When a Magician's Pupil Smiles Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 03, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

とてもよかった…続きは？！

That was great... what's next?!

This review contains spoilers. 感情移入する前にキャラもしくはキャラの感情が死んでしまうから最初は入り辛かったのに、ショウが出てきてからどんどん面白くなって、最後は生江が泣きながらほっぺむにって笑顔作るところで一緒に泣いちゃいました。キャラはレオが特に好き。かっこよくて可愛いです。先先生がやりたかったことと、それにレオがこれからどんな風に絡んでいくのか、とてもとても読みたいとおもったのに最終巻だなんて…！！！！なぜ？！！？どこかで続きを描いては貰えないだろうか…

This review contains spoilers. The character or character's emotions died out before empathizing, so it was hard to get in at first, but after the show came out, it became more and more interesting, and at the end, we cried together where Ikue cried and made a smile. I particularly like Leo as a character. It's cool and cute. I thought I wanted to read what Sensei wanted to do and how Leo would get involved in it from now on, but I can't believe it's the last volume...!!! why?!!? I wonder if I could draw a continuation somewhere...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 12, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが無いのがもったいない！

It would be a waste that there is no continuation!

絵柄も話の設定も凄く大好きなんですが、3巻で完結してしまうのが…もっと続きが見たかったですし今後のみんなが気になる！！最終巻読んでカバー裏見ると本当泣けてくる…本当に友達になって優しい世界だったらいいなぁ

I really love the design and setting of the story, but it ended up being completed in volume 3... I wanted to see more, and everyone is curious about the future!! It really makes me cry when I read the last volume and look back on the cover... it would be nice if they really became friends and it was a kind world

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 20, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが読みたい…！

I want to read more...!

すごく面白かったです！三巻で終わるのがもったいない！最終話を読んだあとにかバー裏を読むと泣けてきます。

It was so much fun! It would be a waste to finish with volume 3! It makes me cry when I read the back of the bar or after reading the last episode.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 19, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

びっくりします。

I'm surprised.

びっくりするくらいの尻切れトンボ具合に驚きを禁じえないです。すっごい不完全燃焼ですがとても面白かったです。主人公可愛いし、先生イケメンだしなかなかの良作ではないかとしかしあのぶつ切りには驚かされた。ページ飛び抜かしたかと思いました。

I can't help but be surprised at how astonishingly sharp the dragonfly is. It was a really incomplete combustion, but it was very interesting. The main character is cute, the teacher is good-looking, and I was surprised by that clash cut. I thought I had jumped over the page.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 13, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

心が…えぐられるッ！！

my heart... can be gobbed!!

This review contains spoilers. 表紙がとてもきれいで購入しました。絵がとても繊細で、キャラの表情も生き生きしていて、ふわふわとキラキラした画面だったのですが…お話がずっしりと心に爪跡を残していきました…魔法使いの弟子が笑う時…というタイトルですが、これがまた…。主人公である学ランの無表情少年は喜怒哀楽が生まれつき無いそうです。でもそんな男の子が笑う時があるんですが、それが切なすぎて…。大切な人を失った時に…すっごいいい笑顔で笑うんです！！すっごいかわいいのに「うわぁ…；；；；；」ってなりました。でも、ただ残酷なお話じゃなくて、キャラクターの一言一言が、表情がわたし達の日常の大切さを伝えてくれます。まだ1巻で、キャラクターたちがどのような動きをするのか分かりませんが、今のところ主人公の桜歌君にドキドキしながら続きを待ちたいと思います！！早く6月になれ！！

This review contains spoilers. The cover was so beautiful that I bought it. The picture was very delicate, the characters' expressions were lively, and the screen was so fluffy and sparkling... the story left a mark on my heart... the title is “When the Sorcerer's Apprentice Laughs...” but this is again... It seems that the main character, the expressionless boy from Gakuran, wasn't born with joy, anger, sorrow, and pleasure. But there are times when boys like that laugh, and it's so sad... When I lose someone important to me... I laugh with a really nice smile!! Even though it was so cute, it turned out “wow...;;;;” But it's not just a cruel story; each word of the characters and their facial expressions convey the importance of our everyday lives. It's still volume 1, and I don't know how the characters will move, but so far I'm excited for the main character, Sakuraua-kun, and I want to wait for the continuation!! Let it be June soon!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 21, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

まだ1巻

Still volume 1

まだ1巻しか読んでいませんが、買おうと思います。なになに…！？で1巻終わった感じです。どーなるのか気になりました。

I've only read volume 1 yet, but I think I'll buy it. What what...!? I feel like I've finished volume 1. I was wondering what would happen.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 27, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

それでも笑って

Laugh nonetheless

大切な人を得ると失う桜歌。ワタシは律とのエピソードが好きだ。あの時の弾けんばかりの桜歌の笑顔がたまらなく悲しい。あと先生ぱなく強いな・・・。

When you gain a loved one, you lose a cherry blossom song. I like the episode with Ritsu. The smile of Sakura Uta, who was just playing hard at that time, is irresistibly sad. Also, the teacher is really strong...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 10, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

なかなか

readily

想像していた内容とは全く違っていましたがいい意味で期待を裏切られました。多少のグロい描写などもありますが、徐々に変わっていく心情など読んでいて切なくなる部分も多く、楽しめました。

It was completely different from what I had imagined, but I was disappointed in a good sense. There are also some grosy depictions, etc., but there are also many parts that make me sad when reading, such as feelings that gradually change, so I enjoyed it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 24, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

最後のシーン良かった

The last scene was good

無表情設定が好きだったので購入した。全巻読んだけど消化不良かな。でも、話の内容はとっても良かった。最後の笑顔にキューンときた( ^ω^ )いろんな謎が解けてなかったりして結末は微妙だが読む価値はあったと思う。

I liked the expressionless setting, so I bought it. I've read the whole volume, but I think I have indigestion. But the content of the story was very good. I had a crush on my last smile (^ω^) I think it was worth reading even though the ending was subtle because various mysteries weren't solved.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 26, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

好みが分かれる内容

Content that divides tastes

他の方のレビューにもありましたが、絵は綺麗です！！内容の世界観は凄いです。グロいとこもしばしば。ハッキリ好き嫌いのわかれる内容だと思います。が！！私は好みです。まぁでも若干イライラします（笑）

It was in other people's reviews, but the picture is beautiful!! The worldview of the content is amazing. Guro cousins are also often there. I think the content clearly separates likes and dislikes. but! I like it. Well, it's a bit frustrating (laughs)

Helpful

Reviews for When a Magician's Pupil Smiles Manga