Former Girl Idol, High School Hunk Manga Reviews

Lucie Nona

Report

Apr 23, 2025 (PST) | Total Reviews: 148

The first chapters...mixed feelings

I find the concept cute and can see the potential for great back story. I am not sure if I like it enough to keep reading. Will require a reread maybe I missed some. So read carefully and keep an open mind. The main lead character is a super cute fan boy which is very much fun to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 19, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

かっこよくなって再会

Be cool and meet again

This review contains spoilers. 大好きだったアイドルと、違うカタチだけど再会出来た。引退してからもずっと気になって、忘れられなかったから、嬉しさが滲み出てる。そして、本人に認められる。これは、嬉しすぎる。元アイドルはカッコよくなってるし、優しい。2人の関係がなんともかわいい。キュンキュンくる。推しのためならなんでも出来る〜積極性がすごい。可愛くて面白かったです。

This review contains spoilers. I was able to reunite with an idol I loved, albeit in a different form. I've been worried about it ever since I retired, and I haven't been able to forget it, so a sense of joy oozes out. Then, it is recognized by the person himself. I'm too happy about this. The former idol has become cool and kind. The relationship between the two is so cute. It's going to roll up. I can do anything for recommendation ~ The aggressiveness is amazing. It was cute and funny.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 25, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ひえ〜

Hie~

チカちゃん、、可愛くて怖くてかっっっこいい！！！推しがいる学校生活、周りは楽しい嬉しいけど、引退した本人は違うんだろうなって分かってたけど、伊織相手だと本音出ちゃうのたまらん

Chika-chan is cute, scary, and so cool!!! School life requires recommendations, and the surroundings are fun and happy, but I knew that the person who retired would be different, but it's unbearable that they would show their true intentions when it was Iori's partner

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 21, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

早めに転がったー。

It rolled early.

いいよねー、姿変わってもわかってくれるの。推しから恋。疑ってたのにあっという間に絆されて。。大好きが散りばめられていて良い。言葉の端々もかわいい。

That's great, they understand even if they change their appearance. Love from a guess. Even though I had doubts, they were bonded in no time.. It's nice to have my favorite things scattered around. The ends of the words are cute too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛い

pretty

受けが少女漫画みたいな見た目かもと思いましたが、可愛いので大丈夫です。身長差も好きなので、サクサクよめる

I thought it might look like a girls' comic, but it's fine because it's cute. I also like height differences, so it's easy to read

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 10, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

何度も読んでいます

I've read it many times

水瀬くんがすごく良い味を出していて、ホントに可愛いです。たまにギャグぽいとことかクスッと笑えるし、ここのところ、暇さえあれば読み返しています。最終回になってしまってもうこれ以上供給ないの？！と涙目になっています。どうかどうか、もっとラブい2人を見せてください！！ツンデレな千景くんのデレをもっともっと見たいです！！！！どうか！！

Minase-kun has a really good taste and is really cute. Sometimes it makes me laugh like a gag, and so far, I've been rereading it when I have free time. It's the last round and there won't be any more supplies?! My eyes are in tears. Please show me 2 more adorable people!! I want to see more and more of Chikage-kun the tsundere!!!! please!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

何もかも好きです

I like everything

この作者さんの絵は、人物がとてもきれいで大好きです。主人公の伊織くんは、性格も顔もとても可愛いくて、今まで読んだBL作品の中でも、一番目か二番目に好きな主人公です。攻め(？)のチカちゃんも、かっこよくて大好きです。内容はほのぼのとした感じで、疲れ時に読んで癒されてます。何もかもよいです。

I love this artist's paintings because the characters are so beautiful. The main character, Iori-kun, has a very cute personality and face, and is my first or second favorite main character among BL works I've read so far. attack (?) I love Chica-chan because she's cool too. The content is heartwarming, and I am healed by reading it when I'm tired. Everything is good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

とにかく最高!!

Anyway, it's awesome!!

This review contains spoilers. 受けの水瀬くんがまじで可愛くてアイドルのチカちゃん一筋なのもこれまた良くていい!!!あと水瀬くんの顔がかわいい!!幼少期の頃の顔とかマジ可愛くて「やっぱ受けっていいなぁw」って思ったし、すごい面白いのでみんなにぜひ見てもらいたいです！

This review contains spoilers. The fact that Minase-kun is really cute and the idol Chika-chan is a fan is also nice!!! Also, Minase-kun's face is so cute!! The face from when I was a child was really cute and I thought “it's okay to take it after all lol,” and it's really interesting, so I definitely want everyone to take a look at it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

後輩(攻め)→→→→→←←先輩(受け)期

Juniors (attack) →→→→→←←Senpai (acceptance) expectations!

This review contains spoilers. 元アイドルの攻めくんの正体に気づいた受けくん(先輩)が距離を縮めようと頑張るお話。今のところ受けくんが攻めくんのこと大大大大大大大好きで一方通行な感じです(笑)攻めくんはそれをあまりよく思っていない？様子でしたが、受けくんにだけは素のまま接することも出来ているようだし、最新話(現在3巻まで)でちょっと先輩の株が上がった感じするので、このまま順調に距離を縮めていって、最終的には後輩くんのが先輩大好きラブラブラブ！！愛激重！！！みたいな展開になって欲しいです！！続きがとても楽しみです！

This review contains spoilers. This is a story about Kakume-kun (senior), who realizes the true identity of the former idol Attack-kun, and works hard to shorten the distance. So far, I love Attack-kun very, very much, and it feels like it's a one-way street (laughs) Attack-kun doesn't think that very well? As it seemed, it seemed like they were able to treat only Otaki-kun as they are, and I feel that Senpai's stock has risen slightly in the latest episode (currently up to 3 volumes), so the distance was steadily shortened, and in the end, Junior-kun is Lovable Love, who loves Senpai!! Love is so heavy!!! I want it to unfold like that! I'm really looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 13, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

表紙が良い?

is the cover good?

絵がとても見やすく良かったです。主人公たちがカッコいいやら、可愛いやらで、とても萌えでした。(ﾉ≧▽≦)ﾉ

It was nice that the picture was very easy to see. The main characters were cool and cute, and they were so cute. (≥▽≤)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

その人は…。

that person...

This review contains spoilers. 憧れの元アイドル(かもしれない)人が同じ学校にいたら…まぁ気持ちを伝えたくなるのも無理はないか。こっそり隠れて覗き見る(！)楽しみもあると思いますが笑

This review contains spoilers. If the former idol (maybe) you admire is in the same school... well, isn't it unreasonable to want to express your feelings? Secretly hide and take a peek (!) I think it's fun too lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 09, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

これから

From now on

いきなり正体突き止めていてすごいなと感心笑展開は?なところはありますがこれからどうなるか気になります。絵がきれい

I'm impressed that it's amazing to suddenly find out the true identity lol what happened? There are a few things, but I'm curious about what will happen in the future. The picture is beautiful

Helpful

Reviews for Former Girl Idol, High School Hunk Manga