Scum's Wish Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 14, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

せつなすぎ｡ﾟ(ﾟ´ω`ﾟ)ﾟ｡

Too busy.° (°'ω`°)°.

絵がとにかく可愛いから好きです。一瞬、少女漫画かなと思うほど！女の子とにかく可愛いくて、表情とか、しぐさとか女のわたしでも萌えました。ストーリーもありきたりな学園ラブストーリーみたいな内容ではないところが、絵とのギャップを醸し出してより一層楽しめました。報われない恋心、人の弱さ、ずるさを全面に描いているところ。結末を含めて流されず妥協しない点、キャラクターのらしさを作者の人が描ききっているところに感動しました。随所随所にある、言葉選びも繊細で美しかった。読んでよかったおすすめの漫画です。

I like the pictures because they are just so cute. For a moment, I thought it was a girls' comic! The girls were just so cute, and their facial expressions and gestures made me fall in love even as a woman. The fact that the story wasn't like an ordinary school love story created a gap with the picture and I was able to enjoy it even more. It completely depicts unrequited love, human weakness, and cunning. I was moved by the fact that they weren't swept away and didn't compromise, including the ending, and that the author fully depicted the character's uniqueness. The words were all over the place, and the choice of words was also delicate and beautiful. This is a recommended comic that I'm glad I read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 04, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い作品です

It's an interesting work

斬新な恋愛模写やキャラクターがみんなそれぞれ個性があり、それをうまく絡めたりと読んでて面白かったです

It was interesting to read that the novel romance reproductions and characters all have their own personality, and it was interesting to read that they were well entwined

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 30, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

絵がとても綺麗です。お話は基本的にドロドロしていますが、切ないところや面白いところもあって続きが気になる作品です。

The picture is very beautiful. The story is basically muddy, but there are also sad and interesting points, so I'm worried about the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 27, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

深いです。

It's deep.

This review contains spoilers. 一口で恋愛漫画と言ってしまうには安易なほど、小難しい小説のように深いです。その深さが好きで、ずっと読んできましたがついに完結。麦や花火の葛藤や少しずつ変わっていく様子がみずみずしいというか生々しいというか、綺麗事が一つもないこのストーリーが本当に好きでした。完結は寂しいです。新作を期待してます！

This review contains spoilers. It's so deep that it's easy to call it a romance comic in one bite, and it's as deep as a small, difficult novel. I love that depth, and I've been reading it for a long time, but I've finally finished it. I really liked this story where the conflict between wheat and fireworks and how it changed little by little was fresh or rather vivid, and there wasn't a single beautiful thing. The completion is lonely. I'm looking forward to new releases!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 23, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

でてくるみんながクズ

Everyone who comes out is scum

本当に出てくる皆クズです。けど皆何かに葛藤したり苦しんだり浮かれたりとても深い漫画と思います。でてくる言葉になるほどと思ったりします。

Really, everyone who comes out is scum. But I think it's a very deep comic where everyone struggles, suffers, and gets carried away by something. I even think it's going to be a word that comes up.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 18, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

せつない

It's annoying

This review contains spoilers. アニメ化されるとのことで、原作読んでみました。とにかく、切ないです！！！本当は〇〇さんを思っているのに、想いが届かないなんて、、、花火と麦がそれぞれの好きな人の代わりで付き合って、お互いを慰め合っていて、もどかしい気持ちでいっぱいで、恋愛成就してほしいと応援しながら、共感しながら読みました。特に、モカが好きで、モカの物語のところは泣いてしまいました。恋愛って切ないなって思いました。

This review contains spoilers. It is said that it will be animated, so I read the original story. Anyway, it's sad!!! I read it with sympathy while cheering that I actually think of Mr. 00, but my feelings haven't arrived... fireworks and wheat go out in place of the people they like, they comfort each other, they are full of frustration, and they want their love to be fulfilled. In particular, I love mocha, and the story of mocha made me cry. I thought love was sad.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 04, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

?

?

絵がキレイでとても好きな作品です。片想いにも色んな形があるんだなぁと思えました。クズ、と言えどそれぞれに抱える感情が見えると愛しく感じます。

The picture is beautiful and I really like it. I thought unrequited love also has many forms. Even though it's scum, I feel lovely when I can see the feelings they each have.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 26, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

百合すきにもオススメ

Also recommended for lily lovers

まずもって花火って名前がいいね。その彼女をお兄ちゃんははなちゃんと呼ぶ。。絵鳩って名の友人を花火はえっちゃんって呼ぶ。なんかいい(笑)。

First of all, I like the name fireworks. My older brother calls that girlfriend Hana-chan.. A friend named Epigeon is called Ecchan for fireworks. Something good (laughs).

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 02, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメ見て

Watch anime

アニメ見て原作読みたくなって買いました。続きが気になって仕方ないです?

I bought it because I watched the anime and wanted to read the original story. can't help but be worried about the continuation?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメから。

From anime.

アニメがとても面白いので、原作読んでみたくて購入させていただきました‼(*´ω｀*)少しずつ買ってる途中ですが、ほんと面白い。好きな人に好かれないって辛いからすごく花火や麦の辛さわかります。あと、えっちゃんも大好き。絵もきれいだし、ストーリーも面白い。はまりました！

The anime is very interesting, so I bought it because I wanted to read the original story ‼ (*'ω`*) I'm in the middle of buying it little by little, but it's really interesting. It's painful not to be liked by someone you like, so I really understand the spiciness of fireworks and wheat. Also, I love Ecchan. The pictures are beautiful and the story is interesting. I'm addicted to it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 16, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

クズにもいろんなクズがいるけど

There are all kinds of scum

これがクズならかわいくて好き(♡˙︶˙♡)初々しくて歯痒さもあって少女マンガかと思ったくらい胸キュンした（笑）今後の展開に期待

If this were crap, it would be cute and I like it (♡ ▽♡) It was fresh and had itchy teeth, and I was so excited that I thought it was a girls' manga (lol) I'm looking forward to future developments

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 14, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

(^O^)

(^O^)

独特の作風ですが、たいへんハマってしまう作品です。内容と絵が合っていて読みやすい。

It's a unique style, but it's a work that I'm very addicted to. The content and pictures match and are easy to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 12, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

ドロドロ

mush

恋のドロドロしたところが印象的、アニメ化もしてるからこれからが楽しみ

The muddy place of love is impressive, and it has also been made into an anime, so I'm looking forward to the future

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 09, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

気持ちがわかる

I understand the feeling

主人公の気持ちが痛いほどわかります。叶わないとわかってるけどどうしても諦められない…だから誰かを代わりにって苦しい片思いしているときに誰でも1度は思ったことあるんじゃないかなぁ。続きが早く読みたいです。

I painfully understand the protagonist's feelings. I know it won't come true, but I just can't give up... so I think everyone has thought about it at least once when they have a painful unrequited love for someone else. I want to read the rest soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 30, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

みんなまっすぐ。

Everyone straight.

大変な片思いをしてる子たちの物語。キャラが濃くて面白い。何度も読む度に、詩的なモノローグに考えさせられます。

This is a story about children who have a terrible unrequited love. The characters are strong and interesting. Every time I read it over and over, it makes me think about the poetic monologue.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 09, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

ドロドロでごちゃごちゃで純粋

muddy, messy, pure

This review contains spoilers. 見事なまでに皆が皆、一方通行な恋模様が切ない。皆歪んでいて、皆清々しいほど自己中。でも好きな人への気持ちだけは純粋。完全な片思いで綺麗に終わる恋は綺麗な思い出として残せるけど、完全な片思いでも綺麗には終われない恋もある。でも、中途半端に利用されて終わる片思いって、利用した方だけが自己中なんじゃなく、利用された側も純粋なふりして実は自己中だったんだな。そうでなければ成り立たないんだって、今さら気付いた。当時は気付かなかったけど。花火と麦は恋愛かはさておき、途中からは何か芽生えてるっぽいのに、やっぱりこうなるんだなあ。先はわからないけど。人間の嫌なところやドロドロしたところなふんだんに描かれていますが、なんだかそれぞれの気持ちが分かる気がするし、皆どこか憎めず好き。全く理解できない人もいるだろうし、好き嫌いは別れると思います。自分は好きです。

This review contains spoilers. To the extent that everyone is amazed, the one-way love pattern is sad. Everyone is distorted, and everyone is so refreshingly self-centered. But my feelings for the people I like are pure. A love that ends beautifully with a complete unrequited love can be left as a beautiful memory, but there are also loves that don't end beautifully even with a perfect unrequited love. However, unrequited love that ended after being used half-heartedly, not only was the person who used it self-indulgent, but the person who used it also pretended to be pure, and it was actually self-centered. I just now realized that it wouldn't be possible otherwise. I didn't notice it at the time though. Aside from whether fireworks and wheat are in love, it seems like something has blossomed along the way, but it's still going to be like this. I don't know where to go though. It depicts plenty of disgusting and muddy things about humans, but I feel like I understand their feelings, and everyone likes them without hating them. There are probably people who don't understand it at all, and I think likes and dislikes will separate. I like myself.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 24, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

大好きです…>_<…

I love it... >_<...

不毛で痛々しくもあるのだけど胸に刺さる言葉がたくさんあります。特に早苗ちゃんには泣かされました（；＿；）

There are so many words that stick to my heart, even though they are barren and painful. Sanae-chan in particular made me cry (; _;)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 17, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

これは買い

Buy this

大分いい。続きが読みたくなるマンガ。なんか読んでてすっごく楽しいし。内容的には少女マンガっぽいかも。

That's pretty good. A manga that makes you want to read more. It's so much fun to read something. It might be like a girls' manga in terms of content.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

花火

fireworks

登場人物たちのリアルな恋愛模様が、描かれているので好感が持てます。クズというよりも、現実ってこんなもんじゃないのかな

The realistic love patterns of the characters are depicted, so I like it. Rather than scum, isn't reality like this

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

どうしようもないクズの話だと思いますが、ある種これがひきつけられる魅力で読んでいると止まらないストーリーです。

I think it's a useless story, but it's a story you can't stop reading because it has a kind of appeal that attracts you.

Helpful

Reviews for Scum's Wish Manga