Hi, I'm a Witch, and My Crush Wants Me to Make a Love Potion Manga Reviews (P.12)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーローファイトだ

It's a hero fight

ヒロイン、可愛すぎる。彼女に感情移入し過ぎるせいか、お相手の騎士が少々残念に思えて来る。人間としては凄く良い人なんだけど、女性への扱いがなぁ。折角カッコイイのに恋心に鈍感すぎるだろ！ってそれ言っちゃったら、このストーリー前提から覆っちゃうんだろうけど（苦笑）3巻以降、今後の２人の関係がどうなって行くのか楽しみ。

The heroine is too cute. My opponent's knight seems a little disappointing, probably because he empathizes too much with her. As a human being, she's a really nice person, but I don't like how they treat women. They're so cool, but they're too insensitive to love! If I said that, it would probably overturn the premise of this story (wry laugh), but I'm looking forward to seeing what the relationship between the two will turn out in the future after volume 3.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 15, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

両片想い？

love for both?

This review contains spoilers. 湖の魔女ロゼのもとに、惚れ薬の依頼で訪ねてきたエリート騎士ハリージュ。ハリージュとの再会と依頼に驚くロゼは、4年もの間ハリージュに片想いしていたため、惚れ薬の依頼によって失恋確定。…と始まったのですが、薬ができるまで定期的に通って来るハリージュと食事を共にしたりと、なんだかほのぼのといい雰囲気。その反面、魔女という自分の立場をわきまえたロゼの膨らむ想いが切なくいじらしい。双方恋愛下手？自分の気持ちをひた隠しにするロゼと、自分の気持ちの変化に気づかない(イケメンエリートなのにちょっと残念な)ハリージュが可愛いです。そして2巻最後、満足げなハリージュが面白い。3巻が待ち遠しいです。

This review contains spoilers. Elite knight Harry Joo visits Rose, the witch of the lake, with a request for love potions. Surprised by her reunion with Haliju and her request, Rose had an unrequited love for 4 years, so her heartbreak was confirmed by a request for love medicine. It started with... but the atmosphere was kind of heartwarming, with sharing meals with Haliju, who regularly goes there until medicine is ready. On the other hand, it seems that Rose's growing feelings, which understand her position as a witch, are painfully troubling. Are they both bad at love? Rose, who keeps her feelings hidden, and Harry Joo, who doesn't notice any changes in her feelings (which is a bit disappointing even though she's a good-looking elite) are cute. And at the end of volume 2, the satisfying Haliju is interesting. I can't wait for volume 3.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 09, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛い可愛い甘酸っぱい！

Cute cute sweet and sour!

This review contains spoilers. (おっさんですが)キュンキュンしましたイケメンもさっさと押し倒してあげれば良いのにと思いつつもそれをやっちゃうと台無しかな？二人がハッピーなエンドを迎えられることを期待してます。

This review contains spoilers. (It's an old man) I thought it would be nice to quickly knock over a handsome guy, but if I did that, it would be ruined? I'm hoping the two of them will have a happy ending.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 09, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが気になる！

I'm worried about the continuation!

絵が好みで読みましたが、ストーリーもかなりツボでした。二人の関係がこの先どうなっていくのか、先が気になって仕方ない！

I read the picture because I liked it, but the story was also quite impressive. I can't help but be worried about the future as to what the relationship between the two will turn out in the future!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

繊細で鈍感な愛しい魔女

Delicate and insensitive, lovely witch

魔法でキラキラファンタジーと言うより、世間に疎くひっそりと生活している孤独な少女をオカンのように世話を焼く青年(笑)とのヒューマンドラマラブストーリー。丁寧な心理描写に感情移入でき、クスッと笑えるところもあり、この2人が幸せになってくれたらと願い続きを楽しみたいです。

Rather than a fantasy that sparkles with magic, it's a human-drama love story about a young man (laughs) who takes care of a lonely girl who lives a quiet life away from the world (laughs). I can empathize with the careful psychological depiction, and there are places where I can laugh quickly, and I want to enjoy continuing to wish these two people would be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろいです?

It's interesting?

これは、高評価なのがわかります‼恋愛感情に鈍感な彼と、キレイな片思いの記憶にしたいから適度な距離を置きたい彼女、キューン?とします?

I understand that this is highly rated ‼ Her girlfriend, who is insensitive to romantic feelings, and Khun, who wants to keep a reasonable distance because she wants to remember her beautiful unrequited love? let's say it?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

惹き込まれる作品

A work that draws you in

This review contains spoilers. とっても丁寧な心理描写で惹き込まれる作品だと思います。大好きな作品のひとつになりました。疑問なのが、魔女さんがお家にいる時は普通ボートは魔女さんのお家側にあるものでは？小説を読めば説明があるのでしょうか。それとも魔法的な何か？？まぁ、ドヤ顔のシカさんも可愛いし、まぁいいか。続きが楽しみです！追記！3巻でボートの仕組みがわかってスッキリしました！3巻もやっぱり素敵な作品でした。購入を迷われている方がいましたらメチャクチャおすすめです！

This review contains spoilers. I think it's a work that draws me in with its very careful psychological depiction. It has become one of my favorite works. The question is, when the witch is at home, isn't the boat usually on the witch's house side? If I read the novel, would there be an explanation? or something magical?? Well, the deer-faced deer are cute too, OK? I'm looking forward to the continuation! postscript! It was refreshing to understand the structure of a boat in volume 3! After all, volume 3 was a wonderful work. If anyone is unsure about purchasing, I definitely recommend it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛い、切ない、大好き。

It's cute, sad, I love it.

This review contains spoilers. 冒頭でいきなり失恋(と思い込み)、せめて少しでも長く関わりたい、というヒロイン・ロゼの想いがいじらしく切ない。ロゼは薬作り等のお仕事以外は相当にズボラで、片想いの相手に対しても、多少身だしなみを気にするようになる程度で全く媚びないところがまたおもしろ可愛いし。お相手のハリージュは、生真面目で神経質かと思いきや世話焼きな尽くし系ヒーローで、だんだんロゼに絆されていく過程にきゅんとする。あと、魔女の薬の材料が素敵。天から最初に落ちてくる雨粒なんかはこっちの世界にもありそうだけど、多分採取できる人はいないな。ほかも全部難易度激高そうなのにハリージュさん凄いな。原作小説も大好きで何度も読み返していますが、コミックの方も原作の雰囲気をそのまま大切に描いて下さっていて、一ファンとしてとても嬉しい。大好きです。

This review contains spoilers. The heroine Rose's feelings of sudden heartbreak (assumption) at the beginning and wanting to be involved for at least a little while are unsettling and sad. Rose is pretty lackluster when it comes to work other than making medicine, etc., and it's also interesting and cute that she doesn't flatter at all, even when it comes to her unrequited partner, to the extent that she is somewhat concerned about personal appearance. Her opponent, Haliju, is a serious and nervous hero who takes care of and burns down, and he gets used to the process of gradually becoming bonded to Rose. Also, the ingredients in the witch's medicine are wonderful. The first raindrops that fall from the sky seem to be in this world too, but there's probably no one who can collect them. Everything else seems to have a very high level of difficulty, but Khaleej is amazing. I love the original novel and have reread it many times, but the comics also carefully depict the atmosphere of the original story as it is, and I am very happy as a fan. I love it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

続きが楽しみ

I'm looking forward to the continuation

試し読みから気になって、コミカライズと原作まで全て読みました。結果、大正解！善き魔法使いロゼがメッチヤ可愛いい！ハリージュと結ばれるまで見届けたい作品です。

I was curious from the trial reading, and I read everything from comicalization to the original story. The result was a great answer! Good Wizard Rose is so cute! It's a work I want to keep watching until I tie the knot with Haliju.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 26, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

原作が好きなので

Because I like the original

漫画も購入。内容に作画が合ってると思います。長いお話だけど、最後まで漫画化してくれるのか気になります。個人的には最後までいって欲しい。原作にないけど、後日談付きで

I also bought comics. I think the drawing fits the content. It's a long story, but I'm wondering if they'll make it into a comic until the end. Personally, I want you to go all the way to the end. It's not in the original story, but it will be discussed at a later date

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

大好き

really like

コミカライズにハマって原作小説も読みましたが、とても良かった！ツンデレ女子＋両片思いで終始ニヤニヤ。ストーリーは4話からヒーロー側の気持ちの変化が起こって面白くなってきます。

I'm addicted to comicalization and read the original novel, and it was so good! I smirked from beginning to end with tsundere girls+both unrequited love. The story becomes interesting when the hero's feelings change from episode 4.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が繊細で好みです。

The picture is delicate and I like it.

This review contains spoilers. 表紙と試し読みで購入しました。表紙だけでなく、漫画全体とても綺麗な絵柄でした。魔女さんの生活感がない感じがとても可愛かったです。両思いなんだから、早く誤解解けてくっついてしまえ。。

This review contains spoilers. I bought the cover and trial reading. Not only the cover, but the entire comic had a very beautiful pattern. The feeling that a witch didn't have a sense of life was so cute. We have both feelings, so please resolve the misunderstanding quickly and stick together...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

雰囲気が好き！

I like the atmosphere!

絵がとても綺麗でいい！ストーリーもしっかりしているので読みやすいです。ヒロインの純粋さ、相手のイケメンさがたまりません！

The picture is so beautiful and nice! The story is also solid, so it's easy to read. The heroine's purity and her opponent's handsome personality are irresistible!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 29, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

雰囲気が好きです

I like the atmosphere

一巻がとても面白く、待ちきれず小説版も買ってしまいましたが、どちらもとても良く満足です。そして更に続きのコミカライズ二巻も購入。こちらも最後まで読みたいと思ってます。ヒーローへの恋心に魔女としての役割がからみ、何度も諦めようとするヒロインの心が切ないです。この世界の魔女のことをもっと詳しく知りたくなりました。

The first volume was very interesting, and I couldn't wait and bought the novel version, but both are very good and satisfied. Also, I bought the second volume of Comicalize which continues. I also want to read this until the end. Her role as a witch is entwined in her love for a hero, and it's sad that the heroine tries to give up over and over again. It made me want to know more about the witches in this world.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

原作とコミックがマッチしてる

The original story matches the comic

ファンタジー風ですが、純愛がベースで心温まります。これからの2人にワクワクドキドキ、続巻が楽しみです。絵柄が優しく好みなのでコミックメインで読み進めようかな。

It's like fantasy, but it's heartwarming based on pure love. I'm excited for the next two, and I'm looking forward to the next volume. The design is gentle and I like it, so maybe I'll read on with comics as the main one.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 22, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

イケメンの嫉妬最高！

A handsome guy's jealousy is awesome!

絵も綺麗で読みやすいです。他の方も書かれていますが、絶対2巻読んで欲しいな。キュンキュンしまくります。今年一番した。笑早く続きが出て欲しい。

The pictures are also beautiful and easy to read. Other people have written it, but I definitely want you to read volume 2. It's going to be cramming. It was the best this year. lol I want the continuation to come out soon.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 21, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ゆっくりとした時間が流れている

Time is flowing slowly

二人の心の距離がゆっくりと変化していく様子がとてもいいです！登場人物は少ないですが、メインで出てくるキャラクターは皆魅力的です。早く続きが読みたい！

It's so nice to see how the distance between their hearts slowly changes! There are few characters, but all of the main characters are fascinating. I want to read more soon!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

思い人に惚れ薬を依頼され

My lover asks me for love medicine

絵がとても可愛いです。世界観に合っていて、読みやすい。ヒロインの魔女が可愛い！！小説も読んでいる大好きな作品です。

The picture is very cute. It fits the worldview and is easy to read. The heroine, the witch, is so cute! I also read novels, and it's my favorite work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

だんだんと溺愛＆執着していく様が・・・

It seems like they gradually become obsessed and obsessed...

とてもとてもかわいいお話です。そして釜田先生の作画が最高に素晴らしいのです・・・魔女も騎士も最高にかわいいし、格好良い！！！またストーリーがいじらしくて、読んでいてキュンキュンさせられます。魔女の設定がとてもよくお話に活きていて・・・それゆえに騎士様が少しずつ、溺愛、そして執着していく様がとてもとても良い◎です。ネタバレなしで読むほうが面白いです。王道の胸キュンが期待できること間違いなしです。

It's a very, very cute story. And Kamata sensei's drawing is amazing... both the witch and the knight are so cute and so cool!!! Also, the story is annoying, and it makes me cringe while reading it. The setting of the witch is very well adapted to the story... so it's so nice how little by little the knight becomes doted on and obsessed. It's more interesting to read without spoilers. There is no doubt that you can expect a royal thrill.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 20, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

可愛い…

cute...

ちょっと前に原作を読んでいて優しいお話で?TL最高！ってほっこりしてました。マンガの試し読みを見付けて絵がイメージどうりだったから、そのまま購入ボタン押してました。まだ2巻ですが買って良かった、満足です。どこまで続き書いてもらえるか今後も楽しみにしています。

I read the original story a little while ago and it's a kind story? TL is the best! I was relieved. I found a trial reading of the manga and the picture was just like the image, so I just pressed the buy button. It's still 2 volumes, but I'm glad I bought it, I'm satisfied. I'm looking forward to seeing how long they keep writing.

Helpful

Reviews for Hi, I'm a Witch, and My Crush Wants Me to Make a Love Potion Manga