When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

妖精の悪戯

Fairy prank

This review contains spoilers. 妖精の悪戯で赤子の頃に貴族の赤子と入れ替えられて育った令嬢がタイトル通りの目に遭うお話です。ただタイトルだと婚約者に捨てられるって印象ですが、捨てたのは貴族で偽りの家族だった家族の方で、婚約者であるエドはアンナに対して特別な想いを残しているところが良かったです。次期辺境伯と庶民…身分差が切なく、二人の恋の行方が気になります。既刊が非常に気になるところで終わっているので新刊が待ち遠しいです。

This review contains spoilers. As the title suggests, it's a story about a young lady who grew up being replaced by a baby from an aristocrat when she was a baby due to fairy pranks. However, when it comes to the title, I have the impression that it will be abandoned by my fiancee, but it was a family member who was an aristocrat and a false family, and it was nice that Ed, who is his fiancee, left a special feeling for Anna. The next frontier Haku and the common man... the status difference is sad, and I'm worried about the whereabouts of their love. It ended at a point where I'm very concerned about the previous publication, so I can't wait for the new publication.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

小さいデルタはキョリ

What is a small delta

他人から決められた役割から自分を解放して、生きたいように生きるというのは現代社会においても未だ実現していないことであるが、それに果敢に挑んでいるのが本作であろうか。それは我々の未来をうらなうものであるとおもう。

Freeing oneself from roles determined by others and living as one would like to live is something that has not yet been realized even in modern society, but I wonder if this work boldly challenges that. I think that makes us jealous of our future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

読み進めるとすごく魅力的なお話になります

It becomes a very fascinating story as you read on

This review contains spoilers. 5巻読了。巻数が増すごとに面白くなる作品です。ただ、タイトルはいただけません！流行りの言葉で誘う感じがあざといし、内容と合っていません。『チェンジリングで過酷な運命を辿る二人』が主軸なのだから、それに見合ったタイトルにして欲しかったと強く思います。庶民だったのに貴族として育てられたが、癒しの魔法が使えない為、両親の愛には恵まれなかった「アンナ」。貴族の証（ｱｶｼ）金髪碧眼だった為、父親から疎まれ居場所がなかった「アネット」。イタズラ妖精の気まぐれで、生まれを取り替えられてしまうという運命に晒され、与えられた環境で、逞しく生きていこうとする二人。まず、「アンナ」視点から物語は動き始めますが、「アネット」視点でも紡がれます。そして貴族の兄視点、庶民の弟たち視点、庶民の母、そして5巻に出てくる庶民の父視点、婚約者だった「エドモンド」視点と、それぞれの立場から、この辛いコトの顛末が語られます。「クリュー」という、チェンジリングをした妖精ではなく、それを見ていた妖精が、コトが明らかになる一年前にやってきて「アンナ」に真実を告げるのですが、真実を知ってしまった彼女は、家族に告げる事に葛藤します。今、恵まれている全てを手放さなければならないから。唯一優しかった兄の愛情を失ってしまうから・・・。だからこそ、2巻の兄の断罪は辛かった！これまでの異世界モノは、どんなに断罪されようとも、ソレは真実では無く冤罪だったからまだよかった。でも本作で、兄に指摘された事柄は、アンナにとって言い訳のできないモノだったから。再会を喜ぶ貴族家の人たちの姿を遠くで茫然と見ていた彼女は、そのまま置き去りにされてしまう。このシーンはものすごく辛い場面でした。そして、それを乗り越えてのその後の展開。貴族として生きた矜持が、人柄の良さが、それからのアンナを助けます。クリューという妖精の謎、アネットの淡い想い・・等々、そして結ばれる事のない貴族と庶民の立場の元婚約者との関係。お話がどうなっていくのか気になります。

This review contains spoilers. I've read volume 5. It is a work that becomes interesting as the number of volumes increases. However, titles are not accepted! The feeling of inviting with popular words is ridiculous, and it doesn't match the content. Since “Two People Who Follow a Harsh Fate in the Changeling” is the main focus, I strongly want the title to be commensurate with that. Even though she was a common man, “Anna” was raised as an aristocrat, but since she couldn't use healing magic, she wasn't blessed with the love of her parents. “Annette” had no place because she had blond hair and blue eyes (proof of nobility), so she was estranged from her father. They are two people who are exposed to the fate of being replaced due to the whim of mischievous fairies, and they try to live well in a given environment. First, the story starts from the “Anna” point of view, but it is also spun from the “Annette” point of view. Then, the details of this painful matter are discussed from the standpoint of an aristocrat's older brother, the common man's younger brothers, the common man's mother, and the common man's father's point of view appearing in volume 5, and the viewpoint of “Edmond,” who was his fiancee. It's not the fairy called “Crew,” who was watching it, and the fairy who was watching it came a year before the incident was revealed and told the truth to “Anna,” but once she knew the truth, she struggled to tell her family. Because I have to let go of everything I'm blessed with right now. Because I'm losing the love of my older brother, who was the only kind... That's why it was so hard to condemn my older brother in volume 2! Up until now, no matter how condemned, things from another world were still good because they weren't true and were false charges. But the things pointed out by my older brother in this film were inexcusable for Anna. She looked blankly in the distance at the sight of people from the aristocracy happy to be reunited, and was left behind as it was. This scene was extremely painful. Then, after overcoming that, it unfolded thereafter. Her pride in living as an aristocrat and her good personality will help Anna from then on. The mystery of the fairy called Crew, Annette's faint feelings... etc., and the relationship between an untied aristocrat and her former fiancee in the position of a common man. I'm curious to see how the story will go.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 17, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

悪戯妖精…イタズラが過ぎる?

mischievous fairy... too much prank?

おもしろい〜!!!「貴族から庶民へ」の意味が、まさかの妖精の悪戯による赤子取り替えとか、可哀想すぎる境遇。。。ヒロインと妖精の関係とか、取り替えられたもう一人の子とか、婚約者との関係、侯爵家兄との関係、血縁の家族との関係、それぞれに考えさせられるし、先の展開も気になるし、今出てるとこまでどんどん読み進めました。魔法の描写があまり細かくないというか、魔法よりストーリー重視かな？なのでそこは少し物足りないようにも感じますが、魔法の種類もストーリーに大きく関わってるので、それも面白いポイントです。最初は元侯爵令嬢がもちろん中心に話が進むけど、取り替えが表沙汰になってからはもう一人の子もグイグイ出てきて、「あれ、どっちが主人公？」ってくらいこの子も強く活躍してくれそうな感じなので、ますます面白くなってきそう！今後にも期待です！

That's interesting~!! The meaning of “from aristocrats to common people” is a situation that is too pathetic, such as a baby being replaced due to an unexpected fairy trick.. It made me think about the relationship between the heroine and the fairy, the other child who was replaced, the relationship with her fiancee, the relationship with the Marquise's brother, and the relationship with the family blood relatives, each made me think, and I was worried about future developments, so I read more and more until it came out now. The depiction of magic isn't very detailed, or is the story more important than magic? So I feel like that's a bit unsatisfactory, but the types of magic also have a lot to do with the story, so that's also an interesting point. At first, of course, the story revolves around the former marquise's daughter, but after the replacement was revealed, the other child also came out loud and asked, “Huh, which one is the main character?” I feel like this kid is also going to be very active, so it seems like it's getting more and more interesting! I'm looking forward to the future!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 15, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

いいね！

That's great!

This review contains spoilers. 絵がとてもきれいに描かれており、見ているだけで楽しいです。話も面白く読みやすいので、この先どうなるのか続きが気になります。

This review contains spoilers. The pictures are so beautifully drawn, and it's fun just to look at them. The story is also interesting and easy to read, so I'm curious about what will happen in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 09, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

身分差を超えるための理性に惹かれる物語

A story drawn to reason to overcome differences in status

老眼になって諦めたマンガを紙ではない電子書籍という神に助けられ、再び漫画の世界に帰ってきたら、寄る年波か度のマンガも同じに作者？と思えるほど似てる。っていうのは初期の感想で今では作者様ごとの分別はできるけれど、今作は確かに違い、その違いに読むのを躊躇したほど特徴的。でも原作を膨らました7コミカライズに引き込まれ読んだらもう面白い！チェンジングで貴族から庶民になった幸せ「じゃない方」が主人公....妖精の助けはあるものの数々の困難に冷静に立ち向かう勇者ヒロインがいい?そしてその陰にいる貴族兄さまの動きがとっても気になるので続巻を至急お願いまします。

When the manga you gave up on due to presbyopia was saved by the god called e-books that aren't paper, and when you come back to the comic world, did you write the same manga that is close to the year waves? They're so similar that you think. That was my initial impression, and now I can sort each author, but this work is certainly different, and it's so characteristic that I hesitated to read it because of that difference. But it's already interesting when I read it when I was drawn into the original 7 Comicalization! The main character is the happy “not one” who went from being an aristocrat to a common man due to changes... would you like a brave heroine who calmly confronts numerous difficulties even though there is help from fairies? And I'm very concerned about the movements of the aristocrat older brother behind that, so please do the next volume as soon as possible.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 08, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

迷っていた作品

The work I was lost about

コミックを購入しようか、迷っていた作品です。まだ、冒頭部分しか読んでいませんが、妖精ってカワイイ存在のはずなのに、悪戯にしては酷いことをするな…と思いました。皆さまの評価では、これからも試練がありそうな感じなので、怖いです。

This is a work I was wondering if I should buy the comic. I've only read the beginning, but I thought fairies are supposed to be cute, so don't do terrible things as a joke... According to everyone's evaluations, it feels like there will be trials in the future, so it's scary.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

続きを楽しみにしている作品

Works I'm looking forward to continuing

タイトルが内容にあっていないという意見には賛成します。が、そんなこと気にならないくらい面白いです。それぞれの立場での想いが丁寧に描かれていて、グッときます。待っているのは絶望だけかと思いきや、そうでもないたくましさと明るさ。アンナがこれから人生をどう切り拓いていくのか、楽しみです。

I agree with the opinion that the title doesn't match the content. But it's so interesting that I don't care about that. Feelings from each position are carefully drawn, and it's amazing. I thought all that was waiting was hopelessness, but that wasn't the case, so strong and bright. I'm excited to see how Anna will carve out her life in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

解消系

Solution system

This review contains spoilers. 貴族からの婚約解消で平民落ちになった令嬢が孤独のグルメでありそうな店を開いて変体貴族の舌を唸らせます。存在感のあるグルメ庶民の店なので見ていて飯テロに感じがあって良かったという感じです。

This review contains spoilers. The daughter, who became commonplace due to the dissolution of her engagement from the aristocrat, opens a restaurant that seems to be a lonely gourmet and makes the tongues of the mutant aristocrat groan. It's a gourmet restaurant with a strong presence for the common people, so I'm glad I was watching it because it felt like a food attack.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 02, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

妖精が出てくるファンタジー

A fantasy where fairies appear

This review contains spoilers. 前半は胸が痛くなるシーンがありますが、登場人物それぞれに過去を振り返るシーンがあるのでその行動にも納得できる部分もあります。ヒロインのアンナよりも、もう一人のヒロインのアネットの方がしっかりしているようで先が気になります。目次にヒロインの年齢が記載されているのが分かりやすくて良いですね。続きも楽しみにしています！

This review contains spoilers. There is a heart-wrenching scene in the first half, but since there is a scene where each character looks back on the past, there are parts where I'm satisfied with their actions. The other heroine, Annette, seems to be more solid than the heroine Anna, so I'm worried about the future. It's nice that the age of the heroine is listed in the table of contents so it's easy to understand. I'm looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

各々の思惑に感動が離れた人も戻ってみて

People who were moved by their own speculations also go back

This review contains spoilers. １巻でめげて読んでなかったくちです。お兄ちゃんその手のひら返しはないわときっと読みやめた大方の人が思ってる。けどそれは思惑あってのことらしい。それでも傷つけるやり様はもう少し違う言い方はなかったのか‥と思いますが。ダブルヒロイン。アネットはきついもの言いに見えてそれにも訳はあったのですね、３巻頭で見えてくるものがあります。元？婚約者さまのエドもなかなか見込みのある人なのもいい。

This review contains spoilers. I didn't want to read volume 1. Most people who just stopped reading it think that older brother can't turn the palm of his hand. But that seems to have been due to speculation. Even so, I don't think there was a slightly different way to say how to hurt someone... Double heroine. Annette seemed like a tough statement, and there was a translation for that too, and there is something you can see at the beginning of chapter 3. yuan? It's also nice that my fiancee, Ed, is also someone who has quite a few prospects.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

This review contains spoilers. 運命の悪戯というか、妖精の悪戯なんだけど、こんな残酷な境遇でもアンナとアネットがとても前向きで頑張っていて、すごく素敵です。アネットもアンナも幸せになって欲しい！

This review contains spoilers. It's a joke of fate, or rather, a fairy prank, but even in such a cruel situation, Anna and Annette are very positive and working hard, which is really wonderful. I want both Annette and Anna to be happy!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

好きな作品のひとつ

One of my favorite works

最初の頃は、妖精って……貴族って何なのよー！ってイライラしたけど、話が進むにつれアンナが頼もしくて応援せずにはいられない作品です。どんな結末を迎えるのか今後が楽しみです。

At the beginning, fairies... what are aristocrats! It was frustrating, but as the story progressed, Anna was so reliable that I couldn't help but cheer for it. I'm looking forward to seeing what kind of ending it will have.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 22, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

チートな能力もなく、ハーレムもなく、巨大な胸もなく、キチンとしたストーリーのもと上手い絵で描かれていて6巻まで読みましたが、とても面白く続きが待ち遠しいです。

There are no cheat abilities, no harems, no huge breasts, and it's drawn with good pictures based on a sharp story, and I've read up to 6 volumes, but it's so interesting and I can't wait to continue.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 18, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

一癖も二癖も！

One habit and two habits too!

This review contains spoilers. ただの貴族令嬢ものとは一味違います！！ストーリー構成、キャラクターの掘り下げ、申し分ないです。とっても面白い。

This review contains spoilers. It's a bit different from just being an aristocrat's daughter!! The story structure and the depth of the characters are perfect. It's very interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

何とか耐えてください！

Please bear with it somehow!

何とか耐えてください！一巻二巻は確かに酷いと思います。でも耐えてくだされば、面白い漫画読めたなと思えます。クソ兄貴は嫌いなままだけれど、嫌いな人間は嫌いなままでも私は読めました。何よりも女子がとってもいい！最高です！入れ替わっていた2人とも、とても頑張り屋さんで素敵なキャラクターです。ちなみに原作小説は完結してます！後日談が更新されてないだけなので物語のラストは読めます。おすすめです。

Please bear with it somehow! I think volume 1 volume 2 is definitely terrible. But if you persevere, I think I was able to read an interesting comic. I was able to read it even though I didn't like Damn Big Brother, but I didn't like The People I Hate. Above all else, girls are so nice! It's awesome! Both of the two people who were replaced are wonderful characters who work very hard. By the way, the original novel is complete! It's just that the story hasn't been updated at a later date, so I can read the last part of the story. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になります

I'm worried about the continuation

夢中になって一気読みしました…アンナもアネットも、2人の気持ちを考えると涙が出てきました。最後幸せになって欲しいです

I got carried away and read it all at once... Anna and Annette both burst into tears when they thought about their feelings. I want them to be happy at the end

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 12, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

読み進めていきたい

I want to read on

一巻で暗い気持ちになりくじけそうになったのですがレビュー見て二巻買いました。どちらもイイ子；；どちらも幸せになってほしい。

The first volume made me feel dark and almost discouraged, but I read the reviews and bought two volumes. They are both good kids;; I want them both to be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

ちょこちょこ泣けてくる

It makes me cry here and there

This review contains spoilers. 今、３巻まで読みましたがちょいちょい泣けるお話元兄や元婚約者が元妹想いの人で良かったですそしてメインの女の子二人(令嬢と庶民がすり替えられてたって話です)がどちらも逞しく頑張ってるのが、どちらも応援できるし、素直で憎めない

This review contains spoilers. Now, I've read up to 3 volumes, but I'm glad the former brother and former fiancee are people who have feelings for their former sister, and the two main girls (it's a story where a daughter and a common man were replaced) are both doing their best, and I can support them both, and they're honest and can't hate

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 07, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

ストーリーが寝られており実に面白い。絵も綺麗だしちょっと男性向けくさいなと思ったら少年まんが書いてる方だったようで。最近こう言うの流行りなのでしょうかね？ひとまず一気読みしました。続きが気になる作品です。

The story is sleeping, and it's really interesting. The pictures are beautiful, and when I thought they were a bit bad for men, it seemed like they were writing shonen manga. I wonder if it's popular to say this lately? I read it all at once. I'm worried about the continuation of this work.

Helpful

Reviews for When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga