Secrets of the Silent Witch Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いです！

It's interesting!

This review contains spoilers. 2巻まで読みました。絵が可愛かったので読んでみたんですが、この可愛さで数字好き・・・を通り越してマニアなモニカちゃんにギャップ萌ー！ただ、ちょっと自信が無くて卑屈すぎる主人公なので、爽快感があまりない感じで進みます。そのあたりが面白いけど好き嫌いが分かれそうです。

This review contains spoilers. I've read up to 2 volumes. The picture was cute, so I read it, but with this cuteness, I went beyond liking numbers... and there was a gap for Monica, who is an enthusiast! However, since the main character lacks a bit of confidence and is too lowly, it progresses with a feeling that there isn't much sense of exhilaration. That area is interesting, but there seems to be a difference in likes and dislikes.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公のモニカがとにかく可愛いです！！

The main character, Monica, is just so cute!!

サスペンスです。モニカが謎を解き明かす様子が見ものでした。数学から、こんなに理路整然と説明されるとスッキリしますね。絵も可愛いし、モニカの、しどろもどろだけど一生懸命で、それでいて間が抜けているところが可愛かったです。５巻が待ち遠しいです。

It's suspense. I watched Monica unravel the mystery. It's refreshing to be explained in such an orderly manner from mathematics. The pictures were cute too, and the fact that Monica was nervous but worked so hard, yet was so cute. I can't wait for volume 5.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が可愛いくて続きが気になる

The picture is so cute that I'm worried about the continuation

モニカちゃんが可愛い！ただ、人見知りが激しいっても、程度問題だと思う。なんであそこまで自分に自信がなく、卑屈な考えなのか不思議。それも今後明かされるのかな。フェリクス殿下も爽やかそうで優しげな見た目に反して、色々と画策している様子。自分の監視は沈黙の魔女が良いと言ってたけど、それが実行されてるのしったらどんなリアクションするのか楽しみ。ルイスが考察していた、食わせ物で不気味な殿下の素顔。早く見て見たい気もするけど、小説読んだ方が早いかな？

Monica is so cute! However, even if they are extremely shy, I think it's a matter of degree. It's strange why I don't have that much confidence in myself, and it's a lowly thought. I wonder if that too will be revealed in the future. Contrary to his fresh and gentle appearance, Prince Felix also seems to be making various plans. They said that the Silent Witch would be good for my surveillance, and I'm looking forward to seeing what kind of reactions they would have if it were carried out. The real face of His Highness, who is an eater and creepy, that Lewis was considering. I also feel like I want to watch it quickly, but would it be faster to read a novel?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

小説になろうから

Because it's going to be a novel

小説になろうで読んで買いました。小説は伏線がすごく、「あれがここでこう来るかー」と何度も驚かされます。人見知りモニカちゃんの成長も見所のひとつ。あの壮大な世界観が、コミカライズでどうなっていくかが楽しみです！！

I read it and bought it to become a novel. The novel has so much foreshadowing, and I'm surprised over and over again, “Is that coming here like this?” The growth of the shy Monica is also one of the highlights. I'm looking forward to seeing how that grand view of the world becomes comicalized!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 22, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いです。

It's interesting.

面白かったです。まだ、1巻しか読んでいませんが2巻も買います。気になることが、チラチラあって…第二皇子とかもですが…よかったです。

That was interesting. I've only read 1 volume yet, but I'm buying 2 volumes. Something bothered me was that there was a flickering... maybe the second prince... I'm glad.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 16, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い。

It's interesting.

魔法、学園、事件、友情があれば面白く無い訳がない。読む前はもっとフワフワした内容かなと勝手に思っていましたが、読んだらなんだか強大な敵がいそう！そのうち敵か悪かわからないけど、友情や信頼やらで立ち向かえるようになるのかな。長編になりそうだけど、絵も綺麗だし読み応えがあるから今から読んでたほうがいいかも！と思いました。

If there is magic, school, incident, or friendship, there's no reason why it's not fun. Before I read it, I was wondering if the content was even more fluffy, but when I read it, it seemed like there was some kind of mighty enemy! I don't know if it's an enemy or evil over time, but I wonder if they'll be able to confront them with friendship or trust. It looks like it's going to be a long story, but the pictures are beautiful and it's worth reading, so maybe I should start reading it now! I thought so.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

小説から

From a novel

This review contains spoilers. 小説原作がしっかりと反映してるようで面白かったです。是非とも感動のラストまで続いてほしいです(⁠*⁠´⁠ω⁠｀⁠*⁠)

This review contains spoilers. It was interesting because the original novel seemed to be clearly reflected. I definitely want it to continue until the moving end (*'ω`*)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

なかなか

readily

面白い?まだまだ序盤…先に期待?最強魔法の使い手なのにダメダメで数字が絡むと人が変わるとか似た話はあるけど、絵のタッチも相性良い好きだ〜

interesting? it's still early... looking forward to it? Even though he's the strongest user of magic, there are similar stories where people change when numbers are involved because it's bad, but I like the touch of the picture goes well too ~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

モニカかわいいーーー！

Monica is so cute!

まず、寝起きのモニカが可愛すぎる。そして小説の中に出てくる様々な魔法を絵で見られるとは！景色とか部屋の中とかの絵も綺麗でとても好みです。小説の方を読んでから見ると楽しさ倍増だと思います！

First, Monica is too cute when she wakes up. Also, being able to see the various spells that appear in the novel in pictures! The pictures of the scenery and the inside of the room are also beautiful and I really like them. If you read the novel and then watch it, I think it will double the fun!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 24, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメから

From anime

まずアニメで観て、コミカライズも気になって、とりあえず立ち読みしました。絵もかわいくて、良さげでした。

First, I watched the anime, and then I was curious about comicalization, so I just read it. The picture was cute and nice too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 29, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

マンガとアニメを比較したら

If you compare manga and anime

アニメ版からマンガ版に入ったせいで、圧倒的にアニメ版がよく、無詠唱魔法も精霊王召喚もすばらしい。マンガが、小説に追いついていないのが、少し残念。

Since it went from the anime version to the manga version, the anime version is overwhelmingly good, and both Unsung Magic and Summon the Spirit King are amazing. It's a bit disappointing that manga hasn't caught up with novels.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 16, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

原作が大好きで

I love the original

見つけた時はあの素敵で繊細なお話をどう絵にするのか楽しみでしたが、、まあそうですよねぇ?‎原作との違いは出ない方が少ないと思っていますが、サイレント･ウィッチの1番の魅力と言えるであろうモニカの極度の人見知り具合が若干薄れていたのは残念でした。（×　×　）あわあわ感とかおどおど感とかが…。それでも、絵は綺麗で読みやすくて、気になるところの購入を考えています?

When I found it, I was looking forward to seeing how to paint that wonderful and delicate story, but that's true, isn't it?‎原作との違いは出ない方が少ないと思っていますが、サイレント･ウィッチの1番の魅力と言えるであろうモニカの極度の人見知り具合が若干薄れていたのは残念でした。 (××) That feeling of being in a daze... Still, the pictures are beautiful and easy to read, and are you thinking about buying something you care about?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

魔術師

sorceress

This review contains spoilers. 人見知りの魔術師が第二王子の護衛をする物語。無詠唱で魔法を使えるのはすごい。人見知りを克服せずに魔法を無詠唱で使う特訓をするのは考えが面白い。登場人物達とどのような関わりをするのか楽しみ。

This review contains spoilers. A story about a shy magician who guards the second prince. It's amazing to be able to use magic without chanting. The idea of doing special training to use magic without chanting without overcoming shyness is interesting. I'm looking forward to seeing how they interact with the characters.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗

The picture is beautiful

This review contains spoilers. 絵が綺麗です。6巻まで読んで続きが気になり原作を読みました。理由はわかりますが最後までおどおどしている主人公と、恋愛関連の展開にやや不満があります。。ストーリー自体はよく考えられており、途中で展開が分かっても最後まで楽しめました。

This review contains spoilers. The picture is beautiful. After reading up to 6 volumes, I was curious about the continuation and read the original story. I understand why, but I'm somewhat dissatisfied with the protagonist, who is in a daze until the end, and romance-related developments. The story itself was well thought out, and I was able to enjoy it until the end even though I understood the development along the way.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

かわいい

cute

モニカがかわいい！コミュ障なのに実はすごい魔法使いなところがいいです。性格も素直でとても好感が持てます。色々事件が起きても解決していってしまうのがカッコいい。読むのが楽しいです。

Monica is so cute! I like the fact that he's actually an amazing wizard even though he has a communication disorder. They also have an honest personality and are very likeable. It's cool that even when various incidents occur, they are solved. It's fun to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

極度のコミュ障だけど誰よりも凄い力を持っている主人公。普通の人間には解決出来ない事を、独特な知識から次々に問題を解決していくところが爽快！

The main character has an extreme communication disorder but has more amazing power than anyone else. It's exhilarating to solve problems one after another from unique knowledge that normal humans cannot solve!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 06, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

魔法絡みの

Entangled with magic

This review contains spoilers. 推理サスペンスもの？って感じがしてワクワクしながら読み進めています！第二王子がカッコいい！この方、どこまで把握してらっしゃるのかしら？王子の動向も楽しみです！

This review contains spoilers. speculative suspense stuff? I feel like that and I'm reading it while being excited! The second prince is so cool! I wonder how far this person knows? I'm also looking forward to the prince's movements!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

異世界　魔法大好き

I love Isekai Magic

This review contains spoilers. 絵が可愛くて綺麗モニカの『沈黙の魔女』と普段のギャップが面白い。色々な人の名前を呼ぶ時がまた面白い。殿下が何者かが気になります

This review contains spoilers. The picture is cute and the beautiful Monica's “Silent Witch” and the gap with everyday life is interesting. It's also interesting when you call people by name. I'm curious who His Highness is

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

原作買い

Buy the original

原作買いです。可愛い絵柄でほのぼのしつつも、内容はハード＆ミステリー。展開をどのように描かれるのかが楽しみです。

I bought the original. While the cute design is heartwarming, the content is hard and mysterious. I'm looking forward to seeing how the development is depicted.

Helpful

Reviews for Secrets of the Silent Witch Manga