is washed!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが読みたい

I want to read more

兄弟が多いって大変だなぁと思いました笑でも大きい子達はしっかりしていたので良しです笑完結してないのではやく続きが読みたいです

I thought it would be difficult to have a lot of siblings lol but the big kids were solid, so it's good lol it's not finished, so I want to read more soon

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

作者さん大好き

I love the author

受けが安定の可愛さ鴇ちゃん好きタカラくんの見た目もちょータイプでこのカプ最高！！表紙についての作者さんと担当さんのやり取りめっちゃウケた微笑ましい

Takara-kun, who has a stable reception and likes cuteness, looks a little type, and this is the best cap!! The exchange between the author and the person in charge about the cover was so funny and smiling

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

美しく尊い作品

A beautiful and precious work

はじめて、はじめました。というタイトルの中に、初恋の意味も込められているんだ、なるほど、それでこのタイトルか、と読み終えた時にあーピッタリだな！と思いました。可愛いくて強くて儚い存在の主人公と、めちゃくちゃイケメン(中身もイケメン)で可愛いところもあるヒーローに釘付けで、あっという間に読んでしまいました。読後感が非常に爽やかでそして温かいな、と。これは是非続編を作っていただきたいです。必ず買います！笑。はじめて拝見した作者様でしたが、これから他の作品も読ませていただこうと思います(^^)素敵な作品との出会いに感謝します☆

For the first time, I started. The meaning of first love is also included in the title, so I see, that's why it's perfect when I finish reading this title! I thought so. I was glued to the main character, who is cute, strong, and ephemeral, and the hero who is insanely handsome (inside is also a handsome guy) and has cute places, and I read it in no time. The feeling after reading it was very refreshing and warm. I definitely want you to make a sequel to this. I will definitely buy it! lol. It was the first time I saw the author, and I think I'll read other works from now on (^^) Thank you for coming across wonderful works ☆

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

感涙

Tears

読んだ後にじんわり涙出て、涙流れ続けて、心軽くなるって凄い作品読んでしまいました、先生の作品どれも読後が良いのでやめれません。

After reading it, I slowly burst into tears, and I read amazing works that made me feel at ease, and all of the teacher's works are good after reading, so I can't stop.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 03, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

19歳と27歳だと…？

19 and 27 years old...?

こんなﾋﾟｭｱｯﾋﾟｭｱなことある？！？！19歳と27歳ぞ？！？！ふたりとも特殊な環境下だったとはいえ、お盛んな年頃にこんな？！？！いや、まて…そうか…年齢は上としてもふたりとも高校生なんだもんな………初恋だもんな………はぁ………すきだ………。鴇ちゃんの長男ムーブたまらないし、たからくんの急にスイッチ入ってさらっとかっこいいのもたまらない………推すしかないcp…………。是非ら爆売れして！続編・恋人編を！ぜひ！

is there such a thing as vooo vooo?!?! 19 and 27 years old huh?!?! Even though they were both in a special environment, they were in such a thriving age?!?! No, wait... well... even though they're older, they're both high school students... it's their first love... huh... I like it... Moves are irresistible, and Takara-kun's sudden switch is irresistible, and being so cool is irresistible... I have no choice but to recommend CP... Be sure to sell it by all means! The sequel, Lover! by all means!

Helpful

Reviews for Starting to Fall in Love for the First Time Manga