Puella Magi Madoka Magica: The Different Story Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

負けるな！

don't lose!

This review contains spoilers. 上巻を読み終えて、まず感じたのは「ああ、この物語をもう一度味わえる喜び」でした。本作は、原作アニメでは深く掘り下げられなかった「巴マミ」と「佐倉杏子」の関係性に焦点を当てたスピンオフ。上巻では、二人の出会いから、魔法少女として異なる信念を持つがゆえの葛藤、そして微かに芽生える友情が丁寧に描かれています

This review contains spoilers. After I finished reading the first volume, the first thing I felt was “Oh, the joy of being able to enjoy this story again.” This is a spin-off focusing on the relationship between “Tomoe Mami” and “Sakura Kyoko,” which could not be delved deep into the original anime. The first volume carefully depicts the encounter between the two, the conflict because they have different beliefs as magical girls, and the friendship that develops slightly

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 30, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

マミさん

Mami

This review contains spoilers. まどマギのスピンオフです。スピンオフはたくさんでていますが、こちらは正統派な感じがしました。絵柄もよいですね。マミさんの出番が多くてよかったです。

This review contains spoilers. This is a Madomagi spin-off. There are a lot of spin-offs, but this one felt orthodox. The design is nice too. I'm glad Mami appeared a lot.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 29, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

まどマギ

Madomagi

This review contains spoilers. まどマギの別世界線のアナザーストーリーです。まどマギは派生作が多く、世界線が幾つもあるので違和感なく読めます。マミさんがメインなので、マミさん推しにオススメです。

This review contains spoilers. This is another story from Madomagi's Another World Line. There are many derivative works of Madomagi, and since there are several world lines, you can read it without any sense of incongruity. Mami is the main one, so I recommend Mami.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 27, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

もうひとつのまどマギ

Another Madomagi

This review contains spoilers. 原作とは異なる視点で描かれる志筑仁美たちの物語。過去の痛みとちょい絆が交錯し、魔女化の悲劇や希望の灯火が丁寧に描かれていた。心にずっしり残る物語だった。

This review contains spoilers. The story of Hitomi Shizuki and others is depicted from a different perspective from the original. Past pains and small bonds intersected, and the tragedy of becoming a witch and the lights of hope were carefully depicted. It was a story that stuck in my heart for a long time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 27, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

コレを機にまどマギライフを

Take this opportunity to enjoy Madomagi Life

まどマギの媒体自体は知っていたんですが、色々感想が飛び交っていて勇気を出せなかった中とうとう手をつけてみました。一気読みできます。全3巻で読みやすい。キャラクターが可愛い！

I knew about Madomagi's medium itself, but there were so many impressions flying around that I couldn't muster the courage, so I finally got my hands on it. You can read it all at once. Easy to read with all 3 volumes. The characters are cute!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 25, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

なるほどー

I see

この世界線もいいですね、やはりまどマギ面白いです。アニメや映画の映像で見た感じと違い、漫画だとまたじっくりキャラの表情が掴めるというか…まみさん…泣

This world line is nice too; after all, Madomagi is interesting. Unlike what I saw in anime and movie images, in comics, I think I can carefully grasp the characters' expressions again... Mami... crying

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 23, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

あったかもしれない世界

A world that might have existed

This review contains spoilers. 大人気アニメのアナザーストーリー。アニメを見て好きだったマミさんが中心の話ということで、救いの話でもある。アニメの世界線も儚くてそれはそれで良かったですけどね。たくさんのスピンオフがあって混乱するかもしれないけど、これはこれでおすすめです！

This review contains spoilers. Another story from the hugely popular anime. It's a story centered around Mami, who watched the anime and loved it, so it's also a story of salvation. The anime world line is also ephemeral, and that's good, though. There are so many spin-offs that can be confusing, but I recommend this one!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 21, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

まどマギ

Madomagi

This review contains spoilers. やっぱり大好き。まどマギ。この世界観、永遠に続いてほしい。ifはいい…。まどか…とも思うが…

This review contains spoilers. I love it after all. Madomagi. I want this view of the world to last forever. if is good... Madoka... I also think...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 19, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

if

if

This review contains spoilers. まどマギのifストーリー。ドラマCDのコミカライズ。マギらしいアップダウンのあるストーリーで漫画的にも読みごたえがある。マミさんと杏子好きにおすすめ。

This review contains spoilers. Madomagi if story. Comicalize the drama CD. It's a story with ups and downs typical of the Magi, and it's comic-like. Recommended for Mami and apricot lovers.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 18, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いです！

It's interesting!

This review contains spoilers. 魔法少女になってみたい！と一度は夢見る女の子たちに、地獄に突き落とすような衝撃を与えたまどマギのスピンオフ。マミ主役のお話で、アニメで見た時、情緒を殴られたのを思い出しました。まどマギの魔法少女たちは、みんなつらかったり悲しかったり、きつい想いを抱えて戦ってるんだけど、作品としてはとても面白い。このスピンオフもオススメです！

This review contains spoilers. I want to be a magical girl! A Madomagi spin-off that shocked girls who once dreamed like they would be thrown into hell. It's a story starring Mami, and when I saw it in the anime, I was struck by emotion. The magical girls in Madomagi are all fighting with hard, sad, and tough feelings, but it's very interesting as a work. I also recommend this spin-off!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 16, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

あんこ派

Anko group

まどマギでは思いやりのある杏子さんが1番好きです。あとマミさんも好きです。Clarisの曲はイイっすねぇ。

In Madomagi, I like the compassionate Kyoko the most. Also, I like Mami. Claris' songs are so good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

見事なコミカライズ

Stunning comicalization

本当に見事なコミカライズです。作画も素晴らしく、原作の魅力を上手く纏め上げています。原作のファンなら必見だと思います。

It's a really spectacular comicalization. The drawing is also excellent, and the appeal of the original story is well summarized. If you're a fan of the original, I think this is a must-see.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

よい

good

アニメから入りましたが、素晴らしい内容でした。王道展開に一捻り加えたような作品で意外性ありで大ファンになりました。映画の続きも楽しみです

I started with the anime, and the content was amazing. It's a work that seems to have added a twist to a classic development, and it was unexpected, and I became a big fan. I'm also looking forward to the continuation of the movie

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

あったかもしれない世界

A world that might have existed

大人気アニメのアナザーストーリー。アニメをみて好きだったマミさんが中心の話ということで、救いの話でもある。アニメの世界戦もはかなくて、それはそれでよかったんだけど。たくさんのスピンオフがあって混乱することもあるけど、これは良いです！

Another story from the hugely popular anime. It's a story centered around Mami, who watched the anime and loved it, so it's also a story of salvation. There wasn't even a world match in the anime, and that was good. There are so many spin-offs that it can be confusing, but this is good!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

サイドストーリー

side story

This review contains spoilers. まどか☆マギカで登場するキャラが主人公となったスピンオフ作品です。作画も上手ですし、本編のファンという方なら楽しめると思います。

This review contains spoilers. This is a spin-off game with characters appearing in Madoka ☆ Magica as the main characters. They're good at drawing, and if you're a fan of the main story, I think you'll enjoy it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 01, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

まどマギイフ

Mado Magiif

This review contains spoilers. 大人気アニメ、まどマギの、別世界線のお話のコミカライズ。こういうの無限にできそうですね。派生作品がけっこう多いんですよね。しかしどの世界線でもまどかは救われないのがえぐいところ。マミさんがマミられない。途中退場するには良すぎるキャラなのでそれはすごい良かったんですけどね。魔法少女の歴史を変えたまどマギの、あったかし知れないストーリー。全３巻と読みやすいのでおすすめです。

This review contains spoilers. A comicalization of the story of the hugely popular anime Madomagi's Another World Line. It seems like something like this can be done endlessly. There are quite a few derivative works, aren't there? However, the bad thing is that Madoka can't be saved on any of the world lines. Mami can't be a mom. It's a character that's too good to leave halfway, so that was really good, though. A heartwarming story about Madomagi who changed the history of magical girls. All 3 volumes are easy to read, so I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

Zo

Zo

魔法少女って衣装も可愛くて、少女も可愛いから大好きやなあ。それに魔法ってのもファンタスティックで好きやなあ。

I love Magical Girls because their costumes are cute, and girls are cute too. Also, magic is fantastic and I love it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメから

From anime

This review contains spoilers. 友達から勧められてアニメから見ました可愛いキャラクターとは似つかない程のグロいストーリーに引き込まれます

This review contains spoilers. Recommended by a friend and watched from the anime, I'm drawn into a grosy story that doesn't resemble cute characters

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

マミらないマミさん

Mami no Mami no Mami

This review contains spoilers. まどかマギカは好きなのでよく呼んでいましたがその中でも巴マミがメインの主人公だったのでこれはとても好きな漫画でした。マミらないマミさんの物語なのでアニメを見た方には本当に感涙もののストーリーだったと思います。本当にアニメはどうしてそうなった　というような感じの物語やっただけに　この漫画は良かったです

This review contains spoilers. I like Madoka Magica, so I often called them, but since Mami Tomoe was the main protagonist, this was my favorite comic. It's a story about Mami who doesn't have a mom, so I think it was really a tearful story for those who watched the anime. This comic was good because it really was a story that felt like why did the anime happen

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

魔法少女最高

Puella Magi is awesome

This review contains spoilers. キュゥべぇに「僕と契約して魔法少女になってよ」と言われて、魔法少女の世界に足を踏み入れたまどかが頑張って敵と戦っていくシーンが好きです！(魔法少女は闇の世界だけど笑)まどか願い事は”すべての魔女を生まれる前から消し去りたい...”で、その願いの代償は大きくて、「ただの概念になり果ててだれもまどかを認識できないし、まどかもまた誰にも干渉できない...」それでも自分を犠牲にしたまどかはやさしすぎる泣まどかの願いによって魔法少女は全員生き返ったけれど、みんなまどかのことを忘れていて、まどかの髪の毛につけていたリボンを持っていないとまどかのことを覚えていられないとなったときは悲しすぎました。まどかが大好きでまどかのために魔法少女になったほむらが号泣した時は読んでいて悲しくなったけれど、大好きなまどかのことを覚えていられる方法があったことで少しは救われているといいなと思います！

This review contains spoilers. I like the scene where Madoka, who is told by Kyube to “sign a contract with me and become a magical girl,” works hard to fight her enemies! (Puella Magi is a dark world lol) Madoka's wish is “I want to get rid of all witches before they're born...”, and the cost of that wish was huge, and “it's just a concept, and no one can recognize Madoka, and Madoka can't interfere with anyone...” Madoka, who sacrificed herself, cried too softly, and all of them came back to life due to Madoka's wishes, but they all forgot about Madoka, and the ribbon she had on Madoka's hair I was so sad when I couldn't remember Madoka if I didn't have it. I read it when Homura, who loved Madoka and became a magical girl for Madoka, cried, but I think it would be nice if there was a way to remember her favorite Madoka and was saved a little bit!

Helpful

Reviews for Puella Magi Madoka Magica: The Different Story Manga