The Other World's Books Depend on the Bean Counter Manga Reviews (P.39)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 04, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

これは良いコミカライズ！

This is a good comicalization!

原作のラブ感の少なさが(すみません、私の読解力の欠如のせい…、甘さ控えめでもストーリーでちょー面白かったです。)、コミカライズで解消されてます！絡み合う視線とか、ちょっとセイイチロウさんにキュッとされてたまらなくなっちゃってる感じとか！アレシュ君、そこにくすぐられてたのねーと初めて実感しました。なるほど！これは、原作ご存知でも、むしろだからこそ！読んで損はないです。

The lack of love in the original story (sorry, due to my lack of reading comprehension... the story was a bit interesting even though the sweetness was modest.) It has been resolved with comicalization! Like intertwining glances, or feeling like I'm being taken by Seiichiro a little bit and it's getting unbearable! It was the first time I realized that Aresh was being tickled by that. I see! Even if you know the original story, that's why! There's no harm in reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 03, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

社畜が標準装備の主人公

Company animals are the main characters with standard equipment

This review contains spoilers. お話のメインは異世界の収支改善、なりゆきでBLに…といった感じで、まだこれからが楽しみの１巻です。巻き込まれて異世界にきた経理の中間管理職の主人公。異世界の物価を円換算で比較して、状況を学ぶところはさすが経理マン。有能な社畜なので早々に異世界の国庫問題に手をつけていきます。仕事本命なので今後もBLの糖度は低そう。自ら馬車馬のごとく働くブレない主人公を、これからもアレシュが何かと助けてくれてゆっくり距離が縮まっていくのかなと期待しています。

This review contains spoilers. The main story is about improving balance in another world, and I feel like I'm going to BL... and I'm still looking forward to the first volume. The main character is an accounting middle manager who got caught up and came to another world. As expected, it is an accountant who compares prices from other worlds in yen conversion and learns the situation. Since they are capable company animals, they will quickly tackle treasury issues in another world. It's my real job, so it seems like the sugar content of BL will continue to be low. I'm hoping that Aresh will continue to help the unshakable protagonist, who works like a horse-drawn carriage and horse, and that the distance will slowly shorten.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

小説前にこちらを試し読みしハマる

I tried reading this before the novel and I'm addicted to it

原作の小説が気になり、コミックも出ているのを知って先にこちらを拝見しハマりました。コミック読み終わってから即小説の方も纏め買いしました。最近エロばかり読んでいて、内容のしっかりとした読み応えのあるものを探していたのでこの出会いに感謝です。コミック読み終わったばかりですが、続きが気になります...ので今から小説を読みに。コミックはもちろん新刊自動購入登録しました。

I was curious about the original novel, and when I learned that comics were also out, I read this one first and got addicted to it. After I finished reading the comics, I immediately bought the novels in bulk. I've been reading only erotic lately, and I was looking for something with solid content that was easy to read, so I'm grateful for this encounter. I just finished reading the comic, but I'm curious about the continuation... so I'm going to read the novel now. Of course, I registered for automatic purchase of new comics.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

社畜

social animals

社畜はどこに行っても社畜なのかと悲しくなりましたが、お話はとても面白いです。続き早く読みたいですね～

Wherever I went, I was sad to wonder if the company animal was a company animal, but the story is very interesting. I want to continue reading soon~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

足りない

limping

面白い！でも、聖女の考えが足りない発言にイライラします。それが作品のスパイスだと分かってはいても…

interesting! But I'm frustrated by the saint's remarks that lack thought. Even though I know that's the spice of the work...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白くて一気読み！

It's interesting and I read it all at once!

本当に面白くて、BL好きな人もそれ以外の人も読める作品。続きが気になって仕方ないです。

It's really interesting, and it's a work that both BL lovers and non-BL lovers can read. I can't help but be worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

BLです❗

It's BL ❗

女性マンガカテゴリーですがBLです?地雷の人はご注意下さい。ザックリ言うと異世界転移もので助けようとして間違いで聖女と転移したあとそこで仕事するってお話?原作小説読んでコミックス発売待ってました‼絵が綺麗で読みやすい?個人的には宰相がお気に入り?そして小説の時も思ったけど頭の悪い聖女と王子にイラァッとする…

It's a female manga category, but is it BL? Please be careful of people with landmines. To put it bluntly, it's a story about trying to help in another world where they work after being transferred to a saint by mistake? I read the original novel and waited for the comics to be released ‼ are the pictures beautiful and easy to read? do you personally like the prime minister? Also, I thought when it was a novel, but I'm annoyed by the clumsy saint and prince...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

感想

Impressions

This review contains spoilers. 一貫して仕事に励む主人公で読んでいて楽しかったです。聖女として主人公とともに召喚された女性の性格が酷すぎて、イライラが募りました。助けようとしてくれた主人公を社畜と馬鹿にする言動には思わず目を疑いました。しかし、周りに流され聖女としての役割を受け入れている様から性格悪さもありますが、それ以上に頭が弱い子みたいでした。個人的には聖女よりも主人公の働きで環境が今後、どのように変化するかが気になります。

This review contains spoilers. It was fun to read it because the main character works hard on a consistent basis. The personality of the woman who was summoned along with the main character as a saint was so bad that I was frustrated. I couldn't help but doubt the words and actions that made a fool of the main character who tried to help me out as a company animal. However, since she was swept away by others and seemed to accept her role as a saint, she also had a bad personality, but even more than that, she seemed to be a weak-headed child. Personally, I'm more concerned about how the environment will change in the future due to the work of the protagonist rather than the saint.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

なんだこれ！なんて現実的なんだ！社畜さん、宰相からニゲテー！

what is this! How realistic is that! Mr. Shazuki-san, nigete from the prime minister!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 30, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

良い！

good!

絵も綺麗、展開もキャラクターも素晴らしい、言うことなしです！早く続きが読みたくて原作も買ってしまいました(笑)

The pictures are beautiful, the development and characters are amazing, there's nothing to say! I wanted to read the continuation soon, so I bought the original one too (laughs)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 30, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

ノベルもいいけど、、

Novels are good too, but...

This review contains spoilers. コミックもいいです！シャープさが出て、アレシュもかっこいい！早く早く続刊プリーズ。

This review contains spoilers. Comics are good too! The sharpness comes out, and Areş is cool too! Please continue to be published soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 29, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

綺麗です。。。

It's beautiful...

涙が出ました。。。凄いです・・・何度も読めます。。。いつもこの漫画と小説の大ファンです。。。

I burst into tears... That's amazing... I can read it over and over... I've always been a big fan of these comics and novels...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 29, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

原作も小説も読みました。

I read both the original story and the novel.

とても面白い作品なのでオススメです。BL要素は少なめなので、そっち系があまり得意でない方にもオススメ。

It's a very interesting work, so I recommend it. There are few BL elements, so it's also recommended for those who aren't very good at that system.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 26, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

良い！

good!

興味がなく読んでいなかったことに後悔。絵も上手く、ストーリー展開も無理なく不自然さがなく、とても好みだった。

I regret not reading it because I wasn't interested. The pictures were good, the story development was reasonable, there was no unnaturalness, and I really liked it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 31, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメと漫画とノベルを比べて

Compare anime, manga, and novels

漫画は「女性漫画」でライトノベルは「ＢＬ」なんですよね。アニメにもなりましたが（絵が雑で少しガッカリ）、アニメよりも漫画のほうが絵が美麗でとても気に入ってます。ライトノベルと読み比べると、「女性漫画」になっているので、ＢＬらしい部分は削られています。異世界ものは色々ありすぎてストーリーもマンネリになっていっている感じもありますが、ただのサラリーマンで無双もなく、チート能力もないうえに魔素中毒や魔力酔いを起こしてしまう弱い主人公が、経理をいう仕事をしていくことで世界を変えていくのが新しく応援したくなります。主人公の誠一郎と、アレシュの関係性が進んでいくのも楽しみです。

The manga is a “female comic,” and the light novel is a “BL,” isn't it? It's also made into an anime (the pictures are messy and a little disappointing), but I really like comics because the pictures are more beautiful than anime. Compared to light novels, it is a “female comic,” so the BL-like part has been omitted. There is also a feeling that there are so many different things from another world that the story is getting into a rut, but I want to cheat on the weak protagonist who is just an office worker, has no invulnerability, and causes magic sickness to change the world by doing work called accounting. I'm also excited to see the relationship between the main character, Seiichiro, and Alesh progress.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 23, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

聖女ちゃんが陰湿じゃないの良いと思う

I think it's good that Seijo isn't insidious

This review contains spoilers. なんかこういう転生ものって謎に聖女を愚かしすぎな性格にするのがテンプレになっていると思うけどこの聖女ちゃんは若さゆえに「こうなったら皆ハッピーじゃん！るんるん」くらいで言ってるのがかたや破綻していて・・というのがリアル。それを糾弾するのでなく、年上の包容力をもってして諫めるコンドゥのよさ。あんまり自分を酷使するのはよく分からないんだけど。そこは本当によくわからないんだけど。コンドゥが近衛騎士だったかな？にリンチされるところも、ああそういう流れで不満が溜まっていったのねって読みやすかった。んでそこからコンドゥの諸事情あって治療できない＝ぱっと見異世界人への偏見による医療拒否に見える、の流れは結構面白かった。というのも設定がしっかり練られてあるからだろうな。宰相や、同僚の王族庶子くん、司祭さん等々から色んな情を向けられるけど、この人の立場からこんな人を見たらこういう感情になるだろうなって範囲で、無理に恋情とかにされていないのもよかった。

This review contains spoilers. I think the template for this kind of reincarnation thing mysteriously makes Seijo too stupid, but because of her youth, Seijo said, “Everyone would be happy if this happened! The reality is that they say something like “run-run” but it just went bankrupt... Instead of denouncing it, it's good for Kondu to criticize him with his ability to be tolerant. I don't really understand overusing myself. I really don't understand that. I wonder if Kondu was a Knight of Guards? It was easy to read that even where they were lynched by, oh, that kind of flow built up dissatisfaction. So from there, the trend of Kondu not being able to be treated due to various circumstances = it seemed like refusal of medical treatment due to prejudice against people in a strange world was quite interesting. That's probably because the settings have been carefully worked out. I get a lot of feelings from the prime minister, my colleague Shoko from the royal family, a priest, etc., but it's also nice that they weren't forced into a relationship or anything, to the extent that they would have this kind of feeling if they saw someone like this from the standpoint of this person.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 25, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

２人の距離

Distance between two people

二人してなんだか分からないけど、近づいていく様子がいい感じ。これから二人の距離と気持ちがどう近づいていくのか楽しみ

The two of them don't know what it is, but it's nice to see them getting closer. I'm looking forward to seeing how the distance and feelings between the two of them will get closer

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 12, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

いい!

good!

ストーリーがしっかりしていて読み応えがあります。BLなのに女性漫画の括りになるんですね。まぁBL要素はそんな濃くないからかな。絵もとても綺麗で続きが楽しみ。

The story is solid and worth reading. Even though it's BL, it's a bundle of female comics, isn't it? Well, maybe it's because the BL elements aren't that strong. The pictures are also very beautiful and I'm looking forward to continuing.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 26, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメ化おめでとうございます

Congratulations on animating

This review contains spoilers. ストーリーの進み方はゆっくりと感じました。ふふふっと笑える要素も多く読んでると温かい気持ちになります。人を大切に想う気持ちはとても大事な事だと感じました。

This review contains spoilers. I felt that the story progressed slowly. It makes me feel warm when I read a lot of elements that make me laugh hehehe. I felt that the feeling of caring for people was very important.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 20, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメと立ち読みが良き！

The anime and standing reading are good!

まさかBLとは知らず購入しました。ストーリーとしてはとても面白く、続きが気になってさらに買い続けて最新刊迄来てしまいました(笑)続きが読みたいです。未だですか～

I didn't know it was BL and bought it. It was very interesting as a story, and I was curious about the continuation, so I kept buying more until the latest edition (laughs) I want to read more. Not yet~

Helpful

Reviews for The Other World's Books Depend on the Bean Counter Manga