The Stone Cold General & the Maid Perplexed by His Burning Passion Manga Reviews (P.5)

Juliana McKenna

Report

Dec 26, 2024 (PST) | Total Reviews: 17

Too many side plots

This review contains spoilers. I think the art is stunning, and I appreciate a confident female lead, but I don’t think this story is progressing in a way I’ll eventually enjoy. I find the male lead too difficult to justify their romantic relationship. He’s probably autistic, but he’s also too difficult to have a conversation with. I dislike men like that. When it comes to the promotional pages I saw on instagram that led me here, I thought they were anticlimactic when I read them irl. I wanted MORE PASSION, MORE ENERGY! I want the male lead to be more passionate. Him purchasing duvets out of gratitude doesn’t satisfy my desire.

Most importantly, I think there are too many side plots! For example, there was a segment in chapter 5 where they introduced a woman being forced to do something by a scary gang… it just came outta nowhere and I don’t want to pivot yet! There’s limited space in each chapter and I’d like it to be focused on the couple as much as possible. Anyway, I don’t think I’ll be purchasing more chapters.

Helpful

(2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 15, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

フィーナちゃんかわいい！

Fina-chan is so cute!

これは今の漫画になかなかないすごい作品だと思います！昔のヨーロッパの設定で凝ってるし絵がとにかく綺麗で凝ってるし内容もいい！個人的に主人公のフィーナの髪の毛やビジュアルがとても好きです?性格や強さ大好き♪

I think this is an amazing work that can't be found in today's comics! The old European setting is elaborate, the pictures are just so beautiful and elaborate, and the content is great! I personally really like the main character Feena's hair and visuals? I love personality and strength ♪

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 13, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

気に入っています

I like it

面白いので気に入って継続購読しています。最初、絵が苦手かなぁと思っていたのですが、今では全く気になりません。むしろ綺麗とさえ思っています。テンポも良く、エロもしつこくなく、読みやすいです。

It's interesting, so I like it and keep subscribing. At first, I thought I wasn't good at painting, but now I don't care at all. Rather, I even think it's pretty. The tempo is good, the eroticism is not strong, and it's easy to read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 13, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが楽しみ

I'm looking forward to the continuation

This review contains spoilers. 賢くて強くてキュートな超有能メイド！と冷徹な将軍…という設定が面白い！フィーナとシルヴェリオの最悪初対面から激甘ラブの過程がワクワクします。荘厳で耽美な画力に圧倒されます。西洋風ファンタジーて本当に画が大事だと思います。

This review contains spoilers. A super talented maid who is smart, strong, and cute! and the cold-hearted shogun... the setting is interesting! From the worst first meeting between Fina and Silverio, the process of super sweet love is exciting. I am overwhelmed by the majestic and beautiful painting power. I think pictures are really important in Western-style fantasy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 12, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い！

interesting!

絵が古いかなと思ったのですが、読んでいたら気にならなくなり、むしろ異国の雰囲気と相待って話に没頭できました。恋愛はもちろんですが、お仕事漫画としても面白かったです。いろんな陰謀が渦巻く中、たかがメイドされどメイド！頭が良く無いとお城のメイドは務まりませんね(*´ω`*)頭がいい女性は素敵だし、そんな女性に惚れる男性陣も素敵です。

I thought the picture was old, but when I was reading it, I didn't care; rather, I was able to immerse myself in the story by waiting for the foreign atmosphere. Of course it was a romance, but it was also interesting as a work comic. In the midst of various intrigues swirling around, they were just maids but maids! If you're not smart, you can't work as a castle maid (*'ω`*) Smart women are wonderful, and so are the men who fall in love with such women.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 08, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

『CAIN』の先生

The teacher of “CAIN”

畏れ多くて下手なことは言えない。力強さと繊細さを兼ね備えた画面作りが印象的で、視線の誘導や見せ方の巧みさに圧倒されます。女性の肌感や髪質の表現も丁寧で触感まで想起させる描写力に作家としての技量を感じました。単行本化して欲しいです。

I have so much fear that I can't say bad things. The screen design, which combines strength and subtlety, is impressive, and I am overwhelmed by how clever it is to guide the line of sight and show. As an artist, I felt my skill as an artist with careful expressions of the skin and hair quality of women, and the ability to depict even tactile feelings. I want it to be made into a standalone book.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 04, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

ぜひ書籍化してほしい！坂東さんの画力！

I definitely want it to be made into a book! Bando-san's drawing power!

作品と、とても合う作風でした。坂東いるか先生の絵はとても好きです。主人公の恋愛に対する初々しさと、頭の回転のよさがとても読み進めたくなる作品。男性側の閣下も、経験はありそうだけど、恋愛はじめてそうなのが垣間見えるのがツボ。チョロすぎませんか、閣下。男子校出身かよ。ぜひ繰り返し読みたいので、書籍化してほしい！本編とは別にはじめて町散策したときの詳細とか、閣下のプライベート1日とかを漫画で見てみたいです。

It was a style that went very well with the work. I really like Iruka Bando's paintings. It's a work that makes me want to read on because of the protagonist's innocence in love and his good sense of rotation. His Excellency on the male side also seems to have experienced it, but the pressure point is that you can catch a glimpse of such a thing for the first time in a relationship. Aren't you being too stupid, sir? you graduated from a boys' school? I definitely want to read it over and over again, so I want it to be made into a book! Apart from the main story, I'd like to take a look at comics such as the details of when I first walked around the town or Your Excellency's Private Day.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 14, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒロインかっこいい

The heroine is cool

昔っぽい絵だなぁと思ったけど、この世界観にピッタリですね。ヒロインは何でも出来て勇敢でカッコイイです。そして可愛い。そりゃヒーローも落ちるよね。続きが楽しみです。

I thought it was an old-fashioned picture, but it's perfect for this view of the world. The heroine can do anything and is brave and cool. And cute. Well, heroes fall too, don't they? I'm looking forward to the continuation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 09, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵なふたり

Two wonderful people

This review contains spoilers. 絵が好みなので、読み始めました。冷徹将軍がヒロインのフィーナにぞっこんな姿が面白いくらいかわいいです。なりふり構わずで、さすがのフィーナも当初はとまどいますが、気持ちを受け入れて超ラブラブです。

This review contains spoilers. I like pictures, so I started reading them. The appearance of Shogun Reitetsu as the heroine, Feena, is so cute that it's funny. It doesn't matter what you pretend to be, and as expected, Fiona is at ease at first, but she accepts her feelings and is super lovey-dovey.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

絵は少しクドいけど…

The picture is a bit crappy, but...

今時の絵でないので、最初はクドさを感じましたが、ヨーロッパ調のストーリーのため、むしろマッチしてます。引き込まれるストーリーで、続きが楽しみ！でも先が気になって仕方ないので原作買おうか悩み中です

It's not a picture of today, so I felt bad at first, but since it's a European-style story, it's rather a match. It's a compelling story, and I'm looking forward to the continuation! But I'm worried about the future and can't help it, so I'm worried about buying the original

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 03, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

ハラハラします。

It's jarring.

次々いろんなことが起こるのはもちろんのこと画力が高いので見入ってしまいます。絵がきれいのでお話がストレートに頭に入ってきます。フィーナがとても賢くて可愛いのでカタブツ将軍にとても愛されているし必要とされていてその辺りもとても楽しみな件です。この度の同僚との掛け合いも何か起こりそうな周りの動きも早く新刊がでないかなぁとすっかりハマってしまいました。

Of course, various things happen one after another, and since my drawing power is high, I can watch it. The picture is beautiful, so the story comes straight into my head. Feena is so smart and cute that she is very loved and needed by General Katabutsu, and I'm really looking forward to that too. I was completely addicted to this interaction with my colleagues and the movements around me where something was likely to happen quickly and wonder if a new publication might come out.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 15, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

美しい！

beautiful!

ストーリーもドキドキで好きですが何より絵が綺麗で好みで読み続けています！メイドと軍人の関係から恋人同士になった２人から目が離せません

The story is exciting and I like it, but above all, the pictures are beautiful and I keep reading as I like! I can't take my eyes off the two who became lovers due to the relationship between the maid and the soldier

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 12, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

単行本待機

Waiting for the book

This review contains spoilers. 主人公もヒーローも芯のあるキャラで魅力的なので、読んでいて楽しいです。単話は読むの手間なので単行本版・合本版を全力待機してます！

This review contains spoilers. Both the main character and hero have strong characters and are fascinating, so it's fun to read. The single episode is a hassle to read, so I'm waiting for the book edition and the combined edition with all my might!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 11, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

馬

horses

作画レベルがものすごく高い！ドレスの生地感、重さ感まで表現されてるすごい！レビューで馬の話が多いですが、馬かっこいいです。馬が一番イケメンくらいのレベルです。ストーリーは仕事出来るメイドが堅物閣下と出会ってからの〜というなろうでよく見るお話ですが、キャラ設定も良いし先が楽しみ。主人公が有能すぎるけど可愛いし、溺愛も仕方ない。

The drawing level is extremely high! It's amazing that even the texture and weight of the dress are expressed! There is a lot of talk about horses in reviews, but horses are cool. Horses are at the level of the most handsome guys. The story is a story I often see after the maid who can work meets His Excellency Mr. Katamono, but the character settings are also good and I'm looking forward to the future. The main character is too talented, but cute, and I can't help but love him.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 04, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

閣下が素敵すぎる！画力と描写が凄すぎる！

Your Excellency is too nice! The drawing power and depiction are amazing!

This review contains spoilers. 話もコメディタッチで軽快で面白く、閣下が素敵すぎる！強面閣下が媚薬で乱れてあーんなエロいことになっちゃう様が最高すぎる〜！そしてフィーナちゃんへの甘さも最高！そして画力の凄さと時代考証の緻密さにも驚き！最近定番のなんちゃって安っぽい子供のお人形遊び西洋お姫様風ではなく、しっかりとした時代背景の描写に感服いたしました。こういう本格的な画力の漫画もないと、本来の漫画の良さがわからなくなっていくと思うので、頑張って下さい！

This review contains spoilers. The story is also light and interesting with a comedic touch, and your Excellency is too nice! It's so awesome that His Excellency Strong Men are messed up with aphrodisiacs and end up in such an erotic thing! Also, the sweetness for Fina-chan is amazing! Also, I was amazed at how amazing the drawing power was and how precise the period was examined! I was impressed by the depiction of the solid historical background of Nancha, which is a staple these days, not a cheap child's doll play in the style of a Western princess. If you don't have comics with this kind of serious drawing power, I think you won't be able to understand the original merits of comics, so please do your best!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 02, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

図柄が綺麗・丁寧です

The pattern is beautiful and careful

冷徹将軍シルヴェリオ閣下は強面軍人、フィーナ嬢に出逢ってから純愛・純情・脇目も触れずフィーナ嬢一筋が魅力です。そのフィーナ嬢が体温め効果の媚薬を寒い時に飲んでいるところが斬新というか、こういう飲み方もあるんだ！本当に？今までにない楽しみな展開期待してます。

His Excellency General Reitetsu General Silverio is a strong soldier, and since he met Miss Feena, he hasn't touched pure love, pure love, pure love, or side effects, and Miss Feena is charming. The fact that Miss Feena takes an aphrodisiac that has a warming effect when it's cold is novel, and there is also a way to drink it like this! really? I'm looking forward to an exciting development that has never been seen before.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 01, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

きゅんきゅんします

I'm going to play kyun kyun

1話試し読みでめちゃ面白くて全話買ってしまいました！！！絵も最初慣れなかったけどもうこれ以外考えられません。超絶おすすめです。

It was a trial reading of episode 1 and it was so interesting that I bought all the episodes!!! I wasn't used to painting at first, but I can't think of anything else. I highly recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 02, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

シルヴェリオ閣下の純情

His Excellency Silverio

This review contains spoilers. 優秀なメイドのフィーナ嬢にぞっこんになってしまった冷徹将軍シルヴェリオ閣下の純情さがツボにハマりました。いつもながら、坂東いるか先生の絵が綺麗で見惚れます。

This review contains spoilers. I was taken aback by the innocence of His Excellency Mr. Reverio, the Reitetsu Shogun, who was taken aback by his excellent maid, Miss Fina. As always, Bando Iruka sensei's paintings are beautiful and I fall in love with them.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗ですよね

The picture is beautiful isn't it

昔の海外設定だと、ドレスや家具とか凝ってるから大変だと思うけど、細かい所まで素晴らしいなぁと感心しながら読みすすめています。イケメンが恥じらうところがまたかわいいというか、一途に想い合う二人が今後も楽しみです。

If it's an overseas setting in the old days, I think it would be difficult because the dresses and furniture are elaborate, but I recommend reading it with admiration that even the details are wonderful. The fact that handsome guys are ashamed is cute again, and I'm looking forward to the two people who have feelings for each other in the future.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 18, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

なんとなく

somehow

読み始めたのがきっかけでしたが結果最後まで課金してしまいました！！！主人公が美しい上に強くてまっすぐで閣下もカッコよくてストレスなしで最高でした！！続きも気になります！

It started when I started reading it, but as a result, I ended up charging until the end!! The main character was beautiful, strong and straight, and your Excellency was so cool and stress-free! I'm curious about the continuation too!

Helpful

Reviews for The Stone Cold General & the Maid Perplexed by His Burning Passion Manga