Hi, I'm a Witch, and My Crush Wants Me to Make a Love Potion Manga Reviews (P.2)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 02, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

心がほっこりします

It makes my heart feel relaxed

作者が大好きで、原作も読んでいます。こちらの漫画のイラストも大好きで、新しいのが出ると気になり、見てしまいます。ほっこりしながら見れる作品です。

I love the author, and I also read the original story. I also love the illustrations in this comic, and I'm curious when new ones come out, so I look at them. It's a work you can watch while feeling relaxed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

何回読んでもいい！

It doesn't matter how many times you read it!

This review contains spoilers. 魔女は健気だし、ハリージュはカッコイイけど何だか可愛いところもあって、そんな2人が少しずつ近づいていくのが良い♡話の進み具合もいいし、何回読んでも面白いです！魔女というありふれているものだけど、他とは少し設定が変わってるのも好きです。

This review contains spoilers. The witch is healthy, and Haliju is cool, but there are also places where they are kind of cute, and it's nice that these two people get closer little by little ♡ The way the story progresses is good, and it's interesting no matter how many times you read it! It's a common thing called a witch, but I also like that the setting is slightly different from the others.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 09, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

めちゃくちゃかわいい魔女殿

Insanely cute witch house

よくできたストーリーです。魔女殿がとにかくかわいい！ハリージュ様の上から目線な感じは好き嫌いがあるかもしれないけど、読み進めていくとハリージュ様のかわいさも分かってもらえると思います。この話は白黒でも十分楽しめるけど、フルカラー版があるのでそちらを読むともっと表情や衣服、情景など分かりやすいのでそちらもオススメ！ちなみに私は全部読み終えた後小説も読みましたが、ニヤケが止まらなかったです。

It's a well-made story. The witch hall is just so cute! There may be likes and dislikes about Haliju looking at her from above, but as you read on, I think you'll understand how cute Harry Ju is. You can fully enjoy this story in black and white, but there is a full color version, so if you read it, it's even easier to understand facial expressions, clothes, scenes, etc., so I recommend that one too! Incidentally, I read novels after I finished reading them all, but I couldn't stop grinning.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 27, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

好き

likes

This review contains spoilers. なんとなくありがちな魔女設定かと思いきや、嘘をつけないというオリジナリティがこの物語をいい味にしてます。嘘をつけないから顔を隠しながら表情を見られないようにしているロゼ、世話焼きでちょっとウザみのあるスパダリハリージュ。他の漫画では見ないアクセントのある個性がわたしに刺さりました。一年に一冊ペースの発売なのでいつかなーと思いながら見返してまた「まだ先かぁ」を繰り返しております。次はいつですか！

This review contains spoilers. Somehow I think it's a common witch setting, but the originality of not telling lies makes this story taste good. Rose, who hides her face so you can't see her expression because she doesn't tell lies, is a spadari harriju with care and a bit annoying. A personality with an accent I don't see in other comics stuck with me. It's sold at a pace of one book a year, so I looked back and repeated “is there still a long way to go?” When is the next one!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

期待以上です

It's more than I expected

初恋のハリージュとやりとりする魔女のロゼがかわいくて。「はい」ではなく、「へい」と返事するのもなんとも言えないかわいさが漂っています。初恋は叶わない事が多いのですが、これは安心して見ていられるというか、今のところ意地の悪い人とか、身分をかさに着て鼻もちならない令嬢とか出てこないので（窃盗犯はいましたが）そこのところは本当に安心してほっこりしながら読めます。割引きの時に、買えて良かった〜。まだまだ、ハッピーエンドまでは行き着きませんがいいところまで来ています。

Rose, the witch who interacts with her first love Haliju, is so cute. There is an indescribable sense of cuteness about replying “hey” instead of “yes.” There are many cases where Hatsukoi doesn't come true, but you can watch this with peace of mind, or so far, there are no mean people or noses that don't even come up (although there were thieves), so I can read that place while feeling really safe and relaxed. I'm glad I was able to buy it when it was discounted. We haven't reached a happy ending yet, but we've come to a good point.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 09, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

おすすめ

recommended

cmoaで見つけた漫画では一番くらいに気に入っている作品です。恋する割には淡白なロゼと溺愛してる割にテンションが高すぎないハリージュがかわいい。

It's my favorite comic book I've found on CMOA. Rose, who is bland for love, and Haliju, whose tension isn't too high in spite of her doting on her, are cute.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 12, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

頑張れ魔女様

Hang in there, witch

This review contains spoilers. 隣国へ嫁ぐお姫様が、お相手に惚れるために惚れ薬を依頼して王女としての覚悟と、気高さをもって嫁ぐエピソードが好きです魔女様と騎士様の進行中の恋物語よりも素敵だと思いました

This review contains spoilers. I like the episode where the princess who gets married to a neighboring country asks for love potions in order to fall in love with her partner, is prepared as a princess, and marries with dignity. I thought it was more wonderful than the ongoing love story between a witch and a knight

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろ

It's interesting

まず主人公のロゼが可愛いです。服装が結構気に入っていて、私もロープを着てみたいと思いました。そして変な薬。ロゼに朝早く起きれる薬を調合して欲しいです。

First of all, the main character, Rose, is cute. I liked the outfit quite a bit, and I wanted to try wearing a rope too. And weird drugs. I want rose to be mixed with medicine to make me wake up early in the morning.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 11, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

個人的にはティエンが好き！

Personally, I like Tien!

ハリージュも口は悪いけど恋人としてロゼを大事にしてて好感はあるんだけど、個人的にはティエンがいい！登場シーン少ないけど兄のような母親のような優しさでロゼを大事にしてるのが伝わってくる現れるタイミングが悪かったり、ちょっと軽い感じがあったりするのもまた良いキャラだと思う

Haliju is also a bad talker, but she cherishes Rose as her lover and I like her, but personally, I like Tien! There are few scenes, but it is conveyed that they take care of Rose with the kindness of a mother like an older brother, and I think it's also a good character that the timing when they appear is bad, and they have a slightly light feeling

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 28, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

キュンキューン！

Kyun Kyun!

むずむずキュンキュンしました！絵柄も可愛らしくて魅力的です＾＾５巻まで読みましたが、二人がどんどん近付いていくのが溜まりません！！

I was so excited! The design is cute and attractive too ^^ I've read up to 5 volumes, but I can't stop watching the two get closer and closer!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 03, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ドキドキ

pounding

2人の関係の続きを読めて幸せでした！話のテンポも良く、早く続きを読みたいと思える作品でした！続きも楽しみです！

I was happy to read more about the relationship between the two! The tempo of the story was also good, and it was a work that made me want to read more soon! I'm looking forward to the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 25, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

生い立ち、境遇への諦めが切ない

I'm sad to give up on my upbringing and circumstances

今までごく自然に沢山のものをあきらめてきたんだなと、切なくなりました。人に触れ少しづつ怖がりながらも変わっていくヒロインがとても好きです。

It made me sad that I had given up so many things quite naturally until now. I really like the heroine who touches people and changes even though she is scared little by little.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 22, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

よい！

good!

ヒロインが健気？で鈍感だけど、逞しいところが可愛い！ヒーローが魔女に惹かれていくのがわかります♡ヒーローもとてつもなく紳士。2人の仲の進展はゆっくりだけど、ヒーローの忍耐がどこまで続くのか…5巻まで一気読みしました！

Is the heroine healthy? So it's insensitive, but the strong part is cute! I understand that heroes are becoming attracted to witches ♡ Heroes are also extremely gentlemen. The relationship between the two progresses slowly, but I wonder how far the hero's patience lasts... I read all the 5 volumes at once!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 16, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

すごくいい！

Very nice!

描写が丁寧できれい。現実にこんな魔女が居たら良いな。と思う。疲労回復薬買いに行きたい。ハリージュ様や屋敷の人々が見守っている感じも素敵。ロゼが少しずつ馴染んでいく感じを嬉しく見守る、親戚のおばさんの心境で、物語を読んでいます。次巻はどんな風に展開するのか、とても楽しみに待っています。

The depiction is careful and beautiful. I wish there were witches like this in real life. I think. I want to go buy medicine to recover from fatigue. The feeling that Mr. Khaleju and the people at the mansion are watching is also wonderful. I'm reading the story in the mood of a relative's aunt, who happily watches over the feeling that Rose is getting used to it little by little. I'm really looking forward to seeing how the next volume will unfold.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

大好き

really like

原作小説が好きで好きで、何度も読み返してます。お話の中の言葉、世界観が大好きなので、その雰囲気そのままでてきたかのようなコミカライズ、最高です！ロゼはめちゃくちゃ可愛いし、ハリージュもカッコいい。文字だけでもキュンキュンしてたのが、視覚化されて、さらに悶え転げ回りました。続きもめちゃくちゃ楽しみです！！

I love the original novel, love it, and I reread it over and over again. I love the words and worldview in the story, so the comicalization as if the atmosphere has remained the same is amazing! Rose is insanely cute, and so is Halige. The letters alone were jumpy, but they were visualized, and I went around in agony even more. I'm really looking forward to the continuation!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ロゼーーーーー?

rosé...?

This review contains spoilers. これも原作を読んで読んで読みまくってます。なのでマンガ化はほんと嬉しすぎる。しかもカラーあり！最高です。タイトルこそほんと不穏というか不憫というか。。。という印象ですが、もう、最高。六つ花えいこ先生作品大ファンなので。ひいき目に見なくてもやっぱり最高。お互いが惚れ薬をそれぞれの事情で飲んで、さらけ出す、ここのくだりはどっちもめっっっっちゃ好き。むずむずギュンギュン(キュン?では言い足りない)させられる。ヒーローなだけに、まさかのタイミングでロゼを助けにくる真夜中のとこはもうほんとヤバいです。最高。そして読んでたら林檎のお菓子が食べたくてしょうがなくなる???

This review contains spoilers. I've been reading and reading the original story too. So I'm really too happy about making it into a manga. What's more, it comes in color! It's the best. The title is really disturbing or rather pitiful... I have the impression, but it's already awesome. I'm a big fan of Mutsuhana Eiko sensei's works. It's still great even if you don't patronize it. They both fall in love with each other, take medicine for their own circumstances, and open up, I really like both of them. Muzumuzu kyun (kyun? That's not enough to say) It makes me feel like it. Since he's a hero, the place in the middle of the night who comes to save Rose at an unexpected timing is already really dangerous. the best. And when I read it, I wanted to eat apple sweets and couldn't help it???

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

かわいっ

That's cute

This review contains spoilers. 主人公の魔女ちゃんが可愛いのなんの。可愛い勘違いなんですねぇ！にやにや胸キュンストーリーです。あと魔女っていまだに憧れます。

This review contains spoilers. The main character, the witch, is cute. That's a cute misunderstanding! It's a smirking and heart-wrenching story. Also, I still admire witches.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

後からのおもろさ

The fun of later

タイトルからして失恋の仕方はキツイですが、後々すごく良くなります。めっちゃ愛されてそう………、！、！

The way to be heartbroken is tough from the title, but it gets really good later. They seem to be loved so much...,! ,!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

タイトル

titles

まずタイトルがすでに面白いです！！こういう形での失恋って辛いですよね…ここから物語がどう展開していくのか楽しみです。

First of all, the title is already interesting!! Heartbreak in this form is painful... I'm looking forward to seeing how the story unfolds from here on out.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 30, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい

entertaining

絵がとにかく自分好みで思わず購入しました。絵も最高だけど内容も面白かったです。魔女っていう設定も好きです。

Anyway, I bought the picture because I liked it. The pictures were great, but so was the content. I also like the witch setting.

Helpful

Reviews for Hi, I'm a Witch, and My Crush Wants Me to Make a Love Potion Manga