Fullmetal Alchemist Manga Reviews (P.13)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 16, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

人にすすめたい漫画の上位ランク作品！

A high ranking comic book that I would recommend to people!

この作品は本当に何度も読み、アニメ（TVオリジナル、原作オリジナルの両方）も何度も観倒しました。それぐらい好き。いや、大好きな作品です。登場人物の人生背景もちゃんと描かれているし最後の最後まで丁寧にストーリーが進むので、読み終わって素直に「素敵な漫画に出会えたな」と思えます。喜怒哀楽すべてが感じられる本当にオススメできる作品です！ああ、書いてたらまた読みたくなってきた。。。

I've read this work so many times, and I've watched the anime (both the TV original and the original original) over and over again. I like it that much. No, it's my favorite work. The life backgrounds of the characters are also properly drawn, and the story progresses carefully until the very end, so after reading it, I honestly think “I came across a wonderful comic.” I can really recommend this work where you can feel all the emotions and sorrow! Oh, once I wrote it, I want to read it again...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 05, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

無駄が無い

There is no waste

大人買いで一気読み。それぞれのキャラも立ってるし、もっと読みたい所だけど潔く終わってる所も含めて良いんだろうなぁ。とにかく無駄が無くて完成度も高い。しかもオマケの4コマもしっかり面白い。

Buy it as an adult and read it all at once. Each character also stands, and I wonder if it's fine to include places I want to read more but have a clean finish. Anyway, there is no waste and the degree of perfection is high. What's more, the 4 bonus frames are also really interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 28, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

キャラクター一人ひとりがとても面白く、話のスケールの大きさ、何度も読み返してしまうほど面白い

Each character is so interesting, and the scale of the story is so interesting that I reread it over and over again

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 27, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

まっすぐ。

straight.

物語の最初から最後までまっすぐ生きる兄弟の生き方が素晴らしいと思います。

I think it's wonderful how the siblings live their lives straight from beginning to end of the story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

本で

In a book

本で買って、息子にも読ませたいと思いながら、とまらずに全巻買ってしまいました。荒川さんの画力が圧巻。伏線の張りかたも、ホントに考えられてる。何度読んでも、時間を忘れて次々に読み進めてしまいます。本でも買いたいなぁ

I bought it in a book, and while I wanted my son to read it too, I couldn't stop buying the whole volume. Arakawa-san's drawing power is impressive. The way to set up foreshadowing is also really being thought out. No matter how many times I read it, I forget the time and read on. I want to buy a book too

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 05, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

なつかしい

nostalgic

昔アニメをよくみてました。とにかく主人公のエルリック兄弟がかっこいい＾＾

I used to watch anime a lot. Anyway, the main characters, the Elric Brothers, are cool ^^

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 31, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

最後までワクワク感！

Excited until the end!

ストーリーや世界観がとても丁寧に作り込まれていて、錬金術の世界に引き込まれます。錬金術で戦う戦闘シーンはとても迫力があり、絵も綺麗なので見やすいです。主人公と弟、仲間と築かれていく信頼関係が人間臭く、男らしくそこもとても魅力的です。

The story and worldview are carefully crafted, and you'll be drawn into the world of alchemy. The battle scenes where they fight with alchemy are very impressive, and the pictures are beautiful, so it's easy to see. The relationship of trust that is built between the main character, younger brother, and friends is humane, and it is also very attractive.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 07, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

❤

❤

素晴らしいの一言。何度読んでもこれ以上の作品はないと思える。

Great word. No matter how many times I read it, I don't think there is a better work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 14, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

さすがハガレン

As expected Hagaren

This review contains spoilers. 第１巻からいくつもの伏線が張り巡らせてあり、何度読み返してもその度に新しい発見があります。主役の兄弟、家族の関係性はもちろん、軍やその周囲の人たちとの関係性が素晴らしく、物語が進むごとに少しずつ変化していく様子も楽しめます。たくさんの登場人物はいるけれど、そのどれもが魅力的で、とくに大人のおじさんお姉さんが物理的にも精神的にも強くてかっこいい人ばかりです。いろんな困難や鬱展開ありますが、登場人物達がどう乗り越えていくのか、誰が助けてくれるのか、実は味方だったとか、そして敵だったとか、いろいろな視点で楽しむことができます。手元にずっと所持していて全く損はしない、自信をもってオススメできる漫画です。

This review contains spoilers. There have been many foreshadowing since volume 1, and no matter how many times you reread it, there are new discoveries every time. Not only is the relationship between the protagonist's siblings and family, but the relationships with the military and the people around them are wonderful, and you can enjoy how it changes little by little as the story progresses. There are many characters, but all of them are attractive, and in particular, the adult old man and older sister are all cool people who are physically and mentally strong. There are various difficulties and depressions, but you can enjoy it from various perspectives, such as how the characters overcome them, who can help, and actually being allies and enemies. It's a comic I can confidently recommend because I've always had it on hand and won't lose it at all.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 08, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

アニメを見てハマった大好きな作品です。もう一度、じっくり読みたくて購入しました。おすすめです!

I'm addicted to watching anime, and it's my favorite work. I bought it because I wanted to read it carefully again. I recommend it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

損はない。

There is no loss.

読んで損はないと思います。幼い子供の過ちと成長、最後まで一気に読めました。

I don't think it would hurt to read it. I was able to read the mistakes and growth of young children all at once until the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 02, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

子ども向けマンガと侮るなかれ

Don't underestimate it as a manga for children

良作です。笑って泣いて感動して考えさせられます。「錬金術は等価交換」の意味がわかったとき震えました。

It's a good work. Laughing and crying is moving and makes me think. I shuddered when I understood the meaning of “alchemy is equivalent exchange.”

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 13, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

真理とは

What is truth

過ちを犯し身体を失った兄弟の物語。テンポも良く、時に軽快に時に絶望を伴い進んでいく二人の旅には目が離せない。

The story of siblings who made a mistake and lost their bodies. The tempo is good, and I can't take my eyes off their journey, which progresses lightly, sometimes with despair.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 06, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

最高！！

the best!!

私の中では少年漫画のザ・王道！って感じです！読み始めたら止まりません！最初から最後までスピーディーに読むのも良いですが、細かく読んで伏線を探しながら読むのも楽しいですよ！

Among me, the shonen manga The Royal Road! That's what it feels like! Once I start reading, I can't stop! It's good to read it quickly from beginning to end, but it's also fun to read it in detail while searching for foreshadowing!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 03, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

少年漫画で一番好き！

My favorite shonen manga!

2人の兄弟の真っ直ぐした生き方や、兄弟と関わってくるキャラクター達の繋がりが凄く良い！少年漫画にありがちな「ダラダラ」が１つもなく、一個一個の話全部が好きです。誰にでもおススメできる最高の漫画です。

The straight way of life of the two siblings and the connections between the characters involved with the siblings are really good! There isn't a single “dull girl,” which is common in shonen comics, and I like every single story. This is the best comic I can recommend to anyone.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 01, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

キャラクター全員の体温を感じる。

I can feel the body temperature of all the characters.

素晴らしい。無駄なエピソードが１つもない。主人公のエドも頑張っているが、彼の周りの大人達がまた、カッコいい！破天荒に見えても信念があり、優しくも厳しい。それでも心に傷を負う一人の人間で、だから行動も言動も薄っぺらくない。自分はいい年だけれど、こんな大人になりたかったなぁと思う。重いストーリーではあるが、フッと笑えるシーンも多く、読者を飽きさせないバランス感覚も荒川先生の才能なのでしょうね。全くブレず、広げた風呂敷はきっちり回収。１つの物語として非常に美しい。私が読んだ全ての漫画の中で、終わり方も含め一番の作品です！是非、未読の方に読んで頂きたい。4コマもイケるよ！

great. Not a single episode is useless. The main character, Ed, is also doing his best, but the adults around him are cool too! They have beliefs even when they seem unbelievable, and they are kind and strict. Even so, he is a person who is traumatized, so his actions, words, and actions are flawless. I'm a good age, but I think I wanted to be this kind of adult. Although it's a heavy story, there are many laughable scenes, and Arakawa-sensei's talent is also a sense of balance that doesn't let readers get bored. There was no blurring at all, and the unfolded furoshiki were collected exactly. It's very beautiful as a single story. Of all the comics I've read, this is the best work, including how it ends! I definitely want those who haven't read it to read it. The 4 frames are cool too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 31, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

最高でした

It was awesome

楽しく読ませて頂きました。感動ものでとても良かったです！絵も綺麗だし、また読み返ししたいです！

I enjoyed reading it. It was inspiring and very nice! The pictures are beautiful and I want to read them again!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 21, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

全てが素晴らしい

Everything is great

キャラクターや話の進み方、終わり方まで全てが素晴らしいです。間延びしてるところもなくてサクサク読めます。昔アニメで見てよく分からなかったところが今読むとこんなに深い話だったのかと思います。あと絵がキレイで戦いのシーンもすごく読みやすいです。ところどころ泣ける所もあれば笑える所もあるし本当に素晴らしい作品です！今まで読んだ漫画の中で1番の作品です。

The characters, the way the story progresses, and even the way it ends are all amazing. There are no places where there are any delays, so I can read it clearly. I think it was such a deep story when I saw it in anime in the past and didn't really understand it when I read it now. Also, the pictures are beautiful and the battle scenes are very easy to read. There are places where I can cry, and there are places where I can laugh, and it's really a wonderful work! This is the best comic I've ever read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 10, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ハマった

Addicted

懐かしい。ガンガン連載の時からハマってて、イベントあった時には参加してた。兄弟愛が感動する。

I miss it. I've been addicted to it since Gangan was serialized, and I participated when there were events. I am moved by the brotherly love.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 26, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

いい話！

nice story!

禁忌を犯した兄弟の友情が感動的。実写映画も良かったけれど、原作も面白かった。

The friendship between siblings who have broken a taboo is moving. The live-action movie was good, but the original story was also interesting.

Helpful

Reviews for Fullmetal Alchemist Manga