When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga Reviews (P.10)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

泣ける

I can cry

This review contains spoilers. ヒロインが、いろいろと苦しいことや、つらいめにあっていて、かわいそうだと思ってしまいました。泣けるストーリーだと思います。

This review contains spoilers. I felt sorry for the heroine because she was in so much pain and suffering. I think it's a story that makes you cry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 17, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

けなげなヒロイン

Naughty heroine

ご都合物語ではなく結構シビアでびっくり。でも頑張るヒロインが可愛くて応援したくなります。ヒロインが幸せになるといいなー

It's not a convenient story; I was surprised that it was quite severe. But the heroine who works hard is so cute that I want to cheer for her. I hope the heroine is happy

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 12, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

せつない

It's annoying

This review contains spoilers. ２巻まで読みました。全体的にせつない雰囲気のストーリーで、悲しくなる場面もありました。でも、そういう話が好きなので、面白いと思いました。３巻も読みたいです。

This review contains spoilers. I've read up to 2 volumes. The story had an overall tense atmosphere, and there were also scenes that made me sad. But I liked that kind of story, so I thought it was interesting. I also want to read volume 3.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 12, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

妖精て悪戯するの

Do fairies play pranks

そもそも貴族と平民の赤ちゃんをどうやってすり替えたんでしょうね、妖精とはいえ。乙女ゲーの残酷選択のような、どんなストーリー展開が待ってるのでしょう。

How did they replace babies between aristocrats and commoners in the first place, albeit a fairy. What kind of storyline awaits, like Cruel Choice in Otome Game?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

なりゆきまかせ

Leave it up to Nariyuki

This review contains spoilers. アンナも被害者なわけだし…何よりまだ子供なんだし、貴族の家族たち酷い！ってなるけど、私は甘ったれで流されやすいアンナより、逆境でもしっかり自分の運命を切り開いていく、アネットのようなタイプが好き。妖精やヒーローがアンナのどこに惹かれるのかわからない。作者、最初はアンナも学園に入学させて、アネットを意地悪キャラにする予定だったんじゃないかな。

This review contains spoilers. Anna is also a victim... and above all else, she's still a child, and the aristocrat families are terrible! But I like the type like Annette who carves out her own destiny even in the face of adversity rather than Anna, who is sweet and easily swept away. I don't know what attracts fairies and heroes to Anna. I think the author initially planned to enroll Anna in the academy and make Annette a mean character.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

いろいろ勉強になります

I'm going to learn a lot

This review contains spoilers. この作品は、名門の上級貴族に生まれながら容姿のせいで貴族界から追い出され一気に平凡な庶民になった女性が妖精と庶民としての奮闘を描いたものです。わたしは読んでみて、お嬢様育ちの方にこの本を読んで、庶民も負けずに頑張っていますと言いたくなりました。

This review contains spoilers. This work depicts the struggles of a woman who was born into a prestigious high-ranking aristocrat but was driven out of the aristocracy due to her appearance and became an ordinary commoner all at once, struggling as a fairy and common man. I read it, read this book to people who grew up as young ladies, and it made me want to say that the common people are doing their best without losing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 09, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公に救いが欲しい

I want the hero to be saved

This review contains spoilers. 最初の主人公の立場が可哀想すぎたので、幸せになって欲しいです！周り(貴族)の態度にイラッと、兄や元婚約者の行動にモヤッとしながらもヒロイン２人が頑張っていく姿に惹き込まれます。もう一人のヒロインの性格がこのまま良い子であることを願います…！狂った妖精許すまじ！！

This review contains spoilers. The initial protagonist's position was so pitiful, so I want him to be happy! I'm annoyed by the attitude of those around me (aristocrats), and I'm drawn to the sight of the two heroines doing their best even though they are puzzled by the actions of their older brother and ex-fiance. I hope the other heroine continues to have a good personality...! I really forgive the crazy fairy!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

貴族から庶民

From aristocrats to commoners

This review contains spoilers. タイトル通り、赤ちゃんのころに、貴族の子どもと庶民の子どもが取り違えられてしまったというお話です。貴族から庶民になったので、婚約を解消されるというのは、少しかわいそうだと思ってしまいましたが、おもしろかったです。

This review contains spoilers. As the title suggests, it's a story about children of aristocrats and children of common people being mistaken when they were babies. I went from being an aristocrat to a common man, so I thought it would be a bit pitiful to have my engagement dissolved, but it was interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

チェンジリング

changeling

This review contains spoilers. 取り替え子のお話を読んだのはこれで二作目。一つ目は高遠砂夜作の純情少年物語シリーズ(こちらは人為的に)。今回は女の子だし恋愛色強めで表現もマイルドなので、一つ目と違いサラッと読めました。絵柄は正直好み分かれると思う。私は小説からなのでストーリー思い出し程度の流し読みなので平気でした。

This review contains spoilers. This is the second time I've read the Sukeko story. The first one is the Junjo Shonen Monogatari series by Takato Saya (this one is artificial). This time it's a girl, has a strong sense of romance, and her expressions are mild, so unlike the first one, I was able to read it smoothly. To be honest, I think there are people who like the design. I started with a novel, so I was fine because it was just a fluke that reminded me of the story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

なんか腑に落ちない

Something doesn't make sense

This review contains spoilers. ストーリーは好きです。途中からとは言え逆境に負けず頑張る子は大好き。しかし、題名にある庶民になったから婚約解消の路線から大幅にズレているような、、。元兄と親のあの態度、ムカつく〜。15年も一緒に過ごしていて、真実をヒロインが知ったのもちょっと前のこと。それを泥棒でも見るかのような顔になるなんて可哀想過ぎる。でも、全く元婚約者は出てこないんですよね。後から出てきてめでたしーとかならないかな？

This review contains spoilers. I love the story. I love kids who work hard without succumbing to adversity, even if they start halfway through. However, since they became common people in the title, it seems that they are drastically off the line of dissolution of the engagement... That attitude of my former brother and his parents is annoying. We've been together for 15 years, and the heroine learned the truth a little while ago. It's too sad that even a thief would look at it. But my former fiancee hasn't come up at all, has she? Wouldn't it be nice if they came out later or something like that?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

スローテンポですが面白い

It's slow tempo but it's interesting

貴族→平民になるまでが結構長い。平民になってからようやくストーリーが、動き出す感じですがそれもスローテンポなので、そこは残念。絵は独特で、綺麗です。ストーリー自体も面白い。元婚約者がどう動くのか楽しみです。

It was quite a long time from being an aristocrat to a commoner. It feels like the story finally starts moving after becoming commonplace, but that is also slow tempo, so that's a shame. The picture is unique and beautiful. The story itself is also interesting. I'm excited to see how my former fiancé moves.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

チェンジリング

changeling

妖精のいたずらで翻弄されるアンナとアネットが前向きに生きて幸せになっていって欲しいと思います。今後の展開が気になります。他レビューにもあった絵がミュシャに似てると。確かに?綺麗です。

I want Anna and Annette, who are at the mercy of fairy pranks, to live positively and be happy. I'm curious about future developments. The picture, which was also in other reviews, is similar to Mucha. for sure? It's beautiful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

妖精

fairy

This review contains spoilers. 妖精のいたずらによって、あることが起きてしまうというところからはじまるストーリーです。この妖精さんがかわいらしいと思いました。全体的に絵がかわいらしく、好みの絵でした。

This review contains spoilers. It's a story that begins where something happens due to a fairy's mischief. I thought this fairy was cute. Overall, the picture was cute, and I liked it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

予想より面白かった！

It was more interesting than I expected!

This review contains spoilers. それぞれの視点でのストーリーも描いてくれているので、現状誰がどんな思いをしているのか分かるのがとてもいいです！ただ、だからこそ話は本当にゆっくり進んでますね。4巻しか出ていないので、もどかしくてもどかしくて…どんどんコミカライズされて先の話が読みたいです！

This review contains spoilers. They also draw stories from each point of view, so it's really nice to understand who is currently feeling what kind of thoughts! However, that's why the story is progressing really slowly. There are only 4 volumes out, so it's frustrating but frustrating... it's getting more and more comicalized and I want to read the previous story!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になります

I'm worried about the continuation

まだ１巻しか読んでませんが、続きが気になります。主人公が妖精に一般人なのに貴族とチェンジリングされて、その貴族の家族の対応も冷たく、主人公が可哀想過ぎます。妖精も自分が面白ければ、他はどうでもいいという態度で、クリュー以外は酷すぎます。ただ、主人公はチートでも超前向きでもないけど、頑張っているので報われてほしいです。

I've only read volume 1 yet, but I'm curious about the continuation. Even though the main character is a fairy and an ordinary person, he is changed to an aristocrat, and the response of that aristocrat's family is also cold, and the main character is too pathetic. Fairies also have an attitude that if they are interesting, they don't care about anything else, and everything other than Crew is just too bad. However, the main character isn't a cheat or super positive person, but he's doing his best, so I want him to be rewarded.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 11, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

平民

commoner

妖精のいたずらがなんとも悪どい。こんなにもたくさんの人を振り回し、喜んでいる。健気な主人公を幸せにしたい。

Fairy pranks are so bad. I'm delighted to be swayed by so many people. I want to make the healthy protagonist happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 09, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

妖精

fairy

This review contains spoilers. のいたずらで…生まれた時に取り違えられてた二人。一人は庶民に、一人はお姫様に…それぞれ違和感を感じながらも14年生きてきたのに…突然本来の家に戻されて。二人とも良い女の子だから二人に幸せになってほしいです

This review contains spoilers. Two people who were mistaken when they were born due to a prank of... One was a common man, and one was a princess... even though they both felt uncomfortable and lived for 14 years... they were suddenly returned to their original home. they are both good girls so I want them to be happy

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

あるようで無かった設定でおもしろい！

It's interesting to have a setting that didn't seem like it was there!

今までにあるようで無かった設定で面白い！アンナは最初はかなり悲劇のヒロインですが、苦労しながらも前向きに進んでいこうとする姿が涙ぐましい…エドには会えるんかな…続きがとても気になります！

It's an interesting setting that hasn't seemed to exist until now! Anna is a pretty tragic heroine at first, but the sight of her struggling to move forward positively is tearful... I wonder if I'll meet Ed... I'm really curious about the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

すごくおもしろい

Very interesting

平民になったアンナがたくましく生きて行こうとしてる様子に好感もてます。絵もとても綺麗でずっと見ていたいです。特に妖精が可愛い！これからの展開にきたいします。星がひとつ少ないのはもう少しお話の進行が早いとうれしいから。次刊も楽しみです。

I like how Anna, who has become a commoner, is trying to live a strong life. The pictures are also very beautiful and I want to look at them all the time. Fairies are especially cute! I would like to expand it in the future. One less star is because I would be happy if the story progressed a little faster. I'm also looking forward to the next edition.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

妖精のいたずら

Fairy prank

本当に似てない親子はいるものですが、現代でも取り違えは事故にせよ意思を持ってにせよあり得ます。それが面白そうだから退屈しのぎに悪戯でされたら。どちらの家庭も居心地は悪かったのに、戻ってもまたなんやかんや。1年間という準備期間を告げられた段階で発表していたら最悪だったのかな。先が気になります。

There are parents and children who really don't look alike, but even in modern times, mix-ups are possible whether it's an accident or if they have intentions. That sounds interesting, so why don't you play pranks on it when you get bored. Both families weren't comfortable, but even when they got back, they had a kettle again. I wonder if it would have been the worst if it had been announced at the stage where they were told the preparation period of 1 year. I'm worried about the future.

Helpful

Reviews for When I Became a Commoner, They Broke Off Our Engagement! Manga